Canonical Classics ← 第四回
第四回
guānfēngxīn
míngzhùtiānwèiníng

Appointed Bìmǎwēn, His Heart Finds It Not Enough · His Name Listed Equal to Heaven, His Will Is Still Unstilled

神兵鏖戰
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

神兵鏖戰 A Clash of Weapons

liùzhātàiliùzhātài
tiānshēngměishíhóuwángtiānshēngměishíhóuwáng
xiāngféngzhēnduìshǒuxiāngféngzhēnduìshǒu
zhèngběnyuánliúzhèngběnyuánliú
méngchāiláixiàjièméngchāiláixiàjiè
zhèxīnnàodǒuniúzhèxīnnàodǒuniú
zhǎnyāobǎojiànfēngmángkuàizhǎnyāobǎojiànfēngmángkuài
kǎnyāodāohěnguǐshénchóukǎnyāodāohěnguǐshénchóu
yāosuǒzifēimǎngyāosuǒzifēimǎng
xiángyāochǔlángtóuxiángyāochǔlángtóu
huǒlúnchèdiànhōnghōngyànhuǒlúnchèdiànhōnghōngyàn
wǎngwǎngláiláigǔnxiùqiúwǎngwǎngláiláigǔnxiùqiú
shèngsāntiáobàngshèngsāntiáobàng
qiánzhēhòudǎngyùnmóuqiánzhēhòudǎngyùnmóu
zhēngshùgāoxiàzhēngshùgāoxià
tàixīnzhōngkěnxiūtàixīnzhōngkěnxiū
liùjiànbīngduōjiàobiànliùjiànbīngduōjiàobiàn
bǎiqiānwànzhàotóudiūbǎiqiānwàn亿zhàotóudiū
hóuwángxiàohóuwángxiào
tiěbàngfānténgyùnchóutiěbàngfānténgyùnchóu
huàqiānqiānhuàwànhuàqiānqiānhuàwàn
滿mǎnkōngluànsàifēiqiúmǎnkōngluànsàifēiqiú
xiàdedòngyāowángdōuxiàdedòngyāowángdōu
biànshānguǐguàijìncángtóubiànshānguǐguàijìncángtóu
shénbīngyúncǎncǎnshénbīngyúncǎncǎn
jīntiěbàngxiǎngsōusōujīntiěbàngxiǎngsōusōu
xiāngtiāndīnghǎnrénrénxiāngtiāndīnghǎnrénrén
zhèxiānghóuguàiyáoyōuzhèxiānghóuguàiyáoyōu
hěnliǎngjiādòuyǒnghěnliǎngjiādòuyǒng
zhīgāngqiángróuzhīgāngqiángróu

逐句解 Line by line

liùzhātài liùzhātài

Six-armed Prince Nezha,

The poem opens by naming the two of them side by side — 六臂哪吒 against the 美石猴王 — before either does anything. The pairing is the argument.

tiānshēngměishíhóuwáng tiānshēngměishíhóuwáng

the heaven-born Handsome-Stone Monkey King —

is shí, stone. 天生美石猴王 packs an entire origin story into six characters: heaven-born, of fine stone, monkey, king. That efficiency is what lets the poem spend the rest of its length on the fight.

xiāngféngzhēnduìshǒu xiāngféngzhēnduìshǒu

meeting, a true match for each other,

真對手, "a true match," and 本源流, "their very source" — the couplet frames the duel as a meeting of equals before a blow lands.

zhèngběnyuánliú zhèngběnyuánliú

they had found their very source and stream.

