Canonical Classics ← 第十五回
第十五回
shépánshānzhūshénànyòu
yīngchóujiànshōujiāng

At Coiled-Snake Mountain the Gods Give Secret Protection · At Eagle-Grief Gorge the Will-Horse Takes the Rein

攪海翻江
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

攪海翻江 Churning the Ravine

zhèhóuwángkāitiàodàojiànbiān使shǐchūfānjiāngjiǎohǎideshéntōngtiáoyīngchóudǒujiànchèchéngqīngdeshuǐjiǎodejiǔhuángfànzhǎngdenièlóngzàishēnjiànzhōngzuòníngxīnzhōngxiǎngdào:「zhècáishìshuāngjiànghuòdānxíngcáituōletiāntiáonànshàngniánzàisuíyuányòuzhuàngzháozhèbānláihài。」kànyuèyuènǎoshòuyǎozhetiàojiāngchūdào:「shìláidezhèděng?」xíngzhědào:「guǎnzhǐhuánlejiùráoxìngmìng。」lóngdào:「deshìtūnxiàchūláihuán便biàndàizěnde?」xíngzhědàohuánshíkàngùnzhǐshāchángledexìngmìng便biàn。」liǎngyòuzàishānxiàdòudòushùxiǎolóngwěishínántángjiāngshēnhuǎngbiànzuòtiáoshuǐshéérzuāncǎozhōnglezhèhóuwángkāitiàodàojiànbiān使shǐchūfānjiāngjiǎohǎideshéntōngtiáoyīngchóudǒujiànchèchéngqīngdeshuǐjiǎodejiǔhuángfànzhǎngdenièlóngzàishēnjiànzhōngzuòníngxīnzhōngxiǎngdào:「zhècáishìshuāngjiànghuòdānxíngcáituōletiāntiáonànshàngniánzàisuíyuányòuzhuàngzháozhèbānláihài。」kànyuèyuènǎoshòuyǎozhetiàojiāngchūdào:「shìláidezhèděng?」xíngzhědào:「guǎnzhǐhuánlejiùráoxìngmìng。」lóngdào:「deshìtūnxiàchūláihuán便biàndàizěnde?」xíngzhědàohuánshíkàngùnzhǐshāchángledexìngmìng便biàn。」liǎngyòuzàishānxiàdòudòushùxiǎolóngwěishínántángjiāngshēnhuǎngbiànzuòtiáoshuǐshéérzuāncǎozhōngle


逐句解 Line by line

zhèhóuwángkāitiàodàojiànbiān使shǐchūfānjiāngjiǎohǎideshéntōng zhèhóuwángkāitiàodàojiànbiān使shǐchūfānjiāngjiǎohǎideshéntōng

The Monkey King strode out, sprang to the brink of the gorge, and put forth that divine power of his for overturning rivers and churning seas.

拽開步 zhuài kāi bù is to stride out, to open up the legs. 翻江攪海, "overturn rivers and churn seas", is the set phrase for water-magic on a huge scale, and it is still used in Chinese for anybody who turns a situation upside down. is the pointing : "that power of his", as though the reader already knew about it, which the reader does.

tiáoyīngchóudǒujiànchèchéngqīngdeshuǐjiǎodejiǔhuángfànzhǎngde tiáoyīngchóudǒujiànchèchéngqīngdeshuǐjiǎodejiǔhuángfànzhǎngde

The water of Eagle-Grief Steep Gorge, limpid to its very floor, he stirred until it was like the flood-swollen billows of the Yellow River in its nine bends.

Look at what is being destroyed here. The gorge's one defining property is 徹底澄清, clear all the way to the bottom — and in a few pages the local gods will explain why that clarity matters more than anything else about the place. Wukong stirs it into 九曲黃河泛漲的波, the flood-swollen billows of the Yellow River in its nine bends: the Yellow River is the standing image of thick, silty, churning water, the exact opposite of what was here. 攪得 takes the unstressed de, stirring tied to what came of it; is read , "like". He cannot reach his enemy, so he unmakes his enemy's world.

nièlóngzàishēnjiànzhōngzuòníngxīnzhōngxiǎngdào:「zhècáishìshuāngjiànghuòdānxíng nièlóngzàishēnjiànzhōngzuòníngxīnzhōngxiǎngdào:「zhècáishìshuāngjiànghuòdānxíng

The vile dragon, down in the deep gorge, could find no rest sitting or lying, and thought within its heart: "This is what is meant by saying that blessings never descend in pairs, and misfortunes never walk alone.

坐臥不寧 is "no peace sitting or lying". Then the dragon quotes a proverb at itself: 福無雙降禍不單行 — blessings never come down two at a time, misfortunes never travel alone. English has the same thought in "it never rains but it pours", and Chinese still uses this one constantly. The two readings that carry it are as jiàng, to come down, and as xíng, to travel — blessings descend, calamities walk.

cáituōletiāntiáonànshàngniánzàisuíyuányòuzhuàngzháozhèbānláihài。」 cáituōletiāntiáonànshàngniánzàisuíyuányòuzhuàngzháozhèbānláihài。」

I have but lately escaped a death-doom under the statutes of Heaven; not a year has passed, and while I bide here as karma allots, I run up against this rascally demon, who comes to do me harm."

