Canonical Classics ← 第二十六回
第二十六回
孫sūn悟wù空kōng三sān島dǎo求qiú方fāng
觀guān世shì音yīn甘gān泉quán活huó樹shù

Sun Wukong Seeks a Cure Among the Three Isles · Guanyin's Sweet Spring Revives the Tree

三星無方
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

三星無方 The Stars Have No Cure

三sān星xīng聞wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng也yě悶mèn道dào:「你nǐ這zhè猴hóu兒er,全quán不bù識shí人rén。那nà鎮zhèn元yuán子zǐ乃nǎi地dì仙xiān之zhī祖zǔ;我wǒ等děng乃nǎi神shén仙xiān之zhī宗zōng;你nǐ雖suī得dé了le天tiān仙xiān,還hái是shì太tài乙yǐ散sǎn數shù,未wèi入rù真zhēn流liú,你nǐ怎zěn麼me脫tuō得de他tā手shǒu?若ruò是shì大dà聖shèng打dǎ殺shā了le走zǒu獸shòu飛fēi禽qín、蜾guǒ蟲chóng鱗lín長zhǎng,只zhǐ用yòng我wǒ黍shǔ米mǐ之zhī丹dān,可kě以yǐ救jiù活huó。那nà人rén參shēn果guǒ乃nǎi仙xiān木mù之zhī根gēn,如rú何hé醫yī治zhì?沒méi方fāng,沒méi方fāng。」那nà行xíng者zhě見jiàn說shuō無wú方fāng,卻què就jiù眉méi峰fēng雙shuāng鎖suǒ,額é蹙cù千qiān痕hén。福fú星xīng道dào:「大dà聖shèng,此cǐ處chù無wú方fāng,他tā處chù或huò有yǒu,怎zěn麼me就jiù生shēng煩fán惱nǎo?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「無wú方fāng別bié訪fǎng,果guǒ然rán容róng易yì,就jiù是shì遊yóu遍biàn海hǎi角jiǎo天tiān涯yá,轉zhuǎn透tòu三sān十shí六liù天tiān,亦yì是shì小xiǎo可kě。只zhǐ是shì我wǒ那nà唐táng長zhǎng老lǎo法fǎ嚴yán量liàng窄zhǎi,止zhǐ與yǔ了le我wǒ三sān日rì期qī限xiàn;三sān日rì以yǐ外wài不bú到dào,他tā就jiù要yào念niàn那nà緊jǐn箍gū兒er咒zhòu哩li。」三sān星xīng笑xiào道dào:「好hǎo,好hǎo,好hǎo,若ruò不bú是shì這zhè個gè法fǎ兒er拘jū束shù你nǐ,你nǐ又yòu鑽zuān天tiān了le。」壽shòu星xīng道dào:「大dà聖shèng放fàng心xīn,不bù須xū煩fán惱nǎo。那nà大dà仙xiān雖suī稱chēng上shàng輩bèi,卻què也yě與yǔ我wǒ等děng有yǒu識shí。一yì則zé久jiǔ別bié,不bù曾céng拜bài望wàng;二èr來lái是shì大dà聖shèng的de人rén情qíng:如rú今jīn我wǒ三sān人rén同tóng去qù望wàng他tā一yí望wàng,就jiù與yǔ你nǐ道dào達dá此cǐ情qíng,教jiào那nà唐táng和hé尚shàng莫mò念niàn緊jǐn箍gū兒er咒zhòu,休xiū說shuō三sān日rì五wǔ日rì,只zhǐ等děng你nǐ求qiú得dé方fāng來lái,我wǒ們men才cái別bié。