Canonical Classics ← 第六回
第六回
kuángjīnzāoxíngxiàn
yīngxiónggàiděngshíxiū

Deceived and wronged, now suffering under the law · The hero's spirit and determination are put to the test

惠岸探營
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

惠岸探營 Huiyan Scouts the Siege

wényánmìnghuìànxíngzhědào:「kuàixiàtiāngōngdàohuāguǒshāntànjūnqíngxiāngjiùxiāngzhùgōngdeshíhuíhuà。」huìànxíngzhězhěngzhěngqúnzhítiáotiěgùnjiàyúnquèjìngzhìshānqiánjiàntiānluówǎngcéngcéngyíngménlínghàojiāngshānwéiràodeshuǐxiètōnghuìànzhùjiào:「yíngméndetiāndīngfánchuánbàonǎitiānwángèrtàizhā──nánhǎiguānyīnhuìànláitànjūnqíng。」yíngyuèshénbīngchuányuánménzhīnèizǎoyǒushǔmǎoxīngfángjiāngyánchuándàozhōngjūnzhàngxiàtiānwángxiàlìngjiàokāitiānluówǎngfàngjìnláishídōngfāngcáiliànghuìànsuíjìnjiàntiānwángtiānwángxiàbàibàitiānwángdào:「háiérxiāngláizhě?」huìàndào:「nánsuípántáohuìjiànshènghuìhuāngliángyáochíyǐnzhòngxiānbìngnánjiànbèiyánwángděngxiàjièshōuyāohóujiànhuíbàoshèngwèizhīyīnmìngnándàotīngshí。」tiānwángdào:「zuódàoānyíngxiàzhàizhuójiǔyàoxīngtiǎozhànbèizhènòngshéntōngjiǔyàoxīngbàizǒuérhuíhòuděngqīnbīngpáikāizhènshìděngshíwàntiānbīnghùnzhànzhìwǎn使shǐfēnshēnzhàn退tuìshōubīngchákānshízhǐzhuōxiēlángchóngbàozhīlèicéngzhuōbànyāohóujīnháiwèichūzhàn。」wényánmìnghuìànxíngzhědào:「kuàixiàtiāngōngdàohuāguǒshāntànjūnqíngxiāngjiùxiāngzhùgōngdeshíhuíhuà。」huìànxíngzhězhěngzhěngqúnzhítiáotiěgùnjiàyúnquèjìngzhìshānqiánjiàntiānluówǎngcéngcéngyíngménlínghàojiāngshānwéiràodeshuǐxiètōnghuìànzhùjiào:「yíngméndetiāndīngfánchuánbàonǎitiānwángèrtàizhā──nánhǎiguānyīnhuìànláitànjūnqíng。」yíngyuèshénbīngchuányuánménzhīnèizǎoyǒushǔmǎoxīngfángjiāngyánchuándàozhōngjūnzhàngxiàtiānwángxiàlìngjiàokāitiānluówǎngfàngjìnláishídōngfāngcáiliànghuìànsuíjìnjiàntiānwángtiānwángxiàbàibàitiānwángdào:「háiérxiāngláizhě?」huìàndào:「nánsuípántáohuìjiànshènghuìhuāngliángyáochíyǐnzhòngxiānbìngnánjiànbèiyánwángděngxiàjièshōuyāohóujiànhuíbàoshèngwèizhīyīnmìngnándàotīngshí。」tiānwángdào:「zuódàoānyíngxiàzhàizhuójiǔyàoxīngtiǎozhànbèizhènòngshéntōngjiǔyàoxīngbàizǒuérhuíhòuděngqīnbīngpáikāizhènshìděngshíwàntiānbīnghùnzhànzhìwǎn使shǐfēnshēnzhàn退tuìshōubīngchákānshízhǐzhuōxiēlángchóngbàozhīlèicéngzhuōbànyāohóujīnháiwèichūzhàn。」


逐句解 Line by line

wényánmìnghuìànxíngzhědào:「kuàixiàtiāngōngdàohuāguǒshāntànjūnqíng wényánmìnghuìànxíngzhědào:「kuàixiàtiāngōngdàohuāguǒshāntànjūnqíng

When the Bodhisattva had heard this, she at once ordered the pilgrim Huiyan: "Go quickly down from the Heavenly Palace to the Mountain of Flowers and Fruit, and find out how the campaign stands.

