Canonical Classics ← 第九十一回
第九十一回
金jīn平píng府fǔ元yuán夜yè觀guān燈dēng
玄xuán英yīng洞dòng唐táng僧sēng供gòng狀zhuàng

Lantern-Viewing on the Fifteenth Night at Jinping Prefecture · The Tang Monk's Deposition in the Dark-Blossom Cave

停留長智
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

停留長智 Delay Breeds Second Thoughts

沙shā僧sēng在zài傍páng道dào:「哥gē哥ge說shuō那nǎ裡lǐ話huà!常cháng言yán道dào:『停tíng留liú長zhǎng智zhì。』那nà妖yāo精jīng倘tǎng或huò今jīn晚wǎn不bú睡shuì,把bǎ師shī父fù害hài了le,卻què如rú之zhī何hé?不bú若ruò如rú今jīn就jiù去qù,嚷rǎng得de他tā措cuò手shǒu不bù及jí,方fāng才cái好hǎo救jiù師shī父fù。少shǎo遲chí,恐kǒng有yǒu失shī也yě。」八bā戒jiè聞wén言yán,抖dǒu擻sǒu神shén威wēi道dào:「沙shā兄xiōng弟dì說shuō得de是shì,我wǒ們men都dōu趁chèn此cǐ月yuè光guāng去qù降xiáng魔mó耶yé。」行xíng者zhě依yī言yán,即jí吩fēn咐fu寺sì僧sēng:「看kān守shǒu行xíng李lǐ、馬mǎ匹pǐ,待dài我wǒ等děng把bǎ妖yāo精jīng捉zhuō來lái,對duì本běn府fǔ刺cì史shǐ證zhèng其qí假jiǎ佛fó,免miǎn卻què燈dēng油yóu,以yǐ蘇sū概gài縣xiàn小xiǎo民mín之zhī困kùn,卻què不bú是shì好hǎo?」眾zhòng僧sēng遵zūn命mìng。他tā三sān個gè遂suì縱zòng起qǐ祥xiáng雲yún,出chū城chéng而ér去qù。沙shā僧sēng在zài傍páng道dào:「哥gē哥ge说shuō那nǎ里lǐ话huà!常cháng言yán道dào:『停tíng留liú长zhǎng智zhì。』那nà妖yāo精jīng倘tǎng或huò今jīn晚wǎn不bú睡shuì,把bǎ师shī父fù害hài了le,却què如rú之zhī何hé?不bú若ruò如rú今jīn就jiù去qù,嚷rǎng得de他tā措cuò手shǒu不bù及jí,方fāng才cái好hǎo救jiù师shī父fù。少shǎo迟chí,恐kǒng有yǒu失shī也yě。」八bā戒jiè闻wén言yán,抖dǒu擞sǒu神shén威wēi道dào:「沙shā兄xiōng弟dì说shuō得de是shì,我wǒ们men都dōu趁chèn此cǐ月yuè光guāng去qù降xiáng魔mó耶yé。」行xíng者zhě依yī言yán,即jí吩fēn咐fu寺sì僧sēng:「看kān守shǒu行xíng李lǐ、马mǎ匹pǐ,待dài我wǒ等děng把bǎ妖yāo精jīng捉zhuō来lái,对duì本běn府fǔ刺cì史shǐ证zhèng其qí假jiǎ佛fó,免miǎn却què灯dēng油yóu,以yǐ苏sū概gài县xiàn小xiǎo民mín之zhī困kùn,却què不bú是shì好hǎo?」众zhòng僧sēng遵zūn命mìng。他tā三sān个gè遂suì纵zòng起qǐ祥xiáng云yún,出chū城chéng而ér去qù。


逐句解 Line by line

沙shā僧sēng在zài傍páng道dào:「哥gē哥ge說shuō那nǎ裡lǐ話huà! 沙shā僧sēng在zài傍páng道dào:「哥gē哥ge说shuō那nǎ里lǐ话huà!

Sha the Monk said from beside him, "What a thing for elder brother to say!

說那裡話 is a set exclamation — literally "where does that talk come from" — used to reject something out of hand, and 那 in it is nǎ, the rhetorical "where." A reading: 傍 is páng, beside. It is Sha Monk, the most deferential of the three, who contradicts Pilgrim, and that is why it carries.

常cháng言yán道dào:『停tíng留liú長zhǎng智zhì。』 常cháng言yán道dào:『停tíng留liú长zhǎng智zhì。』

"As the common saying goes, 'Delay breeds second thoughts.'

The chapter's second and last inner quotation, and like the first it is a citation rather than verse — matter the edition encloses in the inner brackets takes no verse flag whatever its shape. 停留長智 means that waiting gives the other side time to think, and to think is to think of something. A reading: 長 here is zhǎng, to grow or increase — wits growing — and it is the one site in this whole chapter where the automatic reading of that character happens to be right.

那nà妖yāo精jīng倘tǎng或huò今jīn晚wǎn不bú睡shuì,把bǎ師shī父fù害hài了le,卻què如rú之zhī何hé? 那nà妖yāo精jīng倘tǎng或huò今jīn晚wǎn不bú睡shuì,把bǎ师shī父fù害hài了le,却què如rú之zhī何hé?

"If those demons should not sleep tonight, and do our master harm — what then?

