山神土地 The Mountain God and the Local Spirit
猴王拿著棍,趕上前來,撥草尋蛇,那裡得些影響。急得他三尸神咋,七竅煙生,念了一聲「唵」字咒語,即喚出當坊土地、本處山神,一齊來跪下道:「山神、土地來見。」行者道:「伸過孤拐來,各打五棍見面,與老孫散散心。」二神叩頭哀告道:「望大聖方便,容小神訴告。」行者道:「你說甚麼?」二神道:「大聖一向久困,小神不知幾時出來,所以不曾接得,萬望恕罪。」行者道:「既如此,我且不打你。我問你:鷹愁澗裡,是那方來的怪龍?他怎麼搶了我師父的白馬吃了?」二神道:「大聖自來不曾有師父,原來是個不伏天不伏地混元上真,如何得有甚麼師父的馬來?」行者道:「你等是也不知。我只為那誑上的勾當,整受了這五百年的苦難。今蒙觀音菩薩勸善,著唐朝駕下真僧救出我來,教我跟他做徒弟,往西天去拜佛求經。因路過此處,失了我師父的白馬。」二神道:「原來是如此。這澗中自來無邪,只是深陡寬闊,水光徹底澄清,鴉鵲不敢飛過;因水清照見自己的形影,便認做同群之鳥,往往身擲於水內:故名『鷹愁陡澗』。只是向年間,觀音菩薩因為尋訪取經人去,救了一條玉龍,送他在此,教他等候那取經人,不許為非作歹。他只是饑了時,上岸來撲些鳥鵲吃,或是捉些獐鹿食用。不知他怎麼無知,今日衝撞了大聖。」行者道:「先一次,他還與老孫侮手,盤旋了幾合;後一次,是老孫叫罵,他再不出。因此使了一個翻江攪海的法兒,攪混了他澗水,他就攛將上來,還要爭持。不知老孫的棍重,他遮架不住,就變做一條水蛇,鑽在草裡。我趕來尋他,卻無蹤跡。」土地道:「大聖不知。這條澗千萬個孔竅相通,故此這波瀾深遠。想是此間也有一孔,他鑽將下去。也不須大聖發怒,在此找尋;要擒此物,只消請將觀世音來,自然伏了。」猴王拿著棍,赶上前来,拨草寻蛇,那里得些影响。急得他三尸神咋,七窍烟生,念了一声「唵」字咒语,即唤出当坊土地、本处山神,一齐来跪下道:「山神、土地来见。」行者道:「伸过孤拐来,各打五棍见面,与老孙散散心。」二神叩头哀告道:「望大圣方便,容小神诉告。」行者道:「你说甚么?」二神道:「大圣一向久困,小神不知几时出来,所以不曾接得,万望恕罪。」行者道:「既如此,我且不打你。我问你:鹰愁涧里,是那方来的怪龙?他怎么抢了我师父的白马吃了?」二神道:「大圣自来不曾有师父,原来是个不伏天不伏地混元上真,如何得有甚么师父的马来?」行者道:「你等是也不知。我只为那诳上的勾当,整受了这五百年的苦难。今蒙观音菩萨劝善,著唐朝驾下真僧救出我来,教我跟他做徒弟,往西天去拜佛求经。因路过此处,失了我师父的白马。」二神道:「原来是如此。这涧中自来无邪,只是深陡宽阔,水光彻底澄清,鸦鹊不敢飞过;因水清照见自己的形影,便认做同群之鸟,往往身掷于水内:故名『鹰愁陡涧』。只是向年间,观音菩萨因为寻访取经人去,救了一条玉龙,送他在此,教他等候那取经人,不许为非作歹。他只是饥了时,上岸来扑些鸟鹊吃,或是捉些獐鹿食用。不知他怎么无知,今日冲撞了大圣。」行者道:「先一次,他还与老孙侮手,盘旋了几合;后一次,是老孙叫骂,他再不出。因此使了一个翻江搅海的法儿,搅混了他涧水,他就撺将上来,还要争持。不知老孙的棍重,他遮架不住,就变做一条水蛇,钻在草里。我赶来寻他,却无踪迹。」土地道:「大圣不知。这条涧千万个孔窍相通,故此这波澜深远。想是此间也有一孔,他钻将下去。也不须大圣发怒,在此找寻;要擒此物,只消请将观世音来,自然伏了。」
逐句解 Line by line
The Monkey King, cudgel in hand, came running up and parted the grass to seek the snake — but where was he to find any trace of it?
拿著 takes the durative 著 (zhe). 撥草尋蛇, "to part the grass and seek the snake," is a set phrase — and here, for once, a literal act. 那裡 is the rhetorical interrogative, nǎ; 影響 has its old sense of "shadow and echo," any sign at all.