Guanyin sends her own man down, and the errand is more than reconnaissance: it is her first probe of what the monkey is actually made of. 打探軍情 is to reconnoitre the military situation.

xiāngjiùxiāngzhùgōngdeshíhuíhuà。」 xiāngjiùxiāngzhùgōngdeshíhuíhuà。」

If you meet him in battle, you may lend a hand and do your part; but be sure to bring back the truth of it."

的實回話, report the real facts — Guanyin wants an honest reckoning, not a flattering one, which rather suggests she expects the flattering kind. The here is the everyday de doing unfamiliar work: not the possessive de of modern Chinese but part of an old vernacular pairing meaning truly, in fact. And note the licence buried in the order: 相助一功, lend a hand and do your part, is what makes the coming duel possible.

huìànxíngzhězhěngzhěngqúnzhítiáotiěgùnjiàyúnquèjìngzhìshānqián huìànxíngzhězhěngzhěngqúnzhítiáotiěgùnjiàyúnquèjìngzhìshānqián

The pilgrim Huiyan straightened his robes, took up an iron rod, mounted his cloud, left the palace gates, and went straight to the foot of the mountain.

離闕, departed the palace towers — are the paired gate-towers of an imperial seat, so the word carries the whole architecture with it. His weapon, an 鐵棍 or iron rod, marks Huiyan as a fighting monk rather than a contemplative one.

jiàntiānluówǎngcéngcéngyíngménlínghàojiāngshānwéiràodeshuǐxiètōng jiàntiānluówǎngcéngcéngyíngménlínghàojiāngshānwéiràodeshuǐxiètōng

He saw the Heaven-and-Earth nets ranged dense and layer on layer, each camp gate ringing its bells and calling its watchwords, the mountain ringed so tight that not a drop of water could leak through.

水泄不通, so tight not even water leaks through, is the stock idiom for a perfect cordon — and still the phrase Chinese reaches for when a street is jammed solid. 提鈴喝號, ringing bells and calling watchwords ( is , to shout), is the night discipline of a besieging army, and it tells you Heaven is taking this seriously.

huìànzhùjiào:「yíngméndetiāndīngfánchuánbào huìànzhùjiào:「yíngméndetiāndīngfánchuánbào

Huiyan halted and called out, "You heavenly soldiers at the camp gate — I trouble you to pass the word:

天丁 are heavenly conscripts, the rank and file. Huiyan announces himself at the perimeter exactly as a herald would at the gate of a hostile camp — which, given whose son he is, is a slightly odd way to visit one's father.

nǎitiānwángèrtàizhā──nánhǎiguānyīnhuìànláitànjūnqíng。」 nǎitiānwángèrtàizhā──nánhǎiguānyīnhuìànláitànjūnqíng。」

I am Mokṣa, second prince of Heavenly King Li — Huiyan, chief disciple of Guanyin of the Southern Sea — come expressly to learn how the campaign fares."

He gives both identities in one breath: by birth 木吒 (Mokṣa), son of the besieging general; by vocation 惠岸, Guanyin's chief disciple. The first of those gets him through the gate on the spot.

yíngyuèshénbīngchuányuánménzhīnèi yíngyuèshénbīngchuányuánménzhīnèi

The Five-Peaks divine soldiers of the camp relayed it within the headquarters gate.

