Canonical Classics ← 第二回
第二回
chèzhēnmiào
duànguīběnyuánshén

Wukong Fully Comprehends the True Mystery of Bodhi · Severing the Demon, Returning to the Root, Uniting the Primal Spirit

三災利害
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

三災利害 The Three Calamities

quèzǎoguòlesānniánshīdēngbǎozuòzhòngshuōtándeshìgōngànlùndeshìwàixiàngbāowèn:「kōngzài?」kōngjìnqiánguìxià:「yǒu。」shīdào:「zhèxiàngxiūxiēshènmedàolái?」kōngdào:「jìnláixìngtōnggēnyuánjiànjiān。」shīdào:「tōngxìnghuìdegēnyuánzhùshénquèzhǐshìfángbèizhesānzāihài。」kōngtīngshuōchényínliángjiǔdào:「shīzhīyánmiùchángwéndàogāolóngtiāntóngshòushuǐhuǒbǎibìngshēngquèzěnmeyǒusānzāihài?」shīdào:「nǎifēichángzhīdàoduótiānzhīzàohuàqīnyuèzhīxuándānchéngzhīhòuguǐshénnánróngsuīzhùyánshòudàndàolebǎiniánhòutiānjiàngléizāiyàojiànxìngmíngxīnxiānduǒduǒdeguòshòutiānduǒguòjiùjuémìngzàibǎiniánhòutiānjiànghuǒzāishāozhèhuǒshìtiānhuǒshìfánhuǒhuànzuòyīnhuǒběnshēnyǒngquánxuéxiàshāozhítòuyuángōngzàngchénghuīzhījiēxiǔqiānniánxíngwéihuànzàibǎiniányòujiàngfēngzāichuīzhèfēngshìdōngnán西běifēngshìxūnjīnshuòfēngshìhuāliǔsōngzhúfēnghuànzuòfēngxìnménzhōngchuīliùguòdāntián穿chuānjiǔqiàoròuxiāoshūshēnjiěsuǒdōuyàoduǒguò。」quèzǎoguòlesānniánshīdēngbǎozuòzhòngshuōtándeshìgōngànlùndeshìwàixiàngbāowèn:「kōngzài?」kōngjìnqiánguìxià:「yǒu。」shīdào:「zhèxiàngxiūxiēshènmedàolái?」kōngdào:「jìnláixìngtōnggēnyuánjiànjiān。」shīdào:「tōngxìnghuìdegēnyuánzhùshénquèzhǐshìfángbèizhesānzāihài。」kōngtīngshuōchényínliángjiǔdào:「shīzhīyánmiùchángwéndàogāolóngtiāntóng寿shòushuǐhuǒbǎibìngshēngquèzěnmeyǒusānzāihài?」shīdào:「nǎifēichángzhīdàoduótiānzhīzàohuàqīnyuèzhīxuándānchéngzhīhòuguǐshénnánróngsuīzhùyán寿shòudàndàolebǎiniánhòutiānjiàngléizāiyàojiànxìngmíngxīnxiānduǒduǒdeguò寿shòutiānduǒguòjiùjuémìngzàibǎiniánhòutiānjiànghuǒzāishāozhèhuǒshìtiānhuǒshìfánhuǒhuànzuòyīnhuǒběnshēnyǒngquánxuéxiàshāozhítòuyuángōngzàngchénghuīzhījiēxiǔqiānniánxíngwéihuànzàibǎiniányòujiàngfēngzāichuīzhèfēngshìdōngnán西běifēngshìxūnjīnshuòfēngshìhuāliǔsōngzhúfēnghuànzuòfēngxìnménzhōngchuīliùguòdāntián穿chuānjiǔqiàoròuxiāoshūshēnjiěsuǒdōuyàoduǒguò。」


逐句解 Line by line

quèzǎoguòlesānniánshīdēngbǎozuòzhòngshuō quèzǎoguòlesānniánshīdēngbǎozuòzhòngshuō

By now three years had slipped by. The Patriarch again ascended his jeweled seat and expounded the Dharma to the assembly.

