Canonical Classics ← 第二十回
第二十回
huángfēnglǐngtángsēngyǒunàn
bànshānzhōngjièzhēngxiān

On Yellow Wind Ridge the Tang Monk Meets Adversity · Halfway Up the Mountain Bajie Strives for the Lead

定風樁上
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

定風樁上 Bound to the Wind-Stilling Post

dòngzhǔwényánchīlejīngdào:「wénqiánzhěyǒurénchuánshuōsānzàngshīnǎitángfèngzhǐjīngdeshénsēngshǒuxiàyǒumínghuànsūnxíngzhěshéntōngguǎngzhìgāoqiángzěnmenénggòuzhuōlái?」xiānfēngdào:「yǒuliǎngxiānláide使shǐbǐngjiǔchǐdīngshēngdezuǐchángěryòu使shǐgēnjīntiěbàngshēngdehuǒyǎnjīnjīngzhènggǎnzhexiǎojiàngzhēngchíbèixiǎojiàng使shǐjīnchántuōqiàozhīchèshēnkòngzhèshàngláifèngxiànwángliáobiǎocānzhījìng。」dòngzhǔdào:「qiěchīli。」xiānfēngdào:「wángjiànshíshíwéilièjué?」dòngzhǔdào:「xiǎochīlejǐnzhǐkǒngliǎngshàngménchǎonàowèiwéiwěn便biànqiěbǎngzàihòuyuándìngfēngzhuāngshàngdàisānliǎngláijiǎorǎoshíjiéshēnzigānjìngèrláidòngkǒushéquèrènmenxīnhuòzhǔhuòzhēnghuòjiānhuòchǎomànmàndezàishòuyòngchí。」xiānfēngdào:「wángshēnmóuyuǎnshuōdeyǒu。」jiào:「xiǎodemenle。」dòngzhǔwényánchīlejīngdào:「wénqiánzhěyǒurénchuánshuōsānzàngshīnǎitángfèngzhǐjīngdeshénsēngshǒuxiàyǒumínghuànsūnxíngzhěshéntōng广guǎngzhìgāoqiángzěnmenénggòuzhuōlái?」xiānfēngdào:「yǒuliǎngxiānláide使shǐbǐngjiǔ齿chǐdīngshēngdezuǐchángěryòu使shǐgēnjīntiěbàngshēngdehuǒyǎnjīnjīngzhènggǎnzhexiǎojiàngzhēngchíbèixiǎojiàng使shǐjīnchántuōqiàozhīchèshēnkòngzhèshàngláifèngxiànwángliáobiǎocānzhījìng。」dòngzhǔdào:「qiěchīli。」xiānfēngdào:「wángjiànshíshíwéilièjué?」dòngzhǔdào:「xiǎochīlejǐnzhǐkǒngliǎngshàngménchǎonàowèiwéiwěn便biànqiěbǎngzàihòuyuándìngfēngzhuāngshàngdàisānliǎngláijiǎorǎoshíjiéshēnzigānjìngèrláidòngkǒushéquèrènmenxīnhuòzhǔhuòzhēnghuòjiānhuòchǎomànmàndezàishòuyòngchí。」xiānfēngdào:「wángshēnmóuyuǎnshuōdeyǒu。」jiào:「xiǎodemenle。」


逐句解 Line by line

dòngzhǔwényánchīlejīngdào:「wénqiánzhěyǒurénchuánshuō dòngzhǔwényánchīlejīngdào:「wénqiánzhěyǒurénchuánshuō

The lord of the cave, hearing this, was startled. "I have heard it said before now,

聞得 twice, both times toneless de. The demon king's first reaction to the name Sanzang is fright, and the fright is on account of a servant.

sānzàngshīnǎitángfèngzhǐjīngdeshénsēng sānzàngshīnǎitángfèngzhǐjīngdeshénsēng

that Sanzang the Master of the Law is a holy monk of the Tang, gone for the scriptures by imperial command;

奉旨意取經的神僧 — a holy monk travelling under imperial warrant. The demons of this cave have better intelligence about the pilgrimage than the peasants of the last village had.

shǒuxiàyǒumínghuànsūnxíngzhěshéntōngguǎngzhìgāoqiángzěnmenénggòuzhuōlái?」 shǒuxiàyǒumínghuànsūnxíngzhěshéntōng广guǎngzhìgāoqiángzěnmenénggòuzhuōlái?」

and that under him is a disciple called Sun the Pilgrim, whose magic arts are vast and whose wit and strength are high. How were you able to take him?"

神通廣大智力高強: two four-character formulas, and the second is not quite a compliment — 智力, wit and force together, is what you credit an opponent with. 捉得他來 takes as the "managed it" reading .

xiānfēngdào:「yǒuliǎngxiānláide使shǐbǐngjiǔchǐdīngshēngdezuǐchángěr xiānfēngdào:「yǒuliǎngxiānláide使shǐbǐngjiǔ齿chǐdīngshēngdezuǐchángěr

The Vanguard said, "He has two disciples. The one who came up first wields a nine-toothed muckrake, and is long of snout and large of ear;

生得嘴長耳大: is toneless de, and is cháng. Notice the order of the report — the Vanguard describes Bajie first and at greater length, because Bajie is the one who fought him.

yòu使shǐgēnjīntiěbàngshēngdehuǒyǎnjīnjīng yòu使shǐgēnjīntiěbàngshēngdehuǒyǎnjīnjīng

the other wields a gold-banded iron rod, and has fiery eyes and golden pupils.

