Canonical Classics ← 第二回
第二回
悟wù徹chè菩pú提tí真zhēn妙miào理lǐ
斷duàn魔mó歸guī本běn合hé元yuán神shén

Wukong Fully Comprehends the True Mystery of Bodhi · Severing the Demon, Returning to the Root, Uniting the Primal Spirit

七十二變
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

七十二變 The Seventy-Two Transformations

悟wù空kōng聞wén說shuō,毛máo骨gǔ悚sǒng然rán,叩kòu頭tóu禮lǐ拜bài道dào:「萬wàn望wàng老lǎo爺yé垂chuí憫mǐn,傳chuán與yǔ躲duǒ避bì三sān災zāi之zhī法fǎ,到dào底dǐ不bù敢gǎn忘wàng恩ēn。」祖zǔ師shī道dào:「此cǐ亦yì無wú難nán,只zhǐ是shì你nǐ比bǐ他tā人rén不bù同tóng,故gù傳chuán不bù得de。」悟wù空kōng道dào:「我wǒ也yě頭tóu圓yuán頂dǐng天tiān,足zú方fāng履lǚ地dì,一yì般bān有yǒu九jiǔ竅qiào四sì肢zhī,五wǔ臟zàng六liù腑fǔ,何hé以yǐ比bǐ人rén不bù同tóng?」祖zǔ師shī道dào:「你nǐ雖suī然rán像xiàng人rén,卻què比bǐ人rén少shǎo腮sāi。」原yuán來lái那nà猴hóu子zi孤gū拐guǎi面miàn,凹āo臉liǎn尖jiān嘴zuǐ。悟wù空kōng伸shēn手shǒu一yì摸mō,笑xiào道dào:「師shī父fù沒méi成chéng算suàn。我wǒ雖suī少shǎo腮sāi,卻què比bǐ人rén多duō這zhè個gè素sù袋dài,亦yì可kě準zhǔn折zhé過guò也yě。」祖zǔ師shī說shuō:「也yě罷ba,你nǐ要yào學xué那nǎ一yì般bān?有yǒu一yì般bān天tiān罡gāng數shù,該gāi三sān十shí六liù般bān變biàn化huà;有yǒu一yì般bān地dì煞shà數shù,該gāi七qī十shí二èr般bān變biàn化huà。」悟wù空kōng道dào:「弟dì子zǐ願yuàn多duō裡lǐ撈lāo摸mō,學xué一yí個gè地dì煞shà變biàn化huà罷ba。」祖zǔ師shī道dào:「既jì如rú此cǐ,上shàng前qián來lái,傳chuán與yǔ你nǐ口kǒu訣jué。」遂suì附fù耳ěr低dī言yán,不bù知zhī說shuō了le些xiē甚shèn麼me妙miào法fǎ。這zhè猴hóu王wáng也yě是shì他tā一yí竅qiào通tōng時shí百bǎi竅qiào通tōng,當dāng時shí習xí了le口kǒu訣jué,自zì修xiū自zì煉liàn,將jiāng七qī十shí二èr般bān變biàn化huà都dōu學xué成chéng了le。悟wù空kōng闻wén说shuō,毛máo骨gǔ悚sǒng然rán,叩kòu头tóu礼lǐ拜bài道dào:「万wàn望wàng老lǎo爷yé垂chuí悯mǐn,传chuán与yǔ躲duǒ避bì三sān灾zāi之zhī法fǎ,到dào底dǐ不bù敢gǎn忘wàng恩ēn。」祖zǔ师shī道dào:「此cǐ亦yì无wú难nán,只zhǐ是shì你nǐ比bǐ他tā人rén不bù同tóng,故gù传chuán不bù得de。」悟wù空kōng道dào:「我wǒ也yě头tóu圆yuán顶dǐng天tiān,足zú方fāng履lǚ地dì,一yì般bān有yǒu九jiǔ窍qiào四sì肢zhī,五wǔ脏zàng六liù腑fǔ,何hé以yǐ比bǐ人rén不bù同tóng?」祖zǔ师shī道dào:「你nǐ虽suī然rán像xiàng人rén,却què比bǐ人rén少shǎo腮sāi。」原yuán来lái那nà猴hóu子zi孤gū拐guǎi面miàn,凹āo脸liǎn尖jiān嘴zuǐ。悟wù空kōng伸shēn手shǒu一yì摸mō,笑xiào道dào:「师shī父fù没méi成chéng算suàn。我wǒ虽suī少shǎo腮sāi,却què比bǐ人rén多duō这zhè个gè素sù袋dài,亦yì可kě准zhǔn折zhé过guò也yě。」祖zǔ师shī说shuō:「也yě罢ba,你nǐ要yào学xué那nǎ一yì般bān?有yǒu一yì般bān天tiān罡gāng数shù,该gāi三sān十shí六liù般bān变biàn化huà;有yǒu一yì般bān地dì煞shà数shù,该gāi七qī十shí二èr般bān变biàn化huà。」悟wù空kōng道dào:「弟dì子zǐ愿yuàn多duō里lǐ捞lāo摸mō,学xué一yí个gè地dì煞shà变biàn化huà罢ba。」祖zǔ师shī道dào:「既jì如rú此cǐ,上shàng前qián来lái,传chuán与yǔ你nǐ口kǒu诀jué。」遂suì附fù耳ěr低dī言yán,不bù知zhī说shuō了le些xiē甚shèn么me妙miào法fǎ。这zhè猴hóu王wáng也yě是shì他tā一yí窍qiào通tōng时shí百bǎi窍qiào通tōng,当dāng时shí习xí了le口kǒu诀jué,自zì修xiū自zì炼liàn,将jiāng七qī十shí二èr般bān变biàn化huà都dōu学xué成chéng了le。