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「感gǎn激jī,感gǎn激jī。就jiù請qǐng三sān位wèi老lǎo弟dì行xíng行xíng,我wǒ去qù也yě。」大dà聖shèng辭cí別bié三sān星xīng不bù題tí。三sān星xīng闻wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng也yě闷mèn道dào:「你nǐ这zhè猴hóu儿er,全quán不bù识shí人rén。那nà镇zhèn元yuán子zǐ乃nǎi地dì仙xiān之zhī祖zǔ;我wǒ等děng乃nǎi神shén仙xiān之zhī宗zōng;你nǐ虽suī得dé了le天tiān仙xiān,还hái是shì太tài乙yǐ散sǎn数shù,未wèi入rù真zhēn流liú,你nǐ怎zěn么me脱tuō得de他tā手shǒu?若ruò是shì大dà圣shèng打dǎ杀shā了le走zǒu兽shòu飞fēi禽qín、蜾guǒ虫chóng鳞lín长zhǎng,只zhǐ用yòng我wǒ黍shǔ米mǐ之zhī丹dān,可kě以yǐ救jiù活huó。那nà人rén参shēn果guǒ乃nǎi仙xiān木mù之zhī根gēn,如rú何hé医yī治zhì?没méi方fāng,没méi方fāng。」那nà行xíng者zhě见jiàn说shuō无wú方fāng,却què就jiù眉méi峰fēng双shuāng锁suǒ,额é蹙cù千qiān痕hén。福fú星xīng道dào:「大dà圣shèng,此cǐ处chù无wú方fāng,他tā处chù或huò有yǒu,怎zěn么me就jiù生shēng烦fán恼nǎo?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「无wú方fāng别bié访fǎng,果guǒ然rán容róng易yì,就jiù是shì游yóu遍biàn海hǎi角jiǎo天tiān涯yá,转zhuǎn透tòu三sān十shí六liù天tiān,亦yì是shì小xiǎo可kě。只zhǐ是shì我wǒ那nà唐táng长zhǎng老lǎo法fǎ严yán量liàng窄zhǎi,止zhǐ与yǔ了le我wǒ三sān日rì期qī限xiàn;三sān日rì以yǐ外wài不bú到dào,他tā就jiù要yào念niàn那nà紧jǐn箍gū儿er咒zhòu哩li。」三sān星xīng笑xiào道dào:「好hǎo,好hǎo,好hǎo,若ruò不bú是shì这zhè个gè法fǎ儿er拘jū束shù你nǐ,你nǐ又yòu钻zuān天tiān了le。」寿shòu星xīng道dào:「大dà圣shèng放fàng心xīn,不bù须xū烦fán恼nǎo。那nà大dà仙xiān虽suī称chēng上shàng辈bèi,却què也yě与yǔ我wǒ等děng有yǒu识shí。一yì则zé久jiǔ别bié,不bù曾céng拜bài望wàng;二èr来lái是shì大dà圣shèng的de人rén情qíng:如rú今jīn我wǒ三sān人rén同tóng去qù望wàng他tā一yí望wàng,就jiù与yǔ你nǐ道dào达dá此cǐ情qíng,教jiào那nà唐táng和hé尚shàng莫mò念niàn紧jǐn箍gū儿er咒zhòu,休xiū说shuō三sān日rì五wǔ日rì,只zhǐ等děng你nǐ求qiú得dé方fāng来lái,我wǒ们men才cái别bié。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「感gǎn激jī,感gǎn激jī。就jiù请qǐng三sān位wèi老lǎo弟dì行xíng行xíng,我wǒ去qù也yě。」大dà圣shèng辞cí别bié三sān星xīng不bù题tí。


