Canonical Classics ← 第二回
第二回
chèzhēnmiào
duànguīběnyuánshén

Wukong Fully Comprehends the True Mystery of Bodhi · Severing the Demon, Returning to the Root, Uniting the Primal Spirit

金丹口訣
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

金丹口訣 The Golden Elixir Formula

kōngyìngshēngjiàodào:「shīzàiguìhòuduōshí。」shīwénshēngyīnshìkōngpánzuòdào:「zhèsūnzàiqiánbiānshuìquèláizhèhòubiānzuòshèn?」kōngdào:「shīzuótánqiánduìzhòngxiāngyǔnjiàosāngēngshíhòucónghòuménchuándàodǎnjìngbàilǎoxià。」shītīngshuōshífēnhuānànxúndào:「zhèguǒránshìtiānshēngchéngderánjiùpánzhōngzhīàn?」kōngdào:「jiāngèngliùěrzhǐzhǐrénwàngshīshěbēichuánchángshēngzhīdàobayǒngwàngēn。」shīdào:「jīnyǒuyuánshuōshípánzhōngànjìnqiánláitīngzhīdāngchuánchángshēngzhīmiàodào。」kōngkòutóuxièleěryòngxīnguìxiàshīyúnkōngyìngshēngjiàodào:「shīzàiguìhòuduōshí。」shīwénshēngyīnshìkōngpánzuòdào:「zhèsūnzàiqiánbiānshuìquèláizhèhòubiānzuòshèn?」kōngdào:「shīzuótánqiánduìzhòngxiāngyǔnjiàosāngēngshíhòucónghòuménchuándàodǎnjìngbàilǎoxià。」shītīngshuōshífēnhuānànxúndào:「zhèguǒránshìtiānshēngchéngderánjiùpánzhōngzhīàn?」kōngdào:「jiāngèngliùěrzhǐzhǐrénwàngshīshěbēichuánchángshēngzhīdàobayǒngwàngēn。」shīdào:「jīnyǒuyuánshuōshípánzhōngànjìnqiánláitīngzhīdāngchuánchángshēngzhīmiàodào。」kōngkòutóuxièleěryòngxīnguìxiàshīyún

xiǎnyuántōngzhēnmiàojuéxiǎnyuántōngzhēnmiàojué
xiūxìngmìngshuōxiūxìngmìngshuō
dōuláizǒngshìjīngshéndōuláizǒngshìjīngshén
jǐnláocángxiūlòuxièjǐnláocángxiūlòuxiè
xiūlòuxièxiūlòuxiè
zhōngcángzhōngcáng
shòuchuándàochāngshòuchuándàochāng
kǒujuéláiduōyǒukǒujuéláiduōyǒu
bǐngchúxiéqīngliángbǐngchúxiéqīngliáng
qīngliángqīngliáng
guāngjiǎojiéguāngjiǎojié
hǎoxiàngdāntáishǎngmíngyuèhǎoxiàngdāntáishǎngmíngyuè
yuècángcángyuècángcáng
yǒuguīshéxiāngpánjiéyǒuguīshéxiāngpánjié
xiāngpánjiéxiāngpánjié
xìngmìngjiānxìngmìngjiān
quènénghuǒzhòngjīnliánquènénghuǒzhòngjīnlián
cuánxíngdiāndǎoyòngcuánxíngdiāndǎoyòng
gōngwánsuízuòxiāngōngwánsuízuòxiān

逐句解 Line by line

kōngyìngshēngjiàodào:「shīzàiguìhòuduōshí。」 kōngyìngshēngjiàodào:「shīzàiguìhòuduōshí。」

Wukong answered aloud: "Master, your disciple has been kneeling here in waiting a good while."

應聲 is to answer aloud, with as yìng, to respond — not yīng, should, as in 應該 a few lines back. He has been kneeling there the whole time, and he says so.

shīwénshēngyīnshìkōngpánzuòdào:「zhèsūnzàiqiánbiānshuìquèláizhèhòubiānzuòshèn?」 shīwénshēngyīnshìkōngpánzuòdào:「zhèsūnzàiqiánbiānshuìquèláizhèhòubiānzuòshèn?」

Recognizing Wukong's voice, the Patriarch rose, threw on his robe, sat up cross-legged, and barked: "You wretched ape! Why aren't you off sleeping in the front, instead of coming round here to the back to me — what for?"

