Canonical Classics ← 第八十九回
第八十九回
huángshījīngshèdīngyàn
jīnnàobàotóushān

The Yellow Lion Spirit Lays On a Rake Banquet in Vain · Metal, Wood and Earth Plot an Uproar at Leopard-Head Mountain

看看嘉會
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

看看嘉會 A Guest Asks To Look

yāowángtīngshuōhuàn:「xiǎodemenliǎngyínzi。」xíngzhědào:「zhèrénláizhǎoyínzièrláiyàokànkànjiāhuì。」yāodào:「zhèdiāozuānérbèilǎnmǎidōng西leyòurénshuōshénmehuìhuì?」jièshàngqiándào:「zhǔréngōnglebǎobèichéngshìtiānxiàzhīzhēnjiùjiàokànkànzěnde?」guàiduōdeshēngdào:「zhèguàièzhèbǎobèinǎishìhuázhōuchéngzhōngláidetǎngzhèrénkànlezhōuzhōngchuánshuōshuōderénzhīwángshíláifǎngqiúquèzhī?」xíngzhědào:「zhǔgōngzhèrénnǎiqiánfānghòubiānderénzhōuyuǎnyòushìchéngzhōngrénchuánshuōèrleliǎngwèicéngchīfànjiāzhōngyǒuxiànchéngjiǔfànshǎngxiēchīleba。」shuōliǎoyǒuxiǎoyāoleliǎngyínzixíngzhěxíngzhějiāngyínzishāsēngdào:「rénshōuleyínzijìnhòumiànchīxiēfànlái。」yāowángtīngshuōhuàn:「xiǎodemenliǎngyínzi。」xíngzhědào:「zhèrénláizhǎoyínzièrláiyàokànkànjiāhuì。」yāodào:「zhèdiāozuānérbèilǎnmǎidōng西leyòurénshuōshénmehuìhuì?」jièshàngqiándào:「zhǔréngōnglebǎobèichéngshìtiānxiàzhīzhēnjiùjiàokànkànzěnde?」guàiduōdeshēngdào:「zhèguàièzhèbǎobèinǎishìhuázhōuchéngzhōngláidetǎngzhèrénkànlezhōuzhōngchuánshuōshuōderénzhīwángshílái访fǎngqiúquèzhī?」xíngzhědào:「zhǔgōngzhèrénnǎiqiánfānghòubiānderénzhōuyuǎnyòushìchéngzhōngrénchuánshuōèrleliǎngwèicéngchīfànjiāzhōngyǒuxiànchéngjiǔfànshǎngxiēchīleba。」shuōliǎoyǒuxiǎoyāoleliǎngyínzixíngzhěxíngzhějiāngyínzishāsēngdào:「rénshōuleyínzijìnhòumiànchīxiēfànlái。」


逐句解 Line by line

yāowángtīngshuōhuàn:「xiǎodemenliǎngyínzi。」 yāowángtīngshuōhuàn:「xiǎodemenliǎngyínzi。」

The fiend king, hearing this, called at once, "You lads, fetch five taels of silver and send him on his way."

He pays without hesitating, which is the first thing we learn about his character: he is careless with money and wants the stranger gone. Both instincts will cost him.

xíngzhědào:「zhèrénláizhǎoyínzièrláiyàokànkànjiāhuì。」 xíngzhědào:「zhèrénláizhǎoyínzièrláiyàokànkànjiāhuì。」

Pilgrim said, "This guest has come firstly to collect his silver, and secondly to have a look at the goodly gathering."

A completely unnecessary sentence, and it nearly ruins everything. Pilgrim has been paid and could leave; instead he pushes, because the plan needs the party to have a mention.

yāodào:「zhèdiāozuānérbèilǎn yāodào:「zhèdiāozuānérbèilǎn

The fiend flew into a rage and cursed, "You lazy little wretch of a Sly-Devious!

憊懶 is a good Ming insult — slack, shameless, good for nothing. Note that he curses the servant by name, and the name is one of the two on the tablets, so the disguise is holding even while the wearer is being shouted at.

mǎidōng西leyòurénshuōshénmehuìhuì?」 mǎidōng西leyòurénshuōshénmehuìhuì?」

"You bought the goods and that is that — what business have you telling people about gatherings or no gatherings?"