This is the first time the novel lets us inside the monster's head, and what is in there is a sentence being served. 天條 are the statutes of Heaven; 死難 takes as nàn, calamity, here a capital sentence. 隨緣度日, "pass the days as circumstance allots", is Buddhist through and through — is the conditioning circumstance, Sanskrit pratyaya — and 隨緣 is still what a Chinese speaker says today when they mean "take it as it comes". 撞著, "run up against", is one of the that mark something actually attained, so it is read zháo: the collision has happened, it is not a state accompanying something else. And note the word the dragon reaches for — 潑魔, rascally demon. It is Wukong's own word, coming back.

kànyuèyuènǎoshòuyǎozhetiàojiāngchū kànyuèyuènǎoshòuyǎozhetiàojiāngchū

See how, the more it brooded, the angrier it grew. Unable to swallow the affront, it gritted its teeth and sprang out,

受不得屈氣 is "could not swallow the wrong done to him", with the "able to" read under a negative; 咬著牙 takes the unstressed zhe of a state held; and in 跳將出去 the is once more a hinge before the direction word. 你看他, "see how he —", is the storyteller turning to the audience mid-sentence.

dào:「shìláidezhèděng?」 dào:「shìláidezhèděng?」

cursing: "Where do you come from, you rascally demon, to bully me so?"

那裡 is a question here — "where from?" — so . And the dragon throws Wukong's own epithet straight back at him: , rascally, the very word of the loach jibe that baited it out of the water. Neither of them has said anything else about himself yet.

xíngzhědào:「guǎnzhǐhuánlejiùráoxìngmìng。」 xíngzhědào:「guǎnzhǐhuánlejiùráoxìngmìng。」

Said the Pilgrim: "Never mind where I come from or don't. Only give back the horse, and I will spare your life."

那裡不那裡, "wherever or not wherever", both read . 還了馬 takes as huán, give back. This is the sentence the whole chapter will be judged on. The dragon has just asked him who he is, and Wukong has refused to say — not out of secrecy, but because it did not occur to him that it could possibly matter.

lóngdào:「deshìtūnxiàchūlái lóngdào:「deshìtūnxiàchūlái

Said the dragon: "Your horse I have swallowed down into my belly. How am I to spit it up again?

吐得出來 is the "able to" sense in the positive, read : how am I able to spit it out? There is an unanswerable practicality about the retort. What is eaten is eaten.

huán便biàndàizěnde?」 huán便biàndàizěnde?」

And if I do not give it back, what do you propose to do?"

is huán again. 便待怎的, "then what do you propose to do about it?", is a thoroughly truculent piece of vernacular — the sort of line that starts fights outside public houses in any language.

xíngzhědàohuánshíkàngùnzhǐshāchángledexìngmìng便biàn。」 xíngzhědàohuánshíkàngùnzhǐshāchángledexìngmìng便biàn。」

Said the Pilgrim: "If you won't give back the horse, then look to my cudgel. I shall simply beat you dead, and your life shall pay for my horse's, and there's an end of it."

看棍, "mind the staff", is the conventional shout before a blow, rather like calling "fore". is to pay something back in kind, so a life is to settle the account for a horse. A note on the printing: the edition gives 行者道 here without the colon it uses everywhere else to open speech. That is how the text stands, and it is left as it stands.

liǎngyòuzàishānxiàdòu liǎngyòuzàishānxiàdòu

The two of them fought bitterly once more beneath the cliff.

苦鬥 is to fight bitterly, doggedly. 那山崖 is the pointing .

dòushùxiǎolóngwěishínántángjiāngshēnhuǎngbiànzuòtiáoshuǐshéérzuāncǎozhōngle dòushùxiǎolóngwěishínántángjiāngshēnhuǎngbiànzuòtiáoshuǐshéérzuāncǎozhōngle

They had not fought many bouts before the little dragon found it truly could not parry. Giving its body a shake, it changed into a water-snake and went boring away into a clump of grass.

is a bout or pass of arms — the unit fights are counted in. 難搪, "hard to fend off", takes as nán, difficult — set against the nàn of 死難, "death sentence", a few lines earlier: the same character, two readings, in one speech and its aftermath. In 將身一幌 the shunts the body in front of the verb; and 草科 is written here for 草窠, a clump or tussock of grass.


總評 Commentary

Denied a fight, Wukong destroys the conditions of hiding. He takes a gorge whose water is clear to the floor and stirs it into a likeness of the Yellow River in flood. The move is entirely characteristic — where he cannot reach an enemy, he unmakes the enemy's world — and the image is better chosen than it looks, because the gorge's defining property, as we are about to learn, is a clarity so perfect that birds drown in it. He has turned the place into its exact opposite.

What lifts this above a second round of fighting is that the novel now opens the dragon's head and lets us look in. Its private thoughts are a small tragedy assembled out of two proverbs. It has only lately escaped a death sentence under the statutes of Heaven; it has been biding here 隨緣度日, taking the days as they come; and trouble has found it anyway, because 禍不單行 — misfortunes never travel singly.

That vocabulary is Buddhist to the core, and it quietly puts the dragon exactly where Wukong stands: another condemned offender serving out a reprieve. Neither of them knows it. They are two of Guanyin's charges, each convinced the other is a 潑魔, a rascally demon — and each is hurling that word across water no longer clear enough to show either of them a reflection.