Canonical Classics ← 第十九回
第十九回
yúnzhàndòngkōngshōujiè
shānxuánzàngshòuxīnjīng

At the Cloud-Ladder Cave Wukong Takes In Bajie · On Pagoda Mountain Xuanzang Receives the Heart Sutra

亂搗巢穴 下山投西
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

亂搗巢穴 下山投西 The Pilgrim Batters the Nest, and the Party Goes West

xíngzhěwényánlěngxiàodào:「menwènwèn便biànle。」sānzàngháijiěchánshīhuàzuòjīnguāngjìngshàngcháoérzhǎnglǎowǎngshàngbàixièxíngzhěxīnzhōngtiěbàngwàngshàngluàndǎozhǐjiànliánhuāshēngwànduǒxiángqiāncéngxíngzhězòngyǒujiǎohǎifānjiāngxiǎngwǎnzháocháoténgsānzàngjiànlechězhùxíngzhědào:「kōngzhèyàngdǎocháozěnde?」xíngzhědào:「lexiōngliǎngchángle。」sānzàngdào:「jiǎngde西tiānjìngcháng?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎoshuōzhūtiāodànzishìdejiè;『duōniánlǎoshíhóushìdelǎosūnzěnmejiě?」jièdào:「shīxiōngzhèchánshīxiǎoguòwèiláizhīshìdànkànshuǐguàiqiántóuzhèhuàzhīyànfǒuráo。」xíngzhějiànliánhuāxiángjìncháobiānzhǐqǐngshīshàngxiàshānwǎng西érxíngzhěwényánlěngxiàodào:「menwènwèn便biànle。」sānzàngháijiěchánshīhuàzuòjīnguāngjìngshàngcháoérzhǎnglǎowǎngshàngbàixièxíngzhěxīnzhōngtiěbàngwàngshàngluàndǎozhǐjiànliánhuāshēngwànduǒxiángqiāncéngxíngzhězòngyǒujiǎohǎifānjiāngxiǎngwǎnzháocháoténgsānzàngjiànlechězhùxíngzhědào:「kōngzhèyàngdǎocháozěnde?」xíngzhědào:「lexiōngliǎngchángle。」sānzàngdào:「jiǎngde西tiānjìngcháng?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎoshuōzhūtiāodànzishìdejiè;『duōniánlǎoshíhóushìdelǎosūnzěnmejiě?」jièdào:「shīxiōngzhèchánshīxiǎoguòwèiláizhīshìdànkànshuǐguàiqiántóuzhèhuàzhīyànfǒuráo。」xíngzhějiànliánhuāxiángjìncháobiānzhǐqǐngshīshàngxiàshānwǎng西ér

guǎnjiàoqīngrénjiānshǎozhì使shǐzāishānduōguǎnjiàoqīngrénjiānshǎozhì使shǐzāishānduō

jìngzhīqiánchéngduānqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiějìngzhīqiánchéngduānqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiě


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěwényánlěngxiàodào:「menwènwèn便biànle。」 xíngzhěwényánlěngxiàodào:「menwènwèn便biànle。」

The Pilgrim, hearing this, laughed coldly. "We shall go on. There is no need to ask him. Ask me."

冷笑, a cold laugh: the novel's reliable signal that Wukong is about to do something he will regret. 問我便了 takes as the light particle le, not liǎo — "just ask me and that will be that."

sānzàngháijiěchánshīhuàzuòjīnguāngjìngshàngcháoér sānzàngháijiěchánshīhuàzuòjīnguāngjìngshàngcháoér

Sanzang did not take his meaning. The Chan Master turned into a golden light and went straight up to his crow's nest.

還不解其意 — Sanzang has understood none of it, and he does not understand it later either. is hái, still.

zhǎnglǎowǎngshàngbàixièxíngzhěxīnzhōngtiěbàngwàngshàngluàndǎo zhǎnglǎowǎngshàngbàixièxíngzhěxīnzhōngtiěbàngwàngshàngluàndǎo

The elder bowed his thanks towards it; but the Pilgrim's heart swelled with rage, and he raised his iron rod and struck wildly upward.

Master and disciple, in a single sentence, do the two opposite things to the same tree: 往上拜謝, bowing up at it in thanks, and 舉鐵棒望上亂搗, raising an iron rod and jabbing wildly up at it. The novel sets them side by side and says nothing.

zhǐjiànliánhuāshēngwànduǒxiángqiāncéng zhǐjiànliánhuāshēngwànduǒxiángqiāncéng

Then he saw ten thousand lotus blossoms spring forth, and an auspicious mist that wrapped it in a thousand folds.

A balanced couplet sitting inside the prose without any announcement — no 但見, no 正是, nothing to introduce it. The house convention leaves such unheralded couplets as prose, so this one is not set as verse even though it scans like it.

xíngzhězòngyǒujiǎohǎifānjiāngxiǎngwǎnzháocháoténg xíngzhězòngyǒujiǎohǎifānjiāngxiǎngwǎnzháocháoténg

Though the Pilgrim had strength to churn the seas and overturn the rivers, he could not pull loose one strand of the nest's creeper.

