Canonical Classics ← 第四十回
第四十回
嬰yīng兒ér戲xì化huà禪chán心xīn亂luàn
猿yuán馬mǎ刀dāo圭guī木mù母mǔ空kōng

The Baby, Playing at Transformation, Throws the Chan-Mind into Chaos · Ape and Horse, the Sword-Crucible and Wood-Mother, Come to Naught

三讓帝位
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

三讓帝位 Thrice Declining the Throne

眾zhòng文wén武wǔ傳chuán令lìng,著zhuó他tā進jìn來lái。行xíng者zhě看kàn時shí,原yuán來lái是shì那nà寶bǎo林lín寺sì僧sēng人rén,捧pěng著zhe那nà沖chōng天tiān冠guān、碧bì玉yù帶dài、赭zhě黃huáng袍páo、無wú憂yōu履lǚ進jìn得de來lái也yě。行xíng者zhě大dà喜xǐ道dào:「來lái得de好hǎo,來lái得de好hǎo。」且qiě教jiào道dào人rén過guò來lái,摘zhāi下xià包bāo巾jīn,戴dài上shàng沖chōng天tiān冠guān;脫tuō了le布bù衣yī,穿chuān上shàng赭zhě黃huáng袍páo;解jiě了le絛tāo子zi,繫xì上shàng碧bì玉yù帶dài;褪tuì了le僧sēng鞋xié,登dēng上shàng無wú憂yōu履lǚ;教jiào太tài子zǐ拿ná出chū白bái玉yù珪guī來lái,與yǔ他tā執zhí在zài手shǒu裡lǐ:早zǎo請qǐng上shàng殿diàn稱chēng孤gū。正zhèng是shì自zì古gǔ道dào:「朝cháo廷tíng不bù可kě一yí日rì無wú君jūn。」那nà皇huáng帝dì那nǎ裡lǐ肯kěn坐zuò,哭kū啼tí啼tí,跪guì在zài階jiē心xīn道dào:「我wǒ已yǐ死sǐ三sān年nián,今jīn蒙méng師shī父fù救jiù我wǒ回huí生shēng,怎zěn麼me又yòu敢gǎn妄wàng自zì稱chēng尊zūn;請qǐng那nà一yí位wèi師shī父fù為wéi君jūn,我wǒ情qíng願yuàn領lǐng妻qī子zǐ城chéng外wài為wéi民mín足zú矣yǐ。」那nà三sān藏zàng那nǎ裡lǐ肯kěn受shòu,一yì心xīn只zhǐ是shì要yào拜bài佛fó求qiú經jīng。又yòu請qǐng行xíng者zhě,行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「不bù瞞mán列liè位wèi說shuō,老lǎo孫sūn若ruò肯kěn做zuò皇huáng帝dì,天tiān下xià萬wàn國guó九jiǔ州zhōu皇huáng帝dì都dōu做zuò遍biàn了le。只zhǐ是shì我wǒ們men做zuò慣guàn了le和hé尚shàng,是shì這zhè般bān懶lǎn散sàn。若ruò做zuò了le皇huáng帝dì,就jiù要yào留liú頭tóu長zhǎng髮fà,黃huáng昏hūn不bú睡shuì,五wǔ鼓gǔ不bù眠mián;聽tīng有yǒu邊biān報bào,心xīn神shén不bù安ān;見jiàn有yǒu災zāi荒huāng,憂yōu愁chóu無wú奈nài。我wǒ們men怎zěn麼me弄nòng得de慣guàn?你nǐ還hái做zuò你nǐ的de皇huáng帝dì,我wǒ還hái做zuò我wǒ的de和hé尚shàng,修xiū功gōng行xíng去qù也yě。」众zhòng文wén武wǔ传chuán令lìng,着zhuó他tā进jìn来lái。行xíng者zhě看kàn时shí,原yuán来lái是shì那nà宝bǎo林lín寺sì僧sēng人rén,捧pěng着zhe那nà冲chōng天tiān冠guān、碧bì玉yù带dài、赭zhě黄huáng袍páo、无wú忧yōu履lǚ进jìn得de来lái也yě。行xíng者zhě大dà喜xǐ道dào:「来lái得de好hǎo,来lái得de好hǎo。」且qiě教jiào道dào人rén过guò来lái,摘zhāi下xià包bāo巾jīn,戴dài上shàng冲chōng天tiān冠guān;脱tuō了le布bù衣yī,穿chuān上shàng赭zhě黄huáng袍páo;解jiě了le绦tāo子zi,系xì上shàng碧bì玉yù带dài;褪tuì了le僧sēng鞋xié,登dēng上shàng无wú忧yōu履lǚ;教jiào太tài子zǐ拿ná出chū白bái玉yù珪guī来lái,与yǔ他tā执zhí在zài手shǒu里lǐ:早zǎo请qǐng上shàng殿diàn称chēng孤gū。正zhèng是shì自zì古gǔ道dào:「朝cháo廷tíng不bù可kě一yí日rì无wú君jūn。」那nà皇huáng帝dì那nǎ里lǐ肯kěn坐zuò,哭kū啼tí啼tí,跪guì在zài阶jiē心xīn道dào:「我wǒ已yǐ死sǐ三sān年nián,今jīn蒙méng师shī父fù救jiù我wǒ回huí生shēng,怎zěn么me又yòu敢gǎn妄wàng自zì称chēng尊zūn;请qǐng那nà一yí位wèi师shī父fù为wéi君jūn,我wǒ情qíng愿yuàn领lǐng妻qī子zǐ城chéng外wài为wéi民mín足zú矣yǐ。」那nà三sān藏zàng那nǎ里lǐ肯kěn受shòu,一yì心xīn只zhǐ是shì要yào拜bài佛fó求qiú经jīng。又yòu请qǐng行xíng者zhě,行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「不bù瞒mán列liè位wèi说shuō,老lǎo孙sūn若ruò肯kěn做zuò皇huáng帝dì,天tiān下xià万wàn国guó九jiǔ州zhōu皇huáng帝dì都dōu做zuò遍biàn了le。只zhǐ是shì我wǒ们men做zuò惯guàn了le和hé尚shàng,是shì这zhè般bān懒lǎn散sàn。若ruò做zuò了le皇huáng帝dì,就jiù要yào留liú头tóu长zhǎng发fà,黄huáng昏hūn不bú睡shuì,五wǔ鼓gǔ不bù眠mián;听tīng有yǒu边biān报bào,心xīn神shén不bù安ān;见jiàn有yǒu灾zāi荒huāng,忧yōu愁chóu无wú奈nài。我wǒ们men怎zěn么me弄nòng得de惯guàn?你nǐ还hái做zuò你nǐ的de皇huáng帝dì,我wǒ还hái做zuò我wǒ的de和hé尚shàng,修xiū功gōng行xíng去qù也yě。」