卻早 is "by now, already" — three more years gone in four characters, the same trick the chapter used on its opening seven. 復登寶座, he mounts the jewelled seat again; 說法 is to expound the Dharma.

tándeshìgōngànlùndeshìwàixiàngbāo tándeshìgōngànlùndeshìwàixiàngbāo

What he discoursed on were the kōan-cases and figurative sayings; what he treated of were the outer forms and surface wrappings.

A parallel couplet on the master's range. 公案 (gōng àn) are kōan-cases, the Chan teaching-anecdotes — the word means "public case," as in a magistrate's docket, because a kōan is a case put to the student for judgement. 比語 are figurative sayings. Set against those, 外像包皮, outer images and surface wrappings — the exoteric forms. Inner cases and outer wrappings, both together.

wèn:「kōngzài?」 wèn:「kōngzài?」

Suddenly he asked: "Where is Wukong?"

忽問, he asks suddenly; 何在 is "where is?"

kōngjìnqiánguìxià:「yǒu。」 kōngjìnqiánguìxià:「yǒu。」

Wukong came forward and knelt: "Your disciple is here."

弟子有 — "your disciple is present," with doing the work of "here." 弟子 keeps in full tone.

shīdào:「zhèxiàngxiūxiēshènmedàolái?」 shīdào:「zhèxiàngxiūxiēshènmedàolái?」

The Patriarch said: "What sort of Way have you been cultivating all this while?"

一向 (yí xiàng) is "all this while, of late," the rising before the falling tone of . The master knows perfectly well what his disciple has been cultivating. He is asking for a progress report in front of the class.

kōngdào:「jìnláixìngtōnggēnyuánjiànjiān。」 kōngdào:「jìnláixìngtōnggēnyuánjiànjiān。」

Wukong said: "Of late your disciple has grown fairly penetrating in dharma-nature, and his root and source too have gradually grown firm."

The answer is calibrated with some care — enough to be truthful, not enough to give the secret away in public. 法性 (fǎ xìng) is dharma-nature, the fundamental nature of things; is , fairly, quite; is gradually; marks a state arrived at.

shīdào:「tōngxìnghuìdegēnyuánzhùshénquèzhǐshìfángbèizhesānzāihài。」 shīdào:「tōngxìnghuìdegēnyuánzhùshénquèzhǐshìfángbèizhesānzāihài。」

The Patriarch said: "Since you have penetrated dharma-nature and grasped the root and source, and have already settled it into your spirit-body — there yet remains one thing to guard against: the peril of the Three Calamities."

會得 is to grasp, with as de; 已注神體 is that it has already been infused into the spirit-body ( zhù, to fix, to pour in). Then the turn: 卻只是, "except that…" — and out comes the thing nobody mentioned during the sales pitch. is the durative zhe, and 三災利害 is the peril of the Three Calamities, 利害 meaning severity or danger.

kōngtīngshuōchényínliángjiǔdào:「shīzhīyánmiùchángwéndàogāolóngtiāntóngshòushuǐhuǒbǎibìngshēngquèzěnmeyǒusānzāihài?」 kōngtīngshuōchényínliángjiǔdào:「shīzhīyánmiùchángwéndàogāolóngtiāntóng寿shòushuǐhuǒbǎibìngshēngquèzěnmeyǒusānzāihài?」

Hearing this, Wukong pondered a long while, then said: "The master's words must be mistaken. I have heard that when the Way is lofty and virtue eminent one is equal to Heaven in years; that when water and fire are in accord the hundred ailments do not arise — how then could there be any 'peril of the Three Calamities'?"