本源流 is source and current in one word. The line claims the two of them come from the same origin, which for a heaven-born stone and a god's son is a considerable claim, and the poem never explains it.

méngchāiláixiàjiè méngchāiláixiàjiè

That one, sent down by command to the lower world;

A contrast of motives: 蒙差來下界, sent down under orders, against 欺心鬧斗牛, overweening and troubling the stars. 那一個 and 這一個 both take before ; 斗牛 is the Dipper and the Ox.

zhèxīnnàodǒuniú zhèxīnnàodǒuniú

this one, with overweening heart, troubling the very stars.

is dǒu, the Dipper, and 斗牛 names two of the twenty-eight lunar mansions — a patch of sky, not livestock. 欺心 is literally "to cheat one's own heart," the self-deceiving arrogance the novel reserves for Wukong at his worst.

zhǎnyāobǎojiànfēngmángkuài zhǎnyāobǎojiànfēngmángkuài

The demon-beheading sword, its edge keen,

Nezha's six weapons are now itemised in matched pairs: sword and sabre here, rope and pestle next, fire-wheel and embroidered ball to close.

kǎnyāodāohěnguǐshénchóu kǎnyāodāohěnguǐshénchóu

the demon-hacking saber so fierce that gods and ghosts grieved;

carries the ferocity and the consequence. The sabre is described by what it does to the spirits watching, not to the body it hits.

yāosuǒzifēimǎng yāosuǒzifēimǎng

the demon-binding rope like a flying python,

索子 takes as the light, unstressed zi; the in the next line is ; 降妖 takes as xiáng.

xiángyāochǔlángtóu xiángyāochǔlángtóu

the demon-quelling pestle like a wolf's head;

is xiáng, to subdue — not the jiàng of descending, though the character is the same. The pestle is likened to a wolf's head, the only animal figure among the six weapons that is a predator rather than an ornament.

huǒlúnchèdiànhōnghōngyàn huǒlúnchèdiànhōnghōngyàn

the fire-wheel flashing lightning, blazing bright,

掣電, "flashing lightning" ( is chè), and 烘烘艷, blazing bright.

wǎngwǎngláiláigǔnxiùqiú wǎngwǎngláiláigǔnxiùqiú

and to and fro the embroidered ball came rolling.

往往來來 doubles both halves of a coming-and-going, so the ball gets a rhythm rather than a path. It is the least warlike thing in the arsenal, and the poem saves it for last.

shèngsāntiáobàng shèngsāntiáobàng

The Great Sage's three As-You-Will cudgels,

Six weapons on one side; on the other, three cudgels — 前遮後擋 warding front and blocking back, and 運機謀, plied with stratagem.

qiánzhēhòudǎngyùnmóu qiánzhēhòudǎngyùnmóu

warding front and blocking back, plied with stratagem.

運機謀 sets calculation against equipment. Nezha gets an inventory; Wukong gets a defence described entirely in terms of thinking.

zhēngshùgāoxià zhēngshùgāoxià

They fought hard, bout after bout, with neither above the other,

數合無高下, "bout after bout, neither above the other" — is a round of combat, the unit these novels count fights in. 不肯 in the next line takes before the dipping tone of .

tàixīnzhōngkěnxiū tàixīnzhōngkěnxiū

and the prince in his heart would not give up.

keeps its full literary in 太子, as it does at almost every occurrence in this edition, and is zhōng. 不肯休, "would not give up," is the first hint that skill is not going to settle this.

liùjiànbīngduōjiàobiàn liùjiànbīngduōjiàobiàn

He took his six weapons and made them all transform —

And so it escalates. 把那六件兵器多教變 is causative jiào, "made them all transform" — into 百千萬億, hundreds of millions, raining down.

bǎiqiānwànzhàotóudiū bǎiqiānwàn亿zhàotóudiū

by the hundreds, thousands, millions, hurled at the head.

照頭丟 points the entire multiplied arsenal at one target, the head. After three numerals of escalating size, the line ends on the plainest possible verb.

hóuwángxiào hóuwángxiào

The Monkey King, unafraid, laughed aloud,

不懼 takes before the falling tone of . The monkey answers multiplication with multiplication, and does it laughing.

tiěbàngfānténgyùnchóu tiěbàngfānténgyùnchóu

his iron cudgel tumbling and turning at his own command.

運籌 is the general's word for laying plans, and it answers 運機謀 six lines earlier — the same verb, promoted from defence to command.

huàqiānqiānhuàwàn huàqiānqiānhuàwàn

From one he made a thousand, from a thousand ten thousand,

以一化千千化萬, "from one a thousand, from a thousand ten thousand"; takes before the falling tone of . 賽飛虯 is "rivalling flying dragons."

