Canonical Classics ← 第四十六回
第四十六回
wàidàonòngqiángzhèng
xīnyuánxiǎnshèngmièzhūxié

The Heterodox, Flaunting Their Strength, Affront the True Law · The Mind-Monkey, Manifesting His Sainthood, Destroys the Fiends

三藏求祭
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

三藏求祭 A Plea to Mourn

huāngdesānzànggāojiào:「xiàshèpínsēngshícóngguījiàoyǒugōngjīnchōngzhuàngguóshīzàiyóuguōzhīnèinàixiānzhěwéishénpínsēngzěngǎntānshēngzhèngshìtiānxiàguānyuánguǎnzhetiānxiàbǎixìngxiàruòjiàochénchéngǎnzhǐwàngkuānēnbànzhǎnliáng漿jiāngshuǐfànsānzhāngzhǐróngdàoyóuguōqiánshāozhǐbiǎoshīniànshízàilǐngzuì。」guówángwényándào:「shìzhōnghuárénduōyǒu。」mìngxiē漿jiāngfànhuángqiánguǒránletángsēnghuāngdesānzànggāojiào:「xiàshèpínsēngshícóngguījiàoyǒugōngjīnchōngzhuàngguóshīzàiyóuguōzhīnèinàixiānzhěwéishénpínsēngzěngǎntānshēngzhèngshìtiānxiàguānyuánguǎnzhetiānxiàbǎixìngxiàruòjiàochénchéngǎnzhǐwàngkuānēnbànzhǎnliángjiāngshuǐfànsānzhāngzhǐróngdàoyóuguōqiánshāozhǐbiǎoshīniànshízàilǐngzuì。」guówángwényándào:「shìzhōnghuárénduōyǒu。」mìngxiējiāngfànhuángqiánguǒránletángsēng


逐句解 Line by line

huāngdesānzànggāojiào:「xiàshèpínsēngshí huāngdesānzànggāojiào:「xiàshèpínsēngshí

In a fluster the Tang Monk cried aloud: "Your Majesty, spare this poor monk a moment.

慌得三藏高叫 — flustered into shouting. = de; = zàng. 赦貧僧一時, spare this poor monk a moment: the same phrase that saved his life over the first chest, tried once more.

cóngguījiàoyǒugōng cóngguījiàoyǒugōng

That disciple of mine, since he joined the faith, has had merit upon merit.

自從歸教 — since he joined the faith, = jiào, the teaching. 歷歷有功 is merit plain and countable, one item after another. Tripitaka is writing a reference for a dead man.

jīnchōngzhuàngguóshīzàiyóuguōzhīnèinàixiānzhěwéishén jīnchōngzhuàngguóshīzàiyóuguōzhīnèinàixiānzhěwéishén

Today, having crossed the National Preceptor, he has died in the oil-cauldron; but alas, the first to die becomes a spirit.

先死者為神 — the one who dies first becomes a spirit. is wéi here, "becomes, is made," not the wèi that means "for the sake of" — and the lament in the next passage will use that other reading, near enough to compare. The sentiment is folk belief rather than doctrine: the earlier ghost has seniority in the world below.

pínsēngzěngǎntānshēng pínsēngzěngǎntānshēng

How should this poor monk dare cling to life?

怎敢貪生 — how should I dare cling to life? 貪生 is literally to be greedy for living, and it is a real accusation in this moral vocabulary, not a figure of speech.

zhèngshìtiānxiàguānyuánguǎnzhetiānxiàbǎixìng zhèngshìtiānxiàguānyuánguǎnzhetiānxiàbǎixìng

Truly, the realm's officials govern the realm's people.

天下官員也管著天下百姓 — the realm's officials govern the realm's people, with = zhe holding the governing open. Another saying quoted inside the sentence rather than set off as verse. He is arguing that a subject cannot refuse the state, which is a strange thing to volunteer while asking for a favour, and quite deliberate.

xiàruòjiàochénchéngǎn xiàruòjiàochénchéngǎn

If Your Majesty orders me to die, how should I, your servant, dare not to die?

若教臣死: = jiào, if you order me to die. And — your servant, the word an official uses of himself to the throne. Tripitaka, a foreign monk, has cast himself as this king's subject in order to get one small thing.

zhǐwàngkuānēnbànzhǎnliáng漿jiāngshuǐfànsānzhāngzhǐróngdàoyóuguōqiánshāozhǐbiǎoshīniànshízàilǐngzuì。」 zhǐwàngkuānēnbànzhǎnliángjiāngshuǐfànsānzhāngzhǐróngdàoyóuguōqiánshāozhǐbiǎoshīniànshízàilǐngzuì。」

I ask only for clemency: grant me half a cup of cold gruel and three paper-horses, and leave to go before the oil-cauldron to burn a string of spirit-money — to mark our master-and-disciple bond — and then I'll take my punishment."

The one small thing is a funeral. 半盞涼漿水飯 is half a cup of cold gruel — the simplest food-offering there is. 紙馬 are paper horses, burnt so the dead have transport; 一陌紙 is a bundle of spirit-money, being an old way of counting a hundred sheets. It is a modest Ming funeral rite, requested at the edge of a cauldron. = .

guówángwényándào:「shìzhōnghuárénduōyǒu。」 guówángwényándào:「shìzhōnghuárénduōyǒu。」

The king, hearing his words, said: "Just so — those men of China are mostly men of honour."

中華人多有義氣 — men of China are mostly men of honour. 義氣 is loyalty between comrades, the virtue of sworn brothers and outlaws rather than of courts, and it is what finally moves him. = ; = zhōng.

mìngxiē漿jiāngfànhuángqián mìngxiējiāngfànhuángqián

He ordered some gruel and yellow spirit-money fetched and given to him.

黃錢, yellow money, is the coarse yellow paper burnt as currency for the dead. The king supplies the funeral goods himself, which is the closest thing to decency he manages in this chapter.

guǒránletángsēng guǒránletángsēng

It was duly fetched and handed to the Tang Monk.

果然取了遞與唐僧 — duly fetched, and handed over. The offering that is about to be wasted on an empty cauldron.


總評 Commentary

Believing his disciple truly dead, Tripitaka does not ask for rescue or for mercy. He asks for permission to hold a funeral: half a cup of cold gruel, three paper horses, a bundle of spirit-money to burn at the cauldron's edge. It is a modest and entirely conventional Ming offering, and the modesty is the point — this is the emotional counterweight to a chapter otherwise built out of gags, and it is exactly this display of feeling that Wukong, lying at the bottom of the pot as a date-pit, will answer.

The way he frames the request is worth watching. He argues in the language of loyal subjection — the realm's officials govern the realm's people; if Your Majesty orders me to die, how should I, your servant, dare not? — casting himself as this foreign king's subject in order to buy one small favour. It works, and the king's reason for granting it is a nice piece of characterisation on both sides: 中華人多有義氣, men of China are mostly men of honour. 義氣 is loyalty between comrades rather than the obedience Tripitaka has just been professing, and it is that, not the argument, that moves him.