Canonical Classics ← 第五十四回
第五十四回
法fǎ性xìng西xī來lái逢féng女nǚ國guó
心xīn猿yuán定dìng計jì脫tuō煙yān花huā

The Dharma-Nature, Coming West, Meets the Land of Women · The Mind-Monkey Lays a Plan to Escape the Flowery Snare

葷素兩樣
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

葷素兩樣 Two Tables, Meat and Meatless

那nà些xiē文wén武wǔ官guān見jiàn主zhǔ公gōng與yǔ長zhǎng老lǎo同tóng登dēng鳳fèng輦niǎn,並bìng肩jiān而ér坐zuò,一yí個gè個gè眉méi花huā眼yǎn笑xiào,撥bō轉zhuǎn儀yí從cóng,復fù入rù城chéng中zhōng。孫sūn大dà聖shèng才cái教jiào沙shā僧sēng挑tiāo著zhe行xíng李lǐ,牽qiān著zhe白bái馬mǎ,隨suí大dà駕jià後hòu邊biān同tóng行xíng。豬zhū八bā戒jiè往wǎng前qián亂luàn跑pǎo,先xiān到dào五wǔ鳳fèng樓lóu前qián,嚷rǎng道dào:「好hǎo自zì在zài,好hǎo現xiàn成chéng呀ya。這zhè個gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,這zhè個gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,吃chī了le喜xǐ酒jiǔ進jìn親qīn才cái是shì。」諕xià得dé些xiē執zhí儀yí從cóng引yǐn導dǎo的de女nǚ官guān,一yí個gè個gè回huí至zhì駕jià邊biān道dào:「主zhǔ公gōng,那nà一yí個gè長cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de,在zài五wǔ鳳fèng樓lóu前qián嚷rǎng道dào要yào喜xǐ酒jiǔ吃chī哩li。」女nǚ主zhǔ聞wén奏zòu,與yǔ長zhǎng老lǎo倚yǐ香xiāng肩jiān,偎wēi並bìng桃táo腮sāi,開kāi檀tán口kǒu,俏qiào聲shēng叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,長cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de是shì你nǐ那nà個gè高gāo徒tú?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「是shì我wǒ第dì二èr個gè徒tú弟dì。他tā生shēng得dé食shí腸cháng寬kuān大dà,一yì生shēng要yào圖tú口kǒu肥féi,須xū是shì先xiān安ān排pái些xiē酒jiǔ食shí與yǔ他tā吃chī了le,方fāng可kě行xíng事shì。」女nǚ主zhǔ急jí問wèn:「光guāng祿lù寺sì安ān排pái筵yán宴yàn,完wán否fǒu?」女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「已yǐ完wán,設shè了le葷hūn素sù兩liǎng樣yàng,在zài東dōng閣gé上shàng哩li。」女nǚ王wáng又yòu問wèn:「怎zěn麼me兩liǎng樣yàng?」女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「臣chén恐kǒng唐táng朝cháo御yù弟dì與yǔ高gāo徒tú等děng平píng素sù吃chī齋zhāi,故gù有yǒu葷hūn素sù兩liǎng樣yàng。」女nǚ王wáng卻què又yòu笑xiào吟yín吟yín,偎wēi著zhe長zhǎng老lǎo的de香xiāng腮sāi道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,你nǐ吃chī葷hūn吃chī素sù?