Canonical Classics ← 第五十七回
第五十七回
真zhēn行xíng者zhě落luò伽qié山shān訴sù苦kǔ
假jiǎ猴hóu王wáng水shuǐ簾lián洞dòng謄téng文wén

The True Pilgrim Lays His Grievance at Mount Potalaka · The False Monkey King Copies Out the Rescript at the Water-Curtain Cave

半途而廢
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

半途而廢 Halfway and Abandoned

二èr人rén歡huān歡huān喜xǐ喜xǐ回huí至zhì路lù上shàng,只zhǐ見jiàn三sān藏zàng面miàn磕kē地dì,倒dǎo在zài塵chén埃āi;白bái馬mǎ撒sā韁jiāng,在zài路lù傍páng長cháng嘶sī跑pǎo跳tiào;行xíng李lǐ擔dàn不bú見jiàn蹤zōng影yǐng。慌huāng得de八bā戒jiè跌diē腳jiǎo搥chuí胸xiōng,大dà呼hū小xiǎo叫jiào道dào:「不bù消xiāo講jiǎng,不bù消xiāo講jiǎng,這zhè還hái是shì孫sūn行xíng者zhě趕gǎn走zǒu的de餘yú黨dǎng,來lái此cǐ打dǎ殺shā師shī父fù,搶qiǎng了le行xíng李lǐ去qù了le。」沙shā僧sēng道dào:「且qiě去qù把bǎ馬mǎ拴shuān住zhù!」只zhǐ叫jiào:「怎zěn麼me好hǎo?怎zěn麼me好hǎo?這zhè誠chéng所suǒ謂wèi半bàn途tú而ér廢fèi,中zhōng道dào而ér止zhǐ也yě。」叫jiào一yì聲shēng:「師shī父fù。」滿mǎn眼yǎn拋pāo珠zhū,傷shāng心xīn痛tòng哭kū。八bā戒jiè道dào:「兄xiōng弟dì,且qiě休xiū哭kū。如rú今jīn事shì已yǐ到dào此cǐ,取qǔ經jīng之zhī事shì,且qiě莫mò說shuō了le。你nǐ看kàn著zhe師shī父fù的de屍shī靈líng,等děng我wǒ把bǎ馬mǎ騎qí到dào那nǎ個gè府fǔ州zhōu縣xiàn鄉xiāng村cūn店diàn集jí賣mài幾jǐ兩liǎng銀yín子zi,買mǎi口kǒu棺guān木mù,把bǎ師shī父fù埋mái了le,我wǒ兩liǎng個gè各gè尋xún道dào路lù散sàn夥huǒ。」二èr人rén欢huān欢huān喜xǐ喜xǐ回huí至zhì路lù上shàng,只zhǐ见jiàn三sān藏zàng面miàn磕kē地dì,倒dǎo在zài尘chén埃āi;白bái马mǎ撒sā缰jiāng,在zài路lù傍páng长cháng嘶sī跑pǎo跳tiào;行xíng李lǐ担dàn不bú见jiàn踪zōng影yǐng。慌huāng得de八bā戒jiè跌diē脚jiǎo搥chuí胸xiōng,大dà呼hū小xiǎo叫jiào道dào:「不bù消xiāo讲jiǎng,不bù消xiāo讲jiǎng,这zhè还hái是shì孙sūn行xíng者zhě赶gǎn走zǒu的de余yú党dǎng,来lái此cǐ打dǎ杀shā师shī父fù,抢qiǎng了le行xíng李lǐ去qù了le。」沙shā僧sēng道dào:「且qiě去qù把bǎ马mǎ拴shuān住zhù!」只zhǐ叫jiào:「怎zěn么me好hǎo?怎zěn么me好hǎo?这zhè诚chéng所suǒ谓wèi半bàn途tú而ér废fèi,中zhōng道dào而ér止zhǐ也yě。」叫jiào一yì声shēng:「师shī父fù。」满mǎn眼yǎn抛pāo珠zhū,伤shāng心xīn痛tòng哭kū。八bā戒jiè道dào:「兄xiōng弟dì,且qiě休xiū哭kū。如rú今jīn事shì已yǐ到dào此cǐ,取qǔ经jīng之zhī事shì,且qiě莫mò说shuō了le。你nǐ看kàn着zhe师shī父fù的de尸shī灵líng,等děng我wǒ把bǎ马mǎ骑qí到dào那nǎ个gè府fǔ州zhōu县xiàn乡xiāng村cūn店diàn集jí卖mài几jǐ两liǎng银yín子zi,买mǎi口kǒu棺guān木mù,把bǎ师shī父fù埋mái了le,我wǒ两liǎng个gè各gè寻xún道dào路lù散sàn伙huǒ。」


