Canonical Classics ← 第五十六回
第五十六回
shénkuángzhūcǎokòu
dàofàngxīnyuán

The Spirit Runs Mad and Puts the Bandits to Death · The Way Is Clouded and the Mind-Monkey Is Cast Off

綑吊樹上
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

綑吊樹上 Bound and Hung From a Tree

sānzàngjiànzhèbānxiōngèzhǐzǒuláizhǎngdāngxiōngdào:「wángpínsēngshìdōngtángwángchāiwǎng西tiānjīngzhěbiélechángānniánshēnjiǔjiùyǒuxiēpánchán使shǐjìnlechūjiārénzhuānhuàwéiyóucáiwànwàngwángfāng便biànfāng便biànràngpínsēngguòba。」liǎngzéishuàizhòngxiàngqiándào:「menzàizhèpiànxīnjiézhùyàozhuānyàoxiēcáishénmefāng便biànfāng便biànguǒcáikuàizǎotuōxiàliúxiàbáifàngguò。」sānzàngdào:「ātuópínsēngzhèjiànshìdōngjiāhuà西jiāhuàzhēnlínglíngsuìsuìhuàláideruòhàishāzhǐshìzhèshìzuòhǎohànshìbiànchùshengli。」zéiwényánchègùnshàngqiánjiùzhèzhǎnglǎokǒunèiyánxīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「liánzhǐshuōdegùnziháizhīdegùnzili。」zéiróngfēnshuōzhebàngméitóuméiliǎndeláizhǎnglǎoshēnghuìshuōhuǎngzháozhènánchùméinàizhǐkuángdào:「èrwèiwángqiědòngshǒuyǒuxiǎozàihòumiànjiùdàoshēnshàngyǒuliǎngyínziba。」zéidào:「zhèshàngshìchīdekuīqiěkǔnlái。」zhònglóuluóxiàshǒutiáoshéngkǔnlegāogāodiàozàishùshàngsānzàngjiànzhèbānxiōngèzhǐzǒuláizhǎngdāngxiōngdào:「wángpínsēngshìdōngtángwángchāiwǎng西tiānjīngzhěbiélechángānniánshēnjiǔjiùyǒuxiēpánchán使shǐjìnlechūjiārénzhuānhuàwéiyóucáiwànwàngwángfāng便biànfāng便biànràngpínsēngguòba。」liǎngzéishuàizhòngxiàngqiándào:「menzàizhèpiànxīnjiézhùyàozhuānyàoxiēcáishénmefāng便biànfāng便biànguǒcáikuàizǎotuōxiàliúxiàbáifàngguò。」sānzàngdào:「ātuópínsēngzhèjiànshìdōngjiāhuà西jiāhuàzhēnlínglíngsuìsuìhuàláideruòhàishāzhǐshìzhèshìzuòhǎohànshìbiànchùshengli。」zéiwényánchègùnshàngqiánjiùzhèzhǎnglǎokǒunèiyánxīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「liánzhǐshuōdegùnziháizhīdegùnzili。」zéiróngfēnshuōzhebàngméitóuméiliǎndeláizhǎnglǎoshēnghuìshuōhuǎngzháozhènánchùméinàizhǐkuángdào:「èrwèiwángqiědòngshǒuyǒuxiǎozàihòumiànjiùdàoshēnshàngyǒuliǎngyínziba。」zéidào:「zhèshàngshìchīdekuīqiěkǔnlái。」zhònglóuluóxiàshǒutiáoshéngkǔnlegāogāodiàozàishùshàng


逐句解 Line by line

sānzàngjiànzhèbānxiōngèzhǐzǒuláizhǎngdāngxiōngdào:「wángpínsēngshìdōngtángwángchāiwǎng西tiānjīngzhě sānzàngjiànzhèbānxiōngèzhǐzǒuláizhǎngdāngxiōngdào:「wángpínsēngshìdōngtángwángchāiwǎng西tiānjīngzhě

Seeing how ferocious they were, Tripitaka had no help for it but to get to his feet; and joining his palms before his breast he said, “Great Kings, this poor monk is one sent by the Tang emperor of the Land of the East to fetch scriptures from the Western Heaven.”

