Canonical Classics ← 第七回
第七回
guàzhōngtáoshèng
xíngshānxiàdìngxīnyuán

Eight Trigrams Furnace, Where the Great Sage Escapes · Five Elements Mountain, Where the Heart Monkey Is Calmed

一遊留記
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

一遊留記 Sun Wukong Was Here

shèngshōulebàngdǒusǒushénwēijiāngshēnzòngzhànzàishǒuxīnquèdàoshēngchū」。kànyúnguāngxíngyǐnglehuìyǎnguānkànjiànhóuwángfēngchēzibānxiāngzhùzhǐguǎnqiánjìnshèngxíngshíjiànyǒugēnròuhóngzhùzichēngzheqīngdào:「jiānnǎijìntóulezhèfānhuíláizuòzhènglíngxiāogōngdìngshìzuò。」yòuliàngshuō:「qiězhùděngliúxiàxiēhàofānghǎoláishuōhuà。」xiàgēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiàobiàn!」,biànzuòguǎnnóngshuāngháozàizhōngjiānzhùzishàngxiěxíngyún:「tiānshèngdàoyóu。」xiěshōuleháomáoyòuzhuāngzūnquèzàigēnzhùzigēnxiàlepàohóu尿niàofānzhuǎnjīndòuyúnjìnghuíběnchùzhànzàiláizhǎngnèidào:「jīnláilejiàoràngtiāngōng。」láidào:「zhè尿niàojīnghóuzizhènghǎocénglezhǎngli。」shèngdào:「shìzhīdàotiānjìntóujiàngēnròuhóngzhùchēngzheqīngliúzàigǎntóngkànme?」láidào:「xiāozhǐtóukànkàn。」shèngzhēngyuánhuǒyǎnjīnjīngtóukànshíyuánláiyòushǒuzhōngzhǐxiězhetiānshèngdàoyóu」,zhǐháiyǒuxiēhóu尿niàosāoshèngchīlejīngdào:「yǒuzhèděngshìyǒuzhèděngshìjiāngxiězàichēngtiānzhùzishàngquèzàishǒuzhǐshàngfēiyǒuwèixiānzhīdeshùjuéxìnxìnděngzàilái。」shèngshōulebàngdǒusǒushénwēijiāngshēnzòngzhànzàishǒuxīnquèdàoshēngchū」。kànyúnguāngxíngyǐnglehuìyǎnguānkànjiànhóuwángfēngchēzibānxiāngzhùzhǐguǎnqiánjìnshèngxíngshíjiànyǒugēnròuhóngzhùzichēngzheqīngdào:「jiānnǎijìntóulezhèfānhuíláizuòzhènglíngxiāogōngdìngshìzuò。」yòuliàngshuō:「qiězhùděngliúxiàxiēhàofānghǎoláishuōhuà。」xiàgēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiàobiàn!」,biànzuòguǎnnóngshuāngháozàizhōngjiānzhùzishàngxiěxíngyún:「tiānshèngdàoyóu。」xiěshōuleháomáoyòuzhuāngzūnquèzàigēnzhùzigēnxiàlepàohóu尿niàofānzhuǎnjīndòuyúnjìnghuíběnchùzhànzàiláizhǎngnèidào:「jīnláilejiàoràngtiāngōng。」láidào:「zhè尿niàojīnghóuzizhènghǎocénglezhǎngli。」shèngdào:「shìzhīdàotiānjìntóujiàngēnròuhóngzhùchēngzheqīngliúzàigǎntóngkànme?」láidào:「xiāozhǐtóukànkàn。」shèngzhēngyuánhuǒyǎnjīnjīngtóukànshíyuánláiyòushǒuzhōngzhǐxiězhetiānshèngdàoyóu」,zhǐháiyǒuxiēhóu尿niàosāoshèngchīlejīngdào:「yǒuzhèděngshìyǒuzhèděngshìjiāngxiězàichēngtiānzhùzishàngquèzàishǒuzhǐshàngfēiyǒuwèixiānzhīdeshùjuéxìnxìnděngzàilái。」


逐句解 Line by line

shèngshōulebàngdǒusǒushénwēijiāngshēnzòngzhànzàishǒuxīnquèdàoshēngchū」。kànyúnguāngxíngyǐngle shèngshōulebàngdǒusǒushénwēijiāngshēnzòngzhànzàishǒuxīnquèdàoshēngchū」。kànyúnguāngxíngyǐngle

The Great Sage put away his As-You-Will cudgel, roused his spirit-might, flexed his body in a single bound, and stood in the center of the Buddha's palm; then he cried, "And out I go!" Look at him — a streak of cloud-light, gone formless and shadowless.

