Canonical Classics ← 第六回
第六回
欺qī誑kuáng今jīn遭zāo刑xíng憲xiàn苦kǔ
英yīng雄xióng氣qì概gài等děng時shí休xiū

Deceived and wronged, now suffering under the law · The hero's spirit and determination are put to the test

敗陣回奏
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

敗陣回奏 The Rout and the Report

這zhè大dà聖shèng與yǔ惠huì岸àn戰zhàn經jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,惠huì岸àn臂bì膊bó酸suān麻má,不bù能néng迎yíng敵dí,虛xū幌huǎng一yì幌huǎng,敗bài陣zhèn而ér走zǒu。大dà聖shèng也yě收shōu了le猴hóu兵bīng,安ān扎zhā在zài洞dòng門mén之zhī外wài。只zhǐ見jiàn天tiān王wáng營yíng門mén外wài,大dà小xiǎo天tiān兵bīng接jiē住zhù了le太tài子zǐ,讓ràng開kāi大dà路lù,徑jìng入rù轅yuán門mén,對duì四sì天tiān王wáng、李lǐ托tuō塔tǎ、哪né吒zhā,氣qì哈hā哈hā的de喘chuǎn息xī未wèi定dìng:「好hǎo大dà聖shèng,好hǎo大dà聖shèng!著zhuó實shí神shén通tōng廣guǎng大dà,孩hái兒ér戰zhàn不bú過guò,又yòu敗bài陣zhèn而ér來lái也yě!」李lǐ天tiān王wáng見jiàn了le心xīn驚jīng,即jí命mìng寫xiě表biǎo求qiú助zhù,便biàn差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng與yǔ木mù吒zhā太tài子zǐ上shàng天tiān啟qǐ奏zòu。二èr人rén當dāng時shí不bù敢gǎn停tíng留liú,闖chuǎng出chū天tiān羅luó地dì網wǎng,駕jià起qǐ瑞ruì靄ǎi祥xiáng雲yún。須xū臾yú,徑jìng至zhì通tōng明míng殿diàn下xià,見jiàn了le四sì大dà天tiān師shī,引yǐn至zhì靈líng霄xiāo寶bǎo殿diàn,呈chéng上shàng表biǎo章zhāng。惠huì岸àn又yòu見jiàn菩pú薩sà施shī禮lǐ。菩pú薩sà道dào:「你nǐ打dǎ探tàn的de如rú何hé?」惠huì岸àn道dào:「始shǐ領lǐng命mìng到dào花huā果guǒ山shān,叫jiào開kāi天tiān羅luó地dì網wǎng門mén,見jiàn了le父fù親qīn,道dào師shī父fù差chāi命mìng之zhī意yì。父fù王wáng道dào:『昨zuó日rì與yǔ那nà猴hóu王wáng戰zhàn了le一yì場cháng,止zhǐ捉zhuō得dé他tā虎hǔ豹bào獅shī象xiàng之zhī類lèi,更gèng未wèi捉zhuō他tā一yí個gè猴hóu精jīng。』正zhèng講jiǎng間jiān,他tā又yòu索suǒ戰zhàn,是shì弟dì子zǐ使shǐ鐵tiě棍gùn與yǔ他tā戰zhàn經jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,不bù能néng取qǔ勝shèng,敗bài走zǒu回huí營yíng。父fù親qīn因yīn此cǐ差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng同tóng弟dì子zǐ上shàng界jiè求qiú助zhù。」菩pú薩sà低dī頭tóu思sī忖cǔn。这zhè大dà圣shèng与yǔ惠huì岸àn战zhàn经jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,惠huì岸àn臂bì膊bó酸suān麻má,不bù能néng迎yíng敌dí,虚xū幌huǎng一yì幌huǎng,败bài阵zhèn而ér走zǒu。大dà圣shèng也yě收shōu了le猴hóu兵bīng,安ān扎zhā在zài洞dòng门mén之zhī外wài。只zhǐ见jiàn天tiān王wáng营yíng门mén外wài,大dà小xiǎo天tiān兵bīng接jiē住zhù了le太tài子zǐ,让ràng开kāi大dà路lù,径jìng入rù辕yuán门mén,对duì四sì天tiān王wáng、李lǐ托tuō塔tǎ、哪né咤zhā,气qì哈hā哈hā的de喘chuǎn息xī未wèi定dìng:「好hǎo大dà圣shèng,好hǎo大dà圣shèng!着zhuó实shí神shén通tōng广guǎng大dà,孩hái儿ér战zhàn不bú过guò,又yòu败bài阵zhèn而ér来lái也yě!」李lǐ天tiān王wáng见jiàn了le心xīn惊jīng,即jí命mìng写xiě表biǎo求qiú助zhù,便biàn差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng与yǔ木mù咤zhā太tài子zǐ上shàng天tiān启qǐ奏zòu。二èr人rén当dāng时shí不bù敢gǎn停tíng留liú,闯chuǎng出chū天tiān罗luó地dì网wǎng,驾jià起qǐ瑞ruì霭ǎi祥xiáng云yún。须xū臾yú,径jìng至zhì通tōng明míng殿diàn下xià,见jiàn了le四sì大dà天tiān师shī,引yǐn至zhì灵líng霄xiāo宝bǎo殿diàn,呈chéng上shàng表biǎo章zhāng。惠huì岸àn又yòu见jiàn菩pú萨sà施shī礼lǐ。菩pú萨sà道dào:「你nǐ打dǎ探tàn的de如rú何hé?」惠huì岸àn道dào:「始shǐ领lǐng命mìng到dào花huā果guǒ山shān,叫jiào开kāi天tiān罗luó地dì网wǎng门mén,见jiàn了le父fù亲qīn,道dào师shī父fù差chāi命mìng之zhī意yì。父fù王wáng道dào:『昨zuó日rì与yǔ那nà猴hóu王wáng战zhàn了le一yì场cháng,止zhǐ捉zhuō得dé他tā虎hǔ豹bào狮shī象xiàng之zhī类lèi,更gèng未wèi捉zhuō他tā一yí个gè猴hóu精jīng。』正zhèng讲jiǎng间jiān,他tā又yòu索suǒ战zhàn,是shì弟dì子zǐ使shǐ铁tiě棍gùn与yǔ他tā战zhàn经jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,不bù能néng取qǔ胜shèng,败bài走zǒu回huí营yíng。父fù亲qīn因yīn此cǐ差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng同tóng弟dì子zǐ上shàng界jiè求qiú助zhù。」菩pú萨sà低dī头tóu思sī忖cǔn。