逐句解 Line by line

二èr人rén歡huān歡huān喜xǐ喜xǐ回huí至zhì路lù上shàng,只zhǐ見jiàn三sān藏zàng面miàn磕kē地dì,倒dǎo在zài塵chén埃āi;白bái馬mǎ撒sā韁jiāng,在zài路lù傍páng長cháng嘶sī跑pǎo跳tiào;行xíng李lǐ擔dàn不bú見jiàn蹤zōng影yǐng。 二èr人rén欢huān欢huān喜xǐ喜xǐ回huí至zhì路lù上shàng,只zhǐ见jiàn三sān藏zàng面miàn磕kē地dì,倒dǎo在zài尘chén埃āi;白bái马mǎ撒sā缰jiāng,在zài路lù傍páng长cháng嘶sī跑pǎo跳tiào;行xíng李lǐ担dàn不bú见jiàn踪zōng影yǐng。

The two of them came back to the road in high spirits — and there was Tripitaka face down on the ground, fallen in the dust; the white horse loose from its halter, neighing long and plunging about by the roadside; and the baggage-load nowhere to be seen.

One sweep of the eye takes in the wreck. Three things hang off a single 只見 -- master, horse, baggage -- and the sentence does not stop between them. 長嘶 takes 長 at cháng, a long-drawn neigh; this is the second of the chapter's four such readings, against sixteen where the same character means "elder" and reads zhǎng. 行李擔 takes 擔 at dàn, the load as a thing. 倒在塵埃 is the toppling dǎo. One trap here: 行李 reads xíng, as it does everywhere, but inside the longer run 跑跳行李擔 an automatic reading breaks the phrase up and produces háng instead. It is the only place in the chapter where that happens to any of the fifty-four appearances of 行, and it is very easy to miss.

慌huāng得de八bā戒jiè跌diē腳jiǎo搥chuí胸xiōng,大dà呼hū小xiǎo叫jiào道dào:「不bù消xiāo講jiǎng,不bù消xiāo講jiǎng,這zhè還hái是shì孫sūn行xíng者zhě趕gǎn走zǒu的de餘yú黨dǎng,來lái此cǐ打dǎ殺shā師shī父fù,搶qiǎng了le行xíng李lǐ去qù了le。」 慌huāng得de八bā戒jiè跌diē脚jiǎo搥chuí胸xiōng,大dà呼hū小xiǎo叫jiào道dào:「不bù消xiāo讲jiǎng,不bù消xiāo讲jiǎng,这zhè还hái是shì孙sūn行xíng者zhě赶gǎn走zǒu的de余yú党dǎng,来lái此cǐ打dǎ杀shā师shī父fù,抢qiǎng了le行xíng李lǐ去qù了le。」

Bajie was thrown into a panic, stamping his feet and beating his breast, and bawled out: “No need to say it, no need to say it! This will be the remnant of that gang Sun Pilgrim drove off. They have come here and beaten the master to death and carried off the baggage.”

Bajie's diagnosis is wrong and completely reasonable. 慌得 takes 得 as the link hanging a consequence off the verb, de. 餘黨 -- the surviving remnant of a gang -- points straight back at the bandits of the previous chapter, who had every motive and are exactly the sort of people who take baggage.

沙shā僧sēng道dào:「且qiě去qù把bǎ馬mǎ拴shuān住zhù!」 沙shā僧sēng道dào:「且qiě去qù把bǎ马mǎ拴shuān住zhù!」

Sha Monk said: “Go and make the horse fast first!”

The practical instinct, in the middle of a catastrophe: before you grieve, secure the animal.

只zhǐ叫jiào:「怎zěn麼me好hǎo?怎zěn麼me好hǎo? 只zhǐ叫jiào:「怎zěn么me好hǎo?怎zěn么me好hǎo?

And he could only cry: “What are we to do? What are we to do?

He can manage three characters, and then says them twice.

