Canonical Classics ← 第六回
第六回
kuángjīnzāoxíngxiàn
yīngxiónggàiděngshíxiū

Deceived and wronged, now suffering under the law · The hero's spirit and determination are put to the test

廟宇已姓孫了
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

廟宇已姓孫了 The Temple Has Changed Its Name

quèshuōshèngzhìguànjiāngkǒuyáoshēnbiànbiànzuòèrlángyedeyàngànxiàyúntóujìngmiàoguǐpànnéngxiāngrèntóuyíngjiēzuòzhōngjiāndiǎncháxiānghuǒjiànbàihuándesānshēngzhānglóngxiàdebǎozhàojiǎqiúzidewénshūqiánbǐnggàobìngdeliángyuànzhèngkànchùyǒurénbào:「yòuyeláile。」zhòngguǐpànguānkànjīngxīnzhēnjūnquèdào:「yǒushénmetiānshèngcáiláizhèfǒu?」zhòngguǐpàndào:「céngjiànshénmeshèngzhǐyǒuyezàimiànchádiǎnli。」zhēnjūnzhuàngjìnménshèngjiànlexiànchūběnxiàngdào:「lángjūnxiāorǎngmiàoxìngsūnle。」zhèzhēnjūnsānjiānliǎngrènshénfēngliǎnjiùkǎnhóuwáng使shǐshēnràngguòshénfēngchèchūxiùhuāzhēnérhuǎnghuǎngwǎnláigǎndàoqiánduìmiànxiānghuánliǎngrǎngrǎngnàonàochūmiàoménbànbànyúnqiěxíngqiězhàndàohuāguǒshānhuāngdetiānwángděngzhòngfángjǐnzhèkāngzhāngtàiwèiděngyíngzhezhēnjūnxīnměihóuwángwéiràoquèshuōshèngzhìguànjiāngkǒuyáoshēnbiànbiànzuòèrlángyedeyàngànxiàyúntóujìngmiàoguǐpànnéngxiāngrèntóuyíngjiēzuòzhōngjiāndiǎncháxiānghuǒjiànbàihuándesānshēngzhānglóngxiàdebǎozhàojiǎqiúzidewénshūqiánbǐnggàobìngdeliángyuànzhèngkànchùyǒurénbào:「yòuyeláile。」zhòngguǐpànguānkànjīngxīnzhēnjūnquèdào:「yǒushénmetiānshèngcáiláizhèfǒu?」zhòngguǐpàndào:「céngjiànshénmeshèngzhǐyǒuyezàimiànchádiǎnli。」zhēnjūnzhuàngjìnménshèngjiànlexiànchūběnxiàngdào:「lángjūnxiāorǎngmiàoxìngsūnle。」zhèzhēnjūnsānjiānliǎngrènshénfēngliǎnjiùkǎnhóuwáng使shǐshēnràngguòshénfēngchèchūxiùhuāzhēnérhuǎnghuǎngwǎnláigǎndàoqiánduìmiànxiānghuánliǎngrǎngrǎngnàonàochūmiàoménbànbànyúnqiěxíngqiězhàndàohuāguǒshānhuāngdetiānwángděngzhòngfángjǐnzhèkāngzhāngtàiwèiděngyíngzhezhēnjūnxīnměihóuwángwéirào


逐句解 Line by line

quèshuōshèngzhìguànjiāngkǒuyáoshēnbiànbiànzuòèrlángyedeyàngànxiàyúntóujìngmiào quèshuōshèngzhìguànjiāngkǒuyáoshēnbiànbiànzuòèrlángyedeyàngànxiàyúntóujìngmiào

Now the Great Sage had already reached Guanjiang Mouth, where he shook himself, transformed into the very likeness of Lord Erlang, brought down his cloud, and walked straight into the temple.

二郎爺爺, His Lordship Erlang, is what the locals call him. And that is what the monkey turns into. He is fleeing to his pursuer's temple wearing his pursuer's face.

guǐpànnéngxiāngrèntóuyíngjiē guǐpànnéngxiāngrèntóuyíngjiē

The ghost-judges could not tell the difference, and one by one kowtowed in welcome.

