Canonical Classics ← 第十九回
第十九回
yúnzhàndòngkōngshōujiè
shānxuánzàngshòuxīnjīng

At the Cloud-Ladder Cave Wukong Takes In Bajie · On Pagoda Mountain Xuanzang Receives the Heart Sutra

發誓燒洞 剪縛而歸
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

發誓燒洞 剪縛而歸 An Oath Sworn, the Cave Burned, the Fiend Bound

guàiwényándiūledīngchàngdào:「jīngrénzàilèifányǐnjiànyǐnjiàn。」xíngzhědào:「yàojiànzěnde?」guàidào:「běnshìguānshìyīnquànshànshòuledejièxíngzhèchízhāijiàogēnsuíjīngrénwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngjiānggōngzhézuìháizhèngguǒjiàoděngzhèniánwénxiāojīnshìzuòlezǎoshuōjīngzhīshìzhǐxiōngqiángshàngmén?」xíngzhědào:「guǐzhàxīnruǎnwéituōshēnzhīguǒránshìyàobǎotángsēnglüèjiǎcháotiānshìcáidàijiànshī。」guàideguìxiàwàngkōngdǎoduìdebānzhǐguǎntóudào:「ētuóruòshìzhēnxīnshíháijiàofànletiāntiáoshīwànduàn。」xíngzhějiànzhòuyuàndào:「rándiǎnhuǒláishāolezhèzhùchùfāngdài。」guàizhēnbānxiēwěijīngdiǎnzháohuǒjiāngyúnzhàndòngshāodexiàngyáoduìxíngzhědào:「jīnguààilequèyǐn。」xíngzhědào:「dīngzhe。」guàijiùxíngzhěxíngzhěyòulegēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiào:「biàn!」biànzuòtiáosānshéngzǒuguòláishǒubèibǎngjiǎnleguàizhēndàobèizheshǒupíngzěnmebǎngquèyòujiūzheěrduozhejiào:「kuàizǒukuàizǒu。」guàidào:「qīngzhexiēerdeshǒuzhòngjiūdeěrgēnziténg。」xíngzhědào:「qīngchéngchángyándào:『shànzhūè。』zhǐděngjiànleshīguǒyǒuzhēnxīnfāngcáifàng。」liǎngbànyúnbàndejìngzhuǎngāojiāzhuāngláiyǒushīwéizhèngguàiwényándiūledīngchàngdào:「jīngrénzàilèifányǐnjiànyǐnjiàn。」xíngzhědào:「yàojiànzěnde?」guàidào:「běnshìguānshìyīnquànshànshòuledejièxíngzhèchízhāijiàogēnsuíjīngrénwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngjiānggōngzhézuìháizhèngguǒjiàoděngzhèniánwénxiāojīnshìzuòlezǎoshuōjīngzhīshìzhǐxiōngqiángshàngmén?」xíngzhědào:「guǐzhàxīnruǎnwéituōshēnzhīguǒránshìyàobǎotángsēnglüèjiǎcháotiānshìcáidàijiànshī。」guàideguìxiàwàngkōngdǎoduìdebānzhǐguǎntóudào:「ētuóruòshìzhēnxīnshíháijiàofànletiāntiáoshīwànduàn。」xíngzhějiànzhòuyuàndào:「rándiǎnhuǒláishāolezhèzhùchùfāngdài。」guàizhēnbānxiēwěijīngdiǎnzháohuǒjiāngyúnzhàndòngshāodexiàngyáoduìxíngzhědào:「jīnguààilequèyǐn。」xíngzhědào:「dīngzhe。」guàijiùxíngzhěxíngzhěyòulegēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiào:「biàn!」biànzuòtiáosānshéngzǒuguòláishǒubèibǎngjiǎnleguàizhēndàobèizheshǒupíngzěnmebǎngquèyòujiūzheěrduozhejiào:「kuàizǒukuàizǒu。」guàidào:「qīngzhexiēerdeshǒuzhòngjiūdeěrgēnziténg。」xíngzhědào:「qīngchéngchángyándào:『shànzhūè。』zhǐděngjiànleshīguǒyǒuzhēnxīnfāngcáifàng。」liǎngbànyúnbàndejìngzhuǎngāojiāzhuāngláiyǒushīwéizhèng

jīnxìnggāngqiángnéngxīnyuánxiángdelóngguījīnxìnggāngqiángnéngxīnyuánxiángdelóngguī
jīncóngshùnjiēwéiliànjīnrénzǒnghuījīncóngshùnjiēwéiliànjīnrénzǒnghuī
zhǔbīnjiānsānjiāosānyǒuxuánwēizhǔbīnjiānsānjiāosānyǒuxuánwēi
xìngqíngbìngzhēnyuántóngzhèng西fānghuàwéixìngqíngbìngzhēnyuántóngzhèng西fānghuàwéi

