Canonical Classics ← 第八十二回
第八十二回
chàqiúyáng
yuánshéndào

The Fair Girl Seeks the Yang · The Primal Spirit Guards the Way

打得還少
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

打得還少 Beaten and Still Too Little

xíngzhěxiàodào:「deháishǎo。」jièdào:「xièzhàotóudōuzhǒngleháishuōshǎoli。」xíngzhědào:「wēnróutiānxiàdegāngqiángcùnnánxíngzhěxiàodào:「deháishǎo。」jièdào:「xièzhàotóudōuzhǒngleháishuōshǎoli。」xíngzhědào:「wēnróutiānxiàdegāngqiángcùnnán


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěxiàodào:「deháishǎo。」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「deháishǎo。」

Pilgrim laughed. "You were beaten too little."

Here is de, the light syllable that hooks a verb to a verdict on it, so the four characters mean roughly beaten-to-an-extent, and that extent is too small. The laugh in front of it is not kindness.

jièdào:「xièzhào jièdào:「xièzhào

Bajie said, "Thank you very much for your concern."

Flat sarcasm, and it is one of the few times in the chapter Bajie gets a clean hit in. 照顧 is the polite word for looking after somebody, used here at exactly the wrong temperature.

tóudōuzhǒngleháishuōshǎoli。」 tóudōuzhǒngleháishuōshǎoli。」

"My head is swollen all over and you still say it was too little."

The complaint is split off into its own sentence so the sarcasm above can land first. He is genuinely aggrieved, and he is also still not asking why he was hit.

xíngzhědào:「wēnróutiānxiàdegāngqiángcùnnán xíngzhědào:「wēnróutiānxiàdegāngqiángcùnnán

Pilgrim said, "Gentleness will carry you anywhere under heaven; hardness cannot move a cùn."

This is a proverb, balanced character for character, and Pilgrim produces it the way anyone produces a proverb when they are about to lecture. is de again, the light linking syllable that makes going-anywhere possible rather than actual. The measure in the second half is the cùn, about 3.2 cm — so hardness cannot advance the width of a thumb.


總評 Commentary

Pilgrim's verdict is funny and also, by the story's lights, correct. The chapter is going to spend a long stretch on the proposition that softness gets further than force, and it will make Bajie prove it by going back down and trying again politely.

The proverb is the hinge. Everything before it is knockabout; everything after it is a lesson, delivered by a monkey who has spent seventy chapters solving problems by hitting them. The novel enjoys putting its most sensible advice in the mouth of its least patient character.

It is worth noticing that Pilgrim is right about tactics and indifferent about pain. He never does answer the complaint about the swollen head.