逐句解 Line by line

三sān星xīng聞wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng也yě悶mèn道dào:「你nǐ這zhè猴hóu兒er,全quán不bù識shí人rén。 三sān星xīng闻wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng也yě闷mèn道dào:「你nǐ这zhè猴hóu儿er,全quán不bù识shí人rén。

Hearing this, the three Stars too were troubled at heart, and said, "You monkey, you know nothing of people!

心中也悶, inwardly vexed as well -- the Stars are not angry, they are troubled, which is worse. 猴兒, monkey, is dismissive and fond at once, with 兒 the suffix er. 不識人 is not knowing what people are worth.

那nà鎮zhèn元yuán子zǐ乃nǎi地dì仙xiān之zhī祖zǔ;我wǒ等děng乃nǎi神shén仙xiān之zhī宗zōng;你nǐ雖suī得dé了le天tiān仙xiān,還hái是shì太tài乙yǐ散sǎn數shù,未wèi入rù真zhēn流liú,你nǐ怎zěn麼me脫tuō得de他tā手shǒu? 那nà镇zhèn元yuán子zǐ乃nǎi地dì仙xiān之zhī祖zǔ;我wǒ等děng乃nǎi神shén仙xiān之zhī宗zōng;你nǐ虽suī得dé了le天tiān仙xiān,还hái是shì太tài乙yǐ散sǎn数shù,未wèi入rù真zhēn流liú,你nǐ怎zěn么me脱tuō得de他tā手shǒu?

That Zhenyuan is the patriarch of the earth-immortals, and we are the founders of the spirit-immortals; but you, though you have won to the rank of a heaven-immortal, are still of the scattered ranks of Taiyi, not yet entered upon the true stream — how could you ever slip out of his hand?

This is the chapter's ranking table, and Wukong comes out badly. Zhenyuan is 地仙之祖, patriarch of the earth-immortals; the Stars are 神仙之宗, founders of the spirit-immortals; Wukong holds the lesser rank of 天仙 and is still, they say, 太乙散數 -- a loose, unattached number among the followers of Taiyi, with 散 read sǎn, as in 散仙, an immortal on no roll. 未入真流 is not yet in the true current. The two instances of 得 pull apart: 得了 is has attained, dé, while 脫得 asks whether escape was possible at all, toneless de.

若ruò是shì大dà聖shèng打dǎ殺shā了le走zǒu獸shòu飛fēi禽qín、蜾guǒ蟲chóng鱗lín長zhǎng,只zhǐ用yòng我wǒ黍shǔ米mǐ之zhī丹dān,可kě以yǐ救jiù活huó。 若ruò是shì大dà圣shèng打dǎ杀shā了le走zǒu兽shòu飞fēi禽qín、蜾guǒ虫chóng鳞lín长zhǎng,只zhǐ用yòng我wǒ黍shǔ米mǐ之zhī丹dān,可kě以yǐ救jiù活huó。

Had the Great Sage struck dead some running beast or flying bird, some insect or scaly creature, a single grain of our millet-elixir could bring it back to life.

The Stars can raise the dead, but only animals. 走獸飛禽 is beasts that run and birds that fly; 蜾蟲鱗長 pairs the creeping insects with the scaled tribe and its chief, the dragon, from 鱗蟲之長, with 長 read zhǎng. 黍米之丹 is an elixir the size of a millet grain -- a dose small enough to sit on a fingernail, and enough to restore a life.

那nà人rén參shēn果guǒ乃nǎi仙xiān木mù之zhī根gēn,如rú何hé醫yī治zhì? 那nà人rén参shēn果guǒ乃nǎi仙xiān木mù之zhī根gēn,如rú何hé医yī治zhì?

But that ginseng fruit is the root of an immortal tree — how is it to be healed?

仙木之根, the root of a divine tree, puts the ginseng tree in a different category altogether from anything that breathes. 參 is shēn again.

沒méi方fāng,沒méi方fāng。」 没méi方fāng,没méi方fāng。」

There is no remedy — no remedy at all."

The doubled 沒方, no prescription, is flat refusal. The gods of long life, of all beings, have nothing to offer a dead divine tree.

那nà行xíng者zhě見jiàn說shuō無wú方fāng,卻què就jiù眉méi峰fēng雙shuāng鎖suǒ,額é蹙cù千qiān痕hén。 那nà行xíng者zhě见jiàn说shuō无wú方fāng,却què就jiù眉méi峰fēng双shuāng锁suǒ,额é蹙cù千qiān痕hén。

When the pilgrim heard there was no remedy, his brows knit into a double lock and a thousand furrows creased his forehead.

眉峰雙鎖, the brow-peaks locked twice over, and 額蹙千痕, a thousand creases pressed into the forehead, are set phrases for real dismay. This is the first moment in the chapter where Wukong's cheerfulness fails him.

福fú星xīng道dào:「大dà聖shèng,此cǐ處chù無wú方fāng,他tā處chù或huò有yǒu,怎zěn麼me就jiù生shēng煩fán惱nǎo?」 福fú星xīng道dào:「大dà圣shèng,此cǐ处chù无wú方fāng,他tā处chù或huò有yǒu,怎zěn么me就jiù生shēng烦fán恼nǎo?」

Said the Star of Fortune, "Great Sage, if there's no remedy here, perhaps there is one elsewhere — why fall at once into gloom?"