逐句解 Line by line

guàiwényándiūledīngchàngdào guàiwényándiūledīngchàngdào

At these words the fiend threw down his muckrake, made a deep bow with his hands clasped, and said:

The rake goes down first, before the bow. 唱個大喏 is to make a deep bow with the hands clasped and a spoken greeting — a salute with a voice in it. is read . The whole gesture is a soldier surrendering, not a monster yielding.

jīngrénzàilèifányǐnjiànyǐnjiàn。」 jīngrénzàilèifányǐnjiànyǐnjiàn。」

"Where is this scripture-seeker? I beg you take the trouble to present me."

Two in one breath with different readings: 那取經人 is the pointing , that scripture-seeker, and 在那裡 is the question-word , where. 累煩 is to put somebody to trouble on your behalf — the polite way of asking a favour.

xíngzhědào:「yàojiànzěnde?」 xíngzhědào:「yàojiànzěnde?」

The Pilgrim said: "What do you want with him?"

Wukong does not move an inch. The whole scene turns on his refusing to accept a conversion he has not tested himself.

guàidào:「běnshìguānshìyīnquànshànshòuledejièxíngzhèchízhāi guàidào:「běnshìguānshìyīnquànshànshòuledejièxíngzhèchízhāi

The fiend said: "It was the Bodhisattva Guanshiyin who exhorted me to good, and I received her precepts from her, and here I have kept the fast and abstained from flesh,

勸善, exhorted to good — the same word used of the Bodhisattva's commission earlier in the novel, so the reader knows at once that this is a genuine claim. 戒行 is keeping the precepts as a practice; 持齋把素 is keeping the fast and staying off meat.

jiàogēnsuíjīngrénwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngjiānggōngzhézuìháizhèngguǒ jiàogēnsuíjīngrénwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngjiānggōngzhézuìháizhèngguǒ

and she bade me follow that scripture-seeker to the Western Heaven, to worship the Buddha and seek the scriptures, that my merit might redeem my crime and I might come at last to the true fruit.

將功折罪, to set merit against crime and cancel the balance, is the legal formula again — the novel cannot stop reaching for the code book. 還得正果: is hái, moreover, and is , to obtain. The true fruit is the reward at the end of the road.

jiàoděngzhèniánwénxiāo jiàoděngzhèniánwénxiāo

She bade me wait for him these several years, and no word of him has come.

等他這幾年 — waiting all these years. The pathos is real and easy to miss. The Bodhisattva enlisted him back in chapter eight, and he has been sitting in a cave ever since, keeping the fast, waiting for a monk who never came.

jīnshìzuòlezǎoshuōjīngzhīshìzhǐxiōngqiángshàngmén?」 jīnshìzuòlezǎoshuōjīngzhīshìzhǐxiōngqiángshàngmén?」

Today, since you are his disciple, why did you not say at once that this was the business of the scriptures, instead of leaning on your ferocity and coming to my door to strike me?"

何不早說, why did you not say so at once? The reproach is entirely just: Wukong never asked. And 倚兇強, leaning on your own ferocity, is the very phrase the fiend used about himself in the rake-poem, 倚強便撒潑. He is handing his own self-accusation to his opponent.

xíngzhědào:「guǐzhàxīnruǎnwéituōshēnzhī xíngzhědào:「guǐzhàxīnruǎnwéituōshēnzhī

The Pilgrim said: "Do not play the trickster and try to soften me, thinking to make it a way of escape.

詭詐欺心 is deceitful and self-deceiving at once — cheating others and your own heart in the same act. 欲為脫身之計: is wéi, to make.

guǒránshìyàobǎotángsēnglüèjiǎcháotiānshìcáidàijiànshī。」 guǒránshìyàobǎotángsēnglüèjiǎcháotiānshìcáidàijiànshī。」

If you truly mean to guard the Tang Monk, with nothing false in it, then swear an oath to Heaven, and I will take you to see my master."

朝天發誓, to swear an oath facing Heaven. Note who is demanding it. This is a magistrate's requirement, not a monk's: testimony taken under oath, on the record.

guàideguìxiàwàngkōngdǎoduìdebānzhǐguǎntóudào guàideguìxiàwàngkōngdǎoduìdebānzhǐguǎntóudào

The fiend flung himself down on his knees and, bowing towards the void like a pestle in a mortar, knocked his head on the ground and said again and again:

望空似搗碓的一般 — bowing at the empty air like a pestle pounding in a mortar, with read . The comparison is agricultural and thoroughly undignified, and that is the whole point of him.