逐句解 Line by line

悟wù空kōng聞wén說shuō,毛máo骨gǔ悚sǒng然rán,叩kòu頭tóu禮lǐ拜bài道dào:「萬wàn望wàng老lǎo爺yé垂chuí憫mǐn,傳chuán與yǔ躲duǒ避bì三sān災zāi之zhī法fǎ,到dào底dǐ不bù敢gǎn忘wàng恩ēn。」 悟wù空kōng闻wén说shuō,毛máo骨gǔ悚sǒng然rán,叩kòu头tóu礼lǐ拜bài道dào:「万wàn望wàng老lǎo爷yé垂chuí悯mǐn,传chuán与yǔ躲duǒ避bì三sān灾zāi之zhī法fǎ,到dào底dǐ不bù敢gǎn忘wàng恩ēn。」

Hearing this, Wukong felt his hair and bones bristle with dread, and bowing his head in worship he said: "I earnestly beg your honor to take pity and pass me the method for evading the Three Calamities; to the end I shall never forget the kindness."

毛骨悚然 — hair and bones bristling with dread — is a live idiom, still the phrase for a chill down the spine, and for once the monkey has earned it honestly. He has just learned that his prize comes with an execution schedule. 萬望 is to entreat earnestly, and 垂憫 is to bestow pity from above (憫 mǐn). (不敢 keeps bù.)

祖zǔ師shī道dào:「此cǐ亦yì無wú難nán,只zhǐ是shì你nǐ比bǐ他tā人rén不bù同tóng,故gù傳chuán不bù得de。」 祖zǔ师shī道dào:「此cǐ亦yì无wú难nán,只zhǐ是shì你nǐ比bǐ他tā人rén不bù同tóng,故gù传chuán不bù得de。」

The Patriarch said: "This is no hard matter either — only that you are unlike other men, and so it cannot be passed to you."

傳不得 is a potential complement — cannot be transmitted — with 得 as de. The master has an objection, and it is not the one anyone would guess. (不同 and 不得 both keep bù.)

悟wù空kōng道dào:「我wǒ也yě頭tóu圓yuán頂dǐng天tiān,足zú方fāng履lǚ地dì,一yì般bān有yǒu九jiǔ竅qiào四sì肢zhī,五wǔ臟zàng六liù腑fǔ,何hé以yǐ比bǐ人rén不bù同tóng?」 悟wù空kōng道dào:「我wǒ也yě头tóu圆yuán顶dǐng天tiān,足zú方fāng履lǚ地dì,一yì般bān有yǒu九jiǔ窍qiào四sì肢zhī,五wǔ脏zàng六liù腑fǔ,何hé以yǐ比bǐ人rén不bù同tóng?」

Wukong said: "But I too have a round head topping heaven and square feet treading earth; I have the nine orifices and four limbs, the five viscera and six bowels, just as others do. How am I unlike a man?"

His defence is a piece of classical anthropology. 頭圓頂天,足方履地, a round head topping heaven and square feet treading earth, is the standard figure of the human body as a small copy of the cosmos — round sky above, square earth below. He then runs through the standard inventory: nine orifices, four limbs, five viscera, six bowels. He is arguing, in effect, that he qualifies as a person. (一般 is yì bān; 不同 keeps bù.)