這zhè誠chéng所suǒ謂wèi半bàn途tú而ér廢fèi,中zhōng道dào而ér止zhǐ也yě。」 这zhè诚chéng所suǒ谓wèi半bàn途tú而ér废fèi,中zhōng道dào而ér止zhǐ也yě。」

“This is what is meant by giving up halfway and stopping in mid-course.”

半途而廢 and 中道而止 are two classical four-character formulas for abandoning something unfinished, set side by side. The first is still in daily use in Chinese for anyone who gives up half way. 中道 takes 中 at zhōng. Sha Monk reaches for literary language at the worst moment of the chapter, which is very much like him.

叫jiào一yì聲shēng:「師shī父fù。」 叫jiào一yì声shēng:「师shī父fù。」

He called out once: “Master.”

Five characters, and one of them is the whole segment. He calls out once: master.

滿mǎn眼yǎn拋pāo珠zhū,傷shāng心xīn痛tòng哭kū。 满mǎn眼yǎn抛pāo珠zhū,伤shāng心xīn痛tòng哭kū。

His eyes streamed and he wept with a breaking heart.

滿眼拋珠 -- casting pearls from brimming eyes -- is a set figure for weeping, and the novel uses it here entirely straight.

八bā戒jiè道dào:「兄xiōng弟dì,且qiě休xiū哭kū。如rú今jīn事shì已yǐ到dào此cǐ,取qǔ經jīng之zhī事shì,且qiě莫mò說shuō了le。 八bā戒jiè道dào:「兄xiōng弟dì,且qiě休xiū哭kū。如rú今jīn事shì已yǐ到dào此cǐ,取qǔ经jīng之zhī事shì,且qiě莫mò说shuō了le。

Bajie said: “Brother, leave off weeping. Things have come to this, and we had best say no more about fetching scriptures.

And Bajie starts winding up the pilgrimage. 兄弟 keeps both syllables at full weight, as it does throughout this corpus.

你nǐ看kàn著zhe師shī父fù的de屍shī靈líng,等děng我wǒ把bǎ馬mǎ騎qí到dào那nǎ個gè府fǔ州zhōu縣xiàn鄉xiāng村cūn店diàn集jí賣mài幾jǐ兩liǎng銀yín子zi,買mǎi口kǒu棺guān木mù,把bǎ師shī父fù埋mái了le,我wǒ兩liǎng個gè各gè尋xún道dào路lù散sàn夥huǒ。」 你nǐ看kàn着zhe师shī父fù的de尸shī灵líng,等děng我wǒ把bǎ马mǎ骑qí到dào那nǎ个gè府fǔ州zhōu县xiàn乡xiāng村cūn店diàn集jí卖mài几jǐ两liǎng银yín子zi,买mǎi口kǒu棺guān木mù,把bǎ师shī父fù埋mái了le,我wǒ两liǎng个gè各gè寻xún道dào路lù散sàn伙huǒ。」

“You keep watch over the master's remains, and let me ride the horse to whatever prefecture or department or county, village or market town there may be, and sell it for a few taels of silver, and buy a coffin, and bury the master; and then the two of us will each go our own way and break up the company.”

The plan is a horse, a coffin, and goodbye. 那個府州縣鄉村店集 is the whichever-there-may-be 那, nǎ -- the reading this corpus has settled for that construction, not the pointing nà. 散夥 takes 散 as the verb "to break up", sàn. 兩 in 幾兩銀子 is the weight, and it is rendered "taels" because English borrowed a name for this particular Chinese unit; where English has no such name -- 寸 earlier in the chapter -- the Chinese word is kept instead.


總評 Commentary

The discovery is staged as one sweep of the eye. A single 只見 governs three clauses -- the master face down, the horse loose and screaming, the baggage gone -- and the sentence never stops between them. The novel could have given each its own sentence and chose not to; the effect is of taking the whole scene in at once, which is how it would actually happen.

Bajie's diagnosis is wrong and entirely reasonable. Bandits were beaten to death in the previous chapter, a surviving gang would have motive, and the baggage is gone -- which is what robbers take. He cannot reach the true explanation, because reaching it would require knowing that Wukong is at Potalaka, and the only party to this scene who knows that is the reader.

What the two of them settle on is the real shock. Not revenge, not pursuit -- a horse to sell, a coffin to buy, and then 散夥, break up the company. The pilgrimage is treated as finished, and the phrase Sha Monk reaches for, 半途而廢, is the classical formula for exactly that. Fifty-six chapters of journey are wound up by its two least decisive members in the space of two speeches.