Canonical Classics ← 第三十六回
第三十六回
xīnyuánzhèngchùzhūyuán
pángménjiànyuèmíng

The Mind-Monkey, Rightly Settled, Subdues All Conditions · Cleaving the Side-Gate, He Sees the Bright Moon

僧官拒宿
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

僧官拒宿 The Abbot Refuses Lodging

shījiǎogēnjìnfāngzhàngménzhǐjiànsēngguāntuōledezuòzàizhīshìniànjīngyòuzhīshìrénjiāxiěshìjiànzhuōànshàngyǒuxiēzhǐzhāduītángsēnggǎnshēnjiùtiānjǐnggōngshēngāojiàodào:「lǎoyuànzhǔwènxùnle。」shàngjiùyǒuxiēnàifánjìnbiānláidesibàndehuánledào:「shìláide?」sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngtángjiàxiàchāiláishàng西tiānbàihuóqiújīngdejīngguòbǎofāngtiānwǎnqiújiè宿xiǔmíngfàntiānguāngjiùxínglewànwànglǎoyuànzhǔfāng便biànfāng便biàn。」sēngguāncáiqiànshēnláidào:「shìtángsānzàngme?」sānzàngdào:「gǎn便biànshì。」sēngguāndào:「wǎng西tiānjīngzěnmehuìzǒu?」sānzàngdào:「gèngcéngzǒuguìchùde。」dào:「zhèng西zhǐyǒuyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòsānshídiàndiànshàngyǒumàifànderénjiāfāng便biànhǎo宿zhè便biànhǎoliúmenyuǎnláidesēng。」sānzàngzhǎngdào:「yuànzhǔrényǒuyún:『ānguànyuàndōushìfāngshàngréndeguǎnjiànshānménjiùyǒusānshēngfèn。』zěnmeliúquèshìqíng?」sēngguānshēngjiàodào:「zhèyóufāngdeshàng便biànshìyǒuxiēyóuzuǐyóushédeshuōhuà。」sānzàngdào:「wéiyóuzuǐyóushé?」sēngguāndào:「rényún:『lǎojìnlechéngjiājiādōuménsuīrányǎorénqiánhuàilemíng。』」sānzàngdào:「zěnmeqiánhuàilemíng』?」dào:「xiàngniányǒuzhòngxíngjiǎosēngláishānménkǒuzuòxiàshìjiànhánxiéguāngtóuchìjiǎotànbānlánmángqǐngfāngzhàngyánzhīshàngzuòkuǎndàilezhāifànyòujiāngjièjiànjiùliúzhùlezěnzhītānzàishígèngliángshēnjiùzhùleniántóuzhù便biànyòugànchūduōgōngdeshìlái。」sānzàngdào:「yǒushénmegōngdeshì?」sēngguāndào:「tīngshuōshījiǎogēnjìnfāngzhàngménzhǐjiànsēngguāntuōledezuòzàizhīshìniànjīngyòuzhīshìrénjiāxiěshìjiànzhuōànshàngyǒuxiēzhǐzhāduītángsēnggǎnshēnjiùtiānjǐnggōngshēngāojiàodào:「lǎoyuànzhǔwènxùnle。」shàngjiùyǒuxiēnàifánjìnbiānláidesibàndehuánledào:「shìláide?」sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngtángjiàxiàchāiláishàng西tiānbàihuóqiújīngdejīngguòbǎofāngtiānwǎnqiújiè宿xiǔmíngfàntiānguāngjiùxínglewànwànglǎoyuànzhǔfāng便biànfāng便biàn。」sēngguāncáiqiànshēnláidào:「shìtángsānzàngme?」sānzàngdào:「gǎn便biànshì。」sēngguāndào:「wǎng西tiānjīngzěnmehuìzǒu?」sānzàngdào:「gèngcéngzǒuguìchùde。」dào:「zhèng西zhǐyǒuyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòsānshídiàndiànshàngyǒumàifànderénjiāfāng便biànhǎo宿zhè便biànhǎoliúmenyuǎnláidesēng。」sānzàngzhǎngdào:「yuànzhǔrényǒuyún:『ānguànyuàndōushìfāngshàngréndeguǎn驿jiànshānménjiùyǒusānshēngfèn。』zěnmeliúquèshìqíng?」sēngguānshēngjiàodào:「zhèyóufāngdeshàng便biànshìyǒuxiēyóuzuǐyóushédeshuōhuà。」sānzàngdào:「wéiyóuzuǐyóushé?」sēngguāndào:「rényún:『lǎojìnlechéngjiājiādōuménsuīrányǎorénqiánhuàilemíng。』」sānzàngdào:「zěnmeqiánhuàilemíng』?」dào:「xiàngniányǒuzhòngxíngjiǎosēngláishānménkǒuzuòxiàshìjiànhánxiéguāngtóuchìjiǎotànbānlánmángqǐngfāngzhàngyánzhīshàngzuòkuǎndàilezhāifànyòujiāngjièjiànjiùliúzhùlezěnzhītānzàishígèngliángshēnjiùzhùleniántóuzhù便biànyòugànchūduōgōngdeshìlái。」sānzàngdào:「yǒushénmegōngdeshì?」sēngguāndào:「tīngshuō