He grew so frantic that the Three Corpse-gods shrieked within him and smoke burst from his seven orifices. He recited the syllable oṃ,
急得 takes the resultative 得 (de). The 三尸 are the Three Corpse-worms, Daoist parasites lodged in the body's three cinnabar fields, whose agitation signals extremity of feeling; 七竅 are the seven apertures of the head. 咋 is read zhà, "to cry out." 唵 (ǎn) renders the Sanskrit oṃ, the syllable of summoning.
and summoned forth at once the Local God of that ward and the Mountain God of that place, who came and knelt together, saying: "The Mountain God and the Local God attend you."
當坊, "of this ward, of this locality" (當, dāng). The 土地 is the tutelary earth-god of a place and the 山神 the god of the mountain — the humblest rung of the celestial bureaucracy, and the officials Wukong most enjoys bullying.
Said the Pilgrim: "Stick out your ankle-bones and take five strokes apiece by way of greeting, to relieve old Sun's feelings."
孤拐 (gūguǎi) is the ankle-bone; 見面, "by way of a first meeting"; 散心, "to divert oneself, to dispel vexation." A beating offered as a social courtesy: the comedy is entirely in the register.
The two gods knocked their heads on the ground and pleaded: "We beg the Great Sage to be indulgent, and let us humble gods state our case."
叩頭 is "to knock the head on the ground, to kowtow"; 方便 (fāngbiàn) renders Buddhist upāya, "expedient means," but is used here in the everyday sense of indulgence or accommodation. 小神, "this humble god," is the self-deprecating pronoun of a minor deity.
Said the Pilgrim: "What have you to say?"
甚麼 (shénme) — 甚 read shén.
The two gods said: "The Great Sage lay long imprisoned, and we humble gods did not know when he had come forth; therefore we failed to receive him. We beg a thousand pardons."
一向久困 alludes to Wukong's five centuries beneath the Mountain of Five Phases. 接得 takes the resultative 得 (de), on the pattern of 聞得 and 聽得. 萬望恕罪, "ten-thousandfold we beg pardon for our fault."
Said the Pilgrim: "In that case I will not beat you for now.
且, "for the present." The reprieve is provisional — as Wukong's reprieves generally are.
I ask you: this monstrous dragon in Eagle-Grief Gorge — from what quarter does it come?
那方 is interrogative, "which quarter," so 那 is read nǎ.
How comes it to have snatched my master's white horse and eaten it?"
搶 (qiǎng), "to snatch," is the same verb used of the dragon's first lunge at the elder from the water.
The two gods said: "The Great Sage has never had a master.
自來, "from of old, all along." The gods' bewilderment measures how new and how improbable the pilgrimage still is.
You have always been a Perfected One of Primal Chaos, who bowed neither to Heaven nor to Earth. However should you come to have any master's horse at all?"
不伏天不伏地, "submitting neither to Heaven nor to Earth"; 混元上真, "Supreme Perfected One of Primal Chaos," a lofty Daoist title. 得 is here dé, "to come to have"; 甚麼 takes shén. The flattery is also, precisely, an accusation.
Said the Pilgrim: "You do not know the half of it.
是也不知, "indeed do not know." What follows is the nearest thing to candour Wukong offers anyone in this chapter — and he offers it to two terrified minor gods, not to his master.
For that business of deceiving my superiors I served out a full five hundred years of bitter tribulation.
為 is read wèi, "on account of"; 誑上, "to deceive those above," was the formal charge against him; 勾當 (gòudàng) is "affair, business," usually with a shady tinge. 苦難 takes 難 as nàn, "tribulation."
Now, by the grace of the Bodhisattva Guanyin, who exhorted me to goodness, I was set free by a true monk of the Tang court, whom she charged to deliver me;
著 is here causative and read zhuó — "to cause, to have someone do." 唐朝 takes 朝 as cháo; 駕下, "beneath the imperial carriage," means "of the emperor's court."
and she bade me follow him as his disciple and go to the Western Heaven, to worship the Buddha and seek the scriptures.
教 is causative, jiào. 西天, "the Western Heaven," is India; in 拜佛求經, 佛 is always read fó.
Passing this way, we have lost my master's white horse."
A flat closing statement of the grievance, its plainness the more telling after the grandeur of the preceding sentence.
The two gods said: "So that is how it stands.
原來, "so it turns out that" — the formula of sudden understanding, and the cue for the explanation the reader has been waiting for.
There has never been any evil thing in this gorge. Only it is deep and sheer and broad, and the sheen of its water is clear to the very floor, so that crows and magpies dare not fly across it;
深陡寬闊, "deep, precipitous, broad"; 徹底澄清, "limpid clean through to the bottom." 鴉鵲 are crows and magpies. 中 here is zhōng.
for the water is so clear that they see their own shapes reflected there, and take them for birds of their own flock, and again and again fling their bodies into the water.
形影, "form and shadow"; 認做, "to mistake for"; 身擲於水內, "to hurl the body into the water." The image is Narcissan in form but not in moral: what destroys the bird is not vanity but a simple error about what is real.
And so it is called Eagle-Grief Steep Gorge.
