Canonical Classics ← 第六回
第六回
kuángjīnzāoxíngxiàn
yīngxiónggàiděngshíxiū

Deceived and wronged, now suffering under the law · The hero's spirit and determination are put to the test

淨瓶與金鋼琢
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

淨瓶與金鋼琢 The Vase and the Diamond Bangle

kāikǒuduìlǎojūnshuō:「pínsēngsuǒèrlángshénguǒyǒushéntōngshèngwéikùnzhǐshìwèiqínjīnzhùgōngjuézhù。」lǎojūndào:「jiāngshénbīngzěnmezhù?」dào:「jiāngjìngpíngyángliǔpāoxiàhóutóunéngdiējiàoèrlángxiǎoshènghǎo。」lǎojūndào:「zhèpíngshìnéngzháo便biànhǎozháodetóuhuòzhuàngzháodetiěbàngquèsuìleqiědòngshǒuděnglǎojūnzhùgōng。」dào:「yǒushénmebīng?」lǎojūndào:「yǒuyǒuyǒu。」luōxiùzuǒshàngxiàquānzishuōdào:「zhèjiànbīngnǎikūngāngtuánliàndebèijiānghuándāndiǎnchéngyǎngjiùshēnlíngshànnéngbiànhuàshuǐhuǒqīnyòunéngtàozhūmíngjīngāngzhuó』,yòumíngjīngāngtào』。dāngniánguòhánguānhuàwéishènshìkuīzǎowǎnzuìfángshēnděngdiūxiàxià。」kāikǒuduìlǎojūnshuō:「pínsēngsuǒèrlángshénguǒyǒushéntōngshèngwéikùnzhǐshìwèiqínjīnzhùgōngjuézhù。」lǎojūndào:「jiāngshénbīngzěnmezhù?」dào:「jiāngjìngpíngyángliǔpāoxiàhóutóunéngdiējiàoèrlángxiǎoshènghǎo。」lǎojūndào:「zhèpíngshìnéngzháo便biànhǎozháodetóuhuòzhuàngzháodetiěbàngquèsuìleqiědòngshǒuděnglǎojūnzhùgōng。」dào:「yǒushénmebīng?」lǎojūndào:「yǒuyǒuyǒu。」luōxiùzuǒshàngxiàquānzishuōdào:「zhèjiànbīngnǎikūngāngtuánliàndebèijiānghuándāndiǎnchéngyǎngjiùshēnlíngshànnéngbiànhuàshuǐhuǒqīnyòunéngtàozhūmíngjīngāngzhuó』,yòumíngjīngāngtào』。dāngniánguòhánguānhuàwéishènshìkuīzǎowǎnzuìfángshēnděngdiūxiàxià。」


逐句解 Line by line

kāikǒuduìlǎojūnshuō:「pínsēngsuǒèrlángshénguǒyǒushéntōngshèngwéikùnzhǐshìwèiqín kāikǒuduìlǎojūnshuō:「pínsēngsuǒèrlángshénguǒyǒushéntōngshèngwéikùnzhǐshìwèiqín

The Bodhisattva opened her mouth and said to Lord Lao, "How is this Erlang I recommended? He has real divine power, has hemmed the Great Sage in, only he hasn't yet managed the capture.

所舉, the one I recommended. Guanyin proposed Erlang several passages ago, and she is not above pointing that out — with just enough pride to make her human.

jīnzhùgōngjuézhù。」 jīnzhùgōngjuézhù。」

I'll lend him a hand now, and he'll surely take him."

助他一功, lend him an assist toward the merit. Note the phrasing: the credit is a thing to be shared out afterwards, and she is putting in a claim.

lǎojūndào:「jiāngshénbīngzěnmezhù?」 lǎojūndào:「jiāngshénbīngzěnmezhù?」

Lord Lao asked, "What weapon will the Bodhisattva use? How will you help him?"

甚兵器, what weapon ( is shén, what). Lord Lao's question is polite, and also a gentle challenge — he has something in his sleeve and he knows it.

dào:「jiāngjìngpíngyángliǔpāoxiàhóutóunéngdiējiàoèrlángxiǎoshènghǎo。」 dào:「jiāngjìngpíngyángliǔpāoxiàhóutóunéngdiējiàoèrlángxiǎoshènghǎo。」

The Bodhisattva said, "I'll throw down that pure vase with its willow-sprig and strike the monkey on the head — even if it can't kill him, it'll give him a fall, so the young sage Erlang can take him."

The 淨瓶楊柳, the pure vase and the willow-sprig, are Guanyin's signature implements, and everywhere else in the novel they are instruments of mercy: the vase holds the sweet dew that revives the dead and heals the sick. Here she proposes to drop it on somebody's head.

lǎojūndào:「zhèpíngshìnéngzháo便biànhǎozháodetóuhuòzhuàngzháodetiěbàngquèsuìle lǎojūndào:「zhèpíngshìnéngzháo便biànhǎozháodetóuhuòzhuàngzháodetiěbàngquèsuìle

Lord Lao said, "That vase of yours is porcelain — well and good if it strikes him, but if it misses his head, or hits his iron cudgel, won't it just shatter?

磁器 is porcelain. 打著 and 撞著 are strike home and knock against ( is zháo in both). Lord Lao's objection is entirely practical and quietly devastating: throw china at an iron bar and you will not get your china back. It is also, of course, a boast about what he is holding.

qiědòngshǒuděnglǎojūnzhùgōng。」 qiědòngshǒuděnglǎojūnzhùgōng。」

Don't make a move just yet — let me, old Lao, lend him the hand."

