Canonical Classics ← 第四十六回
第四十六回
wàidàonòngqiángzhèng
xīnyuánxiǎnshèngmièzhūxié

The Heterodox, Flaunting Their Strength, Affront the True Law · The Mind-Monkey, Manifesting His Sainthood, Destroys the Fiends

啃桃留核
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

啃桃留核 The Peach Gnawed to the Pit

tángsēngdào:「ayòuláicāile。」xíngzhědào:「fàngxīnděngzàikànkàn。」yòuyīngdeshēngfēijiāngháicóngbǎnfèngerzuānjìnjiànshìtáozizhèngxiànleyuánshēnzuòzàiguìjiāngtáozidùnkǒukěndegāngānjìngjìngliánliǎngbiānsāiāoerdōukěnjìnglejiāngerānzàimiànréngbiànjiāoliáochóngfēijiāngchūdīngzàitángsēngěrduǒshàngdào:「shīzhǐcāishìtáozi。」zhǎnglǎodào:「axiūyàonòngxiānqiánshìkǒukuàidiǎnxíngzhèfāncāibǎobèifānghǎotáozishìshénbǎobèi?」xíngzhědào:「xiūzhǐguǎnyíng便biànle。」tángsēngdào:「ayòuláicāile。」xíngzhědào:「fàngxīnděngzàikànkàn。」yòuyīngdeshēngfēijiāngháicóngbǎnfèngerzuānjìnjiànshìtáozizhèngxiànleyuánshēnzuòzàiguìjiāngtáozidùnkǒukěndegāngānjìngjìngliánliǎngbiānsāiāoerdōukěnjìnglejiāngerānzàimiànréngbiànjiāoliáochóngfēijiāngchūdīngzàitángsēngěrduǒshàngdào:「shīzhǐcāishìtáozi。」zhǎnglǎodào:「axiūyàonòngxiānqiánshìkǒukuàidiǎnxíngzhèfāncāibǎobèifānghǎotáozishìshénbǎobèi?」xíngzhědào:「xiūzhǐguǎnyíng便biànle。」


逐句解 Line by line

tángsēngdào:「ayòuláicāile。」 tángsēngdào:「ayòuláicāile。」

The Tang Monk said: "Disciple, ah — here's another guess to make."

又來猜了 — here we go again. The weariness in the line is the whole joke: for Tripitaka this is a second brush with the executioner, and for Wukong it is a second helping.

xíngzhědào:「fàngxīnděngzàikànkàn。」 xíngzhědào:「fàngxīnděngzàikànkàn。」

The Pilgrim said: "Rest easy; let me go and look once more."

等我再去看看: = kàn, doubled to keep it casual. He is enjoying this.

yòuyīngdeshēngfēijiāngháicóngbǎnfèngerzuānjìnjiànshìtáozizhèng yòuyīngdeshēngfēijiāngháicóngbǎnfèngerzuānjìnjiànshìtáozizhèng

Again with a thin droning buzz he flew off, bored back in through the chink in the boards, and saw it was a peach — which suited his fancy exactly.

又嚶的一聲 — the same thin hum as before, the chapter's audio cue for a gnat on the move. 飛將去: = jiāng, pointing the flight. 還從板縫兒: = hái, back through the same chink, with the small = er. And 正合他意 — it suited him exactly. Of all the objects in the palace, they have handed him a peach.

xiànleyuánshēnzuòzàiguìjiāngtáozidùnkǒukěndegāngānjìngjìngliánliǎngbiānsāiāoerdōukěnjìnglejiāngerānzàimiàn xiànleyuánshēnzuòzàiguìjiāngtáozidùnkǒukěndegāngānjìngjìngliánliǎngbiānsāiāoerdōukěnjìnglejiāngerānzàimiàn

At once he showed his own true form, sat down inside the chest, and in one bout gnawed the peach clean away — even the flesh in the two cheek-hollows he gnawed off bare — and set the stone back inside.

He does not transform the peach; he eats it, which is neater and much more in character. 啃得乾乾淨淨 — gnawed clean away, with = de joining verb to result. Note the : here it is gān, "dry, clean," doubled up for emphasis — not the qián of 乾坤, heaven-and-earth, on the queen's skirt in the passage before. Same character, two worlds apart. 腮凹兒 are the two hollows in the fruit's cheeks, and he strips those too ( = dōu, = er). Then the stone goes back in the box. Both are jiāng.

réngbiànjiāoliáochóngfēijiāngchūdīngzàitángsēngěrduǒshàngdào:「shīzhǐcāishìtáozi。」 réngbiànjiāoliáochóngfēijiāngchūdīngzàitángsēngěrduǒshàngdào:「shīzhǐcāishìtáozi。」

He changed back into a gnat-fly, flew out, perched on the Tang Monk's ear, and said: "Master, just guess it to be a peach-stone."

飛將出去: = jiāng. 桃核子 — a peach-stone, with the light = zi. The instruction is delivered to the ear, as always, and is as bald as it could be.

zhǎnglǎodào:「axiūyàonòng zhǎnglǎodào:「axiūyàonòng

The elder said: "Disciple, ah — don't make sport of me.

休要弄我 — don't make sport of me. The master thinks he is being teased, which after the last round is fair enough. 長老: = zhǎng.

xiānqiánshìkǒukuàidiǎnxíng xiānqiánshìkǒukuàidiǎnxíng

Just now, had I not been quick of tongue, I'd all but been hauled off to execution.

典刑 is the legal term for a capital sentence, not a beating — Tripitaka is quite right about how close it was. 不是口快 is "had I not been quick of tongue."

zhèfāncāibǎobèifānghǎo zhèfāncāibǎobèifānghǎo

This time I must guess a treasure to come off well.

這番 is "this bout"; 須猜寶貝方好, I must guess a treasure and only then will it do. He has learned exactly the wrong lesson from surviving.

táozishìshénbǎobèi?」 táozishìshénbǎobèi?」

How is a peach-stone any treasure?"

是甚寶貝: = shén, "what treasure." 桃核子 again takes the light = zi. The objection is unanswerable and completely irrelevant.

xíngzhědào:「xiūzhǐguǎnyíng便biànle。」 xíngzhědào:「xiūzhǐguǎnyíng便biànle。」

The Pilgrim said: "Never fear — only keep on winning against him, and that will do."

只管贏他便了 — just keep beating him and that's that. In 便了 the is the light le that closes a sentence off, not the verb liǎo, "to finish." It is the most Wukong sentence in the passage: never mind the theory, win the round.


總評 Commentary

The third swap is the neatest of the lot, because it is not a transformation at all. Wukong simply eats the peach and leaves the stone, so that when Tripitaka guesses "a peach-stone" he is not lying, or being magically vindicated — he is just right. 啃得乾乾淨淨, gnawed clean away, down to the hollows in the fruit's cheeks: the storyteller is enjoying the monkey's greed even while it does honest work.

Underneath the farce the danger stays visible. Tripitaka remembers, in the same breath, how close he came to being 拿去典刑, hauled off for a capital sentence, and he is right to. Wukong's reply — 只管贏他便了, just keep winning and that's that — is the whole difference between them in seven characters. And there is a quiet emblem buried in the scene: the peach is the Daoist token of the immortality these three men claim to have achieved, and it is eaten down to nothing by the power they are trying to beat.