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「貧pín僧sēng吃chī素sù,但dàn是shì未wèi曾céng戒jiè酒jiǔ。須xū得dé幾jǐ杯bēi素sù酒jiǔ,與yǔ我wǒ二èr徒tú弟dì吃chī些xiē。」那nà些xiē文wén武wǔ官guān见jiàn主zhǔ公gōng与yǔ长zhǎng老lǎo同tóng登dēng凤fèng辇niǎn,并bìng肩jiān而ér坐zuò,一yí个gè个gè眉méi花huā眼yǎn笑xiào,拨bō转zhuǎn仪yí从cóng,复fù入rù城chéng中zhōng。孙sūn大dà圣shèng才cái教jiào沙shā僧sēng挑tiāo着zhe行xíng李lǐ,牵qiān着zhe白bái马mǎ,随suí大dà驾jià后hòu边biān同tóng行xíng。猪zhū八bā戒jiè往wǎng前qián乱luàn跑pǎo,先xiān到dào五wǔ凤fèng楼lóu前qián,嚷rǎng道dào:「好hǎo自zì在zài,好hǎo现xiàn成chéng呀ya。这zhè个gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,这zhè个gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,吃chī了le喜xǐ酒jiǔ进jìn亲qīn才cái是shì。」諕xià得dé些xiē执zhí仪yí从cóng引yǐn导dǎo的de女nǚ官guān,一yí个gè个gè回huí至zhì驾jià边biān道dào:「主zhǔ公gōng,那nà一yí个gè长cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de,在zài五wǔ凤fèng楼lóu前qián嚷rǎng道dào要yào喜xǐ酒jiǔ吃chī哩li。」女nǚ主zhǔ闻wén奏zòu,与yǔ长zhǎng老lǎo倚yǐ香xiāng肩jiān,偎wēi并bìng桃táo腮sāi,开kāi檀tán口kǒu,俏qiào声shēng叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,长cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de是shì你nǐ那nà个gè高gāo徒tú?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「是shì我wǒ第dì二èr个gè徒tú弟dì。他tā生shēng得dé食shí肠cháng宽kuān大dà,一yì生shēng要yào图tú口kǒu肥féi,须xū是shì先xiān安ān排pái些xiē酒jiǔ食shí与yǔ他tā吃chī了le,方fāng可kě行xíng事shì。」女nǚ主zhǔ急jí问wèn:「光guāng禄lù寺sì安ān排pái筵yán宴yàn,完wán否fǒu?」女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「已yǐ完wán,设shè了le荤hūn素sù两liǎng样yàng,在zài东dōng阁gé上shàng哩li。」女nǚ王wáng又yòu问wèn:「怎zěn么me两liǎng样yàng?」女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「臣chén恐kǒng唐táng朝cháo御yù弟dì与yǔ高gāo徒tú等děng平píng素sù吃chī斋zhāi,故gù有yǒu荤hūn素sù两liǎng样yàng。」女nǚ王wáng却què又yòu笑xiào吟yín吟yín,偎wēi着zhe长zhǎng老lǎo的de香xiāng腮sāi道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,你nǐ吃chī荤hūn吃chī素sù?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「贫pín僧sēng吃chī素sù,但dàn是shì未wèi曾céng戒jiè酒jiǔ。须xū得dé几jǐ杯bēi素sù酒jiǔ,与yǔ我wǒ二èr徒tú弟dì吃chī些xiē。」