且莫動手, hold off for now. He takes the job over, and the friendly rivalry tips his way.

dào:「yǒushénmebīng?」 dào:「yǒushénmebīng?」

The Bodhisattva asked, "And what weapon do you have?"

Guanyin asks the obvious question, and it sets up the unveiling of one of the novel's most famous objects.

lǎojūndào:「yǒuyǒuyǒu。」 lǎojūndào:「yǒuyǒuyǒu。」

Lord Lao said, "I have, I have, I have."

The thrice-repeated — I have, I have, I have — is a lovely bit of comic relish. You can see the old man patting his sleeve.

luōxiùzuǒshàngxiàquānzishuōdào luōxiùzuǒshàngxiàquānzishuōdào

He pushed up his sleeve, took a bangle off his left upper arm, and said:

捋起衣袖, rolled up his sleeve ( is luō); () is the upper arm; 圈子 is a ring or bangle. He has been wearing the most dangerous weapon in the chapter as jewellery.

zhèjiànbīngnǎikūngāngtuánliàndebèijiānghuándāndiǎnchéngyǎngjiùshēnlíngshànnéngbiànhuàshuǐhuǒqīnyòunéngtàozhū zhèjiànbīngnǎikūngāngtuánliàndebèijiānghuándāndiǎnchéngyǎngjiùshēnlíngshànnéngbiànhuàshuǐhuǒqīnyòunéngtàozhū

"This weapon was forged of fine kun-steel, transmuted by my reverted elixir, nurtured to a body full of numinous force; it can transform at will, is proof against water and fire, and can lasso anything.

錕鋼 (kūn gāng) is a legendary fine steel; 摶煉 (tuán liàn) is kneaded and refined, forged; 還丹 (huán dān) is the reverted cinnabar elixir of inner alchemy. The specification is a product description: fireproof, waterproof, shape-shifting, and able to , to lasso, anything at all. Every one of those properties will matter.

míngjīngāngzhuó』,yòumíngjīngāngtào』。 míngjīngāngzhuó』,yòumíngjīngāngtào』。

It is called the 'Diamond Jade-Cutter,' or else the 'Diamond Snare.'

金鋼琢 (jīn gāng zhuó) is the diamond bangle — (zhuó) being a jade-cutting tool, so the name means something hard enough to cut jade. 金鋼套 is the diamond snare. Two names, two virtues: it cannot be broken, and it catches whatever it is thrown over.

dāngniánguòhánguānhuàwéishènshìkuī dāngniánguòhánguānhuàwéishènshìkuī

In years past, when I passed the Hangu Pass and converted the barbarians into Buddhas, I owed a great deal to it.

An allusion to the old 化胡為佛 legend — converting the barbarians into Buddhas — the Daoist tradition that Laozi, having ridden west out of the Hangu Pass, became the Buddha or taught the western peoples. It is a sectarian claim of some cheek, and he drops it in as a casual reminiscence. 甚是虧他, was much indebted to it ( is shèn, very).

zǎowǎnzuìfángshēnděngdiūxiàxià。」 zǎowǎnzuìfángshēnděngdiūxiàxià。」

It's the best thing for self-defense at any hour. Let me throw it down and give him a knock."

早晚, morning or evening, meaning at any hour; 防身 is to guard oneself. Having described a cosmic weapon, he calls it useful for personal safety — and then throws it.


總評 Commentary

This passage is a small comedy of divine one-upmanship, and a revealing one. Guanyin, who recommended Erlang in the first place, claims a sponsor's pride in his performance and offers to finish the job with her own implements — the 淨瓶楊柳, the pure vase and willow-sprig that are everywhere else in the novel the instruments of her mercy, the vase holding the sweet dew that revives the dead and heals the sick. Here, charmingly, she proposes to use the holy vase as a projectile and bean the monkey on the head. Laozi's objection is gently devastating and entirely practical: the vase is mere porcelain, and if it misses or strikes the iron cudgel it will simply break. The exchange has the texture of two old colleagues competing, with perfect courtesy, over who gets to land the decisive blow — and a quiet joke about the unsuitability of mercy's instruments for the work of force.

Laozi's weapon is the famous 金鋼琢, the Diamond Bangle, and the passage takes care to establish its pedigree, for it becomes one of the novel's recurring marvels. Forged of legendary kun-steel and transmuted by his own reverted elixir, it is fireproof, waterproof, shape-shifting and — crucially — able to lasso anything (套諸物). The detail that it played a part in the old 化胡為佛 legend — the Daoist tradition that Laozi, passing west out of the Hangu Pass, became the Buddha or converted the western peoples — is a sly bit of sectarian mischief on Wú Chéng'ēn's part, folding the Buddhist Guanyin's intervention and the Daoist patriarch's ring into a single scene that quietly asserts Daoism's priority. The two great Ways stand side by side at the gate, and it is the Daoist who throws.

In the allegory, the choice of weapon is meaningful. The mind-monkey could not be beaten by force or caught by speed; even the mirror only located him. What finally subdues him is not a sharper blade but a snare — an object that does not wound but binds, that catches the protean thing and holds it fast. The Diamond Bangle's two names capture the logic exactly: hard as diamond, so the cudgel cannot break it as it would have broken the porcelain vase; and a snare, so it does not kill but encircles. This is the third of the chapter's instruments of subduing, after the rout by stratagem and the all-seeing mirror, and it points forward to the greatest of them: the Buddha's palm, two chapters on, which will not strike the monkey at all but simply close over him. The pattern is consistent and pointed — the restless mind is mastered not by overpowering it but by containing it. (On the 化胡為佛 legend and the Diamond Bangle's later appearances, see the notes; 還丹, the reverted elixir, is a central term of Daoist inner alchemy.)