Canonical Classics ← 第四十七回
第四十七回
聖shèng僧sēng夜yè阻zǔ通tōng天tiān水shuǐ
金jīn木mù垂chuí慈cí救jiù小xiǎo童tóng

The Holy Monk Is Barred at Night by the Water That Reaches the Sky · Metal and Wood, Extending Mercy, Rescue the Little Children

家私難捨
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

家私難捨 Wealth That Cannot Buy a Child

三sān藏zàng聞wén言yán,止zhǐ不bú住zhù腮sāi邊biān淚lèi下xià道dào:「這zhè正zhèng是shì古gǔ人rén云yún:『黃huáng梅méi不bú落luò青qīng梅méi落luò,老lǎo天tiān偏piān害hài沒méi兒ér人rén。』」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「等děng我wǒ再zài問wèn他tā。老lǎo公gōng公gong,你nǐ府fǔ上shàng有yǒu多duō大dà家jiā當dāng?」二èr老lǎo道dào:「頗pō有yǒu些xiē兒er:水shuǐ田tián有yǒu四sì五wǔ十shí頃qǐng,旱hàn田tián有yǒu六liù七qī十shí頃qǐng,草cǎo場chǎng有yǒu八bā九jiǔ十shí處chù;水shuǐ黃huáng牛niú有yǒu二èr三sān百bǎi頭tóu,驢lǘ馬mǎ有yǒu三sān二èr十shí匹pǐ,豬zhū羊yáng雞jī鵝é無wú數shù。舍shè下xià也yě有yǒu吃chī不bù著zháo的de陳chén糧liáng,穿chuān不bù了liǎo的de衣yī服fú。家jiā財cái產chǎn業yè,也yě盡jìn得dé數shù。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ這zhè等děng家jiā業yè,也yě虧kuī你nǐ省shěng將jiāng起qǐ來lái的de。」老lǎo者zhě道dào:「怎zěn見jiàn我wǒ省shěng?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「既jì有yǒu這zhè家jiā私sī,怎zěn麼me捨shě得de親qīn生shēng兒ér女nǚ祭jì賽sài?拚pàn了le五wǔ十shí兩liǎng銀yín子zi,可kě買mǎi一yí個gè童tóng男nán;拚pàn了le一yì百bǎi兩liǎng銀yín子zi,可kě買mǎi一yí個gè童tóng女nǚ。連lián絞jiǎo纏chán不bú過guò二èr百bǎi兩liǎng之zhī數shù,可kě就jiù留liú下xià自zì己jǐ兒ér女nǚ後hòu代dài,卻què不bú是shì好hǎo?」二èr老lǎo滴dī淚lèi道dào:「老lǎo爺yé,你nǐ不bù知zhī道dào。那nà大dà王wáng甚shèn是shì靈líng感gǎn,常cháng來lái我wǒ們men人rén家jiā行xíng走zǒu。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「他tā來lái行xíng走zǒu,你nǐ們men看kàn見jiàn他tā是shì甚shén麼me嘴zuǐ臉liǎn?有yǒu幾jǐ多duō長cháng短duǎn?」二èr老lǎo道dào:「不bú見jiàn其qí形xíng,只zhǐ聞wén得dé一yí陣zhèn香xiāng風fēng,就jiù知zhī是shì大dà王wáng爺yé爺ye來lái了le,即jí忙máng滿mǎn斗dǒu焚fén香xiāng,老lǎo少shào望wàng風fēng下xià拜bài。他tā把bǎ我wǒ們men這zhè人rén家jiā匙shi大dà碗wǎn小xiǎo之zhī事shì,他tā都dōu知zhī道dào;老lǎo幼yòu生shēng時shí年nián月yuè,他tā都dōu記jì得de。只zhǐ要yào親qīn生shēng兒ér女nǚ,他tā方fāng受shòu用yòng。不bú要yào說shuō二èr三sān百bǎi兩liǎng沒méi處chù買mǎi,就jiù是shì幾jǐ千qiān萬wàn兩liǎng,也yě沒méi處chù買mǎi這zhè般bān一yì模mú一yí樣yàng同tóng年nián同tóng月yuè的de兒ér女nǚ。」三sān藏zàng闻wén言yán,止zhǐ不bú住zhù腮sāi边biān泪lèi下xià道dào:「这zhè正zhèng是shì古gǔ人rén云yún:『黄huáng梅méi不bú落luò青qīng梅méi落luò,老lǎo天tiān偏piān害hài没méi儿ér人rén。』」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「等děng我wǒ再zài问wèn他tā。老lǎo公gōng公gong,你nǐ府fǔ上shàng有yǒu多duō大dà家jiā当dāng?」二èr老lǎo道dào:「颇pō有yǒu些xiē儿er:水shuǐ田tián有yǒu四sì五wǔ十shí顷qǐng,旱hàn田tián有yǒu六liù七qī十shí顷qǐng,草cǎo场chǎng有yǒu八bā九jiǔ十shí处chù;水shuǐ黄huáng牛niú有yǒu二èr三sān百bǎi头tóu,驴lǘ马mǎ有yǒu三sān二èr十shí匹pǐ,猪zhū羊yáng鸡jī鹅é无wú数shù。舍shè下xià也yě有yǒu吃chī不bù着zháo的de陈chén粮liáng,穿chuān不bù了liǎo的de衣yī服fú。家jiā财cái产chǎn业yè,也yě尽jìn得dé数shù。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ这zhè等děng家jiā业yè,也yě亏kuī你nǐ省shěng将jiāng起qǐ来lái的de。」老lǎo者zhě道dào:「怎zěn见jiàn我wǒ省shěng?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「既jì有yǒu这zhè家jiā私sī,怎zěn么me舍shě得de亲qīn生shēng儿ér女nǚ祭jì赛sài?拚pàn了le五wǔ十shí两liǎng银yín子zi,可kě买mǎi一yí个gè童tóng男nán;拚pàn了le一yì百bǎi两liǎng银yín子zi,可kě买mǎi一yí个gè童tóng女nǚ。连lián绞jiǎo缠chán不bú过guò二èr百bǎi两liǎng之zhī数shù,可kě就jiù留liú下xià自zì己jǐ儿ér女nǚ后hòu代dài,却què不bú是shì好hǎo?」二èr老lǎo滴dī泪lèi道dào:「老lǎo爷yé,你nǐ不bù知zhī道dào。那nà大dà王wáng甚shèn是shì灵líng感gǎn,常cháng来lái我wǒ们men人rén家jiā行xíng走zǒu。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「他tā来lái行xíng走zǒu,你nǐ们men看kàn见jiàn他tā是shì甚shén么me嘴zuǐ脸liǎn?有yǒu几jǐ多duō长cháng短duǎn?」二èr老lǎo道dào:「不bú见jiàn其qí形xíng,只zhǐ闻wén得dé一yí阵zhèn香xiāng风fēng,就jiù知zhī是shì大dà王wáng爷yé爷ye来lái了le,即jí忙máng满mǎn斗dǒu焚fén香xiāng,老lǎo少shào望wàng风fēng下xià拜bài。他tā把bǎ我wǒ们men这zhè人rén家jiā匙shi大dà碗wǎn小xiǎo之zhī事shì,他tā都dōu知zhī道dào;老lǎo幼yòu生shēng时shí年nián月yuè,他tā都dōu记jì得de。只zhǐ要yào亲qīn生shēng儿ér女nǚ,他tā方fāng受shòu用yòng。不bú要yào说shuō二èr三sān百bǎi两liǎng没méi处chù买mǎi,就jiù是shì几jǐ千qiān万wàn两liǎng,也yě没méi处chù买mǎi这zhè般bān一yì模mú一yí样yàng同tóng年nián同tóng月yuè的de儿ér女nǚ。」


