簡帖既讀 院主自陳 The Note Read; the Prior's Confession
三藏才看了簡帖,又遞與那院主道:「你師父敢莫也是妖精麼?」那院主慌忙跪下道:「老爺,我師父是人。只因那黑大王修成人道,常來寺裡與我師父講經,他傳了我師父些養神服氣之術,故以朋友相稱。」行者道:「這夥和尚沒甚妖氣,他一個個頭圓頂天,足方履地,但比老孫肥胖長大些兒,非妖精也。你看那帖兒上寫著『侍生熊羆』,此物必定是個黑熊成精。」三藏道:「我聞得古人云:『熊與猩猩相類。』都是獸類。他卻怎麼成精?」行者笑道:「老孫是獸類,見做了齊天大聖,與他何異?大抵世間之物,凡有九竅者,皆可以修行成仙。」三藏又道:「你才說他本事與你手平,你卻怎生得勝,取我袈裟回來?」行者道:「莫管,莫管,我有處治。」商議間,眾僧擺上晚齋,請他師徒們吃了。三藏教掌燈,仍去前面禪堂安歇。眾僧都挨牆倚壁,苫搭窩棚,各各睡下,只把後方丈讓與那上下院主安身。此時夜靜,但見:三藏才看了简帖,又递与那院主道:「你师父敢莫也是妖精么?」那院主慌忙跪下道:「老爷,我师父是人。只因那黑大王修成人道,常来寺里与我师父讲经,他传了我师父些养神服气之术,故以朋友相称。」行者道:「这伙和尚没甚妖气,他一个个头圆顶天,足方履地,但比老孙肥胖长大些儿,非妖精也。你看那帖儿上写著『侍生熊罴』,此物必定是个黑熊成精。」三藏道:「我闻得古人云:『熊与猩猩相类。』都是兽类。他却怎么成精?」行者笑道:「老孙是兽类,见做了齐天大圣,与他何异?大抵世间之物,凡有九窍者,皆可以修行成仙。」三藏又道:「你才说他本事与你手平,你却怎生得胜,取我袈裟回来?」行者道:「莫管,莫管,我有处治。」商议间,众僧摆上晚斋,请他师徒们吃了。三藏教掌灯,仍去前面禅堂安歇。众僧都挨墙倚壁,苫搭窝棚,各各睡下,只把后方丈让与那上下院主安身。此时夜静,但见:
逐句解 Line by line
Sanzang had scarcely read the card when he passed it to the prior. "Can it be that your master too was a fiend?"
敢莫, "can it be that." 簡帖: 帖 reads tiě. Sanzang, holding a letter of condolence, asks whether the dead man was a monster — and asks it of the dead man's subordinate.
The prior knelt down in haste. "Venerable sir, my master was a man.
The prior kneels to a monkey and defends his abbot in a single flat sentence: 我師父是人.
It was only that the Great King of Black Wind, having cultivated himself into the estate of men, would often come to the temple to expound the scriptures with my master;
修成人道, cultivated himself into the estate of men. The bear came to the temple to 講經, to discourse on the sutras.
and he taught my master certain arts of nourishing the spirit and swallowing the breath. So they called one another friends."
養神服氣 are Taoist longevity arts. The exchange was therefore two-way: the bear received Buddhist scripture and gave back Taoist breath-work. 相稱: 相 is xiāng, 稱 is chēng.
The Pilgrim said, "This crowd of monks has no fiendish air about it. Every one of them has a round head to top the heavens and a square foot to tread the earth;
沒甚 takes shén: not any. 頭圓頂天,足方履地 is the classical definition of man — round head answering the round heaven, square foot the square earth. The Pilgrim applies the anatomical test and pronounces the monks human.
only they are somewhat plumper and taller than old Sun. They are no fiends.
長大: 長 is zhǎng, grown. 些兒 takes the diminutive er. The only difference he can find between himself and a man is girth.
Look at the card there: it is written 'Your junior in the service, the Bear-Fiend.' The thing must certainly be a black bear come to spirithood."
帖兒: tiě and the diminutive er. The signature is the evidence, and the Pilgrim reads it as a confession of species.
Sanzang said, "I have heard the ancients say, 'The bear and the ape are of a kind.' Both are of the tribe of beasts. How then should he come to spirithood?"
聞得 takes the resultative de; 相類 takes xiāng; 都 reads dōu. Sanzang quotes a maxim on the kinship of bears and apes to a disciple who is an ape, and does not appear to hear himself.
The Pilgrim laughed. "Old Sun is of the tribe of beasts, and was made Great Sage Equal to Heaven. Wherein do I differ from him?
見做了齊天大聖: 見 is kept at the default jiàn, the classical passive marker — "was made." Ming vernacular often writes 見 for 現 (xiàn, "presently"), which would give "is now made"; the sense is scarcely altered, and the reading is flagged.
Broadly, of the things of this world, whatever has the nine apertures may cultivate itself and become immortal."
九竅, the nine apertures of the body. The doctrine is stated as a commonplace: any creature so furnished may cultivate the Way. It is the theological hinge of the whole chapter, and it is spoken by a monkey in defence of a bear.
Sanzang said again, "You told me just now that his powers are an even hand with yours. How then will you get the victory, and bring my cassock back?"
手平, an even hand. Sanzang gives the Pilgrim back his own word from the previous passage, and asks the practical question it implies.
The Pilgrim said, "Never mind, never mind. I have my remedy."
處治, a remedy, a way of dealing. He has none, and will have none until a Bodhisattva provides it.
While they were consulting, the monks set out the evening meal and begged master and disciple to eat.
晚齋, the evening meatless meal — the third the monastery has served him today.
Sanzang bade them light the lamps, and went again to rest in the meditation hall at the front.
掌燈, to take up the lamps. 教 is causative jiào.
The monks all leaned against wall and partition, thatched themselves shelters of matting, and lay down each where he was, leaving only the rear lodge for the prior and his second to sleep in.
挨牆倚壁: 挨 reads āi, to press close against. 苫搭窩棚, to thatch up nesting-sheds — the monks have no cells to sleep in, because the Pilgrim burned them.
It was then the still of night. Behold:
但見 opens the night rhapsody.
The prior, kneeling, gives the truest account of the affair that anyone gives in the chapter, and nobody attends to it. The abbot and the bear were friends. They exchanged what each had: the monk expounded the sutras, the bear taught him to nourish the spirit and swallow the breath. 故以朋友相稱 — and so they called one another friends. Two hundred and seventy years of a monk's life are explained in nineteen graphs, and the explanation is a Buddhist and a Taoist teaching each other across a fence.
Then the Pilgrim, of all creatures, states the doctrine on which the chapter rests. Challenged with the proverb that bears and apes are of a kind, he does not deny it. 老孫是獸類,見做了齊天大聖,與他何異? — and from there to 凡有九竅者,皆可以修行成仙, whatever has the nine apertures may cultivate the Way. He has just spent two days trying to kill a bear who keeps a garden, writes letters, and discourses on scripture. The argument he offers for his own sanctity is precisely the argument for the bear's, and Guanyin will act on it before the chapter ends.