Canonical Classics ← 第五十六回
第五十六回
shénkuángzhūcǎokòu
dàofàngxīnyuán

The Spirit Runs Mad and Puts the Bandits to Death · The Way Is Clouded and the Mind-Monkey Is Cast Off

和尚硬頭
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

和尚硬頭 The Monk With the Hard Head

xíngzhěmángjiàodào:「zǒucuòle。」zhebāojiùyàozhuīhuǒzéilánzhùdào:「zǒujiāngpánchánliúxiàmiǎndedòngxíng。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「shuōkāipánchánsānfēnfēnzhī。」zéitóudào:「zhèxiǎoshàngguāijiùyàománzheshīliúxiēerchūláikànruòduōshífēnxiēbèimǎiguǒzichī。」xíngzhědào:「yashìzhèděngshuōyǒushénpánchánshuōliǎngjiébiéréndejīnyínshìfēnxiē。」zéiwényándào:「zhèshàngzhīhuódàokěnfǎnwènyàoyàozǒukàn。」lūntiáoténggùnzhàoxíngzhěguāngtóushànglexiàxíngzhězhǐdàngzhīqiě滿mǎnmiànpéixiàodào:「yaruòshìzhèděngjiùdàoláiniánchūnshìdàngzhēnde。」zéijīngdào:「zhèshànghǎoyìngtóu!」xíngzhěxiàodào:「gǎngǎnchéngguòjiǎnglejiāngjiùkàndeguò。」zéiróngfēnshuōliǎngsānluànxíngzhědào:「lièwèiděngchūlái。」xíngzhěmángjiàodào:「zǒucuòle。」zhebāojiùyàozhuīhuǒzéilánzhùdào:「zǒujiāngpánchánliúxiàmiǎndedòngxíng。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「shuōkāipánchánsānfēnfēnzhī。」zéitóudào:「zhèxiǎoshàngguāijiùyàománzheshīliúxiēerchūláikànruòduōshífēnxiēbèimǎiguǒzichī。」xíngzhědào:「yashìzhèděngshuōyǒushénpánchánshuōliǎngjiébiéréndejīnyínshìfēnxiē。」zéiwényándào:「zhèshàngzhīhuódàokěnfǎnwènyàoyàozǒukàn。」lūntiáoténggùnzhàoxíngzhěguāngtóushànglexiàxíngzhězhǐdàngzhīqiěmǎnmiànpéixiàodào:「yaruòshìzhèděngjiùdàoláiniánchūnshìdàngzhēnde。」zéijīngdào:「zhèshànghǎoyìngtóu!」xíngzhěxiàodào:「gǎngǎnchéngguòjiǎnglejiāngjiùkàndeguò。」zéiróngfēnshuōliǎngsānluànxíngzhědào:「lièwèiděngchūlái。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěmángjiàodào:「zǒucuòle。」 xíngzhěmángjiàodào:「zǒucuòle。」

Pilgrim called out hurriedly, “You have taken the wrong road!”

The shout is aimed at the bolting master, not at the robbers, and it is the last thing Wukong says before he turns to business.

zhebāojiùyàozhuī zhebāojiùyàozhuī

He picked up the bundle and made to go after him.

提著 puts at zhe, action under way — bundle in hand, moving. The pursuit is a feint: it provokes the robbers into blocking him, which is exactly what he wants.

huǒzéilánzhùdào:「zǒujiāngpánchánliúxiàmiǎndedòngxíng。」 huǒzéilánzhùdào:「zǒujiāngpánchánliúxiàmiǎndedòngxíng。」

The gang of robbers barred his way: “Where are you off to? Leave the travelling money behind and spare yourself the rod.”

Two readings of the same character seven characters apart: the pointing of 那夥賊, that gang, and the questioning of 那裡走, where are you off to? is jiāng, marking the money as the thing to be handed over, and 免得 keeps its neutral de.

xíngzhěxiàodào:「shuōkāipánchánsānfēnfēnzhī。」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「shuōkāipánchánsānfēnfēnzhī。」

Pilgrim laughed and said, “Let us be plain about it: the money must be split three ways.”

三分分之 uses twice — first as the noun, a share, then as the verb, to divide — and both keep fēn. The joke is that Wukong is not refusing the demand. He is negotiating a cut of it.

zéitóudào:「zhèxiǎoshàngguāijiùyàománzheshīliúxiēer zéitóudào:「zhèxiǎoshàngguāijiùyàománzheshīliúxiēer

The robber chief said, “This little monk is altogether too sharp. He means to hold something back behind his master’s back.”

is read , the reading the 漢語大詞典 gives for the sense of excess as well as for the sense of error; the dialect form tuī recorded in the 現代漢語詞典 is the noted alternative. 瞞著 has at zhe, action under way, and 些兒 is suffixed, so is er.

chūláikànruòduōshífēnxiēbèimǎiguǒzichī。」 chūláikànruòduōshífēnxiēbèimǎiguǒzichī。」

“Very well then. Bring it out and let us see. If it comes to much, we will share a little with you as well, to buy fruit with on the quiet.”

