Canonical Classics ← 第五十七回
第五十七回
zhēnxíngzhěluòqiéshān
jiǎhóuwángshuǐliándòngténgwén

The True Pilgrim Lays His Grievance at Mount Potalaka · The False Monkey King Copies Out the Rescript at the Water-Curtain Cave

行不更名
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

行不更名 I Do Not Change My Name

zhèshāsēngjiànledào:「lǎoshāxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìngyòuyǒushāshàngyàochīzhàng!」hǎoshāsēngshuāngshǒuxiángyāozhàngjiǎshāsēngtóuxiàyuánláizhèshìhóujīngzhèshāsēngjiànledào:「lǎoshāxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìngyòuyǒushāshàngyàochīzhàng!」hǎoshāsēngshuāngshǒuxiángyāozhàngjiǎshāsēngtóuxiàyuánláizhèshìhóujīng


逐句解 Line by line

zhèshāsēngjiànledào:「lǎoshāxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìngyòuyǒushāshàng zhèshāsēngjiànledào:「lǎoshāxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìngyòuyǒushāshàng

This Sha Monk saw it and flew into a rage: “I, old Sha, do not change my name when I walk nor alter my surname when I sit. Where is there another Sha Monk?

He reaches for the standard boast and it lands very strangely. 行不更名, 坐不改姓 -- I do not change my name when I walk nor my surname when I sit -- is the stock declaration of an honest man with nothing to hide, the thing a fighter says when he announces himself. takes gēng, to alter, not the comparative gèng, and stays xíng. 那裡又有 is the rhetorical , . He is asserting that his identity cannot be falsified, to a thing that is wearing it.

yàochīzhàng!」 yàochīzhàng!」

“Do not be insolent — take a stroke of my staff!”

Eight characters, and the argument is over.

hǎoshāsēngshuāngshǒuxiángyāozhàngjiǎshāsēngtóuxiàyuánláizhèshìhóujīng hǎoshāsēngshuāngshǒuxiángyāozhàngjiǎshāsēngtóuxiàyuánláizhèshìhóujīng

Fine Sha Monk! He raised the demon-quelling staff in both hands and brought it down full on the head of that false Sha Monk and killed him — and it turned out he was a monkey-spirit.

降妖杖 takes at xiáng, to subdue -- an automatic reading gives jiàng, to descend, and the guard list forces the decision. 劈頭 is full in the face, and 一下 takes the ordinary tone change to . One blow, and the copy is a dead monkey-spirit.


總評 Commentary

Sha Monk's boast is the one the novel's fighters make when they announce themselves -- I do not change my name walking nor my surname sitting -- and it has never been aimed at anything like this. He is asserting the fixity of his own identity to a thing that is wearing it. The line is a commonplace everywhere else in the book and lands very oddly here.

The killing is instant and gives him no trouble at all, which is itself information. One blow, and the copy is a dead monkey-spirit. Whatever the false king has assembled, it is not made of anything that can withstand the originals -- a fact that will matter more in the next chapter than it does in this one.