xiánshí沿yánqiángpāomènláishàngbāndīngxiánshí沿yánqiángpāomènláishàngbāndīng
lěngtiānxiànghuǒzhéchuānglínglěngtiānxiànghuǒzhéchuānglíng
xiàtuōménlánjìngxiàtuōménlánjìng
fānchěwéijiǎodàixiāngtōuhuànmànjīngfānchěwéijiǎodàixiāngtōuhuànmànjīng
chángjiāngliúyóuqīngchángjiāngliúyóuqīng
duówǎnduóguōshèng。」duówǎnduóguōshèng。」

逐句解 Line by line

shījiǎogēnjìnfāngzhàngmén shījiǎogēnjìnfāngzhàngmén

The master, treading in the servitor's footsteps, followed him in through the door of the abbot's quarters.

踏腳跡 is to tread in another man's footprints. is .

zhǐjiànsēngguāntuōledezuòzàizhīshìniànjīngyòuzhīshìrénjiāxiěshìjiànzhuōànshàngyǒuxiēzhǐzhāduī zhǐjiànsēngguāntuōledezuòzàizhīshìniànjīngyòuzhīshìrénjiāxiěshìjiànzhuōànshàngyǒuxiēzhǐzhāduī

He saw the abbot, robe now off, sitting there in a huff — whether reciting sūtras or drafting some ritual document for a patron there was no telling — with a heap of papers piled on the desk before him.

The abbot has taken his good robe off again. 氣呼呼 is puffing with annoyance; 法事 is a Buddhist service or the paperwork that goes with one; 紙劄 is papers and documents — the character is an older form of , zhá, a note or a written slip, and survives today mainly in 劄記, jottings, and 劄子, the memorandum an official sent up to the throne.

tángsēnggǎnshēnjiùtiānjǐnggōngshēngāojiàodào:「lǎoyuànzhǔwènxùnle。」 tángsēnggǎnshēnjiùtiānjǐnggōngshēngāojiàodào:「lǎoyuànzhǔwènxùnle。」

Tripitaka, not daring to go far in, stood in the courtyard, bowed, and called out: "Venerable prior, this disciple pays his respects."

Tripitaka does not presume past the threshold. 天井 is the small open courtyard inside a building; 院主 is the prior, the head of the cloister; 問訊 is the Buddhist greeting, gesture and words together.

shàngjiùyǒuxiēnàifánjìnbiānláidesibàndehuánledào:「shìláide?」 shàngjiùyǒuxiēnàifánjìnbiānláidesibàndehuánledào:「shìláide?」

The monk, plainly none too pleased that the visitor had come inside, returned the greeting half-heartedly and said: "Where are you from?"

Barely a greeting at all. 不耐煩 is impatient, put out; 半答不答 is half-answering, scarcely answering. 還了個禮 is to return a courtesy, and here is huán, to give back. 和尚 takes on the first character.

sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngtángjiàxiàchāiláishàng西tiānbàihuóqiújīngde sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngtángjiàxiàchāiláishàng西tiānbàihuóqiújīngde

Tripitaka said: "This disciple is one dispatched by the throne of Great Tang in the Eastern Land, bound for the Western Heaven to worship the living Buddha and seek the scriptures."

