Canonical Classics ← 第四十六回
第四十六回
wàidàonòngqiángzhèng
xīnyuánxiǎnshèngmièzhūxié

The Heterodox, Flaunting Their Strength, Affront the True Law · The Mind-Monkey, Manifesting His Sainthood, Destroys the Fiends

賭禪推應
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

賭禪推應 Demurral and Assent

guówángjiànyǒuxiēnánchùjiù便biànchuánzhǐwèndào:「shàngguóshīyàoyúnxiǎnshèngzuòchánhuìme?」xíngzhěwényánchényínjièdào:「gezěnmeyán?」xíngzhědào:「xiōngshímánshuōruòshìtiānnòngjǐngjiǎohǎifānjiāngdānshāngǎnyuèhuàndǒuxīngzhūbānqiǎoshìdōugànjiùshìkǎntóuduònǎopōuwānxīnyàngténgnuóquèdànshuōzuòchánjiùshūleyǒuzhèzuòxìngjiùsuǒzàitiězhùzishàngyàoshàngxiàchǎxiǎngzuòdezhù。」sānzàngdekāiyándào:「huìzuòchán。」xíngzhěhuāndào:「quèhǎoquèhǎozuòdeduōshǎoshí?」sānzàngdào:「yòuniánfāngshàngchánsēngjiǎngdàoxìngmìnggēnběnshàngdìngxìngcúnshénzàishēngguānzuòèrsānniántóu。」xíngzhědào:「shīruòzuòèrsānniánmenjiùjīngbaduōshàngèrsānshíchénjiùxiàláile。」sānzàngdào:「yaquèshìnéngshàng。」xíngzhědào:「shàngqiányìngsòngshàng。」guówángjiànyǒuxiēnánchùjiù便biànchuánzhǐwèndào:「shàngguóshīyàoyúnxiǎnshèngzuòchánhuìme?」xíngzhěwényánchényínjièdào:「gezěnmeyán?」xíngzhědào:「xiōngshímánshuōruòshìtiānnòngjǐngjiǎohǎifānjiāngdānshāngǎnyuèhuàndǒuxīngzhūbānqiǎoshìdōugànjiùshìkǎntóuduònǎopōuwānxīnyàngténgnuóquèdànshuōzuòchánjiùshūleyǒuzhèzuòxìngjiùsuǒzàitiězhùzishàngyàoshàngxiàchǎxiǎngzuòdezhù。」sānzàngdekāiyándào:「huìzuòchán。」xíngzhěhuāndào:「quèhǎoquèhǎozuòdeduōshǎoshí?」sānzàngdào:「yòuniánfāngshàngchánsēngjiǎngdàoxìngmìnggēnběnshàngdìngxìngcúnshénzàishēngguānzuòèrsānniántóu。」xíngzhědào:「shīruòzuòèrsānniánmenjiùjīngbaduōshàngèrsānshíchénjiùxiàláile。」sānzàngdào:「yaquèshìnéngshàng。」xíngzhědào:「shàngqiányìngsòngshàng。」


逐句解 Line by line

guówángjiànyǒuxiēnánchùjiù便biànchuánzhǐwèndào:「shàngguóshīyàoyúnxiǎnshèngzuòchánhuìme?」 guówángjiànyǒuxiēnánchùjiù便biànchuánzhǐwèndào:「shàngguóshīyàoyúnxiǎnshèngzuòchánhuìme?」

The king, finding here some awkwardness, thereupon issued a decree of inquiry: "Monk — my National Preceptor would wager you at Manifesting Sainthood on the Cloud-Ladder, a contest of meditation. Which of you can do it?"

The king puts the challenge to the monks, and the sentence hands us both sounds of in a row. 那和尚 points — , "that monk over there." 那個會麼 asks — , "which of you can?" Same character, opposite jobs. 難處 is the awkward spot he is in: = nán, = chù, "a point, an aspect."

xíngzhěwényánchényín xíngzhěwényánchényín

The Pilgrim, hearing this, brooded and gave no answer.

沉吟不答 is to chew a thing over in silence — the pause of somebody who has just been asked the one question he cannot bluff.

jièdào:「gezěnmeyán?」 jièdào:「gezěnmeyán?」

Eight Rules said: "Brother, why so tongue-tied?"

怎麼不言語 — "why the silence?" Bajie has never seen his brother stuck for an answer.

xíngzhědào:「xiōngshímánshuō xíngzhědào:「xiōngshímánshuō

The Pilgrim said: "Brother, I'll not hide it from you truly.

實不瞞你說 is "in plain truth, I'll keep nothing back from you" — the phrase that flags a confession coming.

ruòshìtiānnòngjǐngjiǎohǎifānjiāngdānshāngǎnyuèhuàndǒuxīngzhūbānqiǎoshìdōugàn ruòshìtiānnòngjǐngjiǎohǎifānjiāngdānshāngǎnyuèhuàndǒuxīngzhūbānqiǎoshìdōugàn

Kicking the sky and stirring up wells, churning the seas and overturning rivers, shouldering mountains to chase down the moon, swapping the Dipper and shifting the stars — all such cunning feats I can bring off;

Four boasts in eight characters, and every one of them a set phrase: kicking the sky and stirring wells, churning seas and upending rivers, shouldering mountains to chase the moon, swapping the Dipper and shifting the stars. is dān, "to shoulder"; the of 換斗移星 is dǒu, the Dipper. 我都幹得: = dōu, "the lot of them," and = , "can, am able."

jiùshìkǎntóuduònǎopōuwānxīnyàngténgnuóquè jiùshìkǎntóuduònǎopōuwānxīnyàngténgnuóquè

and hacking off heads and mincing brains, splitting bellies and gouging hearts, all manner of uncanny sleights — those too I do not fear;

The list turns grisly, and note what he is casually promising here — heads hacked off, bellies opened, hearts cut out. Every item will be performed on stage before the chapter ends. In 異樣騰那, is nuó: 騰挪 is to leap and shift and work transformations, nothing to do with the pointing .

dànshuōzuòchánjiùshūle dànshuōzuòchánjiùshūle

but speak of sitting in meditation, and I've already lost.