The 鬼判, the ghost-judges, are the temple's spirit staff. They cannot tell the difference, and kowtow to the impostor exactly as they would to their own god — which is either a tribute to the disguise or a comment on how closely temple staff look at anyone.

zuòzhōngjiāndiǎncháxiānghuǒjiànbàihuándesānshēngzhānglóngxiàdebǎozhàojiǎqiúzidewénshūqiánbǐnggàobìngdeliángyuàn zuòzhōngjiāndiǎncháxiānghuǒjiànbàihuándesānshēngzhānglóngxiàdebǎozhàojiǎqiúzidewénshūqiánbǐnggàobìngdeliángyuàn

Seated in the middle, he reviewed the offerings: the three sacrifices Li Hu had pledged in thanks, the blessing Zhang Long had vowed, the petition Zhao Jia had made for a son, the prayer for recovery from illness submitted by Qian Bing.

A wonderfully concrete catalogue of village piety: 三牲, the three sacrifices, pledged in thanks; a vow of blessing; a petition for a son; a prayer for recovery from illness. And they are filed under deadpan generic names — 李虎 Li the Tiger, 張龍 Zhang the Dragon, 趙甲 Zhao the First, 錢丙 Qian the Third, the last two counted off by the heavenly stems like defendants A and B. Enthroned in a stolen face, the monkey plays the receiving god to the life.

zhèngkànchùyǒurénbào:「yòuyeláile。」 zhèngkànchùyǒurénbào:「yòuyeláile。」

Just as he was looking them over, someone reported, "Another Lordship has arrived!"

The comic pivot. There is a second Erlang at the gate, and the staff are about to meet two identical gods.

zhòngguǐpànguānkànjīngxīn zhòngguǐpànguānkànjīngxīn

The ghost-judges hurried to look, and every one of them was alarmed.

無不驚心, not one of them but was startled. Their panic is the engine of the scene, and entirely reasonable.

zhēnjūnquèdào:「yǒushénmetiānshèngcáiláizhèfǒu?」 zhēnjūnquèdào:「yǒushénmetiānshèngcáiláizhèfǒu?」

But the True Lord asked, "Has some so-called Great Sage Equal to Heaven just come here?"

The real Erlang, arriving, asks after the Great Sage — not yet aware that the Great Sage is sitting on his chair, wearing his face, going through his accounts.

zhòngguǐpàndào:「céngjiànshénmeshèngzhǐyǒuyezàimiànchádiǎnli。」 zhòngguǐpàndào:「céngjiànshénmeshèngzhǐyǒuyezàimiànchádiǎnli。」

The ghost-judges said, "We've seen no Great Sage — there's only a Lordship inside, going over the accounts."

查點 is checking the accounts. The staff's literal-minded honesty is the funniest thing in the passage: there is indeed only one Lordship inside. It simply happens to be the wrong one.

zhēnjūnzhuàngjìnménshèngjiànlexiànchūběnxiàngdào:「lángjūnxiāorǎngmiàoxìngsūnle。」 zhēnjūnzhuàngjìnménshèngjiànlexiànchūběnxiàngdào:「lángjūnxiāorǎngmiàoxìngsūnle。」

The True Lord burst in; the Great Sage, seeing him, resumed his true form and said, "No need to shout, my lord — this temple has changed its name to Sun."

廟宇已姓孫了, the temple now bears the surname Sun — one of the most quoted lines in the chapter, and a perfect piece of squatter's cheek. Chinese temples and family properties are spoken of by the surname that holds them, so the claim is not that he has redecorated but that the deeds have changed hands. 本相 is his true form.

zhèzhēnjūnsānjiānliǎngrènshénfēngliǎnjiùkǎn zhèzhēnjūnsānjiānliǎngrènshénfēngliǎnjiùkǎn

The True Lord at once raised his three-pointed, double-edged blade and slashed straight at his face.

Pleasantries over. Erlang attacks on the instant, and the duel resumes inside the shrine.

hóuwáng使shǐshēnràngguòshénfēng hóuwáng使shǐshēnràngguòshénfēng

The Monkey King used a dodging move and slipped past the divine blade.

身法 is a body-technique, an evasive move — footwork, in effect. Whatever else the chase has cost him, the monkey's agility is untouched.

chèchūxiùhuāzhēnérhuǎnghuǎngwǎnláigǎndàoqiánduìmiànxiānghuán chèchūxiùhuāzhēnérhuǎnghuǎngwǎnláigǎndàoqiánduìmiànxiānghuán

He whipped out the embroidery needle, gave it a shake until it was as thick as a bowl, rushed forward, and struck back face to face.