沉吟良久 — he mutters over it a long while before answering, which is new for him. Then he argues, quoting doctrine back at his teacher: a lofty Way and eminent virtue mean years equal to Heaven's, and 水火既濟, water and fire in accord, means the hundred ailments never arise. That phrase is also the name of hexagram 63 of the 《易經》, 既濟, "Already Fording" — the one hexagram in which every line sits in its proper place. is miù, mistaken; is cháng, "once, ever." (百病不生 keeps .)

shīdào:「nǎifēichángzhīdàoduótiānzhīzàohuàqīnyuèzhīxuándānchéngzhīhòuguǐshénnánróng shīdào:「nǎifēichángzhīdàoduótiānzhīzàohuàqīnyuèzhīxuándānchéngzhīhòuguǐshénnánróng

The Patriarch said: "This is no ordinary Way: it wrests away the creative power of Heaven and Earth, it usurps the hidden workings of sun and moon; and once the elixir is formed, neither ghosts nor spirits can abide it.

And here is the answer, bleaker than anything else in the chapter. This is a 非常之道, an out-of-the-ordinary Way, and what it does is 奪天地之造化, wrest away the creative power of Heaven and Earth, and 侵日月之玄機, trespass on the hidden workings of sun and moon ( qīn, to encroach). Once the elixir is formed, 鬼神難容 — gods and ghosts cannot abide it. Immortality is not a reward in this system. It is theft, and the universe notices.

suīzhùyánshòudàndàolebǎiniánhòutiānjiàngléizāiyàojiànxìngmíngxīnxiānduǒ suīzhùyán寿shòudàndàolebǎiniánhòutiānjiàngléizāiyàojiànxìngmíngxīnxiānduǒ

Though it halts your aging and lengthens your years, yet when five hundred years have passed, Heaven sends down a thunder-calamity to strike you, and you must see your nature and illumine your mind to dodge it in advance.

駐顏益壽 is to halt the ageing of the face and lengthen the years. But every five hundred years Heaven sends something, and the first is lightning. Note that the escape is stated in Chan terms: 見性明心, see your nature and illumine your mind, usually written the other way round as 明心見性. Even the fire escape is Buddhist. is jiàng, to send down, not xiáng, and it recurs right through this speech.

duǒdeguòshòutiānduǒguòjiùjuémìng duǒdeguò寿shòutiānduǒguòjiùjuémìng

Dodge it, and your years are level with Heaven's; fail to dodge it, and your life ends then and there.

Six words each way. Dodge it and your years are level with Heaven's; miss and you are finished on the spot. 躲得過 and 躲不過 both take as de. (躲不過 takes before the falling tone of .)

zàibǎiniánhòutiānjiànghuǒzāishāozhèhuǒshìtiānhuǒshìfánhuǒhuànzuòyīnhuǒ zàibǎiniánhòutiānjiànghuǒzāishāozhèhuǒshìtiānhuǒshìfánhuǒhuànzuòyīnhuǒ

After another five hundred years, Heaven sends down a fire-calamity to burn you. This fire is no heavenly fire, nor any mortal fire — it is called yin-fire.

The second calamity, and notice how carefully it is not defined. Not heavenly fire, not mortal fire: 陰火, yin-fire — which turns out to be worse than either. (不是 takes , twice.)

běnshēnyǒngquánxuéxiàshāozhítòuyuángōngzàngchénghuīzhījiēxiǔqiānniánxíngwéihuàn běnshēnyǒngquánxuéxiàshāozhítòuyuángōngzàngchénghuīzhījiēxiǔqiānniánxíngwéihuàn

It kindles from below, at the Bubbling-Spring point of your own body, and shoots straight up through the Ní-yuán Palace; the five viscera turn to ash, the four limbs all rot, and a thousand years of austerities are made empty illusion.

