Canonical Classics ← 第五十一回
第五十一回
xīnyuánkōngyòngqiānbān
shuǐhuǒgōngnánliàn

The Mind-Monkey Spends a Thousand Devices in Vain · Water and Fire Avail Nothing, and the Fiend Is Hard to Refine

玉陛陳奏,前倨後恭
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

玉陛陳奏,前倨後恭 The Memorial at the Jade Steps: Arrogant First, Respectful After

dāngshítiānshīchuánzòulíngxiāoyǐnjiànxíngzhěcháoshàngchàngdào:「lǎoguānerlèilèilǎosūnbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngxiōngduōshǎoxiāoshuōjīnláizàijīndōushānjīndōudòngyǒuguàitángsēngzàidòngzhīshìyàozhēngyàozhǔyàoshàishìlǎosūnxúnshàngménjiāozhànguàiquèjiùyǒuxiērènlǎosūnzhuóshìshéntōngguǎnglǎosūndejīnbàngqiǎngyīnnányāoshìshàngtiānxiōngxīngfánxiàjièwèilǎosūnláizòutiānzūnchuídòngjiànjiàngzhǐchákānxiōngxīngbīngshōujiǎoyāolǎosūnshèngzhànpíngyíngzhīzhì。」quèyòushēngōngdào:「wén。」pángyǒuxiānwēngxiàodào:「hóuzishìqiánhòugōng?」xíngzhědào:「gǎngǎnshìshénqiánhòugōnglǎosūnjīnshìméibàngnòngle。」dāngshítiānshīchuánzòulíngxiāoyǐnjiànxíngzhěcháoshàngchàngdào:「lǎoguānerlèilèilǎosūnbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngxiōngduōshǎoxiāoshuōjīnláizàijīndōushānjīndōudòngyǒuguàitángsēngzàidòngzhīshìyàozhēngyàozhǔyàoshàishìlǎosūnxúnshàngménjiāozhànguàiquèjiùyǒuxiērènlǎosūnzhuóshìshéntōng广guǎnglǎosūndejīnbàngqiǎngyīnnányāoshìshàngtiānxiōngxīngfánxiàjièwèilǎosūnláizòutiānzūnchuídòngjiànjiàngzhǐchákānxiōngxīngbīngshōujiǎoyāolǎosūnshèngzhànpíngyíngzhīzhì。」quèyòushēngōngdào:「wén。」pángyǒuxiānwēngxiàodào:「hóuzishìqiánhòugōng?」xíngzhědào:「gǎngǎnshìshénqiánhòugōnglǎosūnjīnshìméibàngnòngle。」


逐句解 Line by line

dāngshítiānshīchuánzòulíngxiāoyǐnjiàn dāngshítiānshīchuánzòulíngxiāoyǐnjiàn

The four Celestial Masters then carried the memorial up to the Hall of Divine Mists and brought him in before the jade steps.

當時 is dāng, the time reading. 傳奏 and 引見 are both chancery verbs: to pass a memorial upward, and to conduct a petitioner into an audience. The paperwork is moving.

xíngzhěcháoshàngchàngdào:「lǎoguānerlèilèi xíngzhěcháoshàngchàngdào:「lǎoguānerlèilèi

Pilgrim faced upward, sang out a great salute, and said, "Old official! I trouble you, I trouble you.

And here is the joke of the whole passage. 唱喏 is the Song and Ming courtesy — a bow made together with a spoken formula, so quite literally singing your greeting — and is read here, not nuò. 老官兒 ends in the light er. He is addressing the supreme ruler of Heaven as "old official," which is roughly like opening a submission to a head of state with "alright, boss." Everything that follows is going to be immaculate court prose.

lǎosūnbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngxiōngduōshǎoxiāoshuō lǎosūnbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngxiōngduōshǎoxiāoshuō

Old Monkey has been guarding the Tang Monk on his road west to fetch the scriptures. All along that road the ill has outweighed the good, which needs no telling.

一路 gives . 凶多吉少 is a set four-character phrase, still in daily use — ill abundant and good scarce, the Chinese for "it doesn't look promising." is shǎo, the adjective.

jīnláizàijīndōushānjīndōudòngyǒuguàitángsēngzàidòngzhīshìyàozhēngyàozhǔyàoshài jīnláizàijīndōushānjīndōudòngyǒuguàitángsēngzàidòngzhīshìyàozhēngyàozhǔyàoshài

Now we have come to Golden Helm Mountain and the Golden Helm Cave, where a rhinoceros fiend has taken the Tang Monk into his cave — whether to steam him or boil him or dry him in the sun, there is no telling.

