Canonical Classics ← 第四回
第四回
guānfēngxīn
míngzhùtiānwèiníng

Appointed Bìmǎwēn, His Heart Finds It Not Enough · His Name Listed Equal to Heaven, His Will Is Still Unstilled

天門受阻
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

天門受阻 Barred at Heaven's Gate

tàibáijīnxīngměihóuwángtóngchūledòngtiānshēnchùjiàyúnéryuánláikōngjīndǒuyúnzhòngtóngshífēnkuàijīnxīngpiēzàinǎohòuxiānzhìnántiānménwàizhèngshōuyúnqiánjìnbèizēngzhǎngtiānwánglǐngzhepángliúgǒudèngxīnzhāngtáotiāndīngqiāngdāojiàndǎngzhùtiānménkěnfàngjìnhóuwángdào:「zhèjīnxīnglǎoérnǎijiānzhàzhīqǐnglǎosūnjiàoréndòngdāodòngqiāngmén?」zhèngrǎngjiānjīnxīngshūdàokōngjiù覿miànhěndào:「zhèlǎoérzěnmehǒngbèishuōfèngzhāoānzhǐláiqǐngquèzěnmejiàozhèxiērénzhùtiānménfànglǎosūnjìn?」jīnxīngxiàodào:「wángláiwèicéngdàotiāntángquèyòumíngzhòngtiāndīngyòuxiāngshízěnkěnfàngshànděngjīnjiànletiānzūnshòulexiānzhùleguānmíngxiànghòusuíchūshuídǎng?」kōngdào:「zhèděngshuōjìnle。」jīnxīngyòuyòngshǒuchězhùdào:「háitóngjìn。」jiāngjìntiānménjīnxīnggāojiàodào:「tiānméntiānjiàngxiǎobīngfàngkāizhěnǎixiàjièxiānrénfèngshèngzhǐxuānlái。」zēngzhǎngtiānwángzhòngtiāndīngcáiliǎnbīng退tuìhóuwángshǐxìnyántóngjīnxīnghuǎnguānkànzhēnshìtàibáijīnxīngměihóuwángtóngchūledòngtiānshēnchùjiàyúnéryuánláikōngjīndǒuyúnzhòngtóngshífēnkuàijīnxīngpiēzàinǎohòuxiānzhìnántiānménwàizhèngshōuyúnqiánjìnbèizēngzhǎngtiānwánglǐngzhepángliúgǒudèngxīnzhāngtáotiāndīngqiāngdāojiàndǎngzhùtiānménkěnfàngjìnhóuwángdào:「zhèjīnxīnglǎoérnǎijiānzhàzhīqǐnglǎosūnjiàoréndòngdāodòngqiāngmén?」zhèngrǎngjiānjīnxīngshūdàokōngjiùmiànhěndào:「zhèlǎoérzěnmehǒngbèishuōfèngzhāoānzhǐláiqǐngquèzěnmejiàozhèxiērénzhùtiānménfànglǎosūnjìn?」jīnxīngxiàodào:「wángláiwèicéngdàotiāntángquèyòumíngzhòngtiāndīngyòuxiāngshízěnkěnfàngshànděngjīnjiànletiānzūnshòulexiānzhùleguānmíngxiànghòusuíchūshuídǎng?」kōngdào:「zhèděngshuōjìnle。」jīnxīngyòuyòngshǒuchězhùdào:「háitóngjìn。」jiāngjìntiānménjīnxīnggāojiàodào:「tiānméntiānjiàngxiǎobīngfàngkāizhěnǎixiàjièxiānrénfèngshèngzhǐxuānlái。」zēngzhǎngtiānwángzhòngtiāndīngcáiliǎnbīng退tuìhóuwángshǐxìnyántóngjīnxīnghuǎnguānkànzhēnshì


逐句解 Line by line

tàibáijīnxīngměihóuwángtóngchūledòngtiānshēnchùjiàyúnér tàibáijīnxīngměihóuwángtóngchūledòngtiānshēnchùjiàyúnér

The Star-Lord of Venus and the Handsome Monkey King came forth together from the depths of the grotto-heaven and rose as one upon the clouds.

