Canonical Classics ← 第十九回
第十九回
yúnzhàndòngkōngshōujiè
shānxuánzàngshòuxīnjīng

At the Cloud-Ladder Cave Wukong Takes In Bajie · On Pagoda Mountain Xuanzang Receives the Heart Sutra

浮屠山中 口授心經
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

浮屠山中 口授心經 On Pagoda Mountain the Heart Sutra Is Transmitted

sānzàngzàibài:「qǐngwèn西tiānléiyīnháizài?」chánshīdào:「yuǎnyuǎnzhǐshìduōbàonánxíng。」sānzàngyīnqínzhìzàiwèn:「guǒyǒuduōyuǎn?」chánshīdào:「suīyuǎnzhōngyǒudàozhīquèzhǐshìzhàngnánxiāoyǒuduōxīnjīngjuànfánshígòngèrbǎishíruòzhàngzhīchùdànniànjīngshānghài。」sānzàngbàikěnqiúchánshīsuìkǒusòngchuánzhījīngyún:《luóduōxīnjīng》:guānzàixíngshēnluóduōshízhàojiànyùnjiēkōngqièèshěkōngkōngshìkōngkōngshìshòuxiǎngxíngshíshìshěshìzhūkōngxiāngshēngmiègòujìngzēngjiǎnshìkōngzhōngshòuxiǎngxíngshíyǎněrshéshēnshēngxiāngwèichùyǎnjiènǎizhìshíjièmíngmíngjìnnǎizhìlǎolǎojìnmièdàozhìsuǒduǒluóduōxīnguààiguààiyǒukǒngyuǎndiāndǎomèngxiǎngjiūjìngnièpánsānshìzhūluóduōānòuduōluósānmiǎosānzhīluóduōshìshénzhòushìmíngzhòushìshàngzhòushìděngděngzhòunéngchúqièzhēnshíshuōluóduōzhòushuōzhòuyuē:「jiējiēluójiēluósēngjiē!」sānzàngzàibài:「qǐngwèn西tiānléiyīnháizài?」chánshīdào:「yuǎnyuǎnzhǐshìduōbàonánxíng。」sānzàngyīnqínzhìzàiwèn:「guǒyǒuduōyuǎn?」chánshīdào:「suīyuǎnzhōngyǒudàozhīquèzhǐshìzhàngnánxiāoyǒuduōxīnjīngjuànfánshígòngèrbǎishíruòzhàngzhīchùdànniànjīngshānghài。」sānzàngbàikěnqiúchánshīsuìkǒusòngchuánzhījīngyún:《luóduōxīnjīng》:guānzàixíngshēnluóduōshízhàojiànyùnjiēkōngqièèshěkōngkōngshìkōngkōngshìshòuxiǎngxíngshíshìshěshìzhūkōngxiāngshēngmiègòujìngzēngjiǎnshìkōngzhōngshòuxiǎngxíngshíyǎněrshéshēnshēngxiāngwèichùyǎnjiènǎizhìshíjièmíngmíngjìnnǎizhìlǎolǎojìnmièdàozhìsuǒduǒluóduōxīnguààiguààiyǒukǒngyuǎndiāndǎomèngxiǎngjiūjìngnièpánsānshìzhūluóduōānòuduōluósānmiǎosānzhīluóduōshìshénzhòushìmíngzhòushìshàngzhòushìděngděngzhòunéngchúqièzhēnshíshuōluóduōzhòushuōzhòuyuē:「jiējiēluójiēluósēngjiē!」


逐句解 Line by line

sānzàngzàibài:「qǐngwèn西tiānléiyīnháizài?」 sānzàngzàibài:「qǐngwèn西tiānléiyīnháizài?」

Sanzang bowed again. "Might I ask how far it is to the Great Thunderclap Monastery in the Western Heaven?"

大雷音寺, the Monastery of the Great Thunderclap, on Vulture Peak — the destination of the whole book, asked after for the first time on the road. 那裡 is interrogative, .

chánshīdào:「yuǎnyuǎnzhǐshìduōbàonánxíng。」 chánshīdào:「yuǎnyuǎnzhǐshìduōbàonánxíng。」

The Chan Master said: "Far, far. Only the road is thick with tigers and leopards, and hard to travel."

遠哩,遠哩. The doubling is dismissive: he will not name a distance, and never does.

sānzàngyīnqínzhìzàiwèn:「guǒyǒuduōyuǎn?」 sānzàngyīnqínzhìzàiwèn:「guǒyǒuduōyuǎn?」

Sanzang pressed him courteously and asked again: "And how far is the road in truth?"