Steam him, boil him, dry him in the sun: the three verbs are the standard menu of what fiends intend for the monk. Their flatness here is deliberate. He is filing a report, not pleading for help.

shìlǎosūnxúnshàngménjiāozhànguàiquèjiùyǒuxiērènlǎosūnzhuóshìshéntōngguǎnglǎosūndejīnbàngqiǎngyīnnányāo shìlǎosūnxúnshàngménjiāozhànguàiquèjiùyǒuxiērènlǎosūnzhuóshìshéntōng广guǎnglǎosūndejīnbàngqiǎngyīnnányāo

Old Monkey sought him out at his door and gave him battle; but the fiend seemed to know old Monkey somewhat, and his powers are decidedly vast. He carried off old Monkey's gold-banded cudgel, and so the fiend is hard to bind.

卓是 uses to pile on emphasis — "decidedly." Some editions print 卻是 instead; the 世德堂本 reading is kept. 認得 is . Notice that this whole account repeats, almost word for word, what he told the Celestial Masters outside — that is the formal restatement a petitioner makes on entering the audience proper.

shìshàngtiānxiōngxīngfánxiàjièwèilǎosūnláizòu shìshàngtiānxiōngxīngfánxiàjièwèilǎosūnláizòu

I suspect a baleful star of upper Heaven has come down out of a hankering after ordinary life. For this cause old Monkey has come expressly to lay the matter before you.

為此 takes wèi, the reading for cause and purpose — "for this reason" — against the wéi that means "to be" or "to act as," as in 為證 or 劃地為牢. 啟奏 is to open a memorial before the throne.

tiānzūnchuídòngjiànjiàngzhǐchákānxiōngxīngbīngshōujiǎoyāolǎosūnshèngzhànpíngyíngzhīzhì。」 tiānzūnchuídòngjiànjiàngzhǐchákānxiōngxīngbīngshōujiǎoyāolǎosūnshèngzhànpíngyíngzhīzhì。」

Prostrate, I beg the Heavenly Honoured One to bend down mercy and see clear through the matter, to send down an edict for the inspection of the baleful stars and despatch troops to gather up and destroy the fiend. Old Monkey is overcome with trembling and awe."

Every phrase here is boilerplate, and that is the point. 伏乞 ("prostrate, I beg"), 垂慈洞鑒 ("bend down mercy and see clear through"), 發兵收剿 ("despatch troops and destroy"), 戰慄屏營 ("trembling and in awe") are all fixed memorial formulae — the last is the standing self-abasement with which any petition to the throne signs off. 降旨 is jiàng, to send down. 不勝 gives before the falling tone.

quèyòushēngōngdào:「wén。」 quèyòushēngōngdào:「wén。」

Then he made a deep bow and added, "Thus it is reported."

以聞 is the formal tag that closes a memorial: "for your hearing." He has produced the entire document correctly, sign-off and all, having opened it by calling the Jade Emperor an old official.

pángyǒuxiānwēngxiàodào:「hóuzishìqiánhòugōng?」 pángyǒuxiānwēngxiàodào:「hóuzishìqiánhòugōng?」

At his side Ge the Immortal Duke laughed and said, "Why is the monkey arrogant first and respectful after?"

is páng, at the side. 猴子 ends in the light zi. 前倨後恭 — arrogant first, respectful after — comes from the life of Su Qin in the 史記, where the relatives who despised him grovel once he is rich. The reversal runs the same way round here, and the phrase is still the one Chinese reaches for when somebody's manners suddenly improve.

xíngzhědào:「gǎngǎnshìshénqiánhòugōnglǎosūnjīnshìméibàngnòngle。」 xíngzhědào:「gǎngǎnshìshénqiánhòugōnglǎosūnjīnshìméibàngnòngle。」

Pilgrim said, "I dare not, I dare not. It is no arrogance first and respect after — old Monkey simply has no cudgel to play with now."

is shén, "any," the reading it carries in 沒甚坐性 — not the shèn that means "extremely," as in 甚急 or 甚妙. 沒棒弄 takes méi. And the answer is the truest thing said in the passage: his manners rise and fall with his armament.


總評 Commentary

The memorial is delivered in full chancery form — prostrate begging, mercy bent down, troops despatched, trembling and awe, "thus it is reported" — and it opens with "old official." That gap between the two registers is the joke, and Ge the Immortal Duke names it out loud with a phrase every Chinese reader knows: 前倨後恭, arrogant first and respectful after.

Wukong's answer is better than the joke. He does not deny the charge; he explains it. The courtesy arrived at the same moment the cudgel left, and he says so plainly — a harder piece of self-knowledge than the mind-ape usually permits himself.

前倨後恭 comes from the Su Qin chapter of the 史記, where a man's relatives change their manners the instant his fortunes change. 卓是 in the fifth segment is a 世德堂本 reading where 卻是 might be expected, and it is kept as the main text.