Canonical Classics ← 第十七回
第十七回
sūnxíngzhěnàohēifēngshān
guānshìyīnshōuxióngguài

Sun the Pilgrim Makes Great Havoc on Black Wind Mountain · Guanshiyin Subdues the Bear-Fiend

假作金池 入洞探衣
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

假作金池 入洞探衣 In the Abbot's Shape, Into the Cave

hǎoshèngniàndòngzhòuyíngzhefēngbiànguǒránjiùxiànglǎoshàngbāncángletiěbàngkāijìngláidòngkǒujiàoshēng:「kāimén!」xiǎoyāokāileménjiànshìzhèbānyàngzhuǎnshēnbàodào:「wángjīnchízhǎnglǎoláile。」guàijīngdào:「gāngcáichāilexiǎodexiàjiǎntiěqǐngzhèshíhòuháiwèidàolijiùláidezhèděngxùnxiǎngshìxiǎodecéngzhuàngzháoduànshìsūnxíngzhěláitǎojiāshādeguǎnshìdecánglejiàokànjiàn。」xíngzhějìnleqiánméndànjiàntiānjǐngzhōngsōnghuángjiāocuìtáozhēngyáncóngcónghuālánxiāngquèshìdòngtiānzhīchùyòujiànèrménshàngyǒuliánduìzixiězhe:「jìngyǐnshēnshānyōuxiāndòngtiānzhēn。」xíngzhěàndào:「zhèshìtuōgòuchénzhīmìngdeguài。」ménwǎngqiányòujìndàosāncéngméndōushìxiēhuàdòngdiāoliángmíngchuāngcǎizhǐjiànhēihànzi穿chuāndeshìhēizhùpànǎozhàolǐngqīnghuālíngfēngdàidǐngjiǎoruǎnjīn穿chuānshuāngzàoxuējiànxíngzhějìnláizhěngdùnjīnjiàngjiēyíngjiēdào:「jīnchílǎoyǒuliánqiànqīnqǐngzuòqǐngzuò。」xíngzhěxiāngjiànjiànérzuòzuòdìngérchácháyāojīngqiànshēndào:「shìyǒuxiǎojiǎnfènghòulǎoyǒujīnjiùxià?」xíngzhědào:「zhèngláijìnbàihuáhànjiànyǒuhuìbēnláiyuànqiújiànjiàn。」guàixiàodào:「lǎoyǒuchàzhèjiāshāběnshìtángsēngdezàichùzhùcéngkànjiànfǎnláijiùkànkàn?」xíngzhědào:「pínsēngjièláiyīnwǎnháicéngzhǎnkànbèiwángláiyòubèihuǒshāolehuāngshānshīluòlejiātángsēngdeyòuyǒuxiēxiāoyǒngluànmángzhōngxiàdōuxúnjiànyuánláishìwángdehóngshōuláiláijiàn。」hǎoshèngniàndòngzhòuyíngzhefēngbiànguǒránjiùxiànglǎoshàngbāncángletiěbàngkāijìngláidòngkǒujiàoshēng:「kāimén!」xiǎoyāokāileménjiànshìzhèbānyàngzhuǎnshēnbàodào:「wángjīnchízhǎnglǎoláile。」guàijīngdào:「gāngcáichāilexiǎodexiàjiǎntiěqǐngzhèshíhòuháiwèidàolijiùláidezhèděngxùnxiǎngshìxiǎodecéngzhuàngzháoduànshìsūnxíngzhěláitǎojiāshādeguǎnshìdecánglejiàokànjiàn。」xíngzhějìnleqiánméndànjiàntiānjǐngzhōngsōnghuángjiāocuìtáozhēngyáncóngcónghuālánxiāngquèshìdòngtiānzhīchùyòujiànèrménshàngyǒuliánduìzixiězhe:「jìngyǐnshēnshānyōuxiāndòngtiānzhēn。」xíngzhěàndào:「zhèshìtuōgòuchénzhīmìngdeguài。」ménwǎngqiányòujìndàosāncéngméndōushìxiēhuàdòngdiāoliángmíngchuāngcǎizhǐjiànhēihànzi穿chuāndeshìhēi绿zhùpànǎozhàolǐngqīnghuālíngfēngdàidǐngjiǎoruǎnjīn穿chuānshuāngzàoxuējiànxíngzhějìnláizhěngdùnjīnjiàngjiēyíngjiēdào:「jīnchílǎoyǒuliánqiànqīnqǐngzuòqǐngzuò。」xíngzhěxiāngjiànjiànérzuòzuòdìngérchácháyāojīngqiànshēndào:「shìyǒuxiǎojiǎnfènghòulǎoyǒujīnjiùxià?」xíngzhědào:「zhèngláijìnbàihuáhànjiànyǒuhuìbēnláiyuànqiújiànjiàn。」guàixiàodào:「lǎoyǒuchàzhèjiāshāběnshìtángsēngdezàichùzhùcéngkànjiànfǎnláijiùkànkàn?」xíngzhědào:「pínsēngjièláiyīnwǎnháicéngzhǎnkànbèiwángláiyòubèihuǒshāolehuāngshānshīluòlejiātángsēngdeyòuyǒuxiēxiāoyǒngluànmángzhōngxiàdōuxúnjiànyuánláishìwángdehóngshōuláiláijiàn。」