五岳神兵 are soldiers of the Five Sacred Peaks ( is yuè) — the mountain gods have sent levies to this war like any other feudal power. 轅門, the shaft-gate, is the entrance to a military camp, so called because it was anciently formed from two upturned chariot-shafts.

zǎoyǒushǔmǎoxīngfángjiāngyánchuándàozhōngjūnzhàngxià zǎoyǒushǔmǎoxīngfángjiāngyánchuándàozhōngjūnzhàngxià

Presently the Star-Lords Xu the Rat, Mao the Cock, Xing the Horse, and Fang the Hare carried the word to the central command tent.

Four of the 二十八宿, the Twenty-Eight Lunar Mansions, each pairing a constellation with a day-sign and an animal: 虛日鼠 Emptiness and Rat, 昴日雞 Pleiades and Cock, 星日馬 Star and Horse, 房日兔 Room and Hare. In Heaven's army the zodiac runs messages.

tiānwángxiàlìngjiàokāitiānluówǎngfàngjìnlái tiānwángxiàlìngjiàokāitiānluówǎngfàngjìnlái

Heavenly King Li sent down his command-flag, ordered the Heaven-and-Earth nets opened, and let him through.

令旗, the command-banner, is the physical token of a general's order — the flag goes down the line and the line obeys it. The verb here is jiào, to order or cause.

shídōngfāngcáiliànghuìànsuíjìnjiàntiānwángtiānwángxiàbài shídōngfāngcáiliànghuìànsuíjìnjiàntiānwángtiānwángxiàbài

By now the east was just growing light. Huiyan followed the flag inside, and on seeing the Four Heavenly Kings and Heavenly King Li, made his bows.

The 四大天王, the Four Heavenly Kings, are the lokapālas, guardians of the four quarters, familiar to anyone who has walked past the four enormous painted figures inside a Chinese temple gate. Dawn breaking marks a second day of the siege beginning with nothing accomplished.

bàitiānwángdào:「háiérxiāngláizhě?」 bàitiānwángdào:「háiérxiāngláizhě?」

When the bows were done, Heavenly King Li said, "My boy, from what quarter do you come?"

孩兒, my child. The commanding general drops straight into fatherhood. 那廂 is interrogative here, from where ( read ) — one of this edition's characteristic uses of to carry the question word.

huìàndào:「nánsuípántáohuìjiànshènghuìhuāngliángyáochíyǐnzhòngxiānbìngnánjiàn huìàndào:「nánsuípántáohuìjiànshènghuìhuāngliángyáochíyǐnzhòngxiānbìngnánjiàn

Said Huiyan, "Your foolish son attended the Peach Festival with the Bodhisattva. Finding the grand feast desolate and the Jasper Pool forlorn, she led the immortals and your son to see the Jade Emperor.

愚男, your foolish son, is the humble self-reference a son owes his father — the family version of Guanyin's poor monk. Huiyan now retells the chapter's opening from his own vantage, the first of several nested retellings.

bèiyánwángděngxiàjièshōuyāohóujiànhuíbàoshèngwèizhīyīnmìngnándàotīngshí。」 bèiyánwángděngxiàjièshōuyāohóujiànhuíbàoshèngwèizhīyīnmìngnándàotīngshí。」

The Jade Emperor related in full how my royal father and the rest had gone down to subdue the fiendish monkey, and how — no report having come in a whole day — the outcome was unknown; and so the Bodhisattva ordered your son here to learn the truth of it."

打聽虛實, to find out the true state of things. 虛實 is literally the empty and the solid, and it is a technical term of the military arts: where an enemy is weak and where he is strong. Guanyin sent a scout, and her scout uses the vocabulary of one.

tiānwángdào:「zuódàoānyíngxiàzhàizhuójiǔyàoxīngtiǎozhànbèizhènòngshéntōngjiǔyàoxīngbàizǒuérhuí tiānwángdào:「zuódàoānyíngxiàzhàizhuójiǔyàoxīngtiǎozhànbèizhènòngshéntōngjiǔyàoxīngbàizǒuérhuí

Said Heavenly King Li, "Yesterday we came here and pitched camp, and ordered the Nine Luminary Stars to give challenge; but the creature worked his magic so mightily that the Nine Luminaries were all routed and fled back.