如之何 — what is to be done — is Sha Monk's characteristic register, slightly formal even in an argument. The fear is exact: the demons are saving Tripitaka to eat with the others, and any change of plan kills him.

不bú若ruò如rú今jīn就jiù去qù,嚷rǎng得de他tā措cuò手shǒu不bù及jí,方fāng才cái好hǎo救jiù師shī父fù。 不bú若ruò如rú今jīn就jiù去qù,嚷rǎng得de他tā措cuò手shǒu不bù及jí,方fāng才cái好hǎo救jiù师shī父fù。

"Better to go now, and make such an uproar that they are caught unprepared — that is the way to rescue our master.

措手不及 — no time to get a hand to it — is still current Chinese for being caught on the wrong foot. A reading: 得 in 嚷得他措手不及 is the neutral joint hanging the result on the verb.

少shǎo遲chí,恐kǒng有yǒu失shī也yě。」 少shǎo迟chí,恐kǒng有yǒu失shī也yě。」

"Delay a little, and I fear there may be a loss."

Nine characters, and they are the chapter's own argument turned around at last. Everything that has gone wrong in this chapter came from a pause. Sha Monk is the first character to say so, and he says it about tonight.

八bā戒jiè聞wén言yán,抖dǒu擻sǒu神shén威wēi道dào:「沙shā兄xiōng弟dì說shuō得de是shì,我wǒ們men都dōu趁chèn此cǐ月yuè光guāng去qù降xiáng魔mó耶yé。」 八bā戒jiè闻wén言yán,抖dǒu擞sǒu神shén威wēi道dào:「沙shā兄xiōng弟dì说shuō得de是shì,我wǒ们men都dōu趁chèn此cǐ月yuè光guāng去qù降xiáng魔mó耶yé。」

Hearing this, Eight Rules roused his divine might and said, "Brother Sha speaks rightly. Let us all take this moonlight and go and subdue the fiends."

Pig, of all people, voting to skip a night's sleep. A reading: 降 in 降魔 is xiáng, to subdue — the reading chapter 4 seals at 降魔大元帥 — and not the jiàng of descending, which is the same character and its reading at 降祥 earlier in this chapter.

行xíng者zhě依yī言yán,即jí吩fēn咐fu寺sì僧sēng:「看kān守shǒu行xíng李lǐ、馬mǎ匹pǐ,待dài我wǒ等děng把bǎ妖yāo精jīng捉zhuō來lái,對duì本běn府fǔ刺cì史shǐ證zhèng其qí假jiǎ佛fó,免miǎn卻què燈dēng油yóu,以yǐ蘇sū概gài縣xiàn小xiǎo民mín之zhī困kùn,卻què不bú是shì好hǎo?」 行xíng者zhě依yī言yán,即jí吩fēn咐fu寺sì僧sēng:「看kān守shǒu行xíng李lǐ、马mǎ匹pǐ,待dài我wǒ等děng把bǎ妖yāo精jīng捉zhuō来lái,对duì本běn府fǔ刺cì史shǐ证zhèng其qí假jiǎ佛fó,免miǎn却què灯dēng油yóu,以yǐ苏sū概gài县xiàn小xiǎo民mín之zhī困kùn,却què不bú是shì好hǎo?」

Pilgrim agreed, and at once instructed the monks of the monastery: "Mind the baggage and the horse, and wait till we have caught the demons and can prove to the prefect of this place that they are counterfeit buddhas — so as to do away with the lamp-oil and relieve the hardship of the small folk of the whole county. Would that not be well?"

The chapter's moral accounting, and it is Pilgrim who does it. He is not going back for revenge or even, in this sentence, for his master. He is going to produce evidence — 證其假佛, prove them counterfeit buddhas — so that the levy can be cancelled and 概縣小民, the small folk of the whole county, are relieved. Those are the two hundred and forty households, and this is the only line in the chapter that remembers them.

眾zhòng僧sēng遵zūn命mìng。 众zhòng僧sēng遵zūn命mìng。

The monks obeyed.

Four characters. They have done nothing else all chapter.

他tā三sān個gè遂suì縱zòng起qǐ祥xiáng雲yún,出chū城chéng而ér去qù。 他tā三sān个gè遂suì纵zòng起qǐ祥xiáng云yún,出chū城chéng而ér去qù。

So the three of them rose up on auspicious clouds and went out of the city.

The chapter's last action, and it is a departure by night. 祥雲, auspicious cloud, is the same word the town used of what came down over the bridge — but this time the thing riding it is what it appears to be.


總評 Commentary

Sha the Monk, who defers to everyone, contradicts Pilgrim — and he is right. The proverb he produces, 停留長智, delay breeds wits, means that waiting gives the other side time to think of something. He is arguing against a night's sleep, and behind the argument is the whole chapter: everything that has gone wrong here began with a pause that nobody could see any harm in.

Then Pilgrim gives the order, and it is the moral high point of the chapter. He is not going back for revenge, and in this sentence not even for his master. He is going to catch the demons and 證其假佛 — prove them counterfeit buddhas — to the prefect, so that the lamp-oil levy can be lifted and the 概縣小民, the ordinary people of the whole county, are relieved of it.

Those are the two hundred and forty households from the arithmetic four thousand characters ago: each serving a year, each laying out two hundred taels of silver, each 吃累, worn down by a levy nobody could question. In a chapter full of people who cannot see past appearances, the monkey is the only one who thinks to add up who has been paying.