逐句解 Line by line

那nà些xiē文wén武wǔ官guān見jiàn主zhǔ公gōng與yǔ長zhǎng老lǎo同tóng登dēng鳳fèng輦niǎn,並bìng肩jiān而ér坐zuò,一yí個gè個gè眉méi花huā眼yǎn笑xiào,撥bō轉zhuǎn儀yí從cóng,復fù入rù城chéng中zhōng。 那nà些xiē文wén武wǔ官guān见jiàn主zhǔ公gōng与yǔ长zhǎng老lǎo同tóng登dēng凤fèng辇niǎn,并bìng肩jiān而ér坐zuò,一yí个gè个gè眉méi花huā眼yǎn笑xiào,拨bō转zhuǎn仪yí从cóng,复fù入rù城chéng中zhōng。

The civil and military officers, seeing their sovereign and the elder mount the phoenix palanquin together and sit shoulder to shoulder, were every one of them wreathed in smiles; they wheeled the ceremonial train about and went back into the city.

眉花眼笑 — brows in flower and eyes laughing — is a four-character formula of open delight. The court's satisfaction is total and entirely misplaced, which the previous passage has just made sure the reader knows. 城中 takes 中 as zhōng; in 一個個 the 一 shifts to yí before the falling tone of 個.

孫sūn大dà聖shèng才cái教jiào沙shā僧sēng挑tiāo著zhe行xíng李lǐ,牽qiān著zhe白bái馬mǎ,隨suí大dà駕jià後hòu邊biān同tóng行xíng。 孙sūn大dà圣shèng才cái教jiào沙shā僧sēng挑tiāo着zhe行xíng李lǐ,牵qiān着zhe白bái马mǎ,随suí大dà驾jià后hòu边biān同tóng行xíng。

Only then did the Great Sage Sun set Sha Monk to shoulder the luggage and lead the white horse, and follow along behind the great equipage.

The escape is already being staged. 才 — only then — marks Pilgrim waiting until the procession has turned before quietly getting the party's baggage and mount into position behind it. Nobody notices. 挑 is tiāo, to carry on a shoulder-pole; 著 occurs twice, both the zhe that holds an action in place; 同行 here means to travel in company and takes 行 as xíng, not the háng that belongs to the sense of a fellow tradesman.

豬zhū八bā戒jiè往wǎng前qián亂luàn跑pǎo,先xiān到dào五wǔ鳳fèng樓lóu前qián,嚷rǎng道dào:「好hǎo自zì在zài,好hǎo現xiàn成chéng呀ya。 猪zhū八bā戒jiè往wǎng前qián乱luàn跑pǎo,先xiān到dào五wǔ凤fèng楼lóu前qián,嚷rǎng道dào:「好hǎo自zì在zài,好hǎo现xiàn成chéng呀ya。

Zhu Eight Rules went scampering on ahead, reached the front of the Five-Phoenix Tower first, and bawled out, 「Very comfortable! Very convenient!

好自在, 好現成呀 is sarcastic: everything has been made easy for everybody except him. 呀 is the everyday exclamation.

這zhè個gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,這zhè個gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,吃chī了le喜xǐ酒jiǔ進jìn親qīn才cái是shì。」 这zhè个gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,这zhè个gè弄nòng不bù成chéng,吃chī了le喜xǐ酒jiǔ进jìn亲qīn才cái是shì。」

This won't do, this won't do. The wedding wine should be drunk before the bride is taken in — that is the proper way.」

進親 is to bring the bride home, the concluding act of a wedding. Eight Rules is arguing procedure, and he is right on the procedure, which is exactly why it works.

諕xià得dé些xiē執zhí儀yí從cóng引yǐn導dǎo的de女nǚ官guān,一yí個gè個gè回huí至zhì駕jià邊biān道dào:「主zhǔ公gōng,那nà一yí個gè長cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de,在zài五wǔ鳳fèng樓lóu前qián嚷rǎng道dào要yào喜xǐ酒jiǔ吃chī哩li。」 諕xià得dé些xiē执zhí仪yí从cóng引yǐn导dǎo的de女nǚ官guān,一yí个gè个gè回huí至zhì驾jià边biān道dào:「主zhǔ公gōng,那nà一yí个gè长cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de,在zài五wǔ凤fèng楼lóu前qián嚷rǎng道dào要yào喜xǐ酒jiǔ吃chī哩li。」

He so startled the women officials who carried the regalia and led the way that they came back one and all to the carriage and said, 「Your Majesty, that one with the long snout and the big ears is bawling in front of the Five-Phoenix Tower that he wants wedding wine to drink.」

The report is delivered in the flat manner of officials reporting a disturbance, which is what makes it funny. 諕 is xià and 諕得 takes the linking dé; 長嘴 takes 長 as cháng, long; 哩 is li; in 一個個 the 一 shifts to yí before the falling tone of 個.