合掌當胸, palms joined before the breast, puts in its sense of being at or facing something, so dāng. 差往 is chāi, the reading for being sent on official business — not chà. Tripitaka opens with his credentials, which is what a man does when he thinks the problem is a misunderstanding.

biélechángānniánshēnjiǔjiùyǒuxiēpánchán使shǐjìnle biélechángānniánshēnjiǔjiùyǒuxiēpánchán使shǐjìnle

“Since I parted from Chang’an the years have grown deep and the days long, and what little travelling money I had is all spent.”

The same character does two different jobs inside one passage. Here 長安 is the place-name Chang'an, so cháng, long; a few lines away turns up in 長老, elder, as zhǎng. is jìn, used up.

chūjiārénzhuānhuàwéiyóucái chūjiārénzhuānhuàwéiyóucái

“One who has left the household lives by begging and nothing else — where should I come by money or silk?”

出家人 — one who has left the household — is the standard way a monk refers to himself. 那得 is the rhetorical , whence?, with in its sense of coming by something, .

wànwàngwángfāng便biànfāng便biànràngpínsēngguòba。」 wànwàngwángfāng便biànfāng便biànràngpínsēngguòba。」

“I beg the Great Kings will show me a little accommodation and let this poor monk go by.”

方便 is a serious Buddhist term — upāya, skilful means, the expedients a teacher uses to get somebody to enlightenment — worn smooth by everyday use into something like doing a person a favour. Tripitaka reaches for it in the polite sense. The robbers are about to throw it back at him in the next breath. sits at the end of the sentence, so it is the soft ba.

liǎngzéishuàizhòngxiàngqiándào:「menzàizhèpiànxīnjiézhùyàozhuānyàoxiēcáishénmefāng便biànfāng便biàn liǎngzéishuàizhòngxiàngqiándào:「menzàizhèpiànxīnjiézhùyàozhuānyàoxiēcáishénmefāng便biànfāng便biàn

The two robbers led their band forward and said, “We have set up a tiger’s heart here, cut the highway, and want nothing whatever but money and silk. What is all this accommodation, accommodation?”

They repeat 方便方便 back at him word for word, sneering, which is why the English repeats it too. 甚麼 is the question word, so is shén, not shèn.

guǒcáikuàizǎotuōxiàliúxiàbáifàngguò。」 guǒcáikuàizǎotuōxiàliúxiàbáifàngguò。」

“If you truly have no money, then get your robe off quickly and leave the white horse behind, and we will let you pass.”

The demand narrows from money in general to the only two things Tripitaka actually has on him. Both are imperial gifts rather than possessions — which is exactly what makes his next answer possible.

sānzàngdào:「ātuópínsēngzhèjiànshìdōngjiāhuà西jiāhuàzhēnlínglíngsuìsuìhuàláide sānzàngdào:「ātuópínsēngzhèjiànshìdōngjiāhuà西jiāhuàzhēnlínglíngsuìsuìhuàláide

Tripitaka said, “Amitābha Buddha! This robe of mine is cloth begged from a house in the east and needles begged from a house in the west, got together scrap by scrap.”

阿彌陀佛 is read ā mí tuó fó, with held at throughout this project. Then watch : it falls three times in three lines, every time in the beggar-monk's sense — cloth begged here, needles begged there, the whole robe begged scrap by scrap — and every time it is huà.

ruòhàishā ruòhàishā

“If you strip it off me, will you not have killed me outright?”

可不 is a rhetorical frame: is it not the case that…? Note the shift. The elder has stopped pleading and started arguing, for the first time in the scene.

zhǐshìzhèshìzuòhǎohànshìbiànchùshengli。」 zhǐshìzhèshìzuòhǎohànshìbiànchùshengli。」

“It is only that those who play the bold fellow in this life are turned into beasts in the next.”

This is doctrine, not abuse. 畜生 is the 畜生道, the Animal Realm, one of the three bad destinies in the Buddhist scheme of rebirth, and Tripitaka means it in precisely that technical sense. It keeps its fixed everyday reading chù sheng. 那世裡, the next life, is the pointing , set against 這世裡, this one.

zéiwényánchègùnshàngqiánjiù zéiwényánchègùnshàngqiánjiù

The robbers were furious to hear it. They whipped out their great cudgels and came forward to strike.

is to whip a weapon out. Up to this line the threat has been conditional — hand it over and nobody gets hurt. What converts it into action is Tripitaka's remark about coming back as an animal.

zhèzhǎnglǎokǒunèiyánxīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「liánzhǐshuōdegùnziháizhīdegùnzili。」 zhèzhǎnglǎokǒunèiyánxīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「liánzhǐshuōdegùnziháizhīdegùnzili。」

The elder said nothing aloud, but thought within himself: “Poor wretches! You speak only of your own cudgels — you do not yet know about my disciple’s cudgel.”