幌一幌, gave it a shake; 碗來粗細, as thick as a bowl. The embroidery needle is a cudgel again. 相還, struck back ( is xiāng, is huán).

liǎngrǎngrǎngnàonàochūmiàoménbànbànyúnqiěxíngqiězhàndàohuāguǒshān liǎngrǎngrǎngnàonàochūmiàoménbànbànyúnqiěxíngqiězhàndàohuāguǒshān

The two of them, shouting and brawling, fought out the temple gate, half in mist and half in cloud, fighting as they went, and battled all the way back to Flower-Fruit Mountain.

且行且戰, fighting as they went ( is xíng). The running battle carries them from Guanjiang all the way back to Flower-Fruit Mountain, where the entire heavenly host is waiting.

huāngdetiānwángděngzhòngfángjǐn huāngdetiānwángděngzhòngfángjǐn

This threw the Four Heavenly Kings and the rest into alarm, and they tightened their guard all the more.

隄防 (dī fáng) is to guard against, to be on watch. The sudden return of the two combatants startles the besiegers into pulling their ranks tight.

zhèkāngzhāngtàiwèiděngyíngzhezhēnjūnxīnměihóuwángwéirào zhèkāngzhāngtàiwèiděngyíngzhezhēnjūnxīnměihóuwángwéirào

The Marshals Kang and Zhang and the others met the True Lord, and joining their strength, surrounded the Handsome Monkey King — of which no more for now.

迎著, came to meet ( is zhe). 不題 closes the thread and lifts the narrative away from the surrounded monkey to the gods watching from above — where the chapter's ending is about to be decided without him.


總評 Commentary

This is one of the most beloved comic episodes in the novel, and its premise is pure effrontery: the fleeing monkey takes refuge in his pursuer's own temple, disguised as the pursuer himself. Seated on Erlang's altar in Erlang's likeness, he receives the kowtows of the ghost-clerks and gravely reviews the parishioners' offerings — a catalogue of village piety, sacrifices pledged, sons prayed for, illnesses to be cured, filed under the deadpan generic names Li the Tiger, Zhang the Dragon, Zhao the First, Qian the Third. The humour is in the perfect calm of the imposture: the Great Sage, hunted across earth and sky, sits playing the receiving god as though he had all the time in the world, and the joke crystallises in his greeting to the real Erlang — 廟宇已姓孫了, this temple has changed its name to Sun. Squatter's insolence raised to an art.

The episode is also a small masterpiece of the double, a motif Wú Chéng'ēn handles with relish. For a moment there are two identical Erlangs, and the temple staff — honest and literal-minded — cannot tell god from impostor; their flat report that there is only a Lordship inside going over the accounts is funny precisely because it is true. The comedy of indistinguishable doubles has a long life in world literature, but here it carries a particular charge: the monkey has become so complete a master of transformation that he can wear his enemy's identity. Yet the disguise, unlike the shrine, is not a trap but a taunt — he does not try to ambush Erlang, only to occupy his seat and enjoy his discomfiture. When the real Erlang bursts in, the monkey drops the pretence at once and the duel resumes, fought out the temple gate and all the way back to Flower-Fruit Mountain.

Beneath the comedy the chapter is quietly gathering its forces for the end. The running battle returns the monkey to his home mountain, where Heaven's full strength is arrayed — the Four Heavenly Kings, Heavenly King Li with his mirror, the encircling net of celestial troops — and the narrative, with its closing 不題, lifts away from the surrounded fugitive to the watching gods above. The stage is being set for the intervention the chase alone could never accomplish: the monkey cannot be outfought or outrun, and even the mirror only pins down his location. What remains is for a higher power to strike from outside the contest entirely — and in the next passages Guanyin and Laozi, watching from the South Heaven Gate, will debate which of them is to do it. The temple episode is the last moment of the monkey fully in his element, unsubdued and irrepressible, before the descent of Laozi's ring brings the long chase to a close. (On the cult of Erlang at Guanjiang and his temple's ghost-clerks, see the notes on popular religion; the surnames Li, Zhang, Zhao and Qian are the conventional Chinese equivalents of Tom, Dick and Harry.)