此處 ... 他處, here and elsewhere, with 處 read chù. 生煩惱 is to breed vexation. The Star of Fortune, whose job is cheerfulness, talks him out of it.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「無wú方fāng別bié訪fǎng,果guǒ然rán容róng易yì,就jiù是shì遊yóu遍biàn海hǎi角jiǎo天tiān涯yá,轉zhuǎn透tòu三sān十shí六liù天tiān,亦yì是shì小xiǎo可kě。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「无wú方fāng别bié访fǎng,果guǒ然rán容róng易yì,就jiù是shì游yóu遍biàn海hǎi角jiǎo天tiān涯yá,转zhuǎn透tòu三sān十shí六liù天tiān,亦yì是shì小xiǎo可kě。

The pilgrim said, "To seek a remedy elsewhere is easy enough — to roam to the sea's corners and the sky's edge, or wind clean through the thirty-six heavens, would be no great matter.

海角天涯, the sea's horn and heaven's brink, is the Chinese for the ends of the earth. 三十六天 are the thirty-six Daoist heavens; 小可 is a trifle. Distance means nothing to a creature who can cross the world in one somersault. The clock is another matter.

只zhǐ是shì我wǒ那nà唐táng長zhǎng老lǎo法fǎ嚴yán量liàng窄zhǎi,止zhǐ與yǔ了le我wǒ三sān日rì期qī限xiàn;三sān日rì以yǐ外wài不bú到dào,他tā就jiù要yào念niàn那nà緊jǐn箍gū兒er咒zhòu哩li。」 只zhǐ是shì我wǒ那nà唐táng长zhǎng老lǎo法fǎ严yán量liàng窄zhǎi,止zhǐ与yǔ了le我wǒ三sān日rì期qī限xiàn;三sān日rì以yǐ外wài不bú到dào,他tā就jiù要yào念niàn那nà紧jǐn箍gū儿er咒zhòu哩li。」

The trouble is that Elder Tang of mine, strict in the Law and narrow in patience, has granted me but a three-day term; if I'm not back within the three days, he'll start reciting that Tight-Fillet Spell."

And here is the real problem. 法嚴量窄, severe in discipline and narrow in tolerance, is a startlingly frank description of one's own master. 唐長老 is Elder Tang, 長 = zhǎng. 緊箍兒咒 is the Tight-Fillet Spell, with 兒 the suffix er.

三sān星xīng笑xiào道dào:「好hǎo,好hǎo,好hǎo,若ruò不bú是shì這zhè個gè法fǎ兒er拘jū束shù你nǐ,你nǐ又yòu鑽zuān天tiān了le。」 三sān星xīng笑xiào道dào:「好hǎo,好hǎo,好hǎo,若ruò不bú是shì这zhè个gè法fǎ儿er拘jū束shù你nǐ,你nǐ又yòu钻zuān天tiān了le。」

The three Stars laughed. "Good, good, good — were it not for this little trick to keep you in check, you'd be boring holes in the sky again."

鑽天 is to drill up into the heavens, and it is a pointed choice of words -- it is roughly what Wukong actually did during his rebellion. 法兒, device or trick, with 兒 = er, is the Stars' irreverent name for the golden band. They think it suits him.

壽shòu星xīng道dào:「大dà聖shèng放fàng心xīn,不bù須xū煩fán惱nǎo。 寿shòu星xīng道dào:「大dà圣shèng放fàng心xīn,不bù须xū烦fán恼nǎo。

Said the Star of Longevity, "Set your mind at ease, Great Sage — there's no need to fret.

放心 is to set the heart at rest. The eldest of the three now produces the practical help the other two could not.

那nà大dà仙xiān雖suī稱chēng上shàng輩bèi,卻què也yě與yǔ我wǒ等děng有yǒu識shí。 那nà大dà仙xiān虽suī称chēng上shàng辈bèi,却què也yě与yǔ我wǒ等děng有yǒu识shí。

That Great Immortal, though he ranks a generation above us, is nonetheless an acquaintance of ours.

