Canonical Classics ← 第四十回
第四十回
嬰yīng兒ér戲xì化huà禪chán心xīn亂luàn
猿yuán馬mǎ刀dāo圭guī木mù母mǔ空kōng

The Baby, Playing at Transformation, Throws the Chan-Mind into Chaos · Ape and Horse, the Sword-Crucible and Wood-Mother, Come to Naught

兩句常言
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

兩句常言 兩句常言 | Two Old Sayings

沙shā和hé尚shàng笑xiào道dào:「哥gē啊a,常cháng言yán道dào:『三sān年nián不bú上shàng門mén,當dāng親qīn也yě不bù親qīn』哩li。你nǐ與yǔ他tā相xiāng別bié五wǔ六liù百bǎi年nián,又yòu不bù曾céng往wǎng還huán杯bēi酒jiǔ,又yòu沒méi有yǒu個gè節jié禮lǐ相xiāng邀yāo,他tā那nǎ裡lǐ與yǔ你nǐ認rèn甚shén麼me親qīn耶yé?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ怎zěn麼me這zhè等děng量liáng人rén?常cháng言yán道dào:『一yí葉yè浮fú萍píng歸guī大dà海hǎi,為wéi人rén何hé處chù不bù相xiāng逢féng。』縱zòng然rán他tā不bú認rèn親qīn,好hǎo道dào也yě不bù傷shāng我wǒ師shī父fù。不bú望wàng他tā相xiāng留liú酒jiǔ席xí,必bì定dìng也yě還huán我wǒ個gè囫hú圇lún唐táng僧sēng。」沙shā和hé尚shàng笑xiào道dào:「哥gē啊a,常cháng言yán道dào:『三sān年nián不bú上shàng门mén,当dāng亲qīn也yě不bù亲qīn』哩li。你nǐ与yǔ他tā相xiāng别bié五wǔ六liù百bǎi年nián,又yòu不bù曾céng往wǎng还huán杯bēi酒jiǔ,又yòu没méi有yǒu个gè节jié礼lǐ相xiāng邀yāo,他tā那nǎ里lǐ与yǔ你nǐ认rèn甚shén么me亲qīn耶yé?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ怎zěn么me这zhè等děng量liáng人rén?常cháng言yán道dào:『一yí叶yè浮fú萍píng归guī大dà海hǎi,为wéi人rén何hé处chù不bù相xiāng逢féng。』纵zòng然rán他tā不bú认rèn亲qīn,好hǎo道dào也yě不bù伤shāng我wǒ师shī父fù。不bú望wàng他tā相xiāng留liú酒jiǔ席xí,必bì定dìng也yě还huán我wǒ个gè囫hú囵lún唐táng僧sēng。」


逐句解 Line by line

沙shā和hé尚shàng笑xiào道dào:「哥gē啊a,常cháng言yán道dào:『三sān年nián不bú上shàng門mén,當dāng親qīn也yě不bù親qīn』哩li。 沙shā和hé尚shàng笑xiào道dào:「哥gē啊a,常cháng言yán道dào:『三sān年nián不bú上shàng门mén,当dāng亲qīn也yě不bù亲qīn』哩li。

Sha Monk laughed and said: "Brother, the old saying goes: 'Three years without darkening the door, and kin are kin no longer.'

Sha Monk, who is usually the quiet one, punctures the whole argument with a proverb — and the proverb is still current. 三年不上門,當親也不親: let three years pass without visiting and the relationship lapses, whatever the blood. Note the printer encloses it in the inner quotation marks the edition reserves for quoted matter, which is why it is set as prose here rather than as verse. The two instances of 不 behave differently and correctly: bú before the falling tone of 上, plain bù before the level tone of 親.

你nǐ與yǔ他tā相xiāng別bié五wǔ六liù百bǎi年nián,又yòu不bù曾céng往wǎng還huán杯bēi酒jiǔ,又yòu沒méi有yǒu個gè節jié禮lǐ相xiāng邀yāo,他tā那nǎ裡lǐ與yǔ你nǐ認rèn甚shén麼me親qīn耶yé?」 你nǐ与yǔ他tā相xiāng别bié五wǔ六liù百bǎi年nián,又yòu不bù曾céng往wǎng还huán杯bēi酒jiǔ,又yòu没méi有yǒu个gè节jié礼lǐ相xiāng邀yāo,他tā那nǎ里lǐ与yǔ你nǐ认rèn甚shén么me亲qīn耶yé?」

You have been parted from him five or six hundred years, you have never once exchanged a cup of wine with him, nor sent a festival gift to invite him — how should he acknowledge any kinship with you?"