逐句解 Line by line

三sān藏zàng聞wén言yán,止zhǐ不bú住zhù腮sāi邊biān淚lèi下xià道dào:「這zhè正zhèng是shì古gǔ人rén云yún:『黃huáng梅méi不bú落luò青qīng梅méi落luò,老lǎo天tiān偏piān害hài沒méi兒ér人rén。』」 三sān藏zàng闻wén言yán,止zhǐ不bú住zhù腮sāi边biān泪lèi下xià道dào:「这zhè正zhèng是shì古gǔ人rén云yún:『黄huáng梅méi不bú落luò青qīng梅méi落luò,老lǎo天tiān偏piān害hài没méi儿ér人rén。』」

Tripitaka, hearing this, could not stanch the tears at his cheeks: "This is just what the ancients meant: 'The yellow plum falls not, the green plum falls; Heaven wrongs of all men the sonless most.'"

Tripitaka weeps, and reaches for a proverb: 黃梅不落青梅落,老天偏害沒兒人. The yellow plum is ripe and ready to drop; the green one is not. Fate takes the green. And 老天偏害 — heaven goes out of its way — puts the blame squarely: of all people it could pick on, it picks the childless. 沒兒人 takes 兒 as ér, son. 藏 in 三藏 is zàng.

行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「等děng我wǒ再zài問wèn他tā。 行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「等děng我wǒ再zài问wèn他tā。

Pilgrim laughed: "Let me question him further.