The same introduction as before, with one addition: 活佛, the living Buddha. is chāi, dispatched; is , is zàng.

jīngguòbǎofāngtiānwǎnqiújiè宿xiǔmíngfàntiānguāngjiùxíngle jīngguòbǎofāngtiānwǎnqiújiè宿xiǔmíngfàntiānguāngjiùxíngle

"Passing your precious place, and the day being late, I beg a night's lodging; tomorrow I'll be gone before daybreak."

He asks for as little as he can. 不犯天光 is "without trespassing on the daylight," meaning gone before dawn; 就行了 is "and that will do."

wànwànglǎoyuànzhǔfāng便biànfāng便biàn。」 wànwànglǎoyuànzhǔfāng便biànfāng便biàn。」

"I earnestly beg the venerable prior to oblige me."

方便 is to accommodate or do a kindness, and doubling it makes it a plea.

sēngguāncáiqiànshēnláidào:「shìtángsānzàngme?」 sēngguāncáiqiànshēnláidào:「shìtángsānzàngme?」

Only then did the abbot half-rise and say: "Are you that Tang Tripitaka?"

欠起身 is to rise only partway — a grudging half-courtesy, and the exact measure of the abbot's interest. is twice; is zàng.

sānzàngdào:「gǎn便biànshì。」 sānzàngdào:「gǎn便biànshì。」

Tripitaka said: "I dare not claim it — but I am he."

不敢 here is a modest formula, "I dare not presume." is zàng.

sēngguāndào:「wǎng西tiānjīngzěnmehuìzǒu?」 sēngguāndào:「wǎng西tiānjīngzěnmehuìzǒu?」

The abbot said: "If you're bound for the Western Heaven to fetch scriptures, how is it you can't even find your way?"

A gratuitous dig: a man on a scripture-quest who cannot find his own road. 不會走 is "cannot walk the road," read huì.

sānzàngdào:「gèngcéngzǒuguìchùde。」 sānzàngdào:「gèngcéngzǒuguìchùde。」

Tripitaka said: "This disciple has never yet travelled the road of your honoured district."

更不曾 is "have not even once," read gèng; 貴處 is "your honoured place," read chù. is zàng.

dào:「zhèng西zhǐyǒuyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòsānshídiàndiànshàngyǒumàifànderénjiāfāng便biànhǎo宿 dào:「zhèng西zhǐyǒuyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòsānshídiàndiànshàngyǒumàifànderénjiāfāng便biànhǎo宿

He said: "Due west, only four or five off, there's a Thirty-Lǐ Inn, with folk selling food — convenient, and good for lodging."

He points them at a paying inn instead. , , is the Chinese road-measure, a little over half a kilometre, and the Thirty-Lǐ Inn is named for its distance from somewhere — the way an English coaching house might be the Halfway House.

zhè便biànhǎoliúmenyuǎnláidesēng。」 zhè便biànhǎoliúmenyuǎnláidesēng。」

"Here it's not convenient; I can't lodge you monks come from afar."

不便 and 不好 are "inconvenient" and "not good to do." Stripped of the padding, it is no.

sānzàngzhǎngdào:「yuànzhǔrényǒuyún:『ānguànyuàndōushìfāngshàngréndeguǎnjiànshānménjiùyǒusānshēngfèn。』 sānzàngzhǎngdào:「yuànzhǔrényǒuyún:『ānguànyuàndōushìfāngshàngréndeguǎn驿jiànshānménjiùyǒusānshēngfèn。』

Tripitaka, pressing his palms together, said: "Prior, the ancients had a saying: 'Convents and abbeys, temples and cloisters are all the way-stations of us who travel; at the sight of a temple gate one is due three shēng of rice.'"

