Canonical Classics ← 第十五回
第十五回
shépánshānzhūshénànyòu
yīngchóujiànshōujiāng

At Coiled-Snake Mountain the Gods Give Secret Protection · At Eagle-Grief Gorge the Will-Horse Takes the Rein

小龍現身
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

小龍現身 The Little Dragon Comes Forth

jiēguǒjiànbiānjiàoleliǎngbiànxiǎolóngfāntiàolàngtiàochūshuǐláibiànzuòrénxiàngleyúntóudàokōngzhōngduìbàidào:「xiàngméngjiětuōhuómìngzhīēnzàijiǔděnggèngwénjīngréndeyīnxìn。」zhǐzhexíngzhědào:「zhèshìjīngrénde?」xiǎolóngjiànledào:「zhèshìdeduìtóuzuózhōngněiguǒránchīledezheyǒuxiēliàngjiāngdòudeqièérhuíyòudeméngǎnchūláigèngcéngzháojīngdeyàng。」xíngzhědào:「yòucéngwènxìngshénmíngshuízěnmejiùshuō?」xiǎolóngdào:「céngwènshìláiderǎngdào:『guǎnshénmezhǐhuánlái。』zēngshuōchūbàntáng?」dào:「hóutóuzhuānqiángkěnchēngzànbiérénjīnfānqiánháiyǒuguīshùndeliruòwènshíxiānjīngdeláiquèyòngláoxīnrángǒng。」jiēguǒjiànbiānjiàoleliǎngbiànxiǎolóngfāntiàolàngtiàochūshuǐláibiànzuòrénxiàngleyúntóudàokōngzhōngduìbàidào:「xiàngméngjiětuōhuómìngzhīēnzàijiǔděnggèngwénjīngréndeyīnxìn。」zhǐzhexíngzhědào:「zhèshìjīngrénde?」xiǎolóngjiànledào:「zhèshìdeduìtóuzuózhōngněiguǒránchīledezheyǒuxiēliàngjiāngdòudeqièérhuíyòudeméngǎnchūláigèngcéngzháojīngdeyàng。」xíngzhědào:「yòucéngwènxìngshénmíngshuízěnmejiùshuō?」xiǎolóngdào:「céngwènshìláiderǎngdào:『guǎnshénmezhǐhuánlái。』zēngshuōchūbàntáng?」dào:「hóutóuzhuānqiángkěnchēngzànbiérénjīnfānqiánháiyǒuguīshùndeliruòwènshíxiānjīngdeláiquèyòngláoxīnrángǒng。」


逐句解 Line by line

jiēguǒjiànbiānjiàoleliǎngbiàn jiēguǒjiànbiānjiàoleliǎngbiàn

The Guardian did indeed go to the brink of the gorge and call out twice.

is "indeed, just as she said". She told him to call once; the Guardian, sensibly, calls twice.

xiǎolóngfāntiàolàngtiàochūshuǐláibiànzuòrénxiàngleyúntóu xiǎolóngfāntiàolàngtiàochūshuǐláibiànzuòrénxiàngleyúntóu

The little dragon churned the billows and leapt the waves, sprang out of the water, changed into human likeness, and trod upon a cloud;

翻波跳浪 is to churn the billows and leap the waves — the same water, the same exit, as when it came up to take the horse. What is different is what comes out of it. 變作一個人像: the dragon takes human shape. It fought in the body of a beast; the form in which one answers a Bodhisattva is not the form in which one brawls.

dàokōngzhōngduìbàidào dàokōngzhōngduìbàidào

and rising into the air he did reverence to the Bodhisattva, saying:

禮拜 is to do reverence. The creature that would not so much as answer Wukong's abuse kneels in mid-air without being asked, and nobody has struck anybody.

xiàngméngjiětuōhuómìngzhīēnzàijiǔděnggèngwénjīngréndeyīnxìn。」 xiàngméngjiětuōhuómìngzhīēnzàijiǔděnggèngwénjīngréndeyīnxìn。」

"I have long awaited here the grace by which the Bodhisattva loosed me and spared my life, and never yet have I heard tidings of the scripture-seeker."

向蒙 is "having formerly received" a kindness. 解脫 is the Buddhist vimokṣa, release or deliverance, and it carries both its technical sense and its plain one here — he was untied, and he was saved. 更不聞 takes as gèng, "not once, never yet". The reproach is gentle and completely justified: he has been sitting in a gorge for a year waiting for a man nobody described to him.

zhǐzhexíngzhědào:「zhèshìjīngrénde?」 zhǐzhexíngzhědào:「zhèshìjīngrénde?」

The Bodhisattva pointed to the Pilgrim and said: "Is this not the scripture-seeker's chief disciple?"

指著 takes the unstressed zhe. Her entire rebuke is in the gesture rather than the words. The thing he has been waiting for has been standing in front of him, shouting, since yesterday.

xiǎolóngjiànledào:「zhèshìdeduìtóu xiǎolóngjiànledào:「zhèshìdeduìtóu

Seeing him, the little dragon said: "Bodhisattva, this is my adversary.

對頭 is an adversary, an opposite number. Note that the dragon does not deny anything. He simply had the wrong idea about who this was.

zuózhōngněiguǒránchīlede zuózhōngněiguǒránchīlede

Yesterday my belly was famished, and I did indeed eat his horse.