ētuóruòshìzhēnxīnshíháijiàofànletiāntiáoshīwànduàn。」 ētuóruòshìzhēnxīnshíháijiàofànletiāntiáoshīwànduàn。」

"Amitābha Buddha! Namo Buddha! If this is not my true heart and honest meaning, then let me offend against the statutes of Heaven and have my carcass hacked into ten thousand pieces."

南無 transcribes the Sanskrit namo, a word of homage, and the reading follows the Buddhist convention rather than the everyday one: is and is . 劈屍萬段, may my corpse be hacked into ten thousand pieces, is the standard self-curse attached to a vernacular oath — the more extravagant, the more sincere.

xíngzhějiànzhòuyuàndào:「rándiǎnhuǒláishāolezhèzhùchùfāngdài。」 xíngzhějiànzhòuyuàndào:「rándiǎnhuǒláishāolezhèzhùchùfāngdài。」

Seeing him swear and pledge himself, the Pilgrim said: "If it is so, then set a light to this dwelling of yours and burn it, and I will take you."

賭咒發願, to swear and to vow. And then the condition, which is not verbal at all: burn your house down. Nothing in this scene is accepted on the strength of words.

guàizhēnbānxiēwěijīngdiǎnzháohuǒjiāngyúnzhàndòngshāodexiàngyáo guàizhēnbānxiēwěijīngdiǎnzháohuǒjiāngyúnzhàndòngshāodexiàngyáo

The fiend did indeed gather brushwood of reed and thorn, kindled a fire, and burned that Cloud-Ladder Cave until it looked like a broken kiln.

點著一把火 takes as zháo, the result-marker — the fire caught, which is the third and last of the character's readings in this chapter. 燒得像個破瓦窰 takes as de, and is a variant of , a kiln. His home now looks like a broken oven.

duìxíngzhědào:「jīnguààilequèyǐn。」 duìxíngzhědào:「jīnguààilequèyǐn。」

Then he said to the Pilgrim: "I have nothing left to hinder me. Lead me away."

無罣礙, nothing to hinder or obstruct. Hold onto this phrase: it is one of the load-bearing terms of the Heart Sutra, which the pilgrims will receive before the chapter is out. Bajie says it first, nine passages early, and says it about a burnt-out cave.

xíngzhědào:「dīngzhe。」guàijiùxíngzhě xíngzhědào:「dīngzhe。」guàijiùxíngzhě

The Pilgrim said: "Give me that muckrake to carry." The fiend handed him the rake.

拿著 takes as the ongoing zhe. Disarming him is the second condition, and it is imposed without a word of explanation.

xíngzhěyòulegēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiào:「biàn!」 xíngzhěyòulegēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiào:「biàn!」

The Pilgrim plucked out a hair, blew on it with his immortal breath, and cried: "Change!"

The hair-transformation, which is Wukong's most domestic magic. He has used it to make an army of monkeys, to make sleeping-insects, and now to make a piece of rope.

biànzuòtiáosānshéngzǒuguòláishǒubèibǎngjiǎnle biànzuòtiáosānshéngzǒuguòláishǒubèibǎngjiǎnle

It turned into a three-ply hempen rope. He came up and bound the fiend's hands behind his back.

三股麻繩, a three-ply hemp cord. 綁剪 is to pinion the arms behind the back — a specific and unpleasant way of tying somebody.

guàizhēndàobèizheshǒupíngzěnmebǎng guàizhēndàobèizheshǒupíngzěnmebǎng

The fiend really did put his hands behind him and let himself be tied as the other pleased.

真個倒背著手 — he actually put his own hands behind him. The submission is complete, and volunteered, which makes what happens next worse rather than better.

quèyòujiūzheěrduozhejiào:「kuàizǒukuàizǒu。」 quèyòujiūzheěrduozhejiào:「kuàizǒukuàizǒu。」

Then the Pilgrim took him by the ear and hauled him along, calling: "Quick march, quick march!"

揪著耳朵: by the ear. Not the grip of a captor on a prisoner — the grip of a farmer on a hog, and the novel knows exactly what it has written.

guàidào:「qīngzhexiēerdeshǒuzhòngjiūdeěrgēnziténg。」 guàidào:「qīngzhexiēerdeshǒuzhòngjiūdeěrgēnziténg。」

The fiend said: "Gently, will you! Your hand is heavy. You are pulling till the root of my ear aches."