逐句解 Line by line

眾zhòng文wén武wǔ傳chuán令lìng,著zhuó他tā進jìn來lái。 众zhòng文wén武wǔ传chuán令lìng,着zhuó他tā进jìn来lái。

The assembled officials passed on the command, and had them enter.

著 is the hardest-working character in this chapter and it has four separate jobs. Here it is the one that hands out an order — "had them come in" — and takes zhuó. Watch for the other three as we go: zhe for an action in progress, zháo for one that lands, zhāo for a move in a board game.

行xíng者zhě看kàn時shí,原yuán來lái是shì那nà寶bǎo林lín寺sì僧sēng人rén,捧pěng著zhe那nà沖chōng天tiān冠guān、碧bì玉yù帶dài、赭zhě黃huáng袍páo、無wú憂yōu履lǚ進jìn得de來lái也yě。 行xíng者zhě看kàn时shí,原yuán来lái是shì那nà宝bǎo林lín寺sì僧sēng人rén,捧pěng着zhe那nà冲chōng天tiān冠guān、碧bì玉yù带dài、赭zhě黄huáng袍páo、无wú忧yōu履lǚ进jìn得de来lái也yě。

Pilgrim looked, and it turned out to be the monks of Precious Grove Monastery, come bearing in the Heaven-Soaring Cap, the Jasper Belt, the Ochre-Yellow Robe, and the Carefree Shoes.