火眼金睛, the fiery eyes and golden pupils the Pilgrim came out of Laozi's crucible with in chapter 7.

zhènggǎnzhexiǎojiàngzhēngchíbèixiǎojiàng使shǐjīnchántuōqiàozhīchèshēnkòng zhènggǎnzhexiǎojiàngzhēngchíbèixiǎojiàng使shǐjīnchántuōqiàozhīchèshēnkòng

They were pressing your officer hard, when your officer used the stratagem of the golden cicada that sheds its shell, drew himself out and got his opening,

小將 twice, both jiàng. 撤身得空, "drew himself back and got a gap": is . The Vanguard's account is accurate in every particular and omits only that he ran away first.

zhèshàngláifèngxiànwángliáobiǎocānzhījìng。」 zhèshàngláifèngxiànwángliáobiǎocānzhījìng。」

and took this monk and brought him, and offers him to the Great King as a poor mark of respect, worth one meal."

聊表一餐之敬, a mark of respect worth one meal — the second time in two passages that the prisoner has been valued in courses.

dòngzhǔdào:「qiěchīli。」xiānfēngdào:「wángjiànshíshíwéilièjué?」 dòngzhǔdào:「qiěchīli。」xiānfēngdào:「wángjiànshíshíwéilièjué?」

The lord of the cave said, "Do not eat him yet." The Vanguard said, "Great King, to see food and not eat it — is that not what men call a balking mule?"

見食不食呼為劣蹶: is wéi, "to call something." A 劣蹶 is a balky, stubborn beast, and the proverb runs roughly "the mule that will not eat what is put in front of it." The Vanguard is arguing with his king about dinner.

dòngzhǔdào:「xiǎochīlejǐnzhǐkǒngliǎngshàngménchǎonàowèiwéiwěn便biàn dòngzhǔdào:「xiǎochīlejǐnzhǐkǒngliǎngshàngménchǎonàowèiwéiwěn便biàn

The lord of the cave said, "You do not understand. To eat him is no great matter; but I fear those two disciples of his will come to the door and raise a clamor, and that would hardly be safe.

不打緊, of no great consequence. 曉得 takes toneless de; 未為穩便 takes as wéi. The Great King is the first creature in the chapter to reason about the Pilgrim correctly.

qiěbǎngzàihòuyuándìngfēngzhuāngshàngdàisānliǎngláijiǎorǎoshíjié qiěbǎngzàihòuyuándìngfēngzhuāngshàngdàisānliǎngláijiǎorǎoshíjié

Let him rather be bound to the Wind-Stilling Post in the back garden. Wait three days or five; and if the two of them do not come to trouble us, why then,

定風樁, the Wind-Stilling Post — and remember the name, because in the next chapter wind is the demon king's only weapon. 那時節, "at that season, then."

shēnzigānjìngèrláidòngkǒushéquèrènmenxīn shēnzigānjìngèrláidòngkǒushéquèrènmenxīn

first, we shall have him with his body clean; and second, there will be no wagging of tongues; and shall we not then do just as we please?

身子乾淨: is gān. The reasoning is entirely practical — a monk starved for three days will be cleaner meat — and it is delivered with the calm of a man planning a banquet.

huòzhǔhuòzhēnghuòjiānhuòchǎomànmàndezàishòuyòngchí。」 huòzhǔhuòzhēnghuòjiānhuòchǎomànmàndezàishòuyòngchí。」

Boiled or steamed, fried or seared, there will be time enough to enjoy him at our leisure."

或煮或蒸或煎或炒 — four verbs of cookery inside eight characters, in perfect parallel. The novel does not flinch, and neither does the King.

xiānfēngdào:「wángshēnmóuyuǎnshuōdeyǒu。」jiào:「xiǎodemenle。」 xiānfēngdào:「wángshēnmóuyuǎnshuōdeyǒu。」jiào:「xiǎodemenle。」

The Vanguard was delighted. "The Great King plans deep and looks far. What he says is reason itself." And he called, "You there, take him away."

深謀遠慮, "plans deep and looks far," comes from Jia Yi's essay on the fall of Qin and is still in daily use for genuine strategic foresight. Here it is applied to a scheme for keeping a monk fresh. 說得有理 takes toneless de.


總評 Commentary

The Great King of Yellow Wind is the first intelligence the pilgrims have met on this mountain. He knows who Sanzang is; he knows the Pilgrim by name and reputation; and having been handed the prize, he declines to eat it. His reasoning is exact. The meal is trivial, the disciples are not, and a demon who eats a monk on Monday has two immortals at his door on Tuesday. Wait five days. If nobody comes, the meat will keep — and improve.

Against him the Tiger Vanguard argues for dinner, and does it with a proverb about a mule that will not eat what is put in front of it. The comedy is exact and cold. Two paragraphs of military protocol give way to two of menu-planning — 或煮或蒸或煎或炒 — and the Tang Monk, who is standing there throughout, is not addressed once. Note the name of the post they tie him to, as well: 定風樁, the Wind-Stilling Post. In a cave whose master's single weapon is a wind, the prisoner is bound to the one thing that can hold it.