逐句解 Line by line

這zhè大dà聖shèng與yǔ惠huì岸àn戰zhàn經jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,惠huì岸àn臂bì膊bó酸suān麻má,不bù能néng迎yíng敵dí,虛xū幌huǎng一yì幌huǎng,敗bài陣zhèn而ér走zǒu。 这zhè大dà圣shèng与yǔ惠huì岸àn战zhàn经jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,惠huì岸àn臂bì膊bó酸suān麻má,不bù能néng迎yíng敌dí,虚xū幌huǎng一yì幌huǎng,败bài阵zhèn而ér走zǒu。

The Great Sage and Huiyan fought some fifty or sixty rounds, until Huiyan's arms grew sore and numb and he could fight no more: with a feint of his rod he broke off and fled the field.

五六十合, fifty or sixty bouts (合 is hé, one round of combat), is the conventional count for a duel that is even and going nowhere. 虛幌一幌, a feinting flourish, is the standard move by which a beaten fighter buys himself the half-second to run.

大dà聖shèng也yě收shōu了le猴hóu兵bīng,安ān扎zhā在zài洞dòng門mén之zhī外wài。 大dà圣shèng也yě收shōu了le猴hóu兵bīng,安ān扎zhā在zài洞dòng门mén之zhī外wài。

The Great Sage too called in his monkey troops and made camp outside his cave gate.

安扎 is to pitch camp (扎 is zhā). Having seen off another champion, the monkey does not pursue — he simply plants his troops outside the Water-Curtain Cave and holds the ground.

只zhǐ見jiàn天tiān王wáng營yíng門mén外wài,大dà小xiǎo天tiān兵bīng接jiē住zhù了le太tài子zǐ,讓ràng開kāi大dà路lù,徑jìng入rù轅yuán門mén, 只zhǐ见jiàn天tiān王wáng营yíng门mén外wài,大dà小xiǎo天tiān兵bīng接jiē住zhù了le太tài子zǐ,让ràng开kāi大dà路lù,径jìng入rù辕yuán门mén,

Outside the Heavenly King's camp gate, soldiers great and small received the prince, opened a way for him, and let him straight through the headquarters gate,

The defeated prince is helped in through the lines, the army opening a path and closing protectively behind him.

對duì四sì天tiān王wáng、李lǐ托tuō塔tǎ、哪né吒zhā,氣qì哈hā哈hā的de喘chuǎn息xī未wèi定dìng:「好hǎo大dà聖shèng,好hǎo大dà聖shèng!著zhuó實shí神shén通tōng廣guǎng大dà,孩hái兒ér戰zhàn不bú過guò,又yòu敗bài陣zhèn而ér來lái也yě!」 对duì四sì天tiān王wáng、李lǐ托tuō塔tǎ、哪né咤zhā,气qì哈hā哈hā的de喘chuǎn息xī未wèi定dìng:「好hǎo大dà圣shèng,好hǎo大dà圣shèng!着zhuó实shí神shén通tōng广guǎng大dà,孩hái儿ér战zhàn不bú过guò,又yòu败bài阵zhèn而ér来lái也yě!」

where, before the Four Heavenly Kings, Li the Pagoda-Bearer, and Nezha, panting and still out of breath, he gasped: "What a Great Sage, what a Great Sage! Truly his powers are vast — your son could not best him, and has come back beaten again!"

