Canonical Classics ← 第十五回
第十五回
shépánshānzhūshénànyòu
yīngchóujiànshōujiāng

At Coiled-Snake Mountain the Gods Give Secret Protection · At Eagle-Grief Gorge the Will-Horse Takes the Rein

師父搶白
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

師父搶白 The Master's Rebuke

xíngzhěméinàizhǐhuíjiànsānzàngdào:「shīzhèguàibèilǎosūnjiāngchūláidòuduōshíqièzhànérzǒuzhǐduǒzàishuǐzhōngjiānzàichūláile。」sānzàngdào:「zhīduānshìchīle?」xíngzhědào:「kànshuōdehuàshìchīleháikěnchūláizhāoshēnglǎosūnfànduì?」sānzàngdào:「qiánshícéngshuōyǒuxiánglóngdeshǒuduànjīn便biànnéngxiáng?」yuánláihóuzichīrénjiànsānzàngqiǎngbáilezhèjiùshénwēidào:「yàoshuōyàoshuōděngzàijiànshàngxià。」xíngzhěméinàizhǐhuíjiànsānzàngdào:「shīzhèguàibèilǎosūnjiāngchūláidòuduōshíqièzhànérzǒuzhǐduǒzàishuǐzhōngjiānzàichūláile。」sānzàngdào:「zhīduānshìchīle?」xíngzhědào:「kànshuōdehuàshìchīleháikěnchūláizhāoshēnglǎosūnfànduì?」sānzàngdào:「qiánshícéngshuōyǒuxiánglóngdeshǒuduànjīn便biànnéngxiáng?」yuánláihóuzichīrénjiànsānzàngqiǎngbáilezhèjiùshénwēidào:「yàoshuōyàoshuōděngzàijiànshàngxià。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěméinàizhǐhuíjiànsānzàngdào xíngzhěméinàizhǐhuíjiànsānzàngdào

The Pilgrim was at his wits' end, and could only go back and face Sanzang, saying:

沒及奈何 is a variant of 沒奈何 (méi nàihé), "there is no help for it." 只得, "could only, had no choice but," takes in its potential sense, read .

shīzhèguàibèilǎosūnjiāngchūlái shīzhèguàibèilǎosūnjiāngchūlái

"Master, old Sun cursed that monster until it came out.

罵將出來, "to curse [him] out," where is the directional particle (jiāng) before 出來. Wukong's report is, characteristically, a boast with the failure tucked inside it.

dòuduōshíqièzhànérzǒuzhǐduǒzàishuǐzhōngjiānzàichūláile。」 dòuduōshíqièzhànérzǒuzhǐduǒzàishuǐzhōngjiānzàichūláile。」

It contested with me a good while, then quailed at the fight and fled; now it hides in the middle of the water and will not come out again."

賭鬥 is "to fight it out"; 怯戰, "to quail at battle." 水中間 takes as zhōng.

sānzàngdào:「zhīduānshìchīle?」 sānzàngdào:「zhīduānshìchīle?」

Said Sanzang: "I wonder — was it really he who ate my horse?"

端的 (duāndì) is a Song–Yuan colloquial adverb meaning "really, in fact"; the is here read , not the everyday particle de. Sanzang, having been told plainly, still doubts.

xíngzhědào:「kànshuōdehuàshìchīleháikěnchūláizhāoshēnglǎosūnfànduì?」 xíngzhědào:「kànshuōdehuàshìchīleháikěnchūláizhāoshēnglǎosūnfànduì?」

Said the Pilgrim: "Just listen to what you say! If he had not eaten it, would he still be willing to come out and answer back, and set himself against old Sun?"

招聲 is "to answer, to make a sound in reply"; 犯對, "to take on, to set oneself against." Note that here is hái, "still" — the very graph that in Wukong's battle-cry 還我馬來 is read huán, "give back." The same character carries two readings within a page.

sānzàngdào:「qiánshícéngshuōyǒuxiánglóngdeshǒuduànjīn便biànnéngxiáng?」 sānzàngdào:「qiánshícéngshuōyǒuxiánglóngdeshǒuduànjīn便biànnéngxiáng?」

Said Sanzang: "The other day, when you killed the tiger, you said you had the art of subduing dragons and taming tigers. How is it that today you cannot subdue this one?"

降龍伏虎 (xiáng lóng fú hǔ), "to subdue dragons and tame tigers," is a stock phrase for the powers of an adept; is read xiáng, "to subdue," not jiàng, "to descend," and likewise in 不能降他. The taunt reaches back to the tiger Wukong killed in the previous chapter.

yuánláihóuzichīrén yuánláihóuzichīrén

Now this monkey could not bear to be pressed by anybody.

吃不得 is the negative potential, "cannot take, cannot stand," with read ; is used as a verb, "to press, to needle." The line is a rare narratorial aside, letting the reader watch the goad go in.

jiànsānzàngqiǎngbáilezhèjiùshénwēidào jiànsānzàngqiǎngbáilezhèjiùshénwēidào

Seeing that Sanzang had flung this remark in his teeth, he roused his divine might and said:

搶白 (qiǎngbái) is "to rebuke to one's face, to retort scornfully"; 發起神威, "to rouse one's divine might." Sanzang has learned, perhaps without meaning to, exactly which string to pull.

yàoshuōyàoshuōděngzàijiànshàngxià。」 yàoshuōyàoshuōděngzàijiànshàngxià。」

"Say no more, say no more — let me have it out with him again and see which of us is uppermost."

見個上下, "to see which is above and which below," i.e. to settle the mastery between them. The doubled 不要說 is Wukong brushing his master aside as he goes.


總評 Commentary

The quarrel resumes, but its terms have changed. Where before Sanzang wept and forbade, he now doubts and needles: first the flat scepticism of 端的可是他吃了我馬 ("was it really he who ate my horse?"), then the barbed recollection that his disciple had boasted of the art of "subduing dragons and taming tigers." The monk is no strategist, yet he has found the one lever that moves this creature. That the novel pauses to tell us so — 原來那猴子吃不得人急他, "now this monkey could not bear to be pressed" — is unusual; the narrator rarely explains Wukong, preferring to let him act.

It is worth noticing how the chapter keeps turning on a single graph read two ways. Wukong's war-cry is 還我馬來, where is huán, "give back"; here he says 他還肯出來招聲, where the same is hái, "still." So too , which is jiàng when blessings "descend" and xiáng when dragons are "subdued." Classical Chinese narrative delights in such doubleness, and the taunt lands the harder for it: the man who claimed he could xiáng a dragon has just watched one sink out of reach.