罷了 is a fixed expression meaning and there is an end of it, and its first graph keeps the full reading rather than the light one it takes as a sentence-final softener. 會不會 — gathering or no gathering — is the dismissive doubling of a word, the Chinese equivalent of parties and such.

jièshàngqiándào:「zhǔréngōnglebǎobèichéngshìtiānxiàzhīzhēnjiùjiàokànkànzěnde?」 jièshàngqiándào:「zhǔréngōnglebǎobèichéngshìtiānxiàzhīzhēnjiùjiàokànkànzěnde?」

Eight Rules stepped up and said, "The master of the house has got himself treasures, the true wonders of the world. What harm in letting him have a look?"

Eight Rules saves the plan, and he does it by flattery. He has read the monster correctly in a way Pilgrim did not: this is a creature who cannot resist being told his loot is remarkable.

guàiduōdeshēngdào:「zhèguàiè guàiduōdeshēngdào:「zhèguàiè

The fiend gave a snort and said, "And you, Odd-Queer, are as bad!

is a bark of contempt written straight into the text as a sound — the graph exists for very little else.

zhèbǎobèinǎishìhuázhōuchéngzhōngláidetǎngzhèrénkànlezhōuzhōngchuánshuōshuōderénzhīwángshíláifǎngqiúquèzhī?」 zhèbǎobèinǎishìhuázhōuchéngzhōngláidetǎngzhèrénkànlezhōuzhōngchuánshuōshuōderénzhīwángshílái访fǎngqiúquèzhī?」

"These treasures of mine came out of the city of Jade-Flower Prefecture. If this guest sees them and goes off spreading it about the prefecture, and it gets known, and those princes come looking for them one day — what then?"

Two readings of the same graph in one line. 得來 keeps , the full verb: they were come by, obtained. But in 說得人知 the same graph is the light de, linking the telling to its result — said so that people come to know. The monster's fear is also, note, entirely accurate. He has correctly predicted the plot of the chapter he is in.

xíngzhědào:「zhǔgōngzhèrénnǎiqiánfānghòubiānderénzhōuyuǎnyòushìchéngzhōngrénchuánshuō xíngzhědào:「zhǔgōngzhèrénnǎiqiánfānghòubiānderénzhōuyuǎnyòushìchéngzhōngrénchuánshuō

Pilgrim said, "Master, this guest comes from beyond the Qián-Quarter Market, a good way from the prefecture, and he is no city man either. Where would he go to spread it about?

is here, the asking reading — where, not there. The question is rhetorical, and the whole rebuttal is a lie built on the one true fact Pilgrim happens to hold: he really did hear the market named, out on the road.

èrleliǎngwèicéngchīfànjiāzhōngyǒuxiànchéngjiǔfànshǎngxiēchīleba。」 èrleliǎngwèicéngchīfànjiāzhōngyǒuxiànchéngjiǔfànshǎngxiēchīleba。」

"Besides, his belly is empty, and we two have not eaten either. There is food and wine ready in the house — give him some, and send him off."

takes the light ba here, the sentence-final softener that turns an instruction into a suggestion. And this is the sentence that wins: the request has stopped being about seeing the treasure and become about feeding a hungry man.

shuōliǎoyǒuxiǎoyāoleliǎngyínzixíngzhě shuōliǎoyǒuxiǎoyāoleliǎngyínzixíngzhě

Before he had finished, a little fiend had fetched five taels of silver and handed it to Pilgrim.

The staff have gone on obeying the first order while the argument raged. The novel does not comment on it, and it is very funny.

xíngzhějiāngyínzishāsēngdào:「rénshōuleyínzijìnhòumiànchīxiēfànlái。」 xíngzhějiāngyínzishāsēngdào:「rénshōuleyínzijìnhòumiànchīxiēfànlái。」

Pilgrim passed the silver to Sha Monk and said, "Guest, take your silver, and I will bring you in to the back for something to eat."

The line that gets all three of them inside. Every word of it is addressed to Sha Monk and meant for the monster, and it works because being paid and being fed are the two most ordinary things in the world.


總評 Commentary

The argument at the gate is the tensest thing in the chapter, and nobody draws a weapon. It is conducted entirely in the register of a household dispute — a master shouting at two servants about whether a tradesman may look round the house — and the pilgrims win it by being better at that register than he is.

Pilgrim nearly loses it single-handed. He is paid, the transaction is closed, and he volunteers that the guest would like to see the party. It is greedy, and the monster reacts exactly as anyone would. What rescues them is Eight Rules flattering the loot, and then Pilgrim's retreat to the humblest possible ground: the man is hungry, feed him.

The monster's objection deserves respect, because it is correct in every particular. He says that if an outsider sees the weapons the news will reach the prefecture, the princes will come looking, and then what? That is precisely what is happening, in his own hall, to his face. He has worked out the danger and mistaken the men in front of him for his own servants.