祖zǔ師shī道dào:「你nǐ雖suī然rán像xiàng人rén,卻què比bǐ人rén少shǎo腮sāi。」 祖zǔ师shī道dào:「你nǐ虽suī然rán像xiàng人rén,却què比bǐ人rén少shǎo腮sāi。」

The Patriarch said: "You may resemble a man, yet you lack the cheeks a man has."

And the objection, when it comes, is gloriously small: you have no cheeks. 少 here is shǎo, to lack, not shào, young; 腮 is sāi, the cheek.

原yuán來lái那nà猴hóu子zi孤gū拐guǎi面miàn,凹āo臉liǎn尖jiān嘴zuǐ。 原yuán来lái那nà猴hóu子zi孤gū拐guǎi面miàn,凹āo脸liǎn尖jiān嘴zuǐ。

For that monkey had a face with jutting cheekbones, sunken cheeks and a pointed snout.

The narrator steps in to confirm it, and the description is good zoology. 孤拐面 (gū guǎi miàn) is a face with jutting cheekbones, 凹臉 (āo liǎn) is sunken and concave, 尖嘴 is a pointed snout. That is a macaque, drawn from life. Note that 那猴子 takes 子 as the neutral suffix zi, against the full-tone zǐ of 弟子.

悟wù空kōng伸shēn手shǒu一yì摸mō,笑xiào道dào:「師shī父fù沒méi成chéng算suàn。我wǒ雖suī少shǎo腮sāi,卻què比bǐ人rén多duō這zhè個gè素sù袋dài,亦yì可kě準zhǔn折zhé過guò也yě。」 悟wù空kōng伸shēn手shǒu一yì摸mō,笑xiào道dào:「师shī父fù没méi成chéng算suàn。我wǒ虽suī少shǎo腮sāi,却què比bǐ人rén多duō这zhè个gè素sù袋dài,亦yì可kě准zhǔn折zhé过guò也yě。」

Wukong reached up a hand and felt them, then laughed: "The master has reckoned wrong! I may lack the cheeks, but I have, more than a man, this throat-pouch here — surely that can make up the difference."

He reaches up and feels his own face, which is marvellous staging, and then he negotiates. 沒成算 is "you've reckoned it wrong." 素袋, the "plain pouch," is his cheek pouch, offered as a credit against the missing cheeks: 準折 (zhǔn zhé) is to offset, to count in compensation — a bookkeeper's word. 折 is zhé, to discount, not zhē or shé. (一摸 is yì mō.)

祖zǔ師shī說shuō:「也yě罷ba,你nǐ要yào學xué那nǎ一yì般bān?有yǒu一yì般bān天tiān罡gāng數shù,該gāi三sān十shí六liù般bān變biàn化huà;有yǒu一yì般bān地dì煞shà數shù,該gāi七qī十shí二èr般bān變biàn化huà。」 祖zǔ师shī说shuō:「也yě罢ba,你nǐ要yào学xué那nǎ一yì般bān?有yǒu一yì般bān天tiān罡gāng数shù,该gāi三sān十shí六liù般bān变biàn化huà;有yǒu一yì般bān地dì煞shà数shù,该gāi七qī十shí二èr般bān变biàn化huà。」

The Patriarch said: "Very well then — which sort will you learn? There is one sort, the tally of the Heavenly Gang, which comes to thirty-six transformations; and one sort, the tally of the Earthly Sha, which comes to seventy-two transformations."

天罡 (tiān gāng) are the thirty-six martial "Heavenly Gang" stars and 地煞 (dì shà) the seventy-two baleful "Earthly Sha" — together the canonical one hundred and eight, the same tally that supplies the roster of heroes in 《水滸傳》. 那一般 takes 那 as nǎ, which; 煞 is shà, not shā; 該 is gāi, amounts to. (一般 is yì bān throughout.)

悟wù空kōng道dào:「弟dì子zǐ願yuàn多duō裡lǐ撈lāo摸mō,學xué一yí個gè地dì煞shà變biàn化huà罷ba。」 悟wù空kōng道dào:「弟dì子zǐ愿yuàn多duō里lǐ捞lāo摸mō,学xué一yí个gè地dì煞shà变biàn化huà罢ba。」

Wukong said: "Your disciple would rather fish from the larger pile — let me learn one of the Earthly-Sha transformations."