李托塔, Li the Pagoda-Bearer, is Heavenly King Li under his epithet: he carries a miniature pagoda, which in the legend is how he keeps his own rebellious son Nezha in check. 著實 (zhuó shí) is truly, indeed. Note what Huiyan is actually doing while gasping for breath — praising his enemy.

李lǐ天tiān王wáng見jiàn了le心xīn驚jīng,即jí命mìng寫xiě表biǎo求qiú助zhù,便biàn差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng與yǔ木mù吒zhā太tài子zǐ上shàng天tiān啟qǐ奏zòu。 李lǐ天tiān王wáng见jiàn了le心xīn惊jīng,即jí命mìng写xiě表biǎo求qiú助zhù,便biàn差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng与yǔ木mù咤zhā太tài子zǐ上shàng天tiān启qǐ奏zòu。

Seeing this, Heavenly King Li took fright and at once ordered a memorial written asking for aid, dispatching the Mighty-Strength Demon King together with Prince Mokṣa to report it in Heaven.

The 大力鬼王, the Mighty-Strength Demon King, is a celestial courier-officer. 寫表求助, write a memorial begging help: the general concedes the campaign has failed, and does it in writing, up the chain, in the proper form.

二èr人rén當dāng時shí不bù敢gǎn停tíng留liú,闖chuǎng出chū天tiān羅luó地dì網wǎng,駕jià起qǐ瑞ruì靄ǎi祥xiáng雲yún。 二èr人rén当dāng时shí不bù敢gǎn停tíng留liú,闯chuǎng出chū天tiān罗luó地dì网wǎng,驾jià起qǐ瑞ruì霭ǎi祥xiáng云yún。

The two dared not linger: they burst out through the Heaven-and-Earth nets and rose on auspicious mists and propitious clouds.

瑞靄祥雲, auspicious haze and propitious cloud, is the standard celestial transport — the rolling vapour on which gods commute between Heaven and earth.

須xū臾yú,徑jìng至zhì通tōng明míng殿diàn下xià,見jiàn了le四sì大dà天tiān師shī,引yǐn至zhì靈líng霄xiāo寶bǎo殿diàn,呈chéng上shàng表biǎo章zhāng。 须xū臾yú,径jìng至zhì通tōng明míng殿diàn下xià,见jiàn了le四sì大dà天tiān师shī,引yǐn至zhì灵líng霄xiāo宝bǎo殿diàn,呈chéng上shàng表biǎo章zhāng。

In a moment they reached the foot of the Hall of Communicating Brightness, saw the Four Grand Preceptors, were led to the Treasure Hall of Divine Mists, and presented the memorial.

表章 is a memorial, a formal report to the throne. The plea for help travels exactly the route Guanyin walked at the chapter's opening: antechamber, preceptors, audience hall.

惠huì岸àn又yòu見jiàn菩pú薩sà施shī禮lǐ。 惠huì岸àn又yòu见jiàn菩pú萨sà施shī礼lǐ。

Huiyan then saw the Bodhisattva and made his obeisance.

Huiyan goes to his own mistress before anything else — the scout reporting back to the one who sent him.

菩pú薩sà道dào:「你nǐ打dǎ探tàn的de如rú何hé?」 菩pú萨sà道dào:「你nǐ打dǎ探tàn的de如rú何hé?」

Said the Bodhisattva, "How went your reconnaissance?"

Guanyin asks for the report she commissioned, and the errand of two passages ago closes its frame.

惠huì岸àn道dào:「始shǐ領lǐng命mìng到dào花huā果guǒ山shān,叫jiào開kāi天tiān羅luó地dì網wǎng門mén,見jiàn了le父fù親qīn,道dào師shī父fù差chāi命mìng之zhī意yì。 惠huì岸àn道dào:「始shǐ领lǐng命mìng到dào花huā果guǒ山shān,叫jiào开kāi天tiān罗luó地dì网wǎng门mén,见jiàn了le父fù亲qīn,道dào师shī父fù差chāi命mìng之zhī意yì。

Said Huiyan, "When first I received your command and reached the Mountain of Flowers and Fruit, I had the gate of the Heaven-and-Earth nets opened, saw my father, and conveyed the purport of your charge.

