Canonical Classics ← 第五十四回
第五十四回
法fǎ性xìng西xī來lái逢féng女nǚ國guó
心xīn猿yuán定dìng計jì脫tuō煙yān花huā

The Dharma-Nature, Coming West, Meets the Land of Women · The Mind-Monkey Lays a Plan to Escape the Flowery Snare

真情假意
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

真情假意 True Feeling and False

只zhǐ見jiàn那nà女nǚ王wáng走zǒu近jìn前qián來lái,一yì把bǎ扯chě住zhù三sān藏zàng,俏qiào語yǔ嬌jiāo聲shēng,叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,請qǐng上shàng龍lóng車chē,和hé我wǒ同tóng上shàng金jīn鑾luán寶bǎo殿diàn,匹pǐ配pèi夫fū婦fù去qù來lái。」這zhè長zhǎng老lǎo戰zhàn兢jīng兢jīng立lì站zhàn不bú住zhù,似sì醉zuì如rú痴chī。行xíng者zhě在zài側cè教jiào道dào:「師shī父fù不bú必bì太tài謙qiān,請qǐng共gòng師shī娘niáng上shàng輦niǎn。快kuài快kuài倒dǎo換huàn關guān文wén,等děng我wǒ們men取qǔ經jīng去qù罷ba。」長zhǎng老lǎo不bù敢gǎn回huí言yán,把bǎ行xíng者zhě抹mǒ了le兩liǎng抹mǒ,止zhǐ不bú住zhù落luò下xià淚lèi來lái。行xíng者zhě道dào:「師shī父fù切qiè莫mò煩fán惱nǎo,這zhè般bān富fù貴guì,不bú受shòu用yòng還hái待dài怎zěn麼me哩li?」三sān藏zàng沒méi及jí奈nài何hé,只zhǐ得dé依yī從cóng,揩kāi了le眼yǎn淚lèi,強qiáng整zhěng歡huān容róng,移yí步bù近jìn前qián,與yǔ女nǚ主zhǔ:只zhǐ见jiàn那nà女nǚ王wáng走zǒu近jìn前qián来lái,一yì把bǎ扯chě住zhù三sān藏zàng,俏qiào语yǔ娇jiāo声shēng,叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,请qǐng上shàng龙lóng车chē,和hé我wǒ同tóng上shàng金jīn銮luán宝bǎo殿diàn,匹pǐ配pèi夫fū妇fù去qù来lái。」这zhè长zhǎng老lǎo战zhàn兢jīng兢jīng立lì站zhàn不bú住zhù,似sì醉zuì如rú痴chī。行xíng者zhě在zài侧cè教jiào道dào:「师shī父fù不bú必bì太tài谦qiān,请qǐng共gòng师shī娘niáng上shàng辇niǎn。快kuài快kuài倒dǎo换huàn关guān文wén,等děng我wǒ们men取qǔ经jīng去qù罢ba。」长zhǎng老lǎo不bù敢gǎn回huí言yán,把bǎ行xíng者zhě抹mǒ了le两liǎng抹mǒ,止zhǐ不bú住zhù落luò下xià泪lèi来lái。行xíng者zhě道dào:「师shī父fù切qiè莫mò烦fán恼nǎo,这zhè般bān富fù贵guì,不bú受shòu用yòng还hái待dài怎zěn么me哩li?」三sān藏zàng没méi及jí奈nài何hé,只zhǐ得dé依yī从cóng,揩kāi了le眼yǎn泪lèi,强qiáng整zhěng欢huān容róng,移yí步bù近jìn前qián,与yǔ女nǚ主zhǔ:

同tóng攜xié素sù手shǒu,共gòng坐zuò龍lóng車chē。同tóng携xié素sù手shǒu,共gòng坐zuò龙lóng车chē。
那nà女nǚ主zhǔ喜xǐ孜zī孜zī欲yù配pèi夫fū妻qī,這zhè長zhǎng老lǎo憂yōu惶huáng惶huáng只zhǐ思sī拜bài佛fó。那nà女nǚ主zhǔ喜xǐ孜zī孜zī欲yù配pèi夫fū妻qī,这zhè长zhǎng老lǎo忧yōu惶huáng惶huáng只zhǐ思sī拜bài佛fó。
一yí個gè要yào洞dòng房fáng花huā燭zhú交jiāo鴛yuān侶lǚ,一yí個gè要yào西xī宇yǔ靈líng山shān見jiàn世shì尊zūn。一yí个gè要yào洞dòng房fáng花huā烛zhú交jiāo鸳yuān侣lǚ,一yí个gè要yào西xī宇yǔ灵líng山shān见jiàn世shì尊zūn。
女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,聖shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì。女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,圣shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì。
女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,指zhǐ望wàng和hé諧xié同tóng到dào老lǎo;女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,指zhǐ望wàng和hé谐xié同tóng到dào老lǎo;
聖shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì,牢láo藏cáng情qíng意yì養yǎng元yuán神shén。圣shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì,牢láo藏cáng情qíng意yì养yǎng元yuán神shén。
一yí個gè喜xǐ見jiàn男nán身shēn,恨hèn不bù得dé白bái晝zhòu並bìng頭tóu諧xié伉kàng儷lì;一yí个gè喜xǐ见jiàn男nán身shēn,恨hèn不bù得dé白bái昼zhòu并bìng头tóu谐xié伉kàng俪lì;
一yí個gè怕pà逢féng女nǚ色sè,只zhǐ思sī量liáng即jí時shí脫tuō網wǎng上shàng雷léi音yīn。一yí个gè怕pà逢féng女nǚ色sè,只zhǐ思sī量liáng即jí时shí脱tuō网wǎng上shàng雷léi音yīn。
二èr人rén和hé會huì同tóng登dēng輦niǎn,豈qǐ料liào唐táng僧sēng各gè有yǒu心xīn。二èr人rén和hé会huì同tóng登dēng辇niǎn,岂qǐ料liào唐táng僧sēng各gè有yǒu心xīn。

逐句解 Line by line

只zhǐ見jiàn那nà女nǚ王wáng走zǒu近jìn前qián來lái,一yì把bǎ扯chě住zhù三sān藏zàng,俏qiào語yǔ嬌jiāo聲shēng,叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,請qǐng上shàng龍lóng車chē,和hé我wǒ同tóng上shàng金jīn鑾luán寶bǎo殿diàn,匹pǐ配pèi夫fū婦fù去qù來lái。」 只zhǐ见jiàn那nà女nǚ王wáng走zǒu近jìn前qián来lái,一yì把bǎ扯chě住zhù三sān藏zàng,俏qiào语yǔ娇jiāo声shēng,叫jiào道dào:「御yù弟dì哥gē哥ge,请qǐng上shàng龙lóng车chē,和hé我wǒ同tóng上shàng金jīn銮luán宝bǎo殿diàn,匹pǐ配pèi夫fū妇fù去qù来lái。」

Then the queen came up close, seized Tripitaka in one grip, and called out in a pretty, coaxing voice, 「My dear imperial brother, be pleased to mount the dragon carriage and come up with me to the hall of the golden bells, and let us be matched as husband and wife.」

御弟哥哥 stacks an intimate address on an official title — roughly "my dear imperial brother" — and the queen coins it here and keeps it for the rest of the chapter; the doubled family word takes a light second syllable. In 一把 the 一 shifts to yì before the dipping tone of 把: it is the same phrase and the same grip Tripitaka used on Pilgrim at the start of the plan, now used on Tripitaka.

這zhè長zhǎng老lǎo戰zhàn兢jīng兢jīng立lì站zhàn不bú住zhù,似sì醉zuì如rú痴chī。 这zhè长zhǎng老lǎo战zhàn兢jīng兢jīng立lì站zhàn不bú住zhù,似sì醉zuì如rú痴chī。

The elder trembled so that he could not keep his feet, and was like a man drunk, like a man witless.

似醉如痴 inverts the 如醉方醒, 似夢初覺 of the plan passage — there he woke out of a daze, here he goes back into one. 戰兢兢 is a doubled sound-word and keeps its ordinary readings; 不 shifts to bú before the falling tone of 住.

