天將難選,一物降一物 Choosing a General: One Thing Subdues Another
四大天師奉旨意,即出靈霄寶殿,對行者道:「大聖啊,玉帝寬恩,言天宮無神思凡,著你挑選幾員天將,擒魔去哩。」行者低頭暗想道:「天上將不如老孫者多,勝似老孫者少。想我鬧天宮時,玉帝遣十萬天兵,佈天羅地網,更不曾有一將敢與我比手。向後來,調了小聖二郎,方是我的對手。如今那怪物手段又強似老孫,卻怎麼得能夠取勝?」許旌陽道:「此一時,彼一時,大不同也。常言道:『一物降一物』哩。你好違了旨意?但憑高見,選用天將,勿得遲疑誤事。」行者道:「既然如此,深感上恩,果是不好違旨;一則老孫又不可空走這遭。煩旌陽轉奏玉帝,只教托塔李天王與哪吒太子去罷,他還有幾件降妖兵器,且下界與那怪見一仗,以看如何。果若能擒得他,是老孫之幸;若不能,那時再作區處。」四大天师奉旨意,即出灵霄宝殿,对行者道:「大圣啊,玉帝宽恩,言天宫无神思凡,着你挑选几员天将,擒魔去哩。」行者低头暗想道:「天上将不如老孙者多,胜似老孙者少。想我闹天宫时,玉帝遣十万天兵,布天罗地网,更不曾有一将敢与我比手。向后来,调了小圣二郎,方是我的对手。如今那怪物手段又强似老孙,却怎么得能够取胜?」许旌阳道:「此一时,彼一时,大不同也。常言道:『一物降一物』哩。你好违了旨意?但凭高见,选用天将,勿得迟疑误事。」行者道:「既然如此,深感上恩,果是不好违旨;一则老孙又不可空走这遭。烦旌阳转奏玉帝,只教托塔李天王与哪咤太子去罢,他还有几件降妖兵器,且下界与那怪见一仗,以看如何。果若能擒得他,是老孙之幸;若不能,那时再作区处。」
逐句解 Line by line
The four Celestial Masters, having received the command, came straight out of the Hall of Divine Mists and said to Pilgrim, "Great Sage! The Jade Emperor is generous. He says there is no god in the palace of Heaven who has gone down out of longing, and he has you pick out a few heavenly generals and go seize the fiend."
著你挑選 is zhuó again, "have you pick." 天將 is jiàng. 哩 closes on the light li. The Masters pass the order on without softening it, and without appearing to notice that it hands Wukong back the very problem he brought upstairs.
Pilgrim lowered his head and thought quietly: "Of the generals in Heaven, those who fall short of old Monkey are many, and those who outmatch him are few.
天上將 takes jiàng. The sentence is built as a see-saw — 者多 against 者少, many below him and few above — and the vanity in it is arithmetic rather than boasting. He is doing sums on the roster he has just heard read out.
I remember when I made havoc in the palace of Heaven: the Jade Emperor sent a hundred thousand heavenly soldiers and spread the nets of sky and earth, and not one general among them dared try hands with me.
更不曾 takes gèng. 一將 is worth pausing on: left to itself a machine reads 將 as jiāng, a level tone, which would make the 一 in front of it yì. But the character means a general here and is read jiàng, a falling tone — so the 一 has to be lifted by hand to yí. The second character's reading decides the first character's tone, which is why a case like this can never be left to the machine. 天羅地網, nets above and nets below, is the standing phrase for a trap nothing escapes. Nothing did escape it, which is exactly his point.
Later on they brought in the Little Sage Erlang, and he was a match for me.
調 takes diào, to summon and post a man to a job, not the tiáo of tuning an instrument. 方是我的對手 is a genuine concession and the only one in the speech — Erlang did take him, back in Ch.6.
Now this fiend's powers are stronger still than old Monkey's — how then is a victory to be got?"
那怪物 takes nà. 強 is qiáng, the comparative "stronger." 怎麼得 takes dé, the reading for managing or being able. The thought stops exactly where the chapter's trouble starts: he can name nobody on the list who would do.
Xu Jingyang said, "That was one time, this is another; they are not the same at all.
此一時,彼一時 — "that was one time, this is another" — comes from Mencius and is still current Chinese for "circumstances alter cases." Both 一 are yì. The point is that situations govern outcomes, not the ranking of persons, which is the direct answer to Wukong's arithmetic.
As the common saying has it, 'one thing subdues another.'
Here is the proverb the whole chapter runs on: 一物降一物, one thing subdues another. Every schoolchild knows it, and it is the Chinese for rock-paper-scissors as a theory of the world — nothing is strongest, things are only fitted or unfitted to what they meet. 降 is xiáng, to subdue, not the jiàng of coming down; take the wrong reading and the proverb turns to nonsense. Everything the ring swallows over the next several passages proves the saying from the wrong side.
How can you go against the edict?
違了 ends on le. The question is put lightly and it is perfectly real: the order has been given and Wukong is standing about arguing with it.
Use your own judgement, pick the generals you want, and do not lose the matter by hanging back."
天將 takes jiàng and 勿得 takes dé. 誤事 is to ruin a piece of business by dragging your feet — the standard reproach in any office, then and now.
Pilgrim said, "Since that is how it stands, I am deeply obliged for the grace above, and it is indeed not well to go against an edict; and besides, old Monkey ought not to have made this trip for nothing.
Two clauses run together under one semicolon here. 一則 gives yì. And 空走這遭 — to have walked the whole road for nothing — is the honest reason sitting underneath the two polite ones.
Trouble yourself, Jingyang, to report back to the Jade Emperor: let him just send Pagoda-bearing Heavenly King Li and Prince Nezha, since they still have several weapons for subduing fiends. Let them go down to the world and see one bout with the creature, and we shall see how it goes.
降妖 is xiáng, subduing, matching the proverb four segments back. 去罷 takes the light ba; 還有 takes hái; 那怪 takes nà; 一仗 gives yí; 以看 takes kàn. Note whom he picks: the pair who beat him once. It is the nearest he will come to admitting he cannot manage this alone.
If they can take him, it is old Monkey's good fortune; and if they cannot, we shall make other arrangements then."
區處 takes chǔ, the verb — to dispose of a matter, to settle it — not the chù that means a place. 擒得 takes dé and 那時 takes nà. The two conditions run under a single semicolon in one sentence.
一物降一物 — one thing subdues another — is the hinge of the whole 金兜山 episode, and the book plants it here deliberately, before a single force has been sent against the ring. Nothing in this chapter is strong enough. The only question that matters is what the ring is not fitted to swallow, and neither Wukong nor Heaven thinks to ask it.
降 takes xiáng twice in this passage — subduing the fiend, weapons for subduing fiends — against the jiàng of 降旨 and 下降, sending down. The two readings sit close together all through the chapter and each one has to be set by hand.
Wukong's reasoning is worth watching. He works down the roster from memory, finds only Erlang above himself, and then asks for Li Jing and Nezha instead — the pair who took him in the sixth chapter. He does not explain why, and the book does not explain it for him.