洞天 (dòngtiān, “grotto-heaven”) is the Daoist term for a sacred cave-world; the thirty-six 洞天 were imagined as self-contained paradises linking earth to the heavens. The epithet 美猴王 (“Handsome Monkey King”) is Wukong's title from chapter 1, carried here as he ascends in apparent glory.

yuánláikōngjīndǒuyúnzhòngtóngshífēnkuàijīnxīngpiēzàinǎohòuxiānzhìnántiānménwài yuánláikōngjīndǒuyúnzhòngtóngshífēnkuàijīnxīngpiēzàinǎohòuxiānzhìnántiānménwài

Now Wukong's somersault cloud was unlike the others' — so swift that it flung the Star-Lord far behind, and he reached the gate of the Southern Heaven first.

The 觔斗雲 (jīndǒu yún, “somersault cloud”), learned from Patriarch Subhūti, will later be said to span 108,000 li at a single leap; is a variant of (jīn). His outstripping of his escort quietly marks the distance between raw attainment and Heaven's ordered ranks.

zhèngshōuyúnqiánjìnbèizēngzhǎngtiānwánglǐngzhepángliúgǒudèngxīnzhāngtáotiāndīngqiāngdāojiàndǎngzhùtiānménkěnfàngjìn zhèngshōuyúnqiánjìnbèizēngzhǎngtiānwánglǐngzhepángliúgǒudèngxīnzhāngtáotiāndīngqiāngdāojiàndǎngzhùtiānménkěnfàngjìn

Just as he meant to rein in his cloud and press ahead, Heavenly King Virūḍhaka, leading the mighty heavenly troops — Páng, Liú, Gǒu, Bì, Dèng, Xīn, Zhāng, and Táo — with spears, sabers, swords, and halberds, blocked the gate and would not let him pass.

增長天王 (Zēngzhǎng; Skt. Virūḍhaka) is the Guardian King of the South among the 四大天王 — here is zhǎng, “to increase.” The eight surnames 龐、劉、苟、畢、鄧、辛、張、陶 name the dàlì tiāndīng, mighty celestial soldiers later linked in Daoist ritual to the marshals of the Thunder Department (雷部).

hóuwángdào:「zhèjīnxīnglǎoérnǎijiānzhàzhīqǐnglǎosūnjiàoréndòngdāodòngqiāngmén?」 hóuwángdào:「zhèjīnxīnglǎoérnǎijiānzhàzhīqǐnglǎosūnjiàoréndòngdāodòngqiāngmén?」

The Monkey King said, “This Star-Lord is a crafty old schemer! He himself summoned me — so why has he set men here to brandish blade and spear and bar my way?”

老兒 (lǎo'ér) is colloquial for “old fellow / old codger,” faintly contemptuous; the is the full syllable ér (the nominal “one/fellow”), not the northern diminutive -suffix. is causative jiào, “to make / have someone do.”

zhèngrǎngjiānjīnxīngshūdào zhèngrǎngjiānjīnxīngshūdào

In the midst of his shouting, the Star-Lord arrived in a flash.

(shū), “in a flash” — the Star-Lord materializes the instant Wukong's temper boils over.

kōngjiù覿miànhěndào:「zhèlǎoérzěnmehǒngbèishuōfèngzhāoānzhǐláiqǐngquèzěnmejiàozhèxiērénzhùtiānménfànglǎosūnjìn?」 kōngjiùmiànhěndào:「zhèlǎoérzěnmehǒngbèishuōfèngzhāoānzhǐláiqǐngquèzěnmejiàozhèxiērénzhùtiānménfànglǎosūnjìn?」

Wukong rounded on him face to face and said hotly, “You old codger — how dare you trick me? You said you came bearing the Jade Emperor's edict of amnesty to summon me, so why have you set these men to bar the gate of Heaven and keep me out?”

覿面 (dímiàn) is “face to face, head-on.” 招安 (zhāo'ān) is the set term for an imperial offer of amnesty-and-office to a rebel or outlaw — the very device by which Heaven keeps trying to absorb Wukong rather than destroy him.

jīnxīngxiàodào:「wángláiwèicéngdàotiāntángquèyòumíngzhòngtiāndīngyòuxiāngshízěnkěnfàngshànděngjīnjiànletiānzūnshòulexiānzhùleguānmíngxiànghòusuíchūshuídǎng?」 jīnxīngxiàodào:「wángláiwèicéngdàotiāntángquèyòumíngzhòngtiāndīngyòuxiāngshízěnkěnfàngshànděngjīnjiànletiānzūnshòulexiānzhùleguānmíngxiànghòusuíchūshuídǎng?」

The Star-Lord said with a smile, “Calm your anger, Great King. You have never come to this heavenly hall before; you have no name upon its rolls, and the heavenly troops have never met you — how could they let you barge in? Once you have seen the Most Honored One, received your immortal's register, and had your office entered, you may come and go as you please thereafter, and who would bar you then?”