但說坐禪我就輸了 — name the meditation and I have lost already. The joke lands because it is the one thing on the list that costs nothing and requires nothing.

yǒuzhèzuòxìng yǒuzhèzuòxìng

Where should I find the patience to sit?

Here asks a question it does not want answered: , "where should I find…" 坐性 is a sitting temperament, the knack of staying put — and it is precisely what the mind-monkey does not have.

jiùsuǒzàitiězhùzishàngyàoshàngxiàchǎxiǎngzuòdezhù。」 jiùsuǒzàitiězhùzishàngyàoshàngxiàchǎxiǎngzuòdezhù。」

Even were you to chain me to an iron pillar, I'd still be scrambling up and down and could never sit still."

鐵柱子 takes the light = zi. 爬蹅 is to clamber about. 坐得住 joins verb to result with = de: to sit and make it stick. Chain him to an iron pillar and he would still be climbing it.

sānzàngdekāiyándào:「huìzuòchán。」 sānzàngdekāiyándào:「huìzuòchán。」

Tripitaka suddenly spoke up: "I can sit in meditation."

The quietest line in the passage and the turn of the whole scene. 三藏sān zàng, the Three Baskets of scripture, and the name Tripitaka carries because he is going to fetch them; = zàng. He has said nothing for two pages, and now says the one thing nobody expected.

xíngzhěhuāndào:「quèhǎoquèhǎo xíngzhěhuāndào:「quèhǎoquèhǎo

The Pilgrim said gladly: "Splendid, splendid.

卻好卻好 — "just so, just so." Relief, doubled.

zuòdeduōshǎoshí?」 zuòdeduōshǎoshí?」

And how long can you sit?"

坐得多少時: = de, joining the sitting to how long it can be kept up.

sānzàngdào:「yòuniánfāngshàngchánsēngjiǎngdàoxìngmìnggēnběnshàngdìngxìngcúnshénzàishēngguānzuòèrsānniántóu。」 sānzàngdào:「yòuniánfāngshàngchánsēngjiǎngdàoxìngmìnggēnběnshàngdìngxìngcúnshénzàishēngguānzuòèrsānniántóu。」

Tripitaka said: "In my young years I met a wandering Chan monk who expounded the Way; upon the very root of nature and life, in stilling the nature and preserving the spirit, within the barrier of death and birth, I once sat two or three years together."

Tripitaka's credentials, and they are real. 方上禪僧 is a Chan monk of the roving sort, one of the wandering teachers who turned up at a temple gate and moved on. 定性存神 is to still the nature and keep the spirit in place; 死生關 is the pass or barrier of death-and-life, the checkpoint every meditator is trying to hold. Two or three years at a stretch, he says. = .

xíngzhědào:「shīruòzuòèrsānniánmenjiùjīngba xíngzhědào:「shīruòzuòèrsānniánmenjiùjīngba

The Pilgrim said: "Master, if you sit two or three years, then we may as well not fetch the scriptures at all.

Wukong does the arithmetic and panics. at the end is the resigned ba — "we may as well not bother" — not the verb , "to stop."

duōshàngèrsānshíchénjiùxiàláile。」 duōshàngèrsānshíchénjiùxiàláile。」

At most two or three watches, and then come down."

不上二三個時辰 is "no more than two or three watches" — a 時辰 is a double hour, so he is offering four to six hours against his master's two years, and calling it generous.

sānzàngdào:「yaquèshìnéngshàng。」 sānzàngdào:「yaquèshìnéngshàng。」

Tripitaka said: "Disciple, ah — the trouble is I cannot get up there."

卻是不能上去 — "but the thing is, I can't get up there." The whole contest now hangs on a ladder.

xíngzhědào:「shàngqiányìngsòngshàng。」 xíngzhědào:「shàngqiányìngsòngshàng。」

The Pilgrim said: "Step forward and answer the call; I'll send you up."

in 答應 is yìng, "to answer, to take up the call," not the yīng that means "ought." Step forward and say yes; the transport is his problem.


總評 Commentary

This is one of the novel's most likeable self-portraits of the 心猿, the mind-monkey. Wukong can overturn oceans and shift the stars; he says flatly that he does not fear being beheaded or cut open. Then he comes to sitting still and admits defeat before the contest starts. 那裡有這坐性 — where would I find the patience to sit? Chain him to an iron pillar and he would climb it. The whole character is in that sentence: an intelligence that can do anything except be quiet.

The scene also turns on a neat comic hinge. Tripitaka can sit but cannot climb; Wukong can climb but cannot sit; between them they make one complete contestant. And the master's credentials are not a joke — 定性存神, stilling the nature and keeping the spirit, held for two or three years at the 死生關, the barrier of death and life. For once in the journey it is Tripitaka who has the training the Daoist meant to test. The verb that sets the machinery going is 答應 (yìng), to answer the summons: step forward and say yes, and let the disciple work out the transport.