He throws on a robe (披衣), sits up cross-legged (盤坐) and barks — and the bark is theatre. is , to shout, not , to drink. The master is pretending not to know why a disciple might be at his back door in the middle of the night. 聞得 takes as the toneless de that shows the action succeeded. (不在 takes before the falling tone of .)

kōngdào:「shīzuótánqiánduìzhòngxiāngyǔnjiàosāngēngshíhòucónghòuménchuándàodǎnjìngbàilǎoxià。」 kōngdào:「shīzuótánqiánduìzhòngxiāngyǔnjiàosāngēngshíhòucónghòuménchuándàodǎnjìngbàilǎoxià。」

Wukong said: "Yesterday at the dais, before the whole company, the master gave his word — bidding your disciple come at the third watch and pass the teaching to me by the back door; and so I made bold to come straight and bow beneath your honor's couch."

And the monkey calls the bluff, very politely. He treats the coded blows as a public promise — 對眾相允, given before the whole assembly — which is a quiet joke, since nobody else in that assembly understood a syllable of it. 相允 is to give one's word, with as xiāng, toward one, not xiàng. is jiào, the causative "bidding me." 徑拜 is to go straight and bow ( jìng, directly); 老爺 is "your honour"; is gēng.

shītīngshuōshífēnhuānànxúndào:「zhèguǒránshìtiānshēngchéngderánjiùpánzhōngzhīàn?」 shītīngshuōshífēnhuānànxúndào:「zhèguǒránshìtiānshēngchéngderánjiùpánzhōngzhīàn?」

Hearing this, the Patriarch was greatly pleased, and thought to himself: "This creature really is a thing born of Heaven and Earth — else how could he have cracked the hidden riddle of my platter?"

The test is over and he is delighted. 這廝 (zhè sī) is rough and familiar — "this creature." 天地生成的, a thing formed by Heaven and Earth, is the same verdict he reached at the end of the last chapter on hearing the monkey was born out of a stone; now he has evidence for it. 尋思 takes in full tone , to think, not the neutral si of 意思. (不然 keeps .)

kōngdào:「jiāngèngliùěrzhǐzhǐrénwàngshīshěbēichuánchángshēngzhīdàobayǒngwàngēn。」 kōngdào:「jiāngèngliùěrzhǐzhǐrénwàngshīshěbēichuánchángshēngzhīdàobayǒngwàngēn。」

Wukong said: "Here there are no 'six ears' — only your disciple alone. I beg the master to bestow great mercy and pass me the way of long life; I will never forget the kindness."

六耳, "six ears," is a lovely idiom for an eavesdropper: two people make four ears, so a third pair means somebody is listening who should not be. 更無六耳 is therefore "we're alone." here is gèng, moreover, in fourth tone — not the gēng, night-watch, of 三更 two lines earlier. 大捨 is to give generously ( shě), and is ba, a softening syllable at the end. (一人 is yì rén; 不忘 takes before the falling tone of .)

shīdào:「jīnyǒuyuánshuōshípánzhōngànjìnqiánláitīngzhīdāngchuánchángshēngzhīmiàodào。」 shīdào:「jīnyǒuyuánshuōshípánzhōngànjìnqiánláitīngzhīdāngchuánchángshēngzhīmiàodào。」

The Patriarch said: "You have an affinity today, and I am glad to speak. Since you have read the hidden riddle of the platter, come close and listen carefully — I shall pass you the marvelous way of long life."