行者笑道 — Wukong *laughs*, one line after that. It is not callousness. He has stopped listening for sorrow and started listening for a way out, and the questions that follow are him looking for one.

老lǎo公gōng公gong,你nǐ府fǔ上shàng有yǒu多duō大dà家jiā當dāng?」 老lǎo公gōng公gong,你nǐ府fǔ上shàng有yǒu多duō大dà家jiā当dāng?」

Old sir, how large is your household's estate?"

家當 is what a household is worth, goods and land together. An odd question to ask a weeping man, and it has a purpose.

二èr老lǎo道dào:「頗pō有yǒu些xiē兒er:水shuǐ田tián有yǒu四sì五wǔ十shí頃qǐng,旱hàn田tián有yǒu六liù七qī十shí頃qǐng,草cǎo場chǎng有yǒu八bā九jiǔ十shí處chù; 二èr老lǎo道dào:「颇pō有yǒu些xiē儿er:水shuǐ田tián有yǒu四sì五wǔ十shí顷qǐng,旱hàn田tián有yǒu六liù七qī十shí顷qǐng,草cǎo场chǎng有yǒu八bā九jiǔ十shí处chù;

The two elders said: "We have a fair bit: forty or fifty qǐng of paddy-field, sixty or seventy of dry field, eighty or ninety plots of grazing-ground;

The inventory, and it is enormous. 水田 is irrigated paddy, 旱田 unirrigated field, 草場 grazing ground — and 場 is chǎng here, a real place you could walk across, against the cháng it takes in 道場, a rite. A qǐng is a hundred of the smaller land unit English borrowed as *mu*, so forty or fifty of them is a great estate by any Ming reckoning. In 些兒 the 兒 is the little -r ending, er, not the ér that stands on its own meaning child. And note the modesty of the phrase it hangs on: 頗有些兒, "we have a fair bit."

水shuǐ黃huáng牛niú有yǒu二èr三sān百bǎi頭tóu,驢lǘ馬mǎ有yǒu三sān二èr十shí匹pǐ,豬zhū羊yáng雞jī鵝é無wú數shù。 水shuǐ黄huáng牛niú有yǒu二èr三sān百bǎi头tóu,驴lǘ马mǎ有yǒu三sān二èr十shí匹pǐ,猪zhū羊yáng鸡jī鹅é无wú数shù。

two or three hundred head of water-buffalo and ox, twenty or thirty donkeys and horses, and pigs, sheep, fowl, and geese past counting.

Two or three hundred head of cattle, twenty or thirty donkeys and horses, and poultry 無數, past counting — 數 read shù. Every figure is given as a range, which is how a man talks about property he has never had to count.

舍shè下xià也yě有yǒu吃chī不bù著zháo的de陳chén糧liáng,穿chuān不bù了liǎo的de衣yī服fú。 舍shè下xià也yě有yǒu吃chī不bù着zháo的de陈chén粮liáng,穿chuān不bù了liǎo的de衣yī服fú。

At home too we have old grain we cannot eat through, and clothes we cannot wear out.

吃不著的陳糧 is old grain they cannot eat their way through — 著 read zháo, the reading for reaching or attaining a thing, and because zháo rises, the 不 before it stays bù. 穿不了的衣服, clothes they cannot wear out, takes 了 as liǎo. Grain going stale and cloth going unworn: the picture is not luxury but surplus with nobody to leave it to.

家jiā財cái產chǎn業yè,也yě盡jìn得dé數shù。」 家jiā财cái产chǎn业yè,也yě尽jìn得dé数shù。」

Our wealth and holdings, too, can all be reckoned."

盡得數 takes 得 as dé and 數 as shù — it can all be reckoned up. Which is exactly the point Wukong is about to make, and exactly the point they are about to demolish.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ這zhè等děng家jiā業yè,也yě虧kuī你nǐ省shěng將jiāng起qǐ來lái的de。」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ这zhè等děng家jiā业yè,也yě亏kuī你nǐ省shěng将jiāng起qǐ来lái的de。」

Pilgrim said: "With an estate like this, you have done well to save it up.

虧你省將起來的 — you have done well to save it up, 將 read jiāng. It sounds like a compliment. It is bait.

老lǎo者zhě道dào:「怎zěn見jiàn我wǒ省shěng?」 老lǎo者zhě道dào:「怎zěn见jiàn我wǒ省shěng?」

The old man said: "How do you see me as thrifty?"

怎見我省: how do you make me out to be thrifty? The old man walks into it.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「既jì有yǒu這zhè家jiā私sī,怎zěn麼me捨shě得de親qīn生shēng兒ér女nǚ祭jì賽sài? 行xíng者zhě道dào:「既jì有yǒu这zhè家jiā私sī,怎zěn么me舍shě得de亲qīn生shēng儿ér女nǚ祭jì赛sài?

