Canonical Classics ← 第十九回
第十九回
yúnzhàndòngkōngshōujiè
shānxuánzàngshòuxīnjīng

At the Cloud-Ladder Cave Wukong Takes In Bajie · On Pagoda Mountain Xuanzang Receives the Heart Sutra

摩頂受戒 法名八戒
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

摩頂受戒 法名八戒 Tonsure and Precepts: The Name Bajie

sānzàng便biànjiào:「gāotàigōngxiāngànyòngyòng。」lǎogāomángtáichūxiāngànsānzàngjìngleshǒufénxiāngwàngnánbàidào:「duōméngshèngēn。」lǎoertiānxiāngbàibàisānzàngshàngtīnggāozuòjiàokōngfàngleshéngxíngzhěcáishēndǒuledǒushōushàngshēnláijiěguàicóngxīnbàisānzàngyuànsuí西yòuxíngzhěbàilexiānjìnzhěwéixiōngsuìchēngxíngzhěwéishīxiōngsānzàngdào:「cóngshànguǒyàozuòmíngzǎowǎnhǎohuàn。」dào:「shīshìdǐngshòujièlemíngjiàozuòzhūnéng。」sānzàngxiàodào:「hǎohǎoshīxiōngjiàozuòkōngjiàozuònéngshíshìménzhōngdezōngpài。」néngdào:「shīshòulejièxíngduànlehūnsānyànzàizhàngrénjiāchízhāigèngcéngdònghūnjīnjiànleshīkāilezhāi。」sānzàngdào:「shìchīhūnsānyànzàibiémínghuànwéijiè。」dāizihuānhuāndào:「jǐnzūnshīmìng。」yīnyòujiàozuòzhūjièsānzàng便biànjiào:「gāotàigōngxiāngànyòngyòng。」lǎogāomángtáichūxiāngànsānzàngjìngleshǒufénxiāngwàngnánbàidào:「duōméngshèngēn。」lǎoertiānxiāngbàibàisānzàngshàngtīnggāozuòjiàokōngfàngleshéngxíngzhěcáishēndǒuledǒushōushàngshēnláijiěguàicóngxīnbàisānzàngyuànsuí西yòuxíngzhěbàilexiānjìnzhěwéixiōngsuìchēngxíngzhěwéishīxiōngsānzàngdào:「cóngshànguǒyàozuòmíngzǎowǎnhǎohuàn。」dào:「shīshìdǐngshòujièlemíngjiàozuòzhūnéng。」sānzàngxiàodào:「hǎohǎoshīxiōngjiàozuòkōngjiàozuònéngshíshìménzhōngdezōngpài。」néngdào:「shīshòulejièxíngduànlehūnsānyànzàizhàngrénjiāchízhāigèngcéngdònghūnjīnjiànleshīkāilezhāi。」sānzàngdào:「shìchīhūnsānyànzàibiémínghuànwéijiè。」dāizihuānhuāndào:「jǐnzūnshīmìng。」yīnyòujiàozuòzhūjiè


逐句解 Line by line

sānzàng便biànjiào:「gāotàigōngxiāngànyòngyòng。」 sānzàng便biànjiào:「gāotàigōngxiāngànyòngyòng。」

Sanzang was greatly pleased, and called out: "Squire Gao, fetch an incense table, that we may use it."

香案, an incense table. Sanzang's first act on receiving a disciple is a ritual one, and it is not aimed at the disciple at all — it is aimed at the Bodhisattva who sent him.

lǎogāomángtáichūxiāngànsānzàngjìngleshǒufénxiāngwàngnánbàidào:「duōméngshèngēn。」 lǎogāomángtáichūxiāngànsānzàngjìngleshǒufénxiāngwàngnánbàidào:「duōméngshèngēn。」

Old Gao hastened to carry one out. Sanzang washed his hands, burned incense, bowed towards the south, and said: "How much we owe the Bodhisattva's holy grace."

望南禮拜, bowing towards the south — towards Potalaka, Guanyin's island. 聖恩, holy grace, is the vocabulary of an imperial pardon, borrowed here for a Bodhisattva's favour. The two systems keep leaking into each other, and nobody in the book seems to notice.

lǎoertiānxiāngbài lǎoertiānxiāngbài

The several elders added incense too and made their bows with him.

The 老兒 take the little suffix, as er. Worth noting that they join in and burn incense without being asked to.

bàisānzàngshàngtīnggāozuòjiàokōngfàngleshéng bàisānzàngshàngtīnggāozuòjiàokōngfàngleshéng

The worship done, Sanzang went up and sat in state in the hall, and bade Wukong loose the fiend's cords.

上廳高坐, to take the high seat in the hall. It is the posture of a master receiving a disciple and also, exactly, of a magistrate opening court. is the causative jiào, to have someone do something.

xíngzhěcáishēndǒuledǒushōushàngshēnláijiě xíngzhěcáishēndǒuledǒushōushàngshēnláijiě

The Pilgrim shook his body once, drew the hair back into himself, and the bonds fell away of their own accord.

其縛自解, in classical Chinese: and his bonds untied themselves. The rope was a hair all along, and the hair goes home.

guàicóngxīnbàisānzàngyuànsuí西 guàicóngxīnbàisānzàngyuànsuí西

The fiend bowed again before Sanzang and asked to follow him westward.