The etymology is offered with quiet relish. The gorge is not named for any hawk's terror of its depth, but for the birds its deadly clarity drowns — a place, that is, where seeing truly and seeing falsely look exactly alike.
Only in a former year the Bodhisattva Guanyin, going in search of a scripture-seeker, saved a jade dragon,
向年間, "in a former year"; 因為 takes 為 as wèi, "for the sake of, because of." 玉龍, "jade dragon," is the creature's proper style — and the first hint that this monster is already under Guanyin's hand.
and sent it to dwell here, bidding it await that scripture-seeker, and forbidding it to do wrong or work mischief.
教 is causative, jiào. In 為非作歹, "to do wrong and work mischief," 為 is read wéi, "to do" — not the wèi ("for the sake of") that stood a dozen characters earlier. The same graph, twice, in one speech.
Only when hungry does it come up on the bank to pounce on a few birds for food, or catch a river-deer or a stag to eat.
撲 is "to pounce upon"; 獐 (zhāng) is the river-deer or musk-deer. The dragon's diet is that of a beast kept under discipline — until the white horse.
We cannot think how it came to be so senseless as to give offence to the Great Sage today."
無知, "without understanding, senseless"; 衝撞, "to give offence, to run foul of." The gods are careful to lay the fault on the dragon and not on the Bodhisattva who placed it there.
Said the Pilgrim: "The first time, he still crossed hands with old Sun and wheeled through several bouts;
還 here is hái, "still, even so." 侮手 is "to try hands with, to spar"; 幾合, "several bouts."
the second time, when old Sun stood bawling abuse, he would not come out again.
叫罵, "to bawl abuse"; 再不出, "would not come out any more." This is the deafness that provoked the churning of the water.
So I worked a spell for overturning rivers and churning seas, and muddied the water of his gorge; and out he came leaping, still bent on contending.
法兒 is "a trick, a spell." In 攛將上來, 將 is the directional particle; 還要 takes 還 as hái, "still wanted to."
But he did not reckon how heavy old Sun's cudgel is. He could not fend it off, and turned into a water-snake and bored away into the grass.
棍重 reads 重 as zhòng, "heavy"; 遮架不住, "unable to parry and hold." The staff weighs thirteen thousand five hundred catties, a figure the novel never lets its readers forget.
I came chasing after to look for him, but there is no trace."
蹤跡, "trace, track." The complaint closes exactly where the passage opened — at the parted grass and the vanished snake.
The Local God said: "The Great Sage does not know.
大聖不知, "the Great Sage does not know," is a courteous formula for correcting a superior. It is this lowly earth-god, and not the Monkey King, who holds the one piece of knowledge that matters.
This gorge has a myriad holes and passages, all running into one another, and that is why its waters lie so deep and reach so far.
孔竅, "apertures, passages"; 相通 takes 相 as xiāng, "running into one another"; 波瀾, "billows," here the body of the water itself.
Doubtless there is such a hole here too, and he has bored his way down through it.
In 鑽將下去, 將 is again the directional particle — and 鑽, "to bore," is the very verb that carried the dragon up out of the water when it first took the horse.
There is no need for the Great Sage to rage and hunt about here. If you would take this creature, you need only invite Guanshiyin to come, and it will submit of itself."
只消, "one need only"; in 請將…來, 將 is the directional particle. 觀世音, "Perceiver of the World's Sounds," is Guanyin's fuller title. 伏, "to submit, to be subdued," is the word that will govern the remainder of the chapter — and it is the word the gods use of a creature that force alone cannot touch.
Frustrated by grass and silence, Wukong falls back on the one power that never fails him: rank. The 唵 — Sanskrit oṃ — summons the Local God and the Mountain God, and he greets them by demanding they present their ankle-bones for five strokes apiece, "by way of a first meeting." The comedy of the celestial bureaucracy is one of the novel's steadiest pleasures: these are gods, and they kowtow and beg pardon for having failed to notice that a prisoner of five hundred years had been released. Yet the scene also lets Wukong tell his own story plainly for the first time in the chapter — the deception, the sentence, Guanyin's clemency, the monk who freed him — and he tells it not to Sanzang but to two trembling functionaries.
The gods' reply supplies the chapter's two hidden facts, and both are about seeing. First, the gorge's name: its water is so perfectly clear that birds mistake their own reflections for companions and drown reaching for them — a place where seeing truly and seeing falsely are indistinguishable, which is as neat an emblem of the deluded mind as the novel offers. Second, the dragon is no wild monster at all but a 玉龍, a jade dragon whom Guanyin herself rescued and stationed here to await the scripture-seeker. The reader now sees what neither combatant can: Wukong and the dragon are fellow-convicts of the same Bodhisattva, and their whole savage quarrel has been a case of mutual non-recognition. Hence the earth-god's advice, which is also the chapter's thesis — force cannot resolve this; only 請將觀世音來, and the creature will 伏, submit, of itself.