輕著些兒 takes as the softening imperative zhe: "gently, will you." 揪得我耳根子疼 takes as de. The complaint is that of a man being led home by a relative, and it is the first genuinely funny thing he says.

xíngzhědào:「qīngchéngchángyándào:『shànzhūè。』 xíngzhědào:「qīngchéngchángyándào:『shànzhūè。』

The Pilgrim said: "Gently is not to be had; I cannot indulge you. As the saying goes, 'A good pig needs hard handling.'

善豬惡拿 — a good pig needs hard handling — is a proverb, quoted in dialogue, and so it stays prose rather than counting as verse. Wukong has selected it, out of everything available, for the character .

zhǐděngjiànleshīguǒyǒuzhēnxīnfāngcáifàng。」 zhǐděngjiànleshīguǒyǒuzhēnxīnfāngcáifàng。」

Wait till you have seen my master, and if your heart is true, then you shall be let go."

果有真心: the test is still, and remains, the heart. Count what has been demanded so far — an oath, a fire, a surrendered weapon, a rope — and note that not one of the four has been believed.

liǎngbànyúnbàndejìngzhuǎngāojiāzhuāngláiyǒushīwéizhèng liǎngbànyúnbàndejìngzhuǎngāojiāzhuāngláiyǒushīwéizhèng

So the two of them, half cloud and half mist, went straight back to the Gao Farm. There is a poem in evidence:

有詩為證, "there is a poem in evidence," takes as wéi. It is the storyteller's cue for a summing-up in verse, and it closes off the prose; the quatrain follows.

jīnxìnggāngqiángnéngxīnyuánxiángdelóngguī jīnxìnggāngqiángnéngxīnyuánxiángdelóngguī

Metal's nature, hard and strong, can overcome the Wood; the Mind-Monkey has subdued the Wood-Dragon and brought him home.

The quatrain retells the episode in the language of the Five Agents, the classical scheme in which metal, wood, water, fire and earth each overcome and generate one another. , Metal, is Wukong; , Wood, is Bajie, and the 木龍 is the wood-dragon. Metal cuts wood, so the outcome was never in doubt. 降得: is xiáng, to subdue, and is the complement de.

jīncóngshùnjiēwéiliànjīnrénzǒnghuī jīncóngshùnjiēwéiliànjīnrénzǒnghuī

Metal follows, Wood complies, and the two are wholly one; Wood cleaves to Metal's benevolence, and all is set to work.

金從木順 — Metal goes along, Wood complies — turns a conquest into an accommodation in four characters. 皆為一 takes as wéi. And 金仁 is a small surprise: metal is ordinarily the harsh agent, the one that cuts, and here it is credited with rén, benevolence.

zhǔbīnjiānsānjiāosānyǒuxuánwēi zhǔbīnjiānsānjiāosānyǒuxuánwēi

One host, one guest, and no partition between; three crossings, three conjunctions, and a hidden subtlety within.

一主一賓, one host and one guest, is alchemical shorthand for the ruling and the assisting agent in a combination — who leads and who follows. 三交三合 are the three crossings and three conjunctions by which the elixir is made.

xìngqíngbìngzhēnyuántóngzhèng西fānghuàwéi xìngqíngbìngzhēnyuántóngzhèng西fānghuàwéi

Nature and feeling rejoice together, the Chaste and the Primal are gathered; together they bear witness to the West, and the word is not belied.

貞元 pairs the last and the first of the four qualities of the hexagram Qian in the Book of Changes — the ending that is also a beginning, which is why the two characters travel together. 同證西方, to bear witness jointly in the West. The quatrain's claim is that Wukong did not defeat Bajie at all; two agents simply came into their proper relation.


總評 Commentary

The fight ends in the middle of a sentence. The fiend has only to hear the words 取經, seeking the scriptures, and the rake is on the ground and he is bowing. His grievance is not that he was beaten but that nobody told him: 何不早說取經之事, why did you not say at once what this was about? The Bodhisattva enlisted him in chapter eight and he has waited ever since, keeping the fast, in a cave, married to a girl he has never touched. The whole night's combat was a misunderstanding.

Wukong accepts none of it on trust. He demands an oath sworn to Heaven, then the burning of the house, then the surrender of the weapon, then a rope — and having exacted all four he still leads the convert home by the ear, remarking that a good pig needs hard handling. The novel offers no comment on this. What it supplies instead is a quatrain in the language of the Five Agents, which reframes the ear-hauling as Metal subduing Wood and insists the two have entered their proper relation: 一主一賓無間隔, one host, one guest, no partition between them. The gap between the doctrine and the ear is the space Bajie will live in for the rest of the book.