The 九曜星, the Nine Luminaries, are the Sun, the Moon, the five visible planets, and the two eclipse-nodes Rāhu and Ketu — the whole visible sky, routed by one monkey in Chapter 5. The verb here is zhuó, to order; 挑戰 (tiǎo zhàn) is to give challenge.

hòuděngqīnbīngpáikāizhènshì hòuděngqīnbīngpáikāizhènshì

Then we led the troops in person, and the fellow drew up his battle-lines as well.

提兵 is to lead troops in person. 排開陣勢, deployed in battle array — the joke is quiet but real: the monkey's rabble of beasts forms proper ranks.

děngshíwàntiānbīnghùnzhànzhìwǎn使shǐfēnshēnzhàn退tuì děngshíwàntiānbīnghùnzhànzhìwǎn使shǐfēnshēnzhàn退tuì

Our hundred thousand heavenly soldiers fought him in a melee till nightfall, when he used a body-dividing trick and broke off the fight.

分身法, the art of dividing the body. By multiplying himself the monkey both scatters the host's attention and slips out of the middle of it; the same trick returns at the height of the transformation-duel to come.

shōubīngchákānshízhǐzhuōxiēlángchóngbàozhīlèicéngzhuōbànyāohóu shōubīngchákānshízhǐzhuōxiēlángchóngbàozhīlèicéngzhuōbànyāohóu

And when we mustered the troops and took stock, we had caught only the likes of wolves and tigers, leopards and vermin — not so much as half a single monkey-fiend.

狼蟲虎豹, wolves and vermin, tigers and leopards, are the monkey's animal levies, abandoned when his real troops got clear. 不曾捉得他半個, did not catch even half of one — a hundred thousand soldiers, and the tally sheet reads: assorted wildlife.

jīnháiwèichūzhàn。」 jīnháiwèichūzhàn。」

Today we have not yet given battle."

The recap has brought the siege up to this morning. The lull it describes is about to end, in the very next line, with the monkey shouting outside the gate.


總評 Commentary

With Huiyan's descent the chapter shifts from the celestial court to the battlefield, and the narrative quietly nests one retelling inside another. Where the Jade Emperor's speech recapped the monkey's whole career, Heavenly King Li now recaps the previous chapter's failed assault — so that the reader reaches the front already knowing, through two layers of report, exactly how badly Heaven is faring. Wú Chéng'ēn is fond of this layered exposition: events are narrated, then narrated again by the people they happened to, each version tinted by its speaker. Here the device also marks time, since the siege has stalled, and sets the stage for the fresh fight about to begin.

The passage is thick with the bureaucratic and military texture that gives the heavenly host its comic solidity. There are command-flags (令旗) and headquarters gates (轅門), watchwords and night patrols, a roll-call of astral officers — the Lunar Mansions 虛日鼠, 昴日雞 and their fellows, the 九曜星, the 五岳神兵 — the whole machinery of a real Ming campaign transposed to the sky. And yet, for all that machinery, the tally of the first day's fighting is humiliating: a hundred thousand soldiers have netted not half a monkey, only the beasts the troop left behind. The disproportion is the joke, and it is also the theme — one wild creature, the 心猿, running rings round the assembled order of Heaven.

There is dramatic irony in Huiyan himself. Guanyin sends him as a scout with leave to lend a hand, and he turns out to be the besieging general's own son — so that the Bodhisattva's probe and the Heavenly King's campaign are, without either of them planning it, joined inside a single family. His double name, 木吒/惠岸 (Mokṣa, son of Li; Huiyan, disciple of Guanyin), embodies the chapter's larger convergence of Daoist Heaven and Buddhist mercy against the unruly mind. When he steps forward to fight in the next passage he does so both as a son eager to prove himself and as Compassion's first — and doomed — champion.