Read 可憐 carefully: it is aimed downward at the robbers, not upward at heaven. The elder is pitying the men who are about to beat him. And 棍子 is one word doing duty for two very different objects, which is the whole of the joke and the whole of the threat.

zéiróngfēnshuōzhebàngméitóuméiliǎndelái zéiróngfēnshuōzhebàngméitóuméiliǎndelái

The robbers would allow no explaining. They raised their staves and struck at him without regard for head or face.

The same character twice in one clause, with opposite readings two characters apart: the pointing of 那賊, those robbers, and the rhetorical of 那容分說, as if they would let him explain.

zhǎnglǎoshēnghuìshuōhuǎngzháozhènánchùméinàizhǐkuángdào:「èrwèiwángqiědòngshǒu zhǎnglǎoshēnghuìshuōhuǎngzháozhènánchùméinàizhǐkuángdào:「èrwèiwángqiědòngshǒu

The elder had never in all his life been able to tell a lie; but having run into this urgent strait he had no help for it, and brought out a falsehood: “Let the two Great Kings hold their hands a moment.”

遇著 takes zháo, the reading for something that has come off — the encounter has happened — on the pattern of 撞著 and 碰著. That is a different animal from the zhe of action under way in 舉著 one line above. 難處 is nán chù, a tight spot. And 誑語 is the Buddhist term for false speech — the fourth of the five precepts, which is to say the elder is not merely lying but breaking a vow, and the narrator has just told us he has never managed it before.

yǒuxiǎozàihòumiànjiùdàoshēnshàngyǒuliǎngyínziba。」 yǒuxiǎozàihòumiànjiùdàoshēnshàngyǒuliǎngyínziba。」

“I have a young disciple who will be along directly behind me. He has a few taels of silver about him, and you shall have it.”

幾兩銀子 — the is the tael, ten , and the standard English name for the Chinese unit is used because English borrowed it for exactly this purpose. Note what is being promised: silver that does not exist, carried by a disciple who does exist.

zéidào:「zhèshàngshìchīdekuīqiěkǔnlái。」 zéidào:「zhèshàngshìchīdekuīqiěkǔnlái。」

The robbers said, “This monk is one who will not stand a loss. Tie him up for now.”

吃不得虧 — a man who will not take a loss — puts at the neutral de of being able to. Because that syllable goes neutral, the in front of it keeps its ordinary instead of shifting up to .

zhònglóuluóxiàshǒutiáoshéngkǔnlegāogāodiàozàishùshàng zhònglóuluóxiàshǒutiáoshéngkǔnlegāogāodiàozàishùshàng

The whole gang of underlings fell to at once, bound him with a rope, and hung him high up in a tree.

嘍囉 is the standing word for a bandit chief's rank and file — the mooks. 高高吊在樹上 leaves Tripitaka hanging exactly where his disciples will find him, which is the image the rest of the chapter turns on.


總評 Commentary

Tripitaka's defence is a sustained piece of legal argument, and the most articulate he has been in many chapters. He establishes his commission, pleads poverty, states the rule of his order, and asks for 方便 — a technical Buddhist word for accommodation, which the robbers instantly turn into a sneer. When they name the robe he does not refuse but reframes: the garment is not property but accumulated alms, cloth from one house and needles from another, so that stripping it off him is not theft but killing.

Then he loses the argument by winning it. 這世裡做得好漢那世裡變畜生 is doctrinally exact — the Animal Realm really is where violent men are reborn — and it is also the single thing most likely to enrage men who have just been called bold fellows to their faces. The monk who cannot tell a lie has no trouble at all telling an unwelcome truth, and the cudgels come out on the instant.

The unspoken thought that follows is the chapter's hinge. 你只說你的棍子還不知我徒弟的棍子 is not a prayer and not a fear. It is a threat, privately enjoyed. The elder who will shortly recite the Tight-Fillet spell over two corpses is here quietly relishing what his disciple's staff is going to do to these men. Only after that does he tell the first lie of his life, and the lie is bait: it promises the robbers silver and delivers them Wukong.

The passage ends with the master hung in a tree, which the novel has done to him before and will do again. What is new is that he arranged it himself — and arranged what is coming to meet it.