有緣 is to have the karmic affinity — the right connection at the right moment, which in this book is never quite an accident. 識得 takes as de; is dāng, shall.

kōngkòutóuxièleěryòngxīnguìxiàshīyún kōngkòutóuxièleěryòngxīnguìxiàshīyún

Wukong kowtowed his thanks, washed out his ears and fixed his mind, and knelt beneath the couch. The Patriarch intoned:

洗耳用心 — wash out the ears and apply the mind, that is, listen with everything you have. It is the same gesture as the everyday 洗耳恭聽, and tradition traces that phrase back to the recluse Xu You (許由), who rinsed his ears in a stream after somebody offered him the empire. There he was washing something out; here Wukong is cleaning his ears to let something in.

xiǎnyuántōngzhēnmiàojué xiǎnyuántōngzhēnmiàojué

The true and marvelous formula, manifest-and-secret, perfectly penetrating —

顯密圓通 (xiǎn mì yuán tōng) is Buddhist vocabulary through and through: and are the exoteric and esoteric teachings, and 圓通 is complete interpenetration. Note that the supreme Daoist secret is being announced in Buddhist terms. Nobody in the room finds this odd.

xiūxìngmìngshuō xiūxìngmìngshuō

to cherish and cultivate nature-and-life, there is nothing else to tell.

性命 (xìng mìng) is "nature and life-destiny," the paired objects of inner alchemy — the spirit or mind, the vital force. Cultivating the two together, 性命雙修, is the programme the whole poem lays out. Miss the pairing and you have missed the system.

dōuláizǒngshìjīngshén dōuláizǒngshìjīngshén

All of it comes down to essence, breath, and spirit;

精氣神 (jīng qì shén) — essence, breath and spirit — are the 三寶, the Three Treasures, the raw materials the work is done on. 都來 is "all in all," with as dōu, all, not , a capital city.

jǐnláocángxiūlòuxiè jǐnláocángxiūlòuxiè

guard them close and store them firm, and let nothing leak away.

And the first rule of the work: 休漏泄, do not let them leak away. Conservation comes before transformation. is cáng, to store, not zàng.

xiūlòuxiè xiūlòuxiè

Let nothing leak away,

The line repeats to carry the thought over into a new stanza — a standard hinge in form, where the closing words of one stanza open the next.

zhōngcáng zhōngcáng

but store it within the body;

體中藏, store it inside the body. is cáng again.

shòuchuándàochāng shòuchuándàochāng

receive my transmission, and the Way will of itself thrive.

and are archaic "you" and "I" — the register lifts for the transmission itself. 自昌 is "will flourish of itself."

kǒujuéláiduōyǒu kǒujuéláiduōyǒu

Hold the oral formula in memory, and the benefit is great;

口訣 (kǒu jué) is the oral formula, passed mouth to ear and never committed to paper. Which is a nice irony to meet in a printed novel.

bǐngchúxiéqīngliáng bǐngchúxiéqīngliáng

dispel deviant desires, and you attain the clear and cool.

屏除 is to get rid of, with as bǐng, not píng, a screen. 得清涼, attaining "the clear and cool," names a state of purity, and here is full-tone , to attain.

qīngliáng qīngliáng

Attain the clear and cool,

The phrase carried over to open the next stanza, as before.

guāngjiǎojié guāngjiǎojié

the light pure and bright;

皎潔 (jiǎo jié), luminous and pure-bright — the word normally used of moonlight, which the next line duly picks up.

hǎoxiàngdāntáishǎngmíngyuè hǎoxiàngdāntáishǎngmíngyuè

good then to turn to the elixir-terrace and savor the bright moon.

丹臺 (dān tái), the elixir terrace, is the inner site where the elixir is refined and contemplated. And the bright moon to be enjoyed there is not the one in the sky. is hǎo, good, not hào, to like.

yuècángcáng yuècángcáng

The moon hides the jade hare, the sun hides the crow;

A couplet of alchemical code. 玉兔, the jade hare, is the moon's emblem, and , the crow — properly the three-legged sun-crow — is the sun's. So the line means the lunar yin essence and the solar yang essence, both gathered inward ( cáng). In this system, sun and moon are also organs.

yǒuguīshéxiāngpánjié yǒuguīshéxiāngpánjié

of themselves the tortoise and the snake will coil and entwine.