Pilgrim said: "Having such means, how can you bear to sacrifice your own flesh-and-blood children?

And the hook: 捨得, to be able to bring yourself to give a thing up — 得 read de, linking the verb to whether it can be done. Wukong is calling them stingy with their children, which is monstrous and, as a debating move, effective. 兒女 takes 兒 as ér.

拚pàn了le五wǔ十shí兩liǎng銀yín子zi,可kě買mǎi一yí個gè童tóng男nán; 拚pàn了le五wǔ十shí两liǎng银yín子zi,可kě买mǎi一yí个gè童tóng男nán;

For fifty taels of silver you could buy a boy;

拚了 is to lay out money and not count the cost. Fifty taels buys a boy.

拚pàn了le一yì百bǎi兩liǎng銀yín子zi,可kě買mǎi一yí個gè童tóng女nǚ。 拚pàn了le一yì百bǎi两liǎng银yín子zi,可kě买mǎi一yí个gè童tóng女nǚ。

for a hundred taels you could buy a girl.

A hundred buys a girl — twice the price, and the text lets that sit there without a word of explanation. It is a market Wukong evidently knows the rates in.

連lián絞jiǎo纏chán不bú過guò二èr百bǎi兩liǎng之zhī數shù,可kě就jiù留liú下xià自zì己jǐ兒ér女nǚ後hòu代dài,卻què不bú是shì好hǎo?」 连lián绞jiǎo缠chán不bú过guò二èr百bǎi两liǎng之zhī数shù,可kě就jiù留liú下xià自zì己jǐ儿ér女nǚ后hòu代dài,却què不bú是shì好hǎo?」

All told, with incidentals, no more than two hundred taels — and you could keep your own children and your line's posterity. Is that not the better course?"

絞纏 is the incidental costs around a transaction, the wrapping and the middlemen. Two hundred taels all told, against a fortune in land and cattle, and you keep your own children and your line after them. 之數 takes 數 as shù; 兒女 takes 兒 as ér. The arithmetic is unanswerable, and the answer comes anyway.

二èr老lǎo滴dī淚lèi道dào:「老lǎo爺yé,你nǐ不bù知zhī道dào。 二èr老lǎo滴dī泪lèi道dào:「老lǎo爷yé,你nǐ不bù知zhī道dào。

The two elders wept: "Reverend, you do not understand.

你不知道: you don't understand. Said through tears, and it is the turn of the whole passage.

那nà大dà王wáng甚shèn是shì靈líng感gǎn,常cháng來lái我wǒ們men人rén家jiā行xíng走zǒu。」 那nà大dà王wáng甚shèn是shì灵líng感gǎn,常cháng来lái我wǒ们men人rén家jiā行xíng走zǒu。」

That Great King is exceedingly numinous, and comes often to walk among our households."

甚是靈感 takes 甚 as shèn, "extremely" — the god is very good indeed at answering. 行走 takes 行 as xíng, and the verb is domestic: he comes *calling*, the way a neighbour drops in. That is worse than any amount of thunder. 那 points — nà.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「他tā來lái行xíng走zǒu,你nǐ們men看kàn見jiàn他tā是shì甚shén麼me嘴zuǐ臉liǎn? 行xíng者zhě道dào:「他tā来lái行xíng走zǒu,你nǐ们men看kàn见jiàn他tā是shì甚shén么me嘴zuǐ脸liǎn?

Pilgrim said: "When he comes walking, what sort of face do you see him wear?

嘴臉 is the face, features, look of a thing. Wukong asks the two questions a fighter asks: what does he look like, and how big is he? 甚 is shén.

有yǒu幾jǐ多duō長cháng短duǎn?」 有yǒu几jǐ多duō长cháng短duǎn?」

And how tall or short is he?"

長短 takes 長 as cháng, the dimension reading — how long or short, meaning how tall. He is sizing up an opponent.

二èr老lǎo道dào:「不bú見jiàn其qí形xíng,只zhǐ聞wén得dé一yí陣zhèn香xiāng風fēng,就jiù知zhī是shì大dà王wáng爺yé爺ye來lái了le,即jí忙máng滿mǎn斗dǒu焚fén香xiāng,老lǎo少shào望wàng風fēng下xià拜bài。 二èr老lǎo道dào:「不bú见jiàn其qí形xíng,只zhǐ闻wén得dé一yí阵zhèn香xiāng风fēng,就jiù知zhī是shì大dà王wáng爷yé爷ye来lái了le,即jí忙máng满mǎn斗dǒu焚fén香xiāng,老lǎo少shào望wàng风fēng下xià拜bài。

The two elders said: "We see no shape of him; only we smell a gust of fragrant wind, and know the Great King has come, and hasten to burn a full dǒu of incense, young and old bowing toward the wind.