Worse, because it starts inside you. 湧泉穴 (yǒng quán xué), the Bubbling Spring point, is KI-1 on the sole of the foot, the lowest acupoint on the body, and the fire runs from there straight up to the crown. The text writes 泥垣宮 (with yuán); the standard inner-alchemy term is 泥丸宮 (ní wán gōng), the upper cinnabar field in the top of the skull. So the path is sole to crown — the exact route the cultivation itself runs along. 苦行 is austerities, and a thousand years of them 俱為虛幻, all of it turned to empty illusion.

zàibǎiniányòujiàngfēngzāichuīzhèfēngshìdōngnán西běifēngshìxūnjīnshuòfēngshìhuāliǔsōngzhúfēnghuànzuòfēng zàibǎiniányòujiàngfēngzāichuīzhèfēngshìdōngnán西běifēngshìxūnjīnshuòfēngshìhuāliǔsōngzhúfēnghuànzuòfēng

After another five hundred years, a wind-calamity is sent down to blow upon you. This wind is no wind of the four quarters, nor the balmy southern or cold northern wind, nor any breeze through flowers, willows, pines, or bamboo — it is called the Bì-wind.

The third, defined by three rounds of what it is not. Not the winds of the four quarters; not 和薰金朔風, the mild balmy south wind ( xūn) or the metallic northern one ( shuò); not the breeze through flowers, willows, pines or bamboo. It is the 贔風 () a rare character, familiar mainly from 贔屭, the tortoise that carries stone steles on its back. (不是 takes , all three times.)

xìnménzhōngchuīliùguòdāntián穿chuānjiǔqiàoròuxiāoshūshēnjiě xìnménzhōngchuīliùguòdāntián穿chuānjiǔqiàoròuxiāoshūshēnjiě

It blows in through the fontanelle into the six bowels, passes the cinnabar field, pierces the nine orifices; bone and flesh dissolve away, and the body comes apart of itself.

And again it comes in through the body's own doors. 顖門 (xìn mén) is the fontanelle, the soft spot at the crown of the skull — is a variant of . From there through the six bowels, the cinnabar field and the nine orifices, until bone and flesh thin away and 其身自解, the body comes apart of its own accord. is jiě, to dissolve, not jiè or xiè.

suǒdōuyàoduǒguò。」 suǒdōuyàoduǒguò。」

And so all of them must be dodged."

is dōu, all. Three of them, and every one has to be dodged.


總評 Commentary

Three years on, the chapter turns from transmission to a darker and stranger doctrine: the 三災, the Three Calamities. The premise is a piece of Daoist eschatology that later immortal-cultivation fiction would make its stock-in-trade, but it is set out here with unusual specificity — the very success of the work provokes Heaven's retribution. Because the adept 奪天地之造化侵日月之玄機, "wrests away the creative power of Heaven and Earth and usurps the hidden workings of sun and moon," his attainment is a transgression the cosmos will not tolerate (鬼神難容); and so at five-hundred-year intervals it sends thunder, then fire, then wind to annihilate him unless he can hide. Immortality here is not a safe harbour. It is a provocation.

What is striking is how thoroughly the calamities are internalised. These are not storms that strike from outside; they run along the body's own inner geography. The 陰火, the yin-fire, kindles at the 湧泉穴, the Bubbling Spring point on the sole of the foot — the lowest acupoint there is — and shoots straight up to the 泥丸宮, the cinnabar palace in the crown of the head (the 世德堂 text writes the name 泥垣宮, recorded here with the standard term noted). The 贔風 enters through the 顖門, the fontanelle, and courses through the six bowels, the cinnabar field and the nine orifices until the body dissolves. The calamity, in other words, is figured as a catastrophic running-backward of the very channels the cultivation laboriously built — a last test of whether the elixir is truly fixed, written out in precise acupuncture and inner-alchemical anatomy.

Wukong's objection is the natural one, and the exchange does real conceptual work. He assumes, reasonably enough, that being "equal to Heaven in years" with "the hundred ailments stilled" simply means being invulnerable — and the master corrects him: this is a 非常之道, an extraordinary Way, and its extraordinariness is precisely what draws the lightning. Even the escape route is framed in Chan terms, 見性明心, "see one's nature and illumine the mind," so that the syncretism of the elixir-formula carries straight through into its perils. And in plot terms this grim catalogue is a setup: the Three Calamities are the problem to which the seventy-two transformations, chosen in the very next passage, will be the answer. Wukong learns to shapeshift not as a party trick but as a way of hiding from the wrath of Heaven.