攪海翻江, to churn the seas and overturn the rivers, is the standing measure of Wukong's strength, and here it is being measured against a creeper. 莫想挽著 takes as the result-marker zháo: not that he did not pull, but that pulling achieved nothing.

sānzàngjiànlechězhùxíngzhědào:「kōngzhèyàngdǎocháozěnde?」 sānzàngjiànlechězhùxíngzhědào:「kōngzhèyàngdǎocháozěnde?」

Seeing it, Sanzang caught hold of him. "Wukong, he is such a Bodhisattva as that. What do you mean by battering his nest?"

這樣一個菩薩 — Sanzang promotes the hermit to Bodhisattva on the evidence of the lotuses, on the spot and without hesitation. He may well be right.

xíngzhědào:「lexiōngliǎngchángle。」 xíngzhědào:「lexiōngliǎngchángle。」

The Pilgrim said: "He cursed the two of us, my brother and me, and went off."

罵了我兄弟兩個一場: cursed the pair of us, a whole round of it. 一場 takes as cháng, the measure word for a bout or an episode — the same word used of the all-night fight at the cave. Wukong has classified the insult as a battle.

sānzàngdào:「jiǎngde西tiānjìngcháng?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎo sānzàngdào:「jiǎngde西tiānjìngcháng?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎo

Sanzang said: "He was speaking of the road to the Western Heaven. When did he curse you?" The Pilgrim said: "What do you know of it?

何嘗罵你, "when did he ever curse you?" 你那裡曉得 uses the question-word , , and 曉得 takes as de.

shuōzhūtiāodànzishìdejiè;『duōniánlǎoshíhóushìdelǎosūnzěnmejiě?」 shuōzhūtiāodànzishìdejiè;『duōniánlǎoshíhóushìdelǎosūnzěnmejiě?」

By 'a wild boar shoulders the carrying-pole' he was cursing Bajie; by 'an ancient stone ape of many years' he was cursing old Sun. How should you make out his meaning?"

Wukong reads the prophecy back line by line as an indictment, which is a fair reading and a thin-skinned one. 解得此意 takes as , the can-do complement: how could you have made it out?

jièdào:「shīxiōngzhèchánshīxiǎoguòwèiláizhīshì jièdào:「shīxiōngzhèchánshīxiǎoguòwèiláizhīshì

Bajie said: "Brother, let your anger go. This Chan Master knows the affairs of past and future too.

息怒, let your anger rest — the standard phrase for talking somebody down. Bajie, who has just been publicly described as a beast of burden, is the one doing the calming.

dànkànshuǐguàiqiántóuzhèhuàzhīyànfǒuráo。」 dànkànshuǐguàiqiántóuzhèhuàzhīyànfǒuráo。」

Only look to that line of his, 'a water-monster is met with up ahead,' and we shall see whether it proves out or not. Let him be, and let us go."

And here is the shrewdest thing said in the chapter. If the abuse is accurate, then so is the rest of the prophecy, which makes 水怪前頭遇 — a water-monster met with up ahead — a line worth taking seriously rather than resenting. He is right, and the water-monster, when the party reaches him, turns out to be the third disciple.

xíngzhějiànliánhuāxiángjìncháobiānzhǐqǐngshīshàngxiàshānwǎng西ér xíngzhějiànliánhuāxiángjìncháobiānzhǐqǐngshīshàngxiàshānwǎng西ér

Seeing the lotuses and the blessed mist about the nest, the Pilgrim could only ask his master to mount, and they went down the mountain and westward. And going, they went —

只得, he had no choice in the matter. 那一去: is the run-up to the closing couplet, the same class of cue as 但見那:, and it closes off the prose.

guǎnjiàoqīngrénjiānshǎozhì使shǐzāishānduō guǎnjiàoqīngrénjiānshǎozhì使shǐzāishānduō

It will surely make pure blessing scarce among men, and set calamity and demons thick upon the hills.

The closing couplet, delivered as a forecast of the road ahead. 管教, "it will certainly cause," takes as the causative jiào, and 人間少 takes as shǎo, few. It does the work of the usual tag-couplet, but it is not tagged as one: the run-up 那一去: makes it an ordinary block of verse.

jìngzhīqiánchéngduānqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiě jìngzhīqiánchéngduānqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiě

In the end we do not know what really lies ahead. Listen to the next chapter, and it will be explained.

The invariable chapter-closing formula, and 端的 takes as once again. 且聽下回分解 — wait and hear the next instalment expounded — keeps up the storyteller's fiction that all this is being told aloud, in a room, to people who will come back tomorrow for more.


總評 Commentary

The chapter ends by proving its own prophecy. 多年老石猴那裡懷嗔怒 — an old stone ape of many years, there he nurses his spite — and four sentences later the old stone ape is battering a hermit's nest with an iron rod because his feelings have been hurt. The lotuses that spring up in ten thousand blossoms to shield it are the novel's entire judgment on the attempt, and it declines to add a word.

Bajie has the last argument, and it is the best reasoning anybody does in the chapter. If the Chan Master was accurate about the boar and the ape, he is accurate about the rest, and the line worth attending to is 水怪前頭遇 — a water-monster met with up ahead. The Idiot, having just been publicly called a beast of burden, is the one who works out that the insult is evidence. The water-monster is Sha Wujing, and he is waiting for them further along the road.