從新 is a variant of 重新, afresh. The first bow was to a stranger in a hall. This one is to a master, and the difference is the whole ceremony.

yòuxíngzhěbàilexiānjìnzhěwéixiōngsuìchēngxíngzhěwéishīxiōng yòuxíngzhěbàilexiānjìnzhěwéixiōngsuìchēngxíngzhěwéishīxiōng

He bowed also to the Pilgrim, and taking him for elder brother as the one who had entered first, he called him thereafter Elder Brother.

以先進者為兄, whoever entered first is the elder brother. Seniority runs by date of ordination, not by age or by strength — a detail that will supply eighty chapters of resentment. is wéi in both halves, and is chēng.

sānzàngdào:「cóngshànguǒyàozuòmíngzǎowǎnhǎohuàn。」 sānzàngdào:「cóngshànguǒyàozuòmíngzǎowǎnhǎohuàn。」

Sanzang said: "Since you follow me in the good fruit and would be my disciple, I shall give you a religious name, that we may call you by it morning and evening."

善果, the good fruit: the result that ripens out of good action, and by extension the religious life itself. 法名 is a name in the Dharma, the one you get when the old life is over.

dào:「shīshìdǐngshòujièlemíngjiàozuòzhūnéng。」 dào:「shīshìdǐngshòujièlemíngjiàozuòzhūnéng。」

He said: "Master, the Bodhisattva has already laid her hand on my crown and given me the precepts and a name. I am called Zhu Wuneng, Awakened to Power."

摩頂受戒 is the laying of a hand on the crown of the head at the conferring of the precepts — the physical gesture that makes the vow real. The name 悟能, Awakened to Power, was given him by the Bodhisattva and slots neatly beside 悟空, Awakened to Emptiness. He has been carrying it for years and this is the first time anyone has asked.

sānzàngxiàodào:「hǎohǎoshīxiōngjiàozuòkōngjiàozuònéngshíshìménzhōngdezōngpài。」 sānzàngxiàodào:「hǎohǎoshīxiōngjiàozuòkōngjiàozuònéngshíshìménzhōngdezōngpài。」

Sanzang laughed. "Good, good. Your elder brother is called Wukong, and you are called Wuneng. Truly you are of one lineage within my gate."

宗派 is a lineage, a branch of a school. Sanzang is delighted to discover that Guanyin has been quietly building him a generation of disciples with matching names, without ever mentioning it to him.

néngdào:「shīshòulejièxíngduànlehūnsānyàn néngdào:「shīshòulejièxíngduànlehūnsānyàn

Wuneng said: "Master, when I received the Bodhisattva's precepts I cut off the five pungent roots and the three forbidden meats,

五葷 are the five pungent roots — garlic, onions and their relatives — which Buddhist practice forbids because they are held to inflame the appetites. The 三厭 are the three abominations of Daoist abstinence: the wild goose, the dog and the black fish. That the two lists come from two different religions is not a slip. It is how this novel's religion actually works.

zàizhàngrénjiāchízhāigèngcéngdònghūn zàizhàngrénjiāchízhāigèngcéngdònghūn

and in my father-in-law's house I kept the fast and abstained from flesh, and never once tasted meat.

持齋把素 again, and the repetition is the point: it is true. He kept the fast right through the marriage, in a house that had every reason to expect otherwise.

jīnjiànleshīkāilezhāi。」 jīnjiànleshīkāilezhāi。」

Now that I have met my master, may I break my fast?"

And so to the question the whole passage has been walking towards, asked with the guilelessness that is his signature and his defence: 我開了齋罷 — now may I break my fast?

sānzàngdào:「shìchīhūnsānyànzàibiémínghuànwéijiè。」 sānzàngdào:「shìchīhūnsānyànzàibiémínghuànwéijiè。」

Sanzang said: "You may not, you may not. Since you do not eat the five pungents nor the three forbidden meats, I shall give you a second name, and call you Bajie — Eight Rules."

八戒 is the Eight Prohibitions, the eight precepts a lay Buddhist takes on for a fast-day. Sanzang has turned a request for dinner into a name, which is the most economical rebuke anybody delivers in this novel.

dāizihuānhuāndào:「jǐnzūnshīmìng。」yīnyòujiàozuòzhūjiè dāizihuānhuāndào:「jǐnzūnshīmìng。」yīnyòujiàozuòzhūjiè

The Idiot said gladly: "I shall obey my master's command." And so he was also called Zhu Bajie.

歡歡喜喜: delighted. Read the sequence again — he asked to eat meat, was refused, and was handed a name commemorating the refusal, and he is delighted. From this point on it is the narrator, and not only Wukong, who calls him 獃子, the Idiot.


總評 Commentary

The ordination is arranged with great economy. Sanzang calls for an incense table and bows to the south before he says a word to the convert: the thanks belong to Guanyin, and the disciple is her gift, not his catch. Then the high seat, the loosing of the cords — which were never a rope at all, only a hair, and go back into Wukong's body when he shakes himself — and the ranking of the brothers by order of ordination rather than by strength. Bajie will spend the entire pilgrimage resenting that order and never once disputing it.

The naming is the joke and the doctrine at the same time. He already has a Dharma name, 悟能, Awakened to Power, conferred by the Bodhisattva, and it fits beside 悟空, Awakened to Emptiness, like a matching pair of gloves. What he wants is dinner. He explains, quite truthfully, that he has kept the fast for years, and asks whether he may now stop; and Sanzang answers by giving him a second name, 八戒, the Eight Prohibitions, so that the refusal will be pronounced out loud every time anybody addresses him for the rest of his life. He accepts it 歡歡喜喜, delightedly. The name the whole world knows him by is a standing reprimand, and he has never once minded.