Huiyan begins a faithful, compressed retelling of everything that has happened — one more of the chapter's nested reports. 差命之意 is the intent of the order he was sent with.

父fù王wáng道dào:『昨zuó日rì與yǔ那nà猴hóu王wáng戰zhàn了le一yì場cháng,止zhǐ捉zhuō得dé他tā虎hǔ豹bào獅shī象xiàng之zhī類lèi,更gèng未wèi捉zhuō他tā一yí個gè猴hóu精jīng。』 父fù王wáng道dào:『昨zuó日rì与yǔ那nà猴hóu王wáng战zhàn了le一yì场cháng,止zhǐ捉zhuō得dé他tā虎hǔ豹bào狮shī象xiàng之zhī类lèi,更gèng未wèi捉zhuō他tā一yí个gè猴hóu精jīng。』

My royal father said, 'Yesterday we fought the Monkey King a bout, and caught only the likes of his tigers, leopards, lions, and elephants — we did not take so much as one monkey-spirit.'

Now a report inside a report: Huiyan quotes his father's words back to Guanyin verbatim. The tally of captured beasts and no monkeys echoes Heavenly King Li's own lament, and loses none of its sting in the retelling.

正zhèng講jiǎng間jiān,他tā又yòu索suǒ戰zhàn,是shì弟dì子zǐ使shǐ鐵tiě棍gùn與yǔ他tā戰zhàn經jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,不bù能néng取qǔ勝shèng,敗bài走zǒu回huí營yíng。 正zhèng讲jiǎng间jiān,他tā又yòu索suǒ战zhàn,是shì弟dì子zǐ使shǐ铁tiě棍gùn与yǔ他tā战zhàn经jīng五wǔ六liù十shí合hé,不bù能néng取qǔ胜shèng,败bài走zǒu回huí营yíng。

While we were still speaking, he came demanding battle again; so your disciple took up the iron rod and fought him fifty or sixty rounds, but could not prevail, and fled back to camp defeated.

索戰 is to demand combat, to press for a fight. Note that Huiyan reports his own defeat plainly and without excuse — no bad luck, no unfair advantage, just could not prevail and ran.

父fù親qīn因yīn此cǐ差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng同tóng弟dì子zǐ上shàng界jiè求qiú助zhù。」 父fù亲qīn因yīn此cǐ差chāi大dà力lì鬼guǐ王wáng同tóng弟dì子zǐ上shàng界jiè求qiú助zhù。」

For this reason my father dispatched the Mighty-Strength Demon King with your disciple to the upper realm to beg for help."

The report ends where the scene began, with the appeal for reinforcement now sitting in front of both the Jade Emperor and Guanyin.

菩pú薩sà低dī頭tóu思sī忖cǔn。 菩pú萨sà低dī头tóu思sī忖cǔn。

The Bodhisattva bowed her head and pondered.

低頭思忖, bowed her head and reflected. A quiet beat, and a loaded one: what comes out of this silence, in the next passage, is the name that decides the chapter.


總評 Commentary

This passage closes the Huiyan episode and turns the chapter toward its solution. Structurally it completes a small arc begun two passages back — the scout was sent, the scout fought, the scout returns to report — and his return is staged as the mirror image of his departure: back up through the nets, the auspicious clouds, the Hall of Communicating Brightness, to the very throne-hall where Guanyin sits. The symmetry is deliberate, and it lets the chapter measure its own failure. A second champion has tried the monkey, and a second champion has come back beaten.

The heart of the passage is Huiyan's report to Guanyin, worth pausing over as a specimen of the novel's method. It is a retelling nested two and three deep: Huiyan relates to Guanyin what his father related to him, quoting the Heavenly King word for word (昨日與那猴王戰了一場…). Wú Chéng'ēn uses layered report both for economy — the reader is brought up to date without a fresh scene — and for characterisation. Huiyan states his own defeat without flinching or excusing it (不能取勝,敗走回營), a small mark of the honesty Guanyin cultivates in her disciples, and the contrast with the boastful youth who leapt out of the camp gate is quietly telling.

The passage ends on one charged line — 菩薩低頭思忖, the Bodhisattva bowed her head and pondered — and the whole machinery of the chapter turns on that silence. Heaven's brute force has failed twice over; the question is no longer how to overpower the 心猿 but whom to set against it. Guanyin's reflection is the hinge between the chapter's first movement, the failed assaults, and its second, the coming of Erlang. Fittingly the turn comes not from the Jade Emperor's court but from the Bodhisattva of Compassion, thinking in silence — the chapter's wager being that the unruly mind is mastered less by the machinery of power than by a subtler kind of discernment. (For Heavenly King Li and Nezha, and the legend behind the epithet Pagoda-Bearer, see Chapter 4 and the traditional Nezha cycle.)