將身一縱 is as jiāng once more, with 一縱 taking before zòng (falling tone); 一路 takes before . He calls out and out I go, and he is gone. The comedy depends entirely on how certain he is.

huìyǎnguānkànjiànhóuwángfēngchēzibānxiāngzhùzhǐguǎnqiánjìn huìyǎnguānkànjiànhóuwángfēngchēzibānxiāngzhùzhǐguǎnqiánjìn

The Buddha, watching with his wisdom-eye, saw the Monkey King spinning along just like a pinwheel, never stopping, pressing ever onward.

慧眼 (huì yǎn) is the wisdom-eye, Sanskrit prajñā-cakṣus. All the Buddha does with it is watch — perfect stillness set against furious motion, which is the joke and the doctrine at the same time. 一般 takes before bān (level tone); 相似 keeps as xiāng and as . The image chosen for him is a child's pinwheel.

shèngxíngshíjiànyǒugēnròuhóngzhùzichēngzheqīngdào:「jiānnǎijìntóulezhèfānhuíláizuòzhènglíngxiāogōngdìngshìzuò。」 shèngxíngshíjiànyǒugēnròuhóngzhùzichēngzheqīngdào:「jiānnǎijìntóulezhèfānhuíláizuòzhènglíngxiāogōngdìngshìzuò。」

As the Great Sage went, he suddenly saw five flesh-pink pillars propping up a mass of blue vapor. He said: "This must be the end of the road. When I go back this time, with the Tathāgata as witness, the Hall of Divine Mists will surely be mine to sit in."

撐著 takes as zhe, still going on. 一股 takes before (dipping tone). 盡頭路 keeps as jìn, the end of the road. Five flesh-pink pillars holding up a blue haze: the edge of the universe, he decides. They are fingers.

yòuliàngshuō:「qiězhùděngliúxiàxiēhàofānghǎoláishuōhuà。」xiàgēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiàobiàn!」,biànzuòguǎnnóngshuāngháozàizhōngjiānzhùzishàngxiěxíngyún:「tiānshèngdàoyóu。」 yòuliàngshuō:「qiězhùděngliúxiàxiēhàofānghǎoláishuōhuà。」xiàgēnháomáochuīkǒuxiānjiàobiàn!」,biànzuòguǎnnóngshuāngháozàizhōngjiānzhùzishàngxiěxíngyún:「tiānshèngdàoyóu。」

Then he thought again: "Wait! Let me leave some mark, so I'll have proof when I speak to the Tathāgata." He pulled out a hair, blew on it with magic breath, cried "Change!" — and turned it into a thick-inked double-tipped brush, and on the middle pillar wrote a line of large characters: "The Great Sage Equal to Heaven was here."

一根 takes before gēn (level tone), 一管 the same before guǎn (dipping), 一行 before xíng (rising) — and in 一行 the is xíng, a line of writing, not háng — and 一遊 before yóu (rising). What he writes, 齊天大聖到此一遊, the Great Sage Equal to Heaven was here, is among the most quoted sentences in the novel. It is also, word for word, what still gets scratched onto walls and railings by tourists across China.

xiěshōuleháomáoyòuzhuāngzūnquèzàigēnzhùzigēnxiàlepàohóu尿niào xiěshōuleháomáoyòuzhuāngzūnquèzàigēnzhùzigēnxiàlepàohóu尿niào

Having written it, he took back his hair, and then — most unseemly — let loose a gush of monkey-piss at the foot of the first pillar.

第一根 takes before gēn (level tone); 一泡 takes before pào (falling). 不莊尊 is undignified — the narrator says so, and then reports it anyway. Marking the spot is pure animal, and it becomes the second piece of evidence used against him.

fānzhuǎnjīndòuyúnjìnghuíběnchùzhànzàiláizhǎngnèidào:「jīnláilejiàoràngtiāngōng。」 fānzhuǎnjīndòuyúnjìnghuíběnchùzhànzàiláizhǎngnèidào:「jīnláilejiàoràngtiāngōng。」

He flipped his cloud-somersault over, went straight back, stood in the Tathāgata's palm, and said: "I've gone and now I'm back. Tell the Jade Emperor to yield me the Palace of Heaven."

教玉帝 keeps as jiào, to make or tell someone to. He comes back certain of victory and issues his instructions to the Buddha like a man collecting on a debt. He has not moved.

láidào:「zhè尿niàojīnghóuzizhènghǎocénglezhǎngli。」 láidào:「zhè尿niàojīnghóuzizhènghǎocénglezhǎngli。」

The Tathāgata cursed: "You piss-spirit of a monkey! You never once left my palm."