也罷 uses as the verb let it be so — not the soft ba that ends a sentence. 背地裡 takes as bèi, the back you have rather than the bēi of carrying something on it: behind his back. The robbers are now offering a kickback to the man who is about to kill them.

xíngzhědào:「yashìzhèděngshuōyǒushénpánchán xíngzhědào:「yashìzhèděngshuōyǒushénpánchán

Pilgrim said, “Brother, that is not what I meant at all. Where should I have any travelling money?”

那裡 is the rhetorical again — where would I get any? — and the question word shén.

shuōliǎngjiébiéréndejīnyínshìfēnxiē。」 shuōliǎngjiébiéréndejīnyínshìfēnxiē。」

“I mean the gold and silver you two have taken off other people. You must share some of that with me.”

是必 is an emphatic: you positively must. The demand is outrageous by design. Wukong is manufacturing the provocation, and he needs them to strike first.

zéiwényándào:「zhèshàngzhīhuódàokěnfǎnwènyàoyàozǒukàn。」 zéiwényándào:「zhèshàngzhīhuódàokěnfǎnwènyàoyàozǒukàn。」

The robbers were furious to hear it and swore at him: “This monk does not know whether he is alive or dead. You will not give to us, and instead you ask of us. Do not run — take a beating!”

你倒不肯 has in its contrary sense, dào — on the contrary, instead. 看打 is a challenge formula: look out for the blow.

lūntiáoténggùnzhàoxíngzhěguāngtóushànglexià lūntiáoténggùnzhàoxíngzhěguāngtóushànglexià

He swung up a knotted rattan staff and struck Pilgrim seven or eight times across his bald head.

扢撻藤 is the same knotted rattan staff named in the description of the two chiefs, where one of them carried it crosswise on his shoulder. 光頭 is a monk's shaven head, and the aim is deliberate.

xíngzhězhǐdàngzhīqiě滿mǎnmiànpéixiàodào:「yaruòshìzhèděngjiùdàoláiniánchūnshìdàngzhēnde。」 xíngzhězhǐdàngzhīqiěmǎnmiànpéixiàodào:「yaruòshìzhèděngjiùdàoláiniánchūnshìdàngzhēnde。」

Pilgrim behaved as though he had noticed nothing, and with a smile all over his face said, “Brother, if that is how you beat, you may go on beating till next year, till the spring ox has been whipped, and it would still not count for earnest.”

falls twice, both times meaning to take something as something, so both are dàng: 只當不知, as though he knew nothing, and 不當真, not to be taken for real. That second reading pushes up to the fourth tone, which in turn lifts the in front of it from to . As for the joke: 打春, beating the spring, is the Beginning-of-Spring rite in which a clay ox is whipped to start the farming year, and is the verb, to finish. Keep hitting me till next year's ox has been thrashed, he says, and it still would not count.

zéijīngdào:「zhèshànghǎoyìngtóu!」 zéijīngdào:「zhèshànghǎoyìngtóu!」

The robber was startled. “This monk has a hard head on him!”

好硬頭 is admiring in spite of itself, and it is the closest any of these men come to understanding what they are dealing with.

xíngzhěxiàodào:「gǎngǎnchéngguòjiǎnglejiāngjiùkàndeguò。」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「gǎngǎnchéngguòjiǎnglejiāngjiùkàndeguò。」

Pilgrim laughed. “Not at all, not at all. You do me too much honour — it will pass well enough.”

不敢不敢 and 承過獎 are the standard formulae of modest disclaimer — you are too kind — deployed here about the hardness of his own skull. 將就 puts at jiāng, to make do; 看得過 has the of being able to, so de.

zéiróngfēnshuōliǎngsānluàn zéiróngfēnshuōliǎngsānluàn

The robbers would allow no explaining; two or three of them set on him at once and beat him wildly.

那容分說 repeats the pairing exactly: the questioning beside the pointing of 那賊. The same phrase was used when they beat Tripitaka. The same two readings, the other victim.

xíngzhědào:「lièwèiděngchūlái。」 xíngzhědào:「lièwèiděngchūlái。」

Pilgrim said, “Gentlemen, calm your anger. Let me bring it out.”

息怒 is a formula for calming somebody down. It is the last polite thing said in the scene.


總評 Commentary

The whole passage is Wukong manufacturing a grievance he does not have. He is not cornered — he could pick up his master and leave at any moment — so the demand for a three-way split, and then the demand for a share of the robbers' existing plunder, are not negotiation. They are provocation. He is arranging to be struck first.

The comedy of the seven or eight blows is broad, and it is also exact. 只當不知 — he behaved as though he had noticed nothing — is the storyteller's way of showing an invulnerable body from the outside, without ever saying so. The robbers are hitting a man who is not registering that he is being hit. Wukong's reply turns the beating into a joke about the farming calendar, and his 不敢不敢承過獎了 accepts 好硬頭 as though it were a compliment on his poetry.

None of this is cruelty yet, and that is what makes the next two pages land. Everything here belongs to the trickster: the disguise, the outrageous demand, the beating absorbed and laughed off, the courteous formulae. The chapter has been careful to let the reader enjoy it, so that the reader is implicated in what the enjoyment turns into.