饑餒 jī něi is famished, starving. 果然 is "indeed, sure enough". The confession is immediate and comes with no excuse attached, which is itself a kind of dignity — and a pointed contrast with the monkey, who has not admitted to a single error all chapter.

zheyǒuxiēliàngjiāngdòudeqièérhuíyòudeméngǎnchūlái zheyǒuxiēliàngjiāngdòudeqièérhuíyòudeméngǎnchūlái

Trusting to a certain strength of his, he fought me until my courage failed and I withdrew, and then so railed at me that I shut my door and dared not come out.

倚著 takes the unstressed zhe; 力量 reads as liàng, the noun. 將我鬥得 and 罵得我 both take the unstressed de, and the jiāng shunts the object in front of its verb. Then a small piece of comedy hiding in an idiom: 閉門, "shut my door", said by a creature that lives at the bottom of a river and has no door to shut. It is the phrase of a beaten householder barring up for the night, and he uses it because it is simply what one says.

gèngcéngzháojīngdeyàng。」 gèngcéngzháojīngdeyàng。」

Never once did he so much as mention the words 'seeking the scriptures.'"

And here it is — the sentence the whole chapter has been built to arrive at. 更不曾提著 is "never once brought it up", where 提著 is one of the that mark something achieved, read zháo — the mention landing, or here, failing to. The dragon's grievance is that a single word would have prevented the entire battle, and Wukong never said it.

xíngzhědào:「yòucéngwènxìngshénmíngshuízěnmejiùshuō?」 xíngzhědào:「yòucéngwènxìngshénmíngshuízěnmejiùshuō?」

Said the Pilgrim: "You never asked my surname or my name. How should I have said it?"

姓甚名誰 is "what surname, what given name", with read shén. The retort is pure Wukong: the fault must lie with whoever failed to ask.

xiǎolóngdào:「céngwènshìláide xiǎolóngdào:「céngwènshìláide

Said the little dragon: "Did I not ask, 'Whence come you, rascally demon?'

那裡來的 is a question — "where from?" — hence . And the dragon quotes the exchange back word for word. The novel enjoys these little forensic reconstructions, and it is about to win an argument with one.

rǎngdào:『guǎnshénmezhǐhuánlái。』 rǎngdào:『guǎnshénmezhǐhuánlái。』

And you bawled back, 'Never mind whence or whence not — only give me back my horse.'

管甚麼那裡不那裡 is Wukong's own line from the fight, both 那裡 read ; 只還我馬來 takes as huán. Put into the dragon's mouth and played back, the war cry sounds exactly as empty as it was: a demand from nobody, on behalf of nothing.

zēngshuōchūbàntáng?」 zēngshuōchūbàntáng?」

When did you ever utter half a syllable of the word 'Tang'?"

半個字 is "half a character", that is, a single syllable. The Tang, the scriptures, the whole pilgrimage — all of it hung on one name that was never spoken aloud, and a horse died for the omission.

dào:「hóutóuzhuānqiángkěnchēngzànbiérén dào:「hóutóuzhuānqiángkěnchēngzànbiérén

Said the Bodhisattva: "That monkey-head trusts to nothing but his own strength. When would he ever praise another?

猴頭, "monkey-head", is contemptuous and rather fond at the same time. Two in this line and they differ: 那猴頭 is the pointing , while 那肯 is the rhetorical question, — "when would he ever be willing?" 專倚自強 is "relies on nothing but his own strength".

jīnfānqiánháiyǒuguīshùndeli jīnfānqiánháiyǒuguīshùndeli

On this journey forward there will yet be others who submit and follow.

歸順 is to submit and give allegiance. The Bodhisattva is looking past this gorge to the whole road: Zhu Bajie and Sha Wujing are both foreshadowed in this half-line, and both will be won in exactly the way she is about to describe.

ruòwènshíxiānjīngdeláiquèyòngláoxīnrángǒng。」 ruòwènshíxiānjīngdeláiquèyòngláoxīnrángǒng。」

When they question you, speak first of the scripture-seeking, and then, without troubling your heart, they will yield of themselves."

勞心 is to trouble the heart, to expend effort; 拱伏 is to bow with folded hands and submit. Her advice is the moral of the chapter reduced to something you could write on a card: say who you are and what you are here for, and the enemy stops being an enemy.


總評 Commentary

The dragon's defence is devastating precisely because it is not a defence. He admits eating the horse — he was hungry — and then produces the fact that unmakes the whole episode: 他更不曾提著一個取經的字樣, "never once did he so much as mention the words 'seeking the scriptures'." Guanyin had stationed him in this gorge for exactly one purpose, to wait for a scripture-seeker. The scripture-seeker's own disciple came to the water and shouted about a horse.

Wukong's reply is characteristic and hopeless: you never asked my name. So the dragon reads the transcript back to him, and the war cry that sounded so magnificent an hour ago comes out as what it always was — 管甚麼那裡不那裡只還我馬來, a demand issued by nobody on behalf of nothing. This is a novel that likes to let a character defeat himself with his own words, and it has been saving these ones up for four passages.

Guanyin's diagnosis is one line long and covers the remaining eighty-five chapters: 那猴頭專倚自強, "that monkey-head trusts to nothing but his own strength". The vice she names is not cruelty and not disobedience. It is a kind of self-sufficiency so complete that it never crosses his mind to tell anyone who he is or what he is for. Her prescription is correspondingly plain: on the road ahead, speak first of the scripture-seeking, and they will 拱伏, submit, of themselves. It is advice that makes the cudgel unnecessary, and it holds good for both the disciples still to come.