Canonical Classics ← 第五十七回
第五十七回
zhēnxíngzhěluòqiéshān
jiǎhóuwángshuǐliándòngténgwén

The True Pilgrim Lays His Grievance at Mount Potalaka · The False Monkey King Copies Out the Rescript at the Water-Curtain Cave

一一聽從
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

一一聽從 Sha Monk Takes His Orders

zhǎnglǎoyòufēnshāsēngdào:「dàokàntóushìruòkěnbāojiùjiǎxièxièláiruòkěnqièzhēngjìngjìngzhìnánhǎichùjiāngqínggàoqǐngwènyào。」shāsēngtīngcóngxiàngjièdào:「jīnxúnqiānwànchánzhòuhǎoshēnggōngyǎngshīzhèrénjiākǒngkěngōngfànjiùhuí。」jièdiǎntóudào:「huìdàntǎodetǎodechènzǎohuíláiyàonòngzuòjiāndàndāncháiliǎngtóutuō。」shāsēngsuìniǎnlejuéjiàyúnguāngzhíbèndōngshèngshénzhōuérzhǎnglǎoyòufēnshāsēngdào:「dàokàntóushìruòkěnbāojiùjiǎxièxièláiruòkěnqièzhēngjìngjìngzhìnánhǎichùjiāngqínggàoqǐngwènyào。」shāsēngtīngcóngxiàngjièdào:「jīnxúnqiānwànchánzhòuhǎoshēnggōngyǎngshīzhèrénjiākǒngkěngōngfànjiùhuí。」jièdiǎntóudào:「huìdàntǎodetǎodechènzǎohuíláiyàonòngzuòjiāndàndāncháiliǎngtóutuō。」shāsēngsuìniǎnlejuéjiàyúnguāngzhíbèndōngshèngshénzhōuér


逐句解 Line by line

zhǎnglǎoyòufēnshāsēngdào:「dàokàntóushì zhǎnglǎoyòufēnshāsēngdào:「dàokàntóushì

The elder charged Sha Monk further: “When you get there, be sure to see how things stand.

你到那裡 is the pointing , -- there, meaning the Water-Curtain Cave -- not the question the same character takes elsewhere in this chapter. Tripitaka's first instruction is to look before doing anything.

ruòkěnbāojiùjiǎxièxièláiruòkěnqièzhēngjìngjìngzhìnánhǎichùjiāngqínggàoqǐngwènyào。」 ruòkěnbāojiùjiǎxièxièláiruòkěnqièzhēngjìngjìngzhìnánhǎichùjiāngqínggàoqǐngwènyào。」

“If he is willing to give you the bundles, then thank him — however feigned the thanks — and bring them away; and if he is not willing, on no account fall to quarrelling with him, but go straight to the Bodhisattva at the Southern Sea, lay the whole matter before her, and ask her to go and demand them of him.”

A conditional pair, built to match: 他若肯 against 若不肯. 假謝謝 is the sharpest word in the brief -- thank him falsely, and get out. Tripitaka is telling a monk to lie politely, which is either good diplomacy or a small lapse, depending on how charitable you feel.

shāsēngtīngcóng shāsēngtīngcóng

Sha Monk took in every point of it.

一一 is a fixed word in its own right, yī yī -- one by one, point by point -- and both characters need that reading spelled out. The ordinary tone rule would produce yì yì here, and nothing about the character that follows signals the exception; the reading has to be known rather than worked out.

xiàngjièdào:「jīnxúnqiānwànchánzhòuhǎoshēnggōngyǎngshī xiàngjièdào:「jīnxúnqiānwànchánzhòuhǎoshēnggōngyǎngshī

He turned to Bajie: “I am off to look for him now. Whatever you do, do not fret and grumble; look after the master properly.

僝僽 is a rare pair meaning to fret and nag, and it keeps its ordinary readings, chán zhòu. 供養 takes at gōng, the "provide, supply" sense -- not the gòng of giving testimony.

zhèrénjiākǒngkěngōngfànjiùhuí。」 zhèrénjiākǒngkěngōngfànjiùhuí。」

“And you are not to make a scene at this house either, or they may refuse to feed us. I shall go and come straight back.”

撒潑 -- to throw a tantrum -- is precisely what Sha Monk expects of him, and 供飯 takes at gōng again. Note what the two brothers actually discuss on parting: sulking and table manners. Neither mentions the injured man behind them.

jièdiǎntóudào:「huìdàntǎodetǎodechènzǎohuíláiyàonòngzuòjiāndàndāncháiliǎngtóutuō。」 jièdiǎntóudào:「huìdàntǎodetǎodechènzǎohuíláiyàonòngzuòjiāndàndāncháiliǎngtóutuō。」

Bajie nodded: “I take your meaning. But when you go — whether you get them or not — come back quickly. Do not make it a sharp carrying-pole shouldering firewood, that slips off at both ends.”

Bajie signs off with a carrying-pole proverb, and the proverb is a small display of the language's own machinery. 尖擔擔柴 puts both readings of side by side in four characters: 尖擔 is the pole, the noun dàn, and 擔柴 is shouldering it, the verb dān. A pole sharpened at both ends carries nothing -- the load slides off either way -- and the phrase means an errand that fails in both directions. appears three times and twice differently: 理會得 is attainment, , while 討得 and 討不得 are the can and the cannot, both with the light de.

shāsēngsuìniǎnlejuéjiàyúnguāngzhíbèndōngshèngshénzhōuér shāsēngsuìniǎnlejuéjiàyúnguāngzhíbèndōngshèngshénzhōuér

So Sha Monk pinched the finger-sign, mounted his cloud-light, and made straight for the Eastern Continent of Superior Spirit.

直奔 governs a destination and is read bèn -- the last of the chapter's five such appearances. 東勝神洲 is the continent Wukong was born on, and the source prints , spirit, where the standard Buddhist name of this continent has the character for body. It is encoded as printed and rendered accordingly: the Eastern Continent of Superior Spirit.


總評 Commentary

Tripitaka's instructions are the most competent thing he does in this chapter. He anticipates both outcomes, tells Sha Monk to thank the man falsely if he cooperates, forbids a quarrel if he does not, and names the authority to escalate to. It is a diplomatic brief, and Sha Monk 一一聽從 -- takes it point by point.

The exchange that follows between the two brothers is the novel's ordinary domestic register. Sha Monk tells Bajie not to sulk and not to make a scene at the farmhouse, both of which are things Bajie would do; Bajie answers with a proverb about a carrying-pole sharpened at both ends, which drops its load whichever way you turn. Neither of them says a word about the master lying injured behind them, and the omission is the point.

The direction matters. Sha Monk goes east, to 東勝神洲, the continent Wukong was born on -- while the Bodhisattva who could settle everything is south, and the real Wukong is standing beside her. The chapter has now sent its three surviving pilgrims in three different directions, none of them toward the answer.