The Precious Grove monks arrive carrying the regalia they were sent for. Two pointing 那 here — before 寶林寺 and before 沖天冠 — both nà. In 捧著 the 著 is the one that shows an action going on, zhe: they come in bearing the things. And 進得來 takes the light hinge 得, de.

行xíng者zhě大dà喜xǐ道dào:「來lái得de好hǎo,來lái得de好hǎo。」 行xíng者zhě大dà喜xǐ道dào:「来lái得de好hǎo,来lái得de好hǎo。」

Pilgrim, delighted, said: "Well come, well come!"

Twice over, 來得好 — the 得 is the light de again, joining the verb to how it came off. "Well timed," near enough.

且qiě教jiào道dào人rén過guò來lái,摘zhāi下xià包bāo巾jīn,戴dài上shàng沖chōng天tiān冠guān; 且qiě教jiào道dào人rén过guò来lái,摘zhāi下xià包bāo巾jīn,戴dài上shàng冲chōng天tiān冠guān;

and had the acolyte come over, take off his head-wrap, and put on the Heaven-Soaring Cap;

The dressing begins. 教 here means "had someone do it," and its ordinary reading jiào is already the right one — checked directly, no override needed.

脫tuō了le布bù衣yī,穿chuān上shàng赭zhě黃huáng袍páo; 脱tuō了le布bù衣yī,穿chuān上shàng赭zhě黄huáng袍páo;

stripped off his cloth habit and put on the Ochre-Yellow Robe;

赭黃袍, the ochre-yellow robe, is a shade reserved for the throne. The whole undressing and redressing marks the king's passage from resurrected corpse back into a reigning sovereign, one garment at a time.

解jiě了le絛tāo子zi,繫xì上shàng碧bì玉yù帶dài; 解jiě了le绦tāo子zi,系xì上shàng碧bì玉yù带dài;

undid his sash-cord and fastened on the Jasper Belt;

碧玉帶, the jasper belt, is the second piece. Each item of the borrowed monk's habit comes off and its royal counterpart goes on in its place.

褪tuì了le僧sēng鞋xié,登dēng上shàng無wú憂yōu履lǚ; 褪tuì了le僧sēng鞋xié,登dēng上shàng无wú忧yōu履lǚ;

slipped off his monk's sandals and stepped into the Carefree Shoes;

無憂履 — the Carefree Shoes, and the last of the four. With them the borrowed habit is entirely gone.

教jiào太tài子zǐ拿ná出chū白bái玉yù珪guī來lái,與yǔ他tā執zhí在zài手shǒu裡lǐ:早zǎo請qǐng上shàng殿diàn稱chēng孤gū。 教jiào太tài子zǐ拿ná出chū白bái玉yù珪guī来lái,与yǔ他tā执zhí在zài手shǒu里lǐ:早zǎo请qǐng上shàng殿diàn称chēng孤gū。

and had the crown prince bring out the white-jade tablet of state and place it in his hand — then at once invited him to ascend the hall and style himself sovereign.

稱孤 is the royal self-address: a king refers to himself as 孤, "the Solitary One," on the grounds that there is nobody at his level. To style oneself so is to be king, which is exactly what he keeps refusing to do. The second 教, in 教太子, is again the everyday jiào.

正zhèng是shì自zì古gǔ道dào:「朝cháo廷tíng不bù可kě一yí日rì無wú君jūn。」 正zhèng是shì自zì古gǔ道dào:「朝cháo廷tíng不bù可kě一yí日rì无wú君jūn。」

Even as the old saying goes: "A court cannot go a single day without its lord."

A stock proverb of dynastic legitimacy, wheeled out to push a reluctant man onto a throne he has just been dressed for: a court cannot go a single day without its lord. The argument is not that he deserves it but that the seat cannot stay empty.