多裡撈摸 (duō lǐ lāo mō) is colloquial and entirely characteristic — to fish about in the bigger heap. Offered thirty-six or seventy-two, he takes the larger number without a second's thought about what is actually in it. There is a quiet aptness in his choosing the earthly and baleful tally over the heavenly one, given what he is going to do to Heaven. (一個 is yí gè.)

祖zǔ師shī道dào:「既jì如rú此cǐ,上shàng前qián來lái,傳chuán與yǔ你nǐ口kǒu訣jué。」 祖zǔ师shī道dào:「既jì如rú此cǐ,上shàng前qián来lái,传chuán与yǔ你nǐ口kǒu诀jué。」

The Patriarch said: "In that case, come forward, and I will pass you the oral formula."

既如此, since that is how it is. 上前, come forward.

遂suì附fù耳ěr低dī言yán,不bù知zhī說shuō了le些xiē甚shèn麼me妙miào法fǎ。 遂suì附fù耳ěr低dī言yán,不bù知zhī说shuō了le些xiē甚shèn么me妙miào法fǎ。

Thereupon he put his mouth to Wukong's ear and spoke low — and what wondrous method he imparted, none can say.

附耳低言 is to put your mouth to somebody's ear and speak low. And then the narrator declines to tell us: 不知說了些甚麼妙法, what wondrous method he imparted, there is no knowing. The most famous power in Chinese fiction is handed over off-page. (不知 keeps bù.)

這zhè猴hóu王wáng也yě是shì他tā一yí竅qiào通tōng時shí百bǎi竅qiào通tōng,當dāng時shí習xí了le口kǒu訣jué,自zì修xiū自zì煉liàn,將jiāng七qī十shí二èr般bān變biàn化huà都dōu學xué成chéng了le。 这zhè猴hóu王wáng也yě是shì他tā一yí窍qiào通tōng时shí百bǎi窍qiào通tōng,当dāng时shí习xí了le口kǒu诀jué,自zì修xiū自zì炼liàn,将jiāng七qī十shí二èr般bān变biàn化huà都dōu学xué成chéng了le。

And this Monkey King was one for whom, the moment a single aperture opened, a hundred apertures opened: there and then he practiced the formula, cultivating and refining on his own, and learned every one of the seventy-two transformations.

一竅通時百竅通 — when one aperture opens, a hundred open — is a proverb for the kind of person who gets a thing the instant he gets it (竅 qiào, an aperture). The same word does duty for the body's openings and for the mind's, which is the joke. 自修自煉 is to cultivate and refine on one's own. (一竅 is yí qiào.)


總評 Commentary

After the grim catalogue of calamities the chapter snaps back to comedy, and the join is pure Journey to the West: the sublime and the slapstick share a single breath. The master's grave reason that the method "cannot be passed" turns out to hinge on the fact that Wukong, being a monkey, 少腮 — lacks cheeks — a detail at once naturalistic (the jutting cheekbones, sunken face and pointed snout of a real macaque) and absurd. And the response is perfectly in character: he feels his own face, announces that the master has reckoned wrong, and offers his 素袋, his throat-pouch, as more than adequate compensation. The cosmic stakes of a moment earlier are punctured by monkey cheek, and the teaching goes ahead anyway.

The two options come straight out of astral lore. The 天罡, the thirty-six "Heavenly Gang" stars, and the 地煞, the seventy-two "Earthly Sha," together make the canonical one hundred and eight — the same set that supplies the roster of heroes in 《水滸傳》. Wukong's choice is again pure character. He wants the bigger number, and reaches for it with the wonderfully colloquial 多裡撈摸, "fishing from the larger pile"; what he thereby acquires, the 七十二變, is perhaps the single most famous ability in all of Chinese fiction. There is a quiet aptness, too, in his taking the earthly and baleful tally rather than the heavenly one. The gift suits a creature who will shortly set himself against Heaven.

The passage closes on the speed of his mastery. The Patriarch whispers the formula 附耳低言, mouth to ear — and the narrator coyly refuses to repeat it (不知說了些甚麼妙法), keeping the real secret, as ever, just out of the reader's reach. It hardly slows Wukong down, since he is 一竅通時百竅通, one of those for whom the opening of a single aperture opens a hundred; he practises alone and masters all seventy-two at a stroke. With that his apprenticeship is nearly finished — nature and life cultivated, the elixir formula received, the calamities understood, the transformations learned. One thing remains, and the next passage supplies it: a way to travel as fast as his new powers deserve.