Tripitaka appeals to custom, and the custom is real. Religious houses of every kind — convent, Daoist abbey (, read guàn), monastery, cloister — served as the 館驛, the post-house or way-station, of anyone travelling on religious business, and a monk arriving at any gate was reckoned to be owed his keep. The measure stays in Chinese: three shēng of rice, a being about a litre, so some three litres in all — several days' eating. is fèn, one's due share; is dōu, is zàng.

zěnmeliúquèshìqíng?」 zěnmeliúquèshìqíng?」

"Why then do you not lodge me — what feeling is this?"

何情 is "what sort of feeling" — meaning, what has become of ordinary human feeling.

sēngguānshēngjiàodào:「zhèyóufāngdeshàng便biànshìyǒuxiēyóuzuǐyóushédeshuōhuà。」 sēngguānshēngjiàodào:「zhèyóufāngdeshàng便biànshìyǒuxiēyóuzuǐyóushédeshuōhuà。」

The abbot shouted angrily: "You wandering monk — you've a glib and oily tongue, that's what."

遊方 is wandering on religious travels; 油嘴油舌, "oily mouth and oily tongue," is still the phrase for someone too smooth by half. 和尚 takes .

sānzàngdào:「wéiyóuzuǐyóushé?」 sānzàngdào:「wéiyóuzuǐyóushé?」

Tripitaka said: "What do you mean, a glib and oily tongue?"

何為 is "what is meant by," read wéi. is zàng.

sēngguāndào:「rényún:『lǎojìnlechéngjiājiādōumén sēngguāndào:「rényún:『lǎojìnlechéngjiājiādōumén

The abbot said: "The ancients said: 'When a tiger comes into town, every household bars its door.'"

Proverb answers proverb. This one likens the wandering monk to a tiger walking into town — everybody bolts the door on sight. is dōu.

suīrányǎorénqiánhuàilemíng。』」 suīrányǎorénqiánhuàilemíng。』」

"Though he bites no one, his reputation was ruined long before.'"

And the sting in it: 日前壞了名, his name was ruined before he arrived. The tiger is shunned for what tigers are, not for anything this tiger has done — which is, of course, precisely what the abbot is doing to Tripitaka.

sānzàngdào:「zěnmeqiánhuàilemíng』?」 sānzàngdào:「zěnmeqiánhuàilemíng』?」

Tripitaka said: "How 'his reputation was ruined long before'?"

Stung, Tripitaka presses him to explain the slur. is zàng.

dào:「xiàngniányǒuzhòngxíngjiǎosēngláishānménkǒuzuòxià dào:「xiàngniányǒuzhòngxíngjiǎosēngláishānménkǒuzuòxià

He said: "Some years ago a party of itinerant monks came and sat down at our temple gate."

Out comes the grievance. 向年 is "in a former year"; 行腳僧 are monks who travel on foot, mendicants, read xíng.

shìjiànhánxiéguāngtóuchìjiǎotànbānlánmángqǐngfāngzhàngyánzhīshàngzuòkuǎndàilezhāifànyòujiāngjièjiànjiùliúzhùle shìjiànhánxiéguāngtóuchìjiǎotànbānlánmángqǐngfāngzhàngyánzhīshàngzuòkuǎndàilezhāifànyòujiāngjièjiànjiùliúzhùle

"Seeing how poor they were — every one in torn clothes and without shoes, bare-headed and barefoot — I pitied their raggedness, hastily asked them into the abbot's quarters, seated them in the places of honour, served them a vegetarian meal, lent each an old garment of mine, and let them stay a few days."

To be fair to him, the kindness was real and thorough. 寒薄 is poor and threadbare, read in its "meagre" sense; 襤褸 is ragged; 延之上坐 is to usher guests to the seats of honour; 款待 is to entertain properly; 故衣 is old clothing, read jiāng. is .

zěnzhītānzàishígèngliángshēnjiùzhùleniántóu zěnzhītānzàishígèngliángshēnjiùzhùleniántóu

"Who'd have known they'd covet their ease and their board, never once think of moving on, and end by staying seven or eight whole years?"

And here is where it went wrong. 貪圖自在 is to covet an easy life; 更不思量 is "never even considered," read gèng; 年頭 is a colloquial "years."

zhù便biànyòugànchūduōgōngdeshìlái。」 zhù便biànyòugànchūduōgōngdeshìlái。」

"Their staying would have been one thing — but they went and did all manner of dishonest things besides."