那nà皇huáng帝dì那nǎ裡lǐ肯kěn坐zuò,哭kū啼tí啼tí,跪guì在zài階jiē心xīn道dào:「我wǒ已yǐ死sǐ三sān年nián,今jīn蒙méng師shī父fù救jiù我wǒ回huí生shēng,怎zěn麼me又yòu敢gǎn妄wàng自zì稱chēng尊zūn; 那nà皇huáng帝dì那nǎ里lǐ肯kěn坐zuò,哭kū啼tí啼tí,跪guì在zài阶jiē心xīn道dào:「我wǒ已yǐ死sǐ三sān年nián,今jīn蒙méng师shī父fù救jiù我wǒ回huí生shēng,怎zěn么me又yòu敢gǎn妄wàng自zì称chēng尊zūn;

But the king would by no means consent to sit; weeping, he knelt at the center of the stair and said: "I have been dead three years — now, favored by Master's saving me back to life, how could I dare presume to style myself sovereign again?

Here is the crux the whole chapter keeps returning to, so it is worth setting out once. The 1592 edition writes both of two different words with the same character, 那. One is the pointing word, nà, "that" — as in 那皇帝, "that king." The other is the questioning word, nǎ, "which, where" — as in 那裡肯坐, which is not "where he consents to sit" but a flat refusal dressed as a question: "how could he possibly consent?" Modern Chinese pulled the two apart and gave the questioning one a character of its own, 哪, with a mouth added at the left. The old edition did not, so every single 那 in this chapter has to be read for sense before it can be pronounced — and both readings turn up in this one sentence.

請qǐng那nà一yí位wèi師shī父fù為wéi君jūn,我wǒ情qíng願yuàn領lǐng妻qī子zǐ城chéng外wài為wéi民mín足zú矣yǐ。」 请qǐng那nà一yí位wèi师shī父fù为wéi君jūn,我wǒ情qíng愿yuàn领lǐng妻qī子zǐ城chéng外wài为wéi民mín足zú矣yǐ。」

pray let that one master here become ruler instead; I would gladly take wife and children outside the walls and be commoners — that would content me."

The king tries to hand the throne to Tripitaka instead. 那一位師父 takes the pointing nà. Both instances of 為 — in 為君 and 為民 — are wéi, "to become, to serve as," not the wèi that means "for the sake of."

那nà三sān藏zàng那nǎ裡lǐ肯kěn受shòu,一yì心xīn只zhǐ是shì要yào拜bài佛fó求qiú經jīng。 那nà三sān藏zàng那nǎ里lǐ肯kěn受shòu,一yì心xīn只zhǐ是shì要yào拜bài佛fó求qiú经jīng。

But Tripitaka would by no means accept it either — his heart was set on nothing but worshipping the Buddha and seeking the scriptures.

The refusal passes to its second recipient and is refused again. 那三藏 opens with the pointing nà; 藏 in his name is zàng, the "basket" of scripture. Then 那裡肯受 is the questioning 那 once more, nǎ — "as if he would accept."

又yòu請qǐng行xíng者zhě,行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「不bù瞞mán列liè位wèi說shuō,老lǎo孫sūn若ruò肯kěn做zuò皇huáng帝dì,天tiān下xià萬wàn國guó九jiǔ州zhōu皇huáng帝dì都dōu做zuò遍biàn了le。 又yòu请qǐng行xíng者zhě,行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「不bù瞒mán列liè位wèi说shuō,老lǎo孙sūn若ruò肯kěn做zuò皇huáng帝dì,天tiān下xià万wàn国guó九jiǔ州zhōu皇huáng帝dì都dōu做zuò遍biàn了le。

So they asked Pilgrim next; Pilgrim laughed and said: "Not to deceive you all — if old Sun were willing to be an emperor, I'd have been emperor of every nation under Heaven, all Nine Provinces over, long since.

And now the joke everybody remembers. Offered the throne third, the Monkey King does not decline it humbly; he explains that he has passed on better offers. 都做遍了 — 都 is dōu, "the lot of them, all through."