滿mǎnkōngluànsàifēiqiú mǎnkōngluànsàifēiqiú

filling the sky with their wild dance, rivaling soaring dragons.

keeps its single value, to rival. A is a dragon of the lesser sort; the old glossaries disagree over whether it has horns, so "flying dragon" is the safe rendering. By this point the cudgels are numerous enough to be described as weather rather than as weapons.

xiàdedòngyāowángdōu xiàdedòngyāowángdōu

So frightened that the demon-kings of every cave shut their doors,

諕得, "so frightened that" — is xià, a variant writing of , to frighten. The fight is now emptying the mountain, and these are Wukong's own allies.

biànshānguǐguàijìncángtóu biànshānguǐguàijìncángtóu

and across the mountain the goblins all hid their heads.

is cáng, to hide. 盡藏頭 clears the mountain of its own inhabitants: this has become something even the monkeys will not watch.

shénbīngyúncǎncǎn shénbīngyúncǎncǎn

The divine soldiers' fury, clouds grim and dark;

慘慘 and 颼颼 — grim clouds and whistling iron. The doubled syllables carry the gloom of the field and its noise, one to a line.

jīntiěbàngxiǎngsōusōu jīntiěbàngxiǎngsōusōu

the gold-banded iron cudgel whistling and whirring.

颼颼 is the whistle of something moving fast through air, and it is the only sound in a passage otherwise built entirely from sights. The gold band on the cudgel is named here for the first time since the poem began.

xiāngtiāndīnghǎnrénrén xiāngtiāndīnghǎnrénrén

On that side, the heavenly troops shouted, and every man afraid;

The two camps are set in strict parallel: 那壁廂, "on that side," the heavenly troops afraid, and 這壁廂, "on this side," the monkey-fiends anxious. Both armies are frightened of their own champion.

zhèxiānghóuguàiyáoyōu zhèxiānghóuguàiyáoyōu

on this side, the monkey-fiends waved flags, and every one anxious.

個個憂 spreads the anxiety across every individual, where the matching line gave the heavenly side one collective fear. The monkeys are more frightened, and more specifically so.

hěnliǎngjiādòuyǒng hěnliǎngjiādòuyǒng

Roused to fury, the two sides vied in valor alike,

The poem closes on a balance it refuses to break: 不知那個剛強那個柔, "none could tell which was stronger, which softer." Both instances of 那個 are the question word nǎ gè; 不知 takes .

zhīgāngqiángróu zhīgāngqiángróu

and none could tell which was the stronger, which the softer.

Both occurrences of are the questioning , and is qiáng. The poem ends with no result at all — and 剛強 against , hard against yielding, is the old Daoist pair. Declining to choose between them is the whole point.


總評 Commentary

The battle poem is the longest of the chapter's six and its climax, and it is built — like the duel poem before it — on relentless parallels, but to the opposite end. Where the Mighty-Spirit fight tilted every couplet Wukong's way and resolved in one deflating tap, the Nezha fight holds its pairs in perfect balance: weapon answers weapon, multiplication answers multiplication (百千萬億 against 以一化千千化萬), and the verse arrives not at a verdict but at a deadlock — 不知那個剛強那個柔, none could tell which was stronger, which softer.

What the poem stages is the 心猿 meeting its match in kind. Nezha's 三頭六臂 and proliferating weapons are the arsenal of a sanctioned god; Wukong reproduces the same multiplicity out of a single cudgel, and the two of them fill the sky with copies until the heavens go grim and both armies hide. The image is almost a creation myth — 以一化千, the One generating the many — and it is precisely here that brute combat runs out of road. Equals cannot settle anything by force. The deadlock the verse balances so carefully is the structural sign that Wukong will not be beaten in the field at all, and the chapter title has been saying so from the start: this rebellion ends not in defeat but in the granting, and the hollowing, of a name.