也罷 is "would be one thing," read ; 不公 is dishonest, not straight.

sānzàngdào:「yǒushénmegōngdeshì?」 sānzàngdào:「yǒushénmegōngdeshì?」

Tripitaka said: "What dishonest things?"

甚麼 is "what," read shén. is zàng.

sēngguāndào:「tīngshuō sēngguāndào:「tīngshuō

The abbot said: "Listen and I'll tell you:"

And he has the list ready in verse, which tells you how often he has recited it.

xiánshí沿yánqiángpāomènláishàngbāndīng xiánshí沿yánqiángpāomènláishàngbāndīng

At leisure, they flung tiles along the walls; out of boredom, prised the nails from the plaster.

The catalogue of petty vandalism begins. 沿牆 is along the wall; 扳釘 is to prise out nails, read bān. Every item is an idle hand finding something to break.

lěngtiānxiànghuǒzhéchuānglíng lěngtiānxiànghuǒzhéchuānglíng

On cold days, for firewood, they broke up the window-lattices.

Burning the joinery for warmth. 向火 is to sit toward the fire; 窗櫺 is the window-lattice.

xiàtuōménlánjìng xiàtuōménlánjìng

On summer days they hauled off doors to block the paths.

拖門 is to drag doors off; 攔徑 is to block the path. In summer they took the doors away, in winter they burnt the windows.

fānchěwéijiǎodàixiāngtōuhuànmànjīng fānchěwéijiǎodàixiāngtōuhuànmànjīng

Temple banners they tore up for foot-bindings; fine incense they filched and traded for turnips.

Now the sacrilege. 幡布 is banner-cloth, torn up for foot-wrappings; 扯為 is "tore it to make," read wéi; 牙香 is fine incense, swapped for 蔓菁, the turnip. The plant-name carries a reading of its own: is mán here and nowhere else, distinct from the wàn of melon-vines and the màn of spreading.

chángjiāngliúyóuqīng chángjiāngliúyóuqīng

The glazed lamps they were forever tipping to pour off the oil.

Draining the sanctuary lamps for their oil. 琉璃 here is the glazed oil-lamp; is jiāng; 把油傾 is to tip the oil out.

duówǎnduóguōshèng。」 duówǎnduóguōshèng。」

And they'd snatch bowls and snatch pots to wager on their games."

And they gambled with the crockery. is to snatch; 賭勝 is to wager on winning. Set this list beside Tripitaka's protest a few passages back — never damaged a Buddha-hall, never stripped gold from an arhat — and you can see the two men arguing about entirely different monks.


總評 Commentary

Tripitaka follows the servant in and finds the abbot sulking over a heap of papers. What follows is the chapter's central set-piece of discourtesy. Tripitaka is scrupulously humble — bowing from the courtyard, begging one night, promising to be gone before dawn — while the abbot answers with sarcasm (how can a scripture-pilgrim not know his own road?), waves him off toward a commercial inn a few away, and finally refuses outright.

When Tripitaka appeals to the old custom of monastic hospitality — that temples are the way-stations of religious travellers, and a monk is owed three shēng of rice at any gate he reaches — the abbot comes back with a proverb likening the wandering monk to a tiger that every household shuts its door against, then produces his justification. Years ago he took in a band of poor mendicants out of genuine pity, fed them, clothed them, gave them the seats of honour; they repaid him by squatting for seven or eight years and wrecking the place.

That grievance spills into the doggerel catalogue that closes the passage — prising nails out of the walls, burning the window-lattices for fuel, hauling off doors in summer, tearing up temple banners for foot-cloths, trading the good incense for turnips, draining the lamp-oil, gambling with the bowls. It is funny in itself, and it completes the portrait. Read it against Tripitaka's protest two passages earlier, where he swore he had never damaged a shrine or stripped gold from an image, and the shape of the injustice is clear: one bad experience has hardened into a blanket contempt for the poor and the travelling, and the abbot cites his single act of charity not as charity but as the reason he now offers none.