只zhǐ是shì我wǒ們men做zuò慣guàn了le和hé尚shàng,是shì這zhè般bān懶lǎn散sàn。 只zhǐ是shì我wǒ们men做zuò惯guàn了le和hé尚shàng,是shì这zhè般bān懒lǎn散sàn。

It's only that we've grown used to being monks, lazy and easy-going as we are.

懶散, "bone-idle and easy-going," is Wukong's own diagnosis of himself, and the comic premise on which the whole refusal rests. He is not too holy for a throne. He is too lazy.

若ruò做zuò了le皇huáng帝dì,就jiù要yào留liú頭tóu長zhǎng髮fà,黃huáng昏hūn不bú睡shuì,五wǔ鼓gǔ不bù眠mián; 若ruò做zuò了le皇huáng帝dì,就jiù要yào留liú头tóu长zhǎng发fà,黄huáng昏hūn不bú睡shuì,五wǔ鼓gǔ不bù眠mián;

Were I to become emperor, I'd have to keep my crown unshaved and let my hair grow long, not sleep at dusk, not rest at the fifth watch;

The complaint is specific, which is what makes it funny: a king may not shave his head, and must keep hours no reasonable creature would keep. 留頭長髮 — here 長 is the verb "to grow," zhǎng, not the adjective cháng, "long."

聽tīng有yǒu邊biān報bào,心xīn神shén不bù安ān; 听tīng有yǒu边biān报bào,心xīn神shén不bù安ān;

on hearing of frontier alarms, my heart and spirit would know no peace;

邊報, "alarms from the frontier" — the dispatches that arrive at all hours and cannot be ignored. Second item in the catalogue of a sovereign's miseries.

見jiàn有yǒu災zāi荒huāng,憂yōu愁chóu無wú奈nài。 见jiàn有yǒu灾zāi荒huāng,忧yōu愁chóu无wú奈nài。

on seeing famine or calamity, I'd fret and grieve with no relief.

災荒, "famine and disaster." That completes the list, and the punchline follows immediately.

我wǒ們men怎zěn麼me弄nòng得de慣guàn? 我wǒ们men怎zěn么me弄nòng得de惯guàn?

How could the likes of us ever get used to that?"

弄得慣 — the 得 is the light hinge de again: "manage to get used to it." The answer, obviously, is no.

你nǐ還hái做zuò你nǐ的de皇huáng帝dì,我wǒ還hái做zuò我wǒ的de和hé尚shàng,修xiū功gōng行xíng去qù也yě。」 你nǐ还hái做zuò你nǐ的de皇huáng帝dì,我wǒ还hái做zuò我wǒ的de和hé尚shàng,修xiū功gōng行xíng去qù也yě。」

"You go on being your emperor, and I'll go on being my monk — off to cultivate my merit and my works."

A neat closing symmetry — you keep yours, I keep mine. Both instances of 還 are hái, "still, as before."


總評 Commentary

The dressing is a small piece of stagecraft: cap, robe, belt and shoes swapped one at a time for the borrowed monk's habit the king has worn since he came back from the dead. It sets up a three-part refusal that is pure comic set-piece. The throne is offered first to the king, who protests he has no right to it after three years in a well; then to Tripitaka, who wants nothing but the road west; and finally, almost as an afterthought, to Wukong.

Wukong's refusal is the centrepiece, and it is one of the book's clearest comic statements of a serious idea. The Monkey King, who once overturned the courts of Heaven itself, turns down an earthly crown — not out of humility but out of a connoisseur's contempt for the tedium of the job. No shaving. No sleep at dusk, none at the fifth watch. Frontier dispatches. Famine reports. A monk's 懶散 temperament, he explains, simply does not fit a sovereign's vigilance. The joke lands because it is true to the character we have known since the opening chapters: Wukong wants freedom of movement, not a seat to be chained to. And on the eve of the Red Boy ordeal it quietly restates what the four of them actually want, which is only to keep going west.