逐句解 Line by line

hǎoshèngniàndòngzhòuyíngzhefēngbiànguǒránjiùxiànglǎoshàngbān hǎoshèngniàndòngzhòuyíngzhefēngbiànguǒránjiùxiànglǎoshàngbān

Excellent Great Sage! He worked a spell, turned to meet the wind and changed, and was indeed the very likeness of the old monk.

迎著風 takes zhe: is a verb of moving towards something, and the character marks a state kept up rather than a goal reached. Compare the same construction at 在海上迎著我.

cángletiěbàngkāijìngláidòngkǒujiàoshēng:「kāimén!」 cángletiěbàngkāijìngláidòngkǒujiàoshēng:「kāimén!」

He hid away the iron rod, stretched his stride, came straight to the cave mouth, and called, "Open the gate!"

here is cáng, to hide something away — not the zàng of the master's name. 拽開步: reads zhuài, to haul or stretch.

xiǎoyāokāileménjiànshìzhèbānyàngzhuǎnshēnbàodào:「wángjīnchízhǎnglǎoláile。」 xiǎoyāokāileménjiànshìzhèbānyàngzhuǎnshēnbàodào:「wángjīnchízhǎnglǎoláile。」

The little demon opened it, saw such a figure standing there, and turned quickly to report, "Great King, the elder Jinchi is come."

The little demon does not look twice — which is the whole point of the disguise. Two readings: 模樣 takes as , appearance, and 長老 takes as zhǎng, elder.

guàijīngdào:「gāngcáichāilexiǎodexiàjiǎntiěqǐng guàijīngdào:「gāngcáichāilexiǎodexiàjiǎntiěqǐng

The fiend was greatly startled. "I have this moment dispatched the little one with a card to invite him.

差了小的 is chāi, to send someone off on an errand. Two segments further on the same character turns up in 差矣 and reads chà, to be mistaken.

zhèshíhòuháiwèidàolijiùláidezhèděngxùn zhèshíhòuháiwèidàolijiùláidezhèděngxùn

At this hour he cannot yet have reached there. How is it he comes so speedily?

那裡 is pointing here, , meaning over there at the temple. 來得 takes the manner-marking de, and is the particle li. Watch what the fiend does: he reasons correctly from a false premise and arrives at the truth.

xiǎngshìxiǎodecéngzhuàngzháoduànshìsūnxíngzhěláitǎojiāshāde xiǎngshìxiǎodecéngzhuàngzháoduànshìsūnxíngzhěláitǎojiāshāde

I suppose the little one never fell in with him, and that Sun the Pilgrim has assuredly called him here to demand the cassock.

撞著 reports a meeting that actually happened, so it reads zháo. His deduction is exact — the messenger never did meet the abbot — and the conclusion he draws from it is exactly wrong.

guǎnshìdecánglejiàokànjiàn。」 guǎnshìdecánglejiàokànjiàn。」

Steward — put the Buddha-robe away, and let him not lay eyes on it."

管事的 is the steward. 藏了: cáng. is again the causative jiào. Hiding the robe is the one precaution he takes, and it turns out to be enough.

xíngzhějìnleqiánméndànjiàntiānjǐngzhōngsōnghuángjiāocuì xíngzhějìnleqiánméndànjiàntiānjǐngzhōngsōnghuángjiāocuì

The Pilgrim came in at the front gate, and saw in the courtyard pine and bamboo mingling their green,

天井 is the open court inside the gate; is bamboo. What follows is prose rather than verse, but it is the chapter's third garden.

táozhēngyáncóngcónghuālánxiāngquèshìdòngtiānzhīchù táozhēngyáncóngcónghuālánxiāngquèshìdòngtiānzhīchù

peach and plum contending in loveliness, flowers opening in clusters, orchids fragrant in tufts: a very cave-heaven of a place.

