Canonical Classics ← 第五十六回
第五十六回
shénkuángzhūcǎokòu
dàofàngxīnyuán

The Spirit Runs Mad and Puts the Bandits to Death · The Way Is Clouded and the Mind-Monkey Is Cast Off

只告行者
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

只告行者 Only Accuse Pilgrim

jièxiàodào:「shītuīlegānjìngshíquèméiyǒumenliǎng。」sānzàngzhēnyòucuōdǎogàodào:「hǎohàngàozhuàngzhǐgàoxíngzhěgānjièshāsēngzhīshì。」jièxiàodào:「shītuīlegānjìngshíquèméiyǒumenliǎng。」sānzàngzhēnyòucuōdǎogàodào:「hǎohàngàozhuàngzhǐgàoxíngzhěgānjièshāsēngzhīshì。」


逐句解 Line by line

jièxiàodào:「shītuīlegānjìngshíquèméiyǒumenliǎng。」 jièxiàodào:「shītuīlegānjìngshíquèméiyǒumenliǎng。」

Bajie laughed. “Master, you have pushed yourself quite clean of it. But when he did the beating, we two were not there either.”

推了乾淨 — to push yourself clean off a matter — takes as gān, dry, not qián, the hexagram. Bajie has understood exactly what the prayer was for, and he wants the same protection.

sānzàngzhēnyòucuōdǎogàodào:「hǎohàngàozhuàngzhǐgàoxíngzhěgānjièshāsēngzhīshì。」 sānzàngzhēnyòucuōdǎogàodào:「hǎohàngàozhuàngzhǐgàoxíngzhěgānjièshāsēngzhīshì。」

Tripitaka did indeed take up another pinch of earth and pray again: “Brave fellows, when you lay your charge, charge Pilgrim only. It is no concern of Bajie or of Sha Monk.”

真個又, he really did do it again, marks the narrator's dry surprise. 不干 keeps at gān, meaning no concern of — and because that syllable sits at the first tone rather than the falling tone, the in front of it stays at instead of rising to .


總評 Commentary

Forty-eight characters, and they undo the prayer. Bajie's objection is purely self-interested and perfectly logical: if the point of the petition was to allocate blame, then he and Sha Monk should be named as absent too. He is not shocked by the manoeuvre. He wants in on it.

And Tripitaka obliges. 真個又撮土禱告 — he really did take up another pinch of earth — and amends the filing: charge Pilgrim only. The second prayer has no grief in it at all. No apology for the poor offering, no address to the dead as 好漢. It is a schedule of exclusions. The rite that began as the one decent thing in the chapter ends as paperwork, and the disciple who is about to be driven away has now been formally named, twice, before the court of the dead.