稱上輩 is reckoned a generation senior, 稱 = chēng; 有識 is to be acquainted. What the Stars cannot do by power they may be able to do by knowing the right person.

一yì則zé久jiǔ別bié,不bù曾céng拜bài望wàng;二èr來lái是shì大dà聖shèng的de人rén情qíng:如rú今jīn我wǒ三sān人rén同tóng去qù望wàng他tā一yí望wàng,就jiù與yǔ你nǐ道dào達dá此cǐ情qíng,教jiào那nà唐táng和hé尚shàng莫mò念niàn緊jǐn箍gū兒er咒zhòu,休xiū說shuō三sān日rì五wǔ日rì,只zhǐ等děng你nǐ求qiú得dé方fāng來lái,我wǒ們men才cái別bié。」 一yì则zé久jiǔ别bié,不bù曾céng拜bài望wàng;二èr来lái是shì大dà圣shèng的de人rén情qíng:如rú今jīn我wǒ三sān人rén同tóng去qù望wàng他tā一yí望wàng,就jiù与yǔ你nǐ道dào达dá此cǐ情qíng,教jiào那nà唐táng和hé尚shàng莫mò念niàn紧jǐn箍gū儿er咒zhòu,休xiū说shuō三sān日rì五wǔ日rì,只zhǐ等děng你nǐ求qiú得dé方fāng来lái,我wǒ们men才cái别bié。」

For one thing, we've long been parted and never paid our respects; for another, it is a kindness to the Great Sage. So we three will go together to look in on him, put your case to him, and bid the Tang monk hold off the Tight-Fillet Spell — never mind three days or five, but wait until you've found your remedy before we take our leave."

The solution is pure social engineering. 一則 ... 二來, firstly and secondly, sets out the two motives in the order a polite person would give them: an overdue courtesy call first, the favour second. 道達此情 is to convey the circumstances; 求得方來 is to seek out and obtain the remedy, 得 = dé.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「感gǎn激jī,感gǎn激jī。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「感gǎn激jī,感gǎn激jī。

The pilgrim said, "I'm much obliged, much obliged!

感激, grateful, doubled in Wukong's usual emphatic manner. Unfeigned thanks are rare enough from him to be worth marking.

就jiù請qǐng三sān位wèi老lǎo弟dì行xíng行xíng,我wǒ去qù也yě。」 就jiù请qǐng三sān位wèi老lǎo弟dì行xíng行xíng,我wǒ去qù也yě。」

Then I beg you three old brothers to be on your way — and off I go."

行行 is go along, off you go, both instances read xíng. The doubling gives it a hurrying, colloquial ring -- he is already halfway out of the door.

大dà聖shèng辭cí別bié三sān星xīng不bù題tí。 大dà圣shèng辞cí别bié三sān星xīng不bù题tí。

The Great Sage took leave of the three Stars, and of this we say no more.

不題, no more of this, is the storyteller closing one thread so he can pick up another. Film would call it a cut.


總評 Commentary

The scene turns briefly from comedy to something graver. The Stars' refusal rests on a worked-out hierarchy of immortality: Zhenyuan is a patriarch of the earth-immortals, the Stars are founders of the spirit-immortals, and Wukong, for all his self-awarded title, is a junior heaven-immortal on nobody's roll. Their millet-grain elixir can raise dead animals; a slain divine tree is beyond it. The distinction humbles Wukong and raises the stakes of his search at the same time.

For a moment the mask slips. The stock phrases of a furrowed brow -- brow-peaks locked twice over, a thousand creases -- show a Wukong genuinely stricken, his flippancy spent. It is a small but telling beat: the destruction he has been treating as a joke turns out to have consequences even he cannot laugh off.

The eldest Star's solution is characteristic of the novel's social imagination. What the Stars cannot do by power they can do by acquaintance, calling on an old connection with Zhenyuan to win Wukong a stay of execution. Heaven runs, in part, on courtesy and standing. And Wukong's doubled much obliged is one of his more disarming moments of plain gratitude.