仙籙 (xiānlù) is a register of immortals, a Daoist investiture document; to be “entered on the rolls” is to gain celestial standing and the right of passage. 天尊 (“Most Honored”) here designates the Jade Emperor. The Star-Lord's reasoning is purely bureaucratic: in Heaven, power without registration is illegitimate.

kōngdào:「zhèděngshuōjìnle。」 kōngdào:「zhèděngshuōjìnle。」

Wukong said, “Put that way — fine. I won't go in.”

也罷 (yěbà), “so be it, then” — a petulant climb-down. 不進: by sandhi before the fourth-tone .

jīnxīngyòuyòngshǒuchězhùdào:「háitóngjìn。」 jīnxīngyòuyòngshǒuchězhùdào:「háitóngjìn。」

The Star-Lord caught hold of his hand again and said, “Come in along with me, won't you.”

here is hái (“come now, after all”), not huán; the coaxing tug — half command, half cajolery — breaks the standoff.

jiāngjìntiānménjīnxīnggāojiàodào:「tiānméntiānjiàngxiǎobīngfàngkāizhěnǎixiàjièxiānrénfèngshèngzhǐxuānlái。」 jiāngjìntiānménjīnxīnggāojiàodào:「tiānméntiānjiàngxiǎobīngfàngkāizhěnǎixiàjièxiānrénfèngshèngzhǐxuānlái。」

Nearing the gate, the Star-Lord called out loudly, “You gate-wardens, generals, and officers great and small — clear the way! This is an immortal of the lower world; I come by the Jade Emperor's holy command to usher him in.”

The announcement is a credential-check made aloud: 下界仙人 (“an immortal of the lower world”) plus 玉帝聖旨 (“the Jade Emperor's command”) together license entry. in 天將 is jiàng, “general.”

zēngzhǎngtiānwángzhòngtiāndīngcáiliǎnbīng退tuì zēngzhǎngtiānwángzhòngtiāndīngcáiliǎnbīng退tuì

Only then did Heavenly King Virūḍhaka and the host of troops draw back their weapons and stand aside.

俱才 (jùcái), “only then did they all” — the troops stand down not for Wukong but for the edict he now visibly travels under.

hóuwángshǐxìnyántóngjīnxīnghuǎnguānkàn hóuwángshǐxìnyántóngjīnxīnghuǎnguānkàn

The Monkey King, now trusting his words, stepped slowly inside alongside the Star-Lord to take it all in.

緩步, “with measured steps” — the swagger of the somersault yields to a guarded, deliberate entry.

zhēnshì zhēnshì

And truly it was a sight to behold —

真個是 (“and truly it was —”) is the standard vernacular formula that ushers in a set-piece description; here it opens onto the rhapsody on the courts of Heaven that follows.


總評 Commentary

This chapter stands under the couplet 官封弼馬心何足,名注齊天意未寧 — “Appointed Bìmǎwēn, how could his heart be content; / his name enrolled as Equal to Heaven, his will is still unquiet.” The two lines announce the chapter's two movements, the menial post of stable-keeper and the grand-sounding title that follows, and both close on dissatisfaction (何足, 未寧). The real subject is not Wukong's defeat but the impossibility of buying off an appetite with rank: each office Heaven extends only sharpens the want it was meant to quiet.

The opening scene stages that theme in miniature at the gate of Heaven. Wukong's somersault cloud flings his escort behind him — raw attainment outrunning office — yet at the threshold sheer power counts for nothing: he is 無名, without a name on the rolls, and is barred. The Star-Lord's remedy is pure procedure: see the sovereign, receive the 仙籙, have the office entered, and the gates open of themselves. As Andrew Plaks notes of the novel's celestial machinery, Heaven is imagined as an empire of registers and ranks; the monkey who struck his name from the ledgers of death in the previous chapter must now consent to be written into the ledgers of office before he may pass.

Read inwardly, the episode tracks the 心猿 (“mind-monkey”) at the moment it seeks admission to a higher order. The cloud that overshoots its guide figures an unschooled mind whose speed outstrips its discipline; the closed gate is the resistance that ungoverned spirit meets when it would force its own way upward. 招安 — amnesty joined to investiture — is Heaven's wager that a restless faculty can be domesticated by station rather than subdued by force. The rest of the chapter tests that wager and finds it wanting: a title is not a transformation, and the mind-monkey cannot be stilled by a seal.