洞天, the cave-heaven, is a technical term from Taoist sacred geography: one of the graded paradises hidden inside mountains. The narrator applies it to a bear-fiend's front yard with no visible irony at all.

yòujiànèrménshàngyǒuliánduìzixiězhe:「jìngyǐnshēnshānyōuxiāndòngtiānzhēn。」 yòujiànèrménshàngyǒuliánduìzixiězhe:「jìngyǐnshēnshānyōuxiāndòngtiānzhēn。」

On the second gate he saw a matched pair of lines, of the kind known as a couplet, which read: In stillness hidden in the deep hills, no vulgar cares; secluded in an immortal cave, delighting in heaven's own truth.

一聯對子 is a matched pair of lines mounted one on each leaf of a gate — the same thing you still see pasted up either side of a Chinese doorway at New Year, where the two lines answer each other phrase for phrase and the second caps the first. That is what a couplet is, and the translation names it here on its first appearance. This one is an object being looked at, a 對子 quoted as a thing seen, like the six characters on the slab over the cave door, and so it is set as prose rather than verse. 樂天真: reads , to delight in. 天真 is heaven-given nature, and the whole thing is a recluse's boast about himself — posted, note, on a bear-fiend's second gate.

xíngzhěàndào:「zhèshìtuōgòuchénzhīmìngdeguài。」 xíngzhěàndào:「zhèshìtuōgòuchénzhīmìngdeguài。」

The Pilgrim said within himself, "This creature too has shed the dust and left the world — a monster who knows what is allotted him."

脫垢離塵, shedding the grime and leaving the dust behind, is Buddhist; 知命, knowing what is allotted, comes from the Analects. Alone and with nobody to hear him, the Pilgrim pays the fiend the highest compliment anyone pays him in the chapter — and then walks straight on in to rob him.

ménwǎngqiányòujìndàosāncéngméndōushìxiēhuàdòngdiāoliángmíngchuāngcǎi ménwǎngqiányòujìndàosāncéngméndōushìxiēhuàdòngdiāoliángmíngchuāngcǎi

Passing in and going further forward, he came within the third gate to painted ridgepoles and carven beams, bright windows and coloured doors.

畫棟雕梁, painted ridgepole and carved beam, is the set formula for a rich house. reads dōu.

zhǐjiànhēihànzi穿chuāndeshìhēizhùpànǎo zhǐjiànhēihànzi穿chuāndeshìhēi绿zhùpànǎo

He saw the black fellow wearing a lined jacket of dark-green ramie silk,

紵絲 is ramie silk; 袢襖 is a lined jacket. The fiend is dressed for a caller now rather than for war, and the armour-poem from earlier should be read against this.

zhàolǐngqīnghuālíngfēngdàidǐngjiǎoruǎnjīn穿chuānshuāngzàoxuē zhàolǐngqīnghuālíngfēngdàidǐngjiǎoruǎnjīn穿chuānshuāngzàoxuē

over it a cloak of raven-blue figured damask, on his head a soft cap of black horn, and on his feet a pair of deerskin boots dyed black.

Three garments, three different measure words, and three instances of 一領, 一頂, 一雙 — every one of them sitting before a first- or third-tone character, and every one therefore .

jiànxíngzhějìnláizhěngdùnjīnjiàngjiēyíngjiēdào:「jīnchílǎoyǒuliánqiànqīnqǐngzuòqǐngzuò。」 jiànxíngzhějìnláizhěngdùnjīnjiàngjiēyíngjiēdào:「jīnchílǎoyǒuliánqiànqīnqǐngzuòqǐngzuò。」

Seeing the Pilgrim enter, he set his gown and cap straight and came down the steps to receive him. "Old friend Jinchi, these many days we have been strangers. Pray sit, pray sit."

降階 takes jiàng, to come down the steps: the correct courtesy of a host receiving an honoured guest. 欠親 is to have been remiss about keeping in touch.

xíngzhěxiāngjiànjiànérzuòzuòdìngérchá xíngzhěxiāngjiànjiànérzuòzuòdìngérchá

The Pilgrim greeted him with due ceremony. The greeting done, they sat; and being seated, they took tea.