Sha Monk is doing arithmetic on the friendship and finding nothing in the ledger. Two readings here are worth flagging. In 往還, "to have dealings, to come and go," the second character is the verb "to go back," huán — not the hái meaning "still" that this chapter has used a dozen times. And 他那裡 is the questioning 那, nǎ: not "over there" but "how on earth would he." Both 相 are the mutual one, xiāng. 節禮 are the gifts exchanged at the calendar festivals — the machinery by which a Chinese relationship was kept alive, and exactly what Wukong has not done.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ怎zěn麼me這zhè等děng量liáng人rén? 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ怎zěn么me这zhè等děng量liáng人rén?

Pilgrim said: "How can you take the measure of a man like that?

A real crux, and the dictionary settles it. 量 splits by tone according to the job it is doing: level-tone liáng for the verb, to weigh or measure or gauge, and falling-tone liàng for the noun, a capacity or a quantity. The 康熙字典 states the division outright — one reads 度量 and 器量, capacity and magnanimity, as liàng, but 丈量 and 商量, surveying and deliberating, as liáng. Here 量人 is plainly the verb, to take a man's measure, so it is liáng — the same reading this chapter already gives it in 思量 and 商量. Worth adding that 量人 occurs exactly once in the whole novel, and this is it.

常cháng言yán道dào:『一yí葉yè浮fú萍píng歸guī大dà海hǎi,為wéi人rén何hé處chù不bù相xiāng逢féng。』 常cháng言yán道dào:『一yí叶yè浮fú萍píng归guī大dà海hǎi,为wéi人rén何hé处chù不bù相xiāng逢féng。』

The old saying goes: 'A single duckweed leaf comes home to the sea; and living as men, where shall we not meet again?'

Wukong answers a proverb with a proverb, and his is the more famous. 一葉浮萍歸大海,為人何處不相逢 — the duckweed drifts wherever the water takes it and still ends in the sea, so people who have once known each other will cross paths again. It is worth noticing that this is a seven-and-seven couplet, verse by any scansion; but the edition prints it inside quotation marks, and by the printer's own test quoted matter is prose however it scans, so it carries no verse marking. 為人 takes 為 as wéi, "being a person"; 相逢 has the mutual 相, xiāng.

縱zòng然rán他tā不bú認rèn親qīn,好hǎo道dào也yě不bù傷shāng我wǒ師shī父fù。 纵zòng然rán他tā不bú认rèn亲qīn,好hǎo道dào也yě不bù伤shāng我wǒ师shī父fù。

Even if he does not own the kinship, he surely will not harm my Master.

The argument quietly retreats from "he owes me" to "he probably will not." 好道 is a Ming turn of phrase for "surely, presumably" — and the hedge in it is the tell.

不bú望wàng他tā相xiāng留liú酒jiǔ席xí,必bì定dìng也yě還huán我wǒ個gè囫hú圇lún唐táng僧sēng。」 不bú望wàng他tā相xiāng留liú酒jiǔ席xí,必bì定dìng也yě还huán我wǒ个gè囫hú囵lún唐táng僧sēng。」

I do not look to be kept to a banquet — but he is bound at least to give me back a Tang Monk in one piece."

The joke that closes the chapter's talk, and it is a good one: no need to lay on dinner, just return the Master undamaged. 囫圇 means "whole, entire, in one piece," and applying it to a person is deliberately comic — the word one would use of a swallowed dumpling. 還我 has 還 as huán, the verb "to give back," the second time in this passage that this character is a verb rather than the "still" word it has been all chapter. 相留 carries the mutual 相, xiāng.


總評 Commentary

The exchange of proverbs is one of the finest small scenes in the chapter, and it belongs to Sha Monk. He rarely speaks at length, but when he does he is usually the one holding the party to reality, as he was when he talked them out of disbanding a few passages back. Here he answers Wukong's confidence with a piece of ordinary household wisdom — 三年不上門,當親也不親, let three years pass without visiting and kin are kin no longer — and then does the arithmetic that makes it bite: five or six hundred years, not one cup of wine exchanged, not one festival gift sent. In a culture where a relationship was kept alive by exactly those observances, the ledger is empty.

Wukong answers a proverb with a proverb, and the one he reaches for is still in daily use: 一葉浮萍歸大海,為人何處不相逢 — the duckweed leaf drifts wherever the water takes it and still comes home to the sea, so people who have once known each other will meet again somewhere. It is a beautiful line and it is also, in context, a dodge; it argues that meetings recur, not that debts are honoured. And Wukong seems to feel the weakness, because he immediately climbs down — first to "surely he will not harm my Master," then to the joke that closes the argument and gets the last laugh: never mind a banquet, just hand back a Tang Monk 囫圇, in one piece. It is funny, and it is also the exact shape of the anxiety he will not admit to.