And gets nothing to fight. 不見其形, no shape is ever seen; only 一陣香風, a gust of fragrant wind — which in this book is the standard warning that something supernatural has arrived, and here it is the whole of what anyone knows. 滿斗焚香 is burning a full dǒu measure of incense, 斗 read dǒu; 望風下拜, bowing toward the wind, is worship aimed at a direction because there is no figure to aim it at. 聞得 takes 得 as dé.

他tā把bǎ我wǒ們men這zhè人rén家jiā匙shi大dà碗wǎn小xiǎo之zhī事shì,他tā都dōu知zhī道dào; 他tā把bǎ我wǒ们men这zhè人rén家jiā匙shi大dà碗wǎn小xiǎo之zhī事shì,他tā都dōu知zhī道dào;

The petty affairs of our households, down to the size of a spoon or a bowl, he knows them all;

匙大碗小之事 — matters the size of a spoon or a bowl — is a homely way of saying he knows everything, down to the crockery. The god has been in their kitchens. 都 is dōu.

老lǎo幼yòu生shēng時shí年nián月yuè,他tā都dōu記jì得de。 老lǎo幼yòu生shēng时shí年nián月yuè,他tā都dōu记jì得de。

the birth-times of young and old, the year and month, he remembers them all.

And he keeps the register: 老幼生時年月, the birth year and month of every soul in the village, young and old. 記得 takes 得 as de; 都 is dōu. He is not a monster in the hills. He is an administrator with a census.

只zhǐ要yào親qīn生shēng兒ér女nǚ,他tā方fāng受shòu用yòng。 只zhǐ要yào亲qīn生shēng儿ér女nǚ,他tā方fāng受shòu用yòng。

Only flesh-and-blood children will he accept for his enjoyment.

親生 is your own, born of your body; 受用 is to take enjoyment of a thing. Only true-born children will do — which closes the loophole and, without anyone noticing, opens a different one.

不bú要yào說shuō二èr三sān百bǎi兩liǎng沒méi處chù買mǎi,就jiù是shì幾jǐ千qiān萬wàn兩liǎng,也yě沒méi處chù買mǎi這zhè般bān一yì模mú一yí樣yàng同tóng年nián同tóng月yuè的de兒ér女nǚ。」 不bú要yào说shuō二èr三sān百bǎi两liǎng没méi处chù买mǎi,就jiù是shì几jǐ千qiān万wàn两liǎng,也yě没méi处chù买mǎi这zhè般bān一yì模mú一yí样yàng同tóng年nián同tóng月yuè的de儿ér女nǚ。」

Not to speak of two or three hundred taels, with no place to buy them — even for tens of millions there is nowhere to buy children so exactly alike, of the same year and month."

一模一樣, cut from the same mould, is still the everyday Chinese for identical; 同年同月 matches them by birth year and month. Not two or three hundred taels, not tens of millions — there is nowhere to buy children who match. The reply is meant to close the argument. What it actually does is write the specification for a forgery, and the one creature in the room who can meet it is listening. 兒女 takes 兒 as ér.


總評 Commentary

Wukong's first instinct is entirely practical, and the passage lets him run the whole way with it before knocking it down. Learning that the Chens are in fact rich — paddy and dry field by the qǐng, cattle by the hundred, grain going stale and cloth going unworn — he proposes the obvious remedy: fifty taels buys a boy, a hundred buys a girl, two hundred covers the lot with incidentals, and you keep your own children. It is humane in intent and completely worldly in logic, and Tripitaka has already set something truer against it, weeping over the proverb of the green plum taken while the ripe one hangs on.

The elders' answer closes the escape and makes the demon far worse than a big animal in the water. He cannot be cheated with bought substitutes, because he is not a stranger. He calls at their houses. Nobody ever sees a shape — only a gust of scented wind, and then the whole village burning incense and bowing toward a direction. He knows every household's affairs down to the size of a spoon; he knows every villager's birth year and month; and he will take none but the true-born, matched by age to the month. It is the portrait of a god as an administrator with a complete census, and the villagers' helplessness is total.

And then the reply does something its speakers cannot see. In specifying exactly what the god will accept — this child, this age, this month, indistinguishable — the old men have written a set of requirements. Money cannot meet them. But there is somebody in the room who has spent the whole book being other people, and he has been listening very carefully.