女nǚ主zhǔ聞wén奏zòu,與yǔ長zhǎng老lǎo倚yǐ香xiāng肩jiān,偎wēi並bìng桃táo腮sāi,開kāi檀tán口kǒu,俏qiào聲shēng叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,長cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de是shì你nǐ那nà個gè高gāo徒tú?」 女nǚ主zhǔ闻wén奏zòu,与yǔ长zhǎng老lǎo倚yǐ香xiāng肩jiān,偎wēi并bìng桃táo腮sāi,开kāi檀tán口kǒu,俏qiào声shēng叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,长cháng嘴zuǐ大dà耳ěr的de是shì你nǐ那nà个gè高gāo徒tú?」

Hearing the report, the sovereign lady leaned her fragrant shoulder against the elder's, pressed her peach-blossom cheek to his, opened her sandalwood mouth and called prettily, 「My dear imperial brother, which of your worthy disciples is the one with the long snout and the big ears?」

She conducts an administrative enquiry about a disorderly pig without once letting go of her bridegroom, and the novel reports both halves in the same sentence. 檀口 — a sandalwood mouth — is a set poetic phrase for red lips. 長 occurs twice with different readings: 長老 is zhǎng, senior, and 長嘴 is cháng, long.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「是shì我wǒ第dì二èr個gè徒tú弟dì。他tā生shēng得dé食shí腸cháng寬kuān大dà,一yì生shēng要yào圖tú口kǒu肥féi,須xū是shì先xiān安ān排pái些xiē酒jiǔ食shí與yǔ他tā吃chī了le,方fāng可kě行xíng事shì。」 三sān藏zàng道dào:「是shì我wǒ第dì二èr个gè徒tú弟dì。他tā生shēng得dé食shí肠cháng宽kuān大dà,一yì生shēng要yào图tú口kǒu肥féi,须xū是shì先xiān安ān排pái些xiē酒jiǔ食shí与yǔ他tā吃chī了le,方fāng可kě行xíng事shì。」

「That is my second disciple,」 said Tripitaka. 「He was born with a wide gullet and has spent his whole life seeking a full mouth. Some wine and food must be set out for him to eat first; only then can anything be done.」

食腸寬大 — a broad food-gut — is Eight Rules' standing epithet in the novel. 生得 takes 得 as dé; in 一生 the 一 shifts to yì before the flat tone of 生. This is the first time in the chapter Tripitaka has volunteered anything, and what he volunteers moves the plan forward.

女nǚ主zhǔ急jí問wèn:「光guāng祿lù寺sì安ān排pái筵yán宴yàn,完wán否fǒu?」 女nǚ主zhǔ急jí问wèn:「光guāng禄lù寺sì安ān排pái筵yán宴yàn,完wán否fǒu?」

The sovereign lady asked at once, 「Has the Court of Imperial Entertainments finished setting out the banquet?」

急問 — asked at once, urgently. Told there is an obstacle, her first instinct is to clear it, which is the same administrative reflex that produced the whole match: identify the blockage, task somebody with it, move on.

女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「已yǐ完wán,設shè了le葷hūn素sù兩liǎng樣yàng,在zài東dōng閣gé上shàng哩li。」 女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「已yǐ完wán,设shè了le荤hūn素sù两liǎng样yàng,在zài东dōng阁gé上shàng哩li。」

A woman official reported, 「It is finished. Two kinds have been laid, meat and meatless, in the Eastern Pavilion.」

葷 covers meat and also the pungent onion-family plants forbidden to monks, so 葷素兩樣 is not simply meat and vegetables but defiling food and permitted food. 哩 is li.

女nǚ王wáng又yòu問wèn:「怎zěn麼me兩liǎng樣yàng?」 女nǚ王wáng又yòu问wèn:「怎zěn么me两liǎng样yàng?」

「Why two kinds?」 the queen asked again.

Eight characters. The queen has never in her life had occasion to feed a monk.