尿精猴子 — you piss-spirit of a monkey. The Buddha meets the vulgarity on its own level, which is rare enough to be worth noticing; the Tathāgata does not usually talk like this. is li, a soft sound tacked onto the end of the sentence. 不曾 is never once.

shèngdào:「shìzhīdàotiānjìntóujiàngēnròuhóngzhùchēngzheqīngliúzàigǎntóngkànme?」 shèngdào:「shìzhīdàotiānjìntóujiàngēnròuhóngzhùchēngzheqīngliúzàigǎntóngkànme?」

The Great Sage said: "You don't know. I went to the very end of the sky, saw five flesh-pink pillars propping a mass of blue vapor, and left my mark there. Dare you go with me to look?"

天盡頭 keeps as jìn; 撐著 keeps as zhe; 一股 takes . is me, the little word that turns the sentence into a question. Dare you come and look? He is still perfectly sure his writing is at the rim of the cosmos rather than on somebody's finger.

láidào:「xiāozhǐtóukànkàn。」shèngzhēngyuánhuǒyǎnjīnjīngtóukànshíyuánláiyòushǒuzhōngzhǐxiězhetiānshèngdàoyóu」,zhǐháiyǒuxiēhóu尿niàosāo láidào:「xiāozhǐtóukànkàn。」shèngzhēngyuánhuǒyǎnjīnjīngtóukànshíyuánláiyòushǒuzhōngzhǐxiězhetiānshèngdàoyóu」,zhǐháiyǒuxiēhóu尿niàosāo

The Tathāgata said: "No need to go — just lower your head and look." The Great Sage opened wide his fiery eyes and golden pupils, looked down, and there on the Buddha's right middle finger was written "The Great Sage Equal to Heaven was here," and in the fork of the thumb there yet lingered the rank reek of monkey-piss.

不消去 is no need to go. 中指 keeps as zhōng, middle — the middle finger. 寫著 keeps as zhe. In 到此一遊, before (yóu, rising tone) is ; 還有 keeps as hái, still there. And the clinching proof is not the writing. It is the smell in the fork of the thumb.

shèngchīlejīngdào:「yǒuzhèděngshìyǒuzhèděngshìjiāngxiězàichēngtiānzhùzishàngquèzàishǒuzhǐshàngfēiyǒuwèixiānzhīdeshùjuéxìnxìnděngzàilái。」 shèngchīlejīngdào:「yǒuzhèděngshìyǒuzhèděngshìjiāngxiězàichēngtiānzhùzishàngquèzàishǒuzhǐshàngfēiyǒuwèixiānzhīdeshùjuéxìnxìnděngzàilái。」

The Great Sage was startled and said: "Can such a thing be? Can such a thing be? I wrote these words on a sky-propping pillar — how can they be on his finger? Unless he has some art of foreknowing without divining? I won't believe it! I won't! Let me go again."

一驚 takes before jīng (level tone); 將此字 is as jiāng. 未卜先知 keeps as , to divine — knowing beforehand without casting the sticks, still the ordinary Chinese for uncanny foresight. His refusal to accept the evidence in front of him is what triggers the last move of the fight.


總評 Commentary

This is the comic and philosophical heart of the chapter. The monkey launches his somersault certain that 108,000 will carry him well past a hand not a foot across. He arrives at what he takes for the world's edge — five flesh-pink pillars holding up a blue mist — writes his name on it, marks it in the coarsest way available to him, and comes back to collect the throne. He has never left the Buddha's hand. The pillars are fingers.

The force of the episode lies in how exact the monkey's mistake is. He is not stupid; his reasoning about distance is faultless, and that is the trap. The 心猿 is a mind of dazzling local competence that cannot conceive of the order of being it is inside. Distance, speed, transformation — all his powers work within a frame he cannot see as a frame. The Buddha needs no power to beat him, only to be the encompassing reality, which is why he simply watches with the 慧眼 while the monkey wears himself out.

The graffiti 齊天大聖到此一遊 has become proverbial in Chinese for pointless self-assertion, and the crudeness of the joke — the monkey piss in the fork of the thumb — is doing real work. Wú Chéng'ēn pins the whole grandeur of the rebellion to a tourist's scrawl and an animal marking its patch. As Plaks notes, the palm is the dharmadhātu, the total field of reality; to leave a vandal's mark on it and call that a conquest is the perfect emblem of an unenlightened mind mistaking movement for transcendence.