慇懃致意, to press one's respects with earnestness. Sanzang asks twice, because he wants a number.

chánshīdào:「suīyuǎnzhōngyǒudàozhīquèzhǐshìzhàngnánxiāo chánshīdào:「suīyuǎnzhōngyǒudàozhīquèzhǐshìzhàngnánxiāo

The Chan Master said: "The road is long, yet a day must come when you arrive. It is the demon-miasmas that cannot be dispelled.

終須有到之日 — "a day of arriving must come at last." It is the only assurance the novel ever gives. 魔瘴, demon-miasmas: the mountain vapours that breed both fever and fiends.

yǒuduōxīnjīngjuànfánshígòngèrbǎishí yǒuduōxīnjīngjuànfánshígòngèrbǎishí

I have a Heart Sutra, one scroll, fifty-four lines in all, two hundred and seventy graphs.

The scripture is described by its bibliography before its content: one scroll, fifty-four lines, two hundred and seventy graphs. The count is exact for the received Chinese text, and this passage is why the reader is told it.

ruòzhàngzhīchùdànniànjīngshānghài。」 ruòzhàngzhīchùdànniànjīngshānghài。」

Where you meet with demon-miasmas, only recite this scripture, and of itself no harm will come to you."

但念此經 — only recite it. The sutra is offered as a prophylactic, not as a doctrine, and Sanzang receives it as one.

sānzàngbàikěnqiúchánshīsuìkǒusòngchuánzhījīngyún sānzàngbàikěnqiúchánshīsuìkǒusòngchuánzhījīngyún

Sanzang prostrated himself on the ground and begged for it, and the Chan Master recited it aloud and transmitted it to him. The scripture says:

口誦傳之, transmitted it by recitation from the mouth. 經云: is the lead-in, and closes the prose segment.

luóduōxīnjīng》: luóduōxīnjīng》:

The Heart Sutra of the Perfection of Great Wisdom:

The title, 《摩訶般若波羅蜜多心經》, transcribes Mahā-prajñāpāramitā-hṛdaya. 般若 is read bō rě, a Buddhist transcription-reading that overrides both bān and ruò. The title becomes its own lead-in segment.

guānzàixíngshēnluóduōshízhàojiànyùnjiēkōngqièè guānzàixíngshēnluóduōshízhàojiànyùnjiēkōngqièè

The Bodhisattva Who Regards the World Freely, coursing deep in the perfection of wisdom, saw then that the five aggregates are all empty, and passed beyond every suffering and affliction.

觀自在菩薩, Avalokiteśvara "who regards freely" — the same Bodhisattva the pilgrims call 觀世音. 五蘊, the five skandhas; 苦厄, suffering and calamity.

shěkōngkōngshìkōngkōngshìshòuxiǎngxíngshíshì shěkōngkōngshìkōngkōngshìshòuxiǎngxíngshíshì

Śāriputra: form is not other than emptiness, nor emptiness other than form; form is itself emptiness, and emptiness is itself form. So it is also with sensation, perception, volition and consciousness.

舍利子 is Śāriputra, a name, so is , not the neutral suffix zi that pypinyin supplies. 受想行識: sensation, perception, volition, consciousness — is xíng, saṃskāra.

shěshìzhūkōngxiāngshēngmiègòujìngzēngjiǎn shěshìzhūkōngxiāngshēngmiègòujìngzēngjiǎn

Śāriputra: all things bear the mark of emptiness. They neither arise nor perish, are neither defiled nor pure, neither increase nor diminish.

空相: the mark or characteristic of emptiness — is xiāng here, lakṣaṇa, not the xiàng of physical appearance. The six negations are three matched pairs.

shìkōngzhōngshòuxiǎngxíngshíyǎněrshéshēnshēngxiāngwèichù shìkōngzhōngshòuxiǎngxíngshíyǎněrshéshēnshēngxiāngwèichù

Therefore in emptiness there is no form; no sensation, perception, volition or consciousness; no eye, ear, nose, tongue, body or mind; no form, sound, scent, savour, touch or thing thought of;

The negation of the five aggregates, the six sense-faculties, and the six sense-objects, in that order. 空中 takes as zhōng.

yǎnjiènǎizhìshíjièmíngmíngjìn yǎnjiènǎizhìshíjièmíngmíngjìn

no realm of the eye, and so on to no realm of mind-consciousness; no ignorance, and no ending of ignorance.