相見: xiāng. 見畢而坐坐定而茶 — four beats of ceremony in eight characters, and the matched shape of the two clauses is the point. Everything here is being done properly.

cháyāojīngqiànshēndào:「shìyǒuxiǎojiǎnfènghòulǎoyǒujīnjiùxià?」 cháyāojīngqiànshēndào:「shìyǒuxiǎojiǎnfènghòulǎoyǒujīnjiùxià?」

The tea over, the fiend leaned forward. "I sent but now a small note, begging a meeting the day after tomorrow. How is it my old friend condescends to visit me today?"

小簡 is my poor little note; 下顧 is to condescend to call on someone. The fiend is asking the one question that could unmask his guest, and he asks it in the form of an apology.

xíngzhědào:「zhèngláijìnbàihuáhànjiànyǒuhuìbēnláiyuànqiújiànjiàn。」 xíngzhědào:「zhèngláijìnbàihuáhànjiànyǒuhuìbēnláiyuànqiújiànjiàn。」

The Pilgrim said, "I was on my way to pay my respects, and unlooked-for met your splendid brush upon the road. Seeing that there was an elegant gathering for a Buddha-robe, I came hurrying, desiring only to be granted a sight of it."

華翰, your splendid brush, is the courteous word for another man's letter — and the Pilgrim has just beaten its bearer flat. He confesses to having read it and calls the reading a chance meeting on the road.

guàixiàodào:「lǎoyǒuchàzhèjiāshāběnshìtángsēngdezàichùzhù guàixiàodào:「lǎoyǒuchàzhèjiāshāběnshìtángsēngdezàichùzhù

The fiend laughed. "My old friend is mistaken. This cassock belongs by right to the Tang monk. He lodged his staff at your house:

差矣: chà, mistaken. 住錫, to set down one's staff, is what a travelling monk does when he lodges somewhere. The fiend is now correcting his guest on a point of ownership, and he is right: the cassock is the Tang monk's. The thief is the only person in the chapter who says so.

céngkànjiànfǎnláijiùkànkàn?」 céngkànjiànfǎnláijiùkànkàn?」

can it be you never saw it, that you come to me for a sight of it?"

豈不曾看見 — surely you have seen it already? The question is unanswerable, and the Pilgrim answers it at length.

xíngzhědào:「pínsēngjièláiyīnwǎnháicéngzhǎnkànbèiwánglái xíngzhědào:「pínsēngjièláiyīnwǎnháicéngzhǎnkànbèiwánglái

The Pilgrim said, "This poor monk had borrowed it, and it being late at night had not yet unrolled it, when unlooked-for the Great King took it away.

is the adverb hái, not yet. The lie is a good one: it explains why an abbot would not have examined the robe, and it is very nearly what actually happened.

yòubèihuǒshāolehuāngshānshīluòlejiātángsēngdeyòuyǒuxiēxiāoyǒng yòubèihuǒshāolehuāngshānshīluòlejiātángsēngdeyòuyǒuxiēxiāoyǒng

Then fire burned our barren hill and my substance was lost; and the Tang monk's disciple is a stout fellow besides.

家私 is household goods. Notice that he calls the burnt monastery 荒山, our barren hill — the self-deprecating style in which an abbot properly refers to his own house.

luànmángzhōngxiàdōuxúnjiànyuánláishìwángdehóngshōuláiláijiàn。」 luànmángzhōngxiàdōuxúnjiànyuánláishìwángdehóngshōuláiláijiàn。」

In all that confusion we searched on every side and could not find it. So it was the Great King's abundant fortune that gathered it in — and therefore I have come expressly to see it."

洪福收來, your abundant good fortune gathered it in: a phrase that converts a theft into a stroke of luck and compliments the thief on it. reads dōu.


總評 Commentary

The impersonation is a triumph of observation: the Pilgrim can wear the abbot because he looked at him closely enough to despise him. What he walks into is not a lair. It is a house — courtyard, second gate, inscribed couplet, third gate, painted beams, a host in ramie silk who comes down his own steps to meet a guest, and tea taken in the right order. 見畢而坐坐定而茶。 The bear-fiend does everything right.

And in the middle of all the ceremony he says the true thing. 這袈裟本是唐僧的 — this cassock belongs by right to the Tang monk. The thief knows whose it is; the abbot who died for it did not care; and the disciple who has come to steal it back is at this moment impersonating the dead man. Guanyin will observe later that the bear has 道分, a portion of the Way. The couplet on his second gate has already said as much, and the Pilgrim, alone in the courtyard a moment ago, had already agreed: 這廝也是個脫垢離塵知命的怪物