女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「臣chén恐kǒng唐táng朝cháo御yù弟dì與yǔ高gāo徒tú等děng平píng素sù吃chī齋zhāi,故gù有yǒu葷hūn素sù兩liǎng樣yàng。」 女nǚ官guān奏zòu道dào:「臣chén恐kǒng唐táng朝cháo御yù弟dì与yǔ高gāo徒tú等děng平píng素sù吃chī斋zhāi,故gù有yǒu荤hūn素sù两liǎng样yàng。」

The woman official reported, 「Your servant feared that the imperial brother of the Tang and his worthy disciples habitually keep a meatless diet, and so there are two kinds, meat and meatless.」

吃齋 is to keep the monastic abstinence. The official has anticipated a requirement her sovereign did not know existed, which is the same competence this whole civil service has shown all chapter. 唐朝 takes 朝 as cháo.

女nǚ王wáng卻què又yòu笑xiào吟yín吟yín,偎wēi著zhe長zhǎng老lǎo的de香xiāng腮sāi道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,你nǐ吃chī葷hūn吃chī素sù?」 女nǚ王wáng却què又yòu笑xiào吟yín吟yín,偎wēi着zhe长zhǎng老lǎo的de香xiāng腮sāi道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,你nǐ吃chī荤hūn吃chī素sù?」

The queen, smiling and smiling again, pressed close to the elder's fragrant cheek and said, 「My dear imperial brother, do you eat meat, or meatless?」

She asks the man she has married what he eats, which is an ordinary domestic question and, in the circumstances, an unanswerable one. 偎著 takes the zhe that holds an action in place; 長老 is zhǎng; 笑吟吟 is a doubled sound-word and keeps its ordinary readings.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「貧pín僧sēng吃chī素sù,但dàn是shì未wèi曾céng戒jiè酒jiǔ。 三sān藏zàng道dào:「贫pín僧sēng吃chī素sù,但dàn是shì未wèi曾céng戒jiè酒jiǔ。

「This poor monk keeps a meatless diet,」 said Tripitaka, 「but I have never taken a vow against wine.

未曾戒酒 — has never sworn off wine — is technically true and practically a concession. It is the second thing Tripitaka has volunteered in this passage after a chapter of silence, and both have served Pilgrim's plan.

須xū得dé幾jǐ杯bēi素sù酒jiǔ,與yǔ我wǒ二èr徒tú弟dì吃chī些xiē。」 须xū得dé几jǐ杯bēi素sù酒jiǔ,与yǔ我wǒ二èr徒tú弟dì吃chī些xiē。」

A few cups of the meatless wine will be wanted, so that my second disciple may drink a little.」

素酒 is wine a monk may drink: unfortified, and brewed without animal products. Tripitaka is now arranging the drink for the disciple whose demand for it created the banquet at which the passport will be sealed. 須得 takes 得 as dé.


總評 Commentary

The procession turns for home and the chapter's tension quietly changes hands. Until now the danger has been to Tripitaka and the initiative has been the queen's; from here the plan is running, and the first sign of it is a single word. 才 — only then — marks the Great Sage waiting until the whole train has turned before setting Sha Monk to shoulder the luggage and take the horse. Nobody notices a party getting its baggage into position behind an imperial carriage, and that is exactly why it is done now.

Eight Rules then produces the chapter's second useful piece of gluttony. His objection is procedural — the wedding wine is drunk before the bride is taken in — and it is correct, which is why a court of officials who have spent the chapter insisting on correct form cannot refuse it. He wanted a drink at the posthouse and got one promised; he wants one here and gets a banquet. The plan needs exactly that banquet, and he has now supplied it twice without knowing it once.

The two tables are the passage's real subject. 葷素兩樣 — meat and meatless — is the country meeting the pilgrims halfway on a point of religious observance it has no experience of, and the official who thought of it did so unprompted. The queen has to ask why there are two. She has married a monk without knowing what monks eat, and that small domestic ignorance is more affecting than the grand deception, because it is the sort of thing a real marriage would have to work out.

Tripitaka speaks twice here, and both times he helps. He explains his disciple's appetite; he allows that he has never sworn off wine. After a chapter of 低頭不語 and 不敢擡頭 these are his first volunteered words, and both are in service of the fraud. Whatever the plan has cost him, he is now inside it and working.