The eighteen dhātus are dismissed by naming their first and last, then the twelve links of dependent origination by the same device. 無明 is avidyā. is jìn, and takes no before it — the sandhi override of chapter seventeen does not apply.

nǎizhìlǎolǎojìnmièdàozhì nǎizhìlǎolǎojìnmièdàozhì

So too there is no old age and death, and no ending of old age and death. No suffering, no stilling, no cessation, no path; no wisdom, and nothing to attain.

無苦寂滅道: the received text of the sutra reads 無苦集滅道, the Four Noble Truths — suffering, arising, cessation, path. The 世德堂本 writes for . We encode the edition and note the variant. 無智亦無得 takes as .

suǒduǒluóduōxīnguààiguààiyǒukǒng suǒduǒluóduōxīnguààiguààiyǒukǒng

Because there is nothing to attain, the bodhisattva, resting upon the perfection of wisdom, has a mind free of hindrance; and having no hindrance, he has nothing to fear.

罣礙 (guà ài), obstruction — the word Bajie used of his burnt cave twelve pages ago, and did not know he was quoting.

yuǎndiāndǎomèngxiǎngjiūjìngnièpán yuǎndiāndǎomèngxiǎngjiūjìngnièpán

Far removed from all inversion and dreaming fancy, he comes at the last to nirvāṇa.

顛倒 takes as dǎo: viparyāsa, the inversions of a deluded mind. 究竟涅槃, final nirvāṇa.

sānshìzhūluóduōānòuduōluósānmiǎosān sānshìzhūluóduōānòuduōluósānmiǎosān

The buddhas of the three times, resting upon the perfection of wisdom, attain the unexcelled, right and universal enlightenment.

阿耨多羅三藐三菩提 transcribes anuttara-samyak-saṃbodhi, and is read ā nòu duō luó sān miǎo sān pú tí.

zhīluóduōshìshénzhòushìmíngzhòushìshàngzhòushìděngděngzhòu zhīluóduōshìshénzhòushìmíngzhòushìshàngzhòushìděngděngzhòu

Know therefore that the perfection of wisdom is the great spirit-spell, the great spell of light, the unsurpassed spell, the spell that has no equal;

Four epithets of the (zhòu, mantra): great spirit, great light, unsurpassed, and 無等等 — "equal to the unequalled."

néngchúqièzhēnshí néngchúqièzhēnshí

it can cut away every suffering, in truth and not in vain.

真實不虛, true and not empty — where is falsity, not the emptiness the sutra has been expounding. The two words are not the same, and the sentence depends on their not being the same.

shuōluóduōzhòushuōzhòuyuē shuōluóduōzhòushuōzhòuyuē

Therefore is spoken the spell of the perfection of wisdom. The spell runs thus:

即說咒曰: the doctrine ends and the sound begins.

jiējiēluójiēluósēngjiē!」 jiējiēluójiēluósēngjiē!」

"Gate gate pāragate pārasaṃgate bodhi svāhā!"

The mantra is transliteration, not language: 揭諦 = gate, 波羅 = pāra, 薩婆訶 = svāhā. It is given here in its Sanskrit form because in Chinese it is already a foreign body, and its meaning was never the point. Being scripture quoted verbatim, the whole sutra is a quoted artifact and is set as prose.


總評 Commentary

Sanzang wants a distance and is given a text. He asks twice how far it is to the Great Thunderclap Monastery; the Chan Master answers 遠哩,遠哩 — far, far — declines to say more, and observes that the real obstacle is not the road but the 魔瘴, the demon-miasmas. Then he recites two hundred and seventy graphs, and the novel prints them entire. It is the longest quotation of a canonical scripture anywhere in the book, and it arrives at the exact structural centre of the pilgrimage's beginning: the party is complete but for one member, and it has just been given the one thing it will carry the whole way.

On the setting. The sutra is quoted verbatim from another book. By the ruling established in chapter seventeen — that quoted artifacts are prose, not verse — it is set at three chips, with no 含詞賦: it is neither 詩 nor 詞 nor 賦, has no metre, no rhyme, and no couplet structure. Note two features of this edition. Its punctuation joins 行深般若波羅蜜多 to what follows as 時照見五蘊皆空, where the received text reads …波羅蜜多時,照見…. And at 無苦寂滅道 the 世德堂本 writes where the canonical text has , the second of the Four Noble Truths. We encode the edition and record the variant rather than silently correcting it.