龜蛇, tortoise and snake, is the emblem of 玄武, the Dark Warrior of the north and of water — the same god Wukong will go to for help some sixty chapters later. Their coiling together (相盤結) figures the union of the opposed forces inside the body.

xiāngpánjié xiāngpánjié

Coil and entwine,

Carried over once more to open the stanza: the coiling union of the inner forces.

xìngmìngjiān xìngmìngjiān

and nature-and-life grow firm;

性命堅, nature-and-life grown firm — the union made stable, which is the whole object of the exercise.

quènénghuǒzhòngjīnlián quènénghuǒzhòngjīnlián

then within the fire you can plant the golden lotus.

火裡種金蓮, planting a golden lotus in the middle of a fire, is the tradition's favourite paradox for the birth of the immortal embryo in the refining heat. A lotus grows in water and burns in fire; raising one inside a furnace is exactly the point. is the verb zhòng, to plant, not zhǒng, a seed.

cuánxíngdiāndǎoyòng cuánxíngdiāndǎoyòng

Cluster the Five Phases and turn them upside-down to use;

攢簇五行 is to cluster the Five Phases together ( cuán, to gather, not zǎn, to hoard; xíng), and 顛倒用 is to run them backwards. This is the great "reversal" of inner alchemy: ordinary life flows down and outward through the Five Phases in their generative order, and the adept turns the whole sequence round and drives it back toward the source. is dǎo, to invert, in third tone — distinct from the dào, backward, of 倒背著手 two passages ago.

gōngwánsuízuòxiān gōngwánsuízuòxiān

the work complete, you become at will a Buddha or an immortal.

And the closing line does in seven characters what the novel takes a hundred chapters to do: the work complete, you become at will 佛和仙 — a Buddha and an immortal. That little conjunction is carrying a great deal of weight.


總評 Commentary

This is the secret transmission itself, the still point the whole chapter has been moving toward. The conditions are carefully drawn — the dead of night, the back room, the explicit check that there are no 六耳, no third party listening in — because what passes here is 口訣, an oral formula handed mouth to ear, the most closely guarded form of teaching in both the Chan and the Daoist alchemical lineages. The master's despair a few lines earlier, that without a worthy recipient a teacher only talks himself hoarse, is answered on the spot: Wukong has proved himself the 至人 by reading the riddle, and the long life he demanded through every one of the four refused gateways is about to be given him.

The poem the Patriarch intones is a genuine and quite technical piece of internal-alchemy (內丹) verse, and it repays being read as one. Its raw materials are the 精氣神 — essence, breath and spirit, the Three Treasures — which must be conserved and never allowed to leak; its programme is 性命雙修, the joint cultivation of , mind-nature, and , vital force. What follows is the standard cryptography of the tradition. The 玉兔 and the , hare and crow, are the lunar and solar essences drawn inward; the 龜蛇, tortoise and snake of the northern 玄武, coil into the union of opposites; 火裡種金蓮, planting a golden lotus in the midst of fire, is the paradoxical birth of the immortal embryo; and 攢簇五行顛倒用, clustering the Five Phases and running them in reverse, names the great reversal that turns the ordinary downward flow of life back toward its source. Much of this diction comes down from the Quanzhen tradition and classics such as Zhang Boduan's Wuzhen pian, and it is passages exactly like this one that led generations of readers to treat the novel as a coded 丹經, an alchemical scripture in disguise.

What makes the formula unmistakably this novel's, though, is how seamlessly it mixes traditions. The supreme secret is announced in Buddhist terms — 顯密圓通, the exoteric and esoteric perfectly interfused — yet its content is the Daoist 金丹, the golden elixir; and the promised end, in the poem's last line, is to become at will a Buddha and an immortal, 佛和仙 in one breath. The claim made abstractly in the lecture-verse, that the Three Teachings are "fundamentally so," is no longer a claim about doctrine here. It is the actual substance of the highest instruction. And in plot terms this is the hinge of Wukong's whole career: the cultivation passed on in these few whispered lines is the root of his deathlessness and his powers — the thing that will let a stone monkey shake Heaven itself a few chapters from now.