行xíng者zhě在zài側cè教jiào道dào:「師shī父fù不bú必bì太tài謙qiān,請qǐng共gòng師shī娘niáng上shàng輦niǎn。 行xíng者zhě在zài侧cè教jiào道dào:「师shī父fù不bú必bì太tài谦qiān,请qǐng共gòng师shī娘niáng上shàng辇niǎn。

Pilgrim, at his side, instructed him: 「Master, there is no need for so much modesty. Be pleased to mount the palanquin with our teacher-mother.

師娘 — teacher-mother, the wife of one's master — is Pilgrim's own coinage for the queen, and delivering it deadpan in front of the whole court is the most audacious line he speaks in the chapter. 教 is jiào.

快kuài快kuài倒dǎo換huàn關guān文wén,等děng我wǒ們men取qǔ經jīng去qù罷ba。」 快kuài快kuài倒dǎo换huàn关guān文wén,等děng我wǒ们men取qǔ经jīng去qù罢ba。」

Have the passport countersigned quickly, and let us be off to fetch the scriptures.」

去罷 takes 罷 as the little rounding-off word ba that softens a suggestion, not the verb bà of 茶罷. Where it sits decides which it is, as always with this character. 倒換 takes 倒 as dǎo.

長zhǎng老lǎo不bù敢gǎn回huí言yán,把bǎ行xíng者zhě抹mǒ了le兩liǎng抹mǒ,止zhǐ不bú住zhù落luò下xià淚lèi來lái。 长zhǎng老lǎo不bù敢gǎn回huí言yán,把bǎ行xíng者zhě抹mǒ了le两liǎng抹mǒ,止zhǐ不bú住zhù落luò下xià泪lèi来lái。

The elder dared not answer; he gave Pilgrim two rubs with his hand, and could not stop the tears from falling.

把行者抹了兩抹 is a small private signal, hand to sleeve, made where the court cannot see it. The novel does not say what it means and neither does Pilgrim. 落 is luò, not the là the same character takes elsewhere.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「師shī父fù切qiè莫mò煩fán惱nǎo,這zhè般bān富fù貴guì,不bú受shòu用yòng還hái待dài怎zěn麼me哩li?」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「师shī父fù切qiè莫mò烦fán恼nǎo,这zhè般bān富fù贵guì,不bú受shòu用yòng还hái待dài怎zěn么me哩li?」

「Master, do not distress yourself,」 said Pilgrim. 「Such wealth and rank as this — and you will not enjoy it? What are you waiting for?」

The line is cruel taken straight and kind taken as cover, and Tripitaka, weeping, has to take it one way in public and the other in private. 還 is hái; 哩 is li.

三sān藏zàng沒méi及jí奈nài何hé,只zhǐ得dé依yī從cóng,揩kāi了le眼yǎn淚lèi,強qiáng整zhěng歡huān容róng,移yí步bù近jìn前qián,與yǔ女nǚ主zhǔ: 三sān藏zàng没méi及jí奈nài何hé,只zhǐ得dé依yī从cóng,揩kāi了le眼yǎn泪lèi,强qiáng整zhěng欢huān容róng,移yí步bù近jìn前qián,与yǔ女nǚ主zhǔ:

Tripitaka had no help for it and could only comply. He wiped his eyes, forced his face into a cheerful set, stepped forward, and with the sovereign lady —

The sentence does not end here. 與女主 — together with the sovereign lady — is left hanging, and its verb is the first line of the verse that follows, 同攜素手. The colon is the printer's mark introducing the verse, not a break in the grammar, so the English ends on a dash rather than a stop. 沒 is méi; 只得 takes 得 as dé; 強整 takes 強 as qiáng.

同tóng攜xié素sù手shǒu,共gòng坐zuò龍lóng車chē。 同tóng携xié素sù手shǒu,共gòng坐zuò龙lóng车chē。

took hands, pale hand in pale hand, and shared the dragon carriage.

素手 — plain or white hands — is a poetic word for a woman's hands, applied here to both parties at once. The line finishes the prose sentence above and is at the same time the opening four-and-four couplet of the verse, which is an unusual seam.

那nà女nǚ主zhǔ喜xǐ孜zī孜zī欲yù配pèi夫fū妻qī,這zhè長zhǎng老lǎo憂yōu惶huáng惶huáng只zhǐ思sī拜bài佛fó。 那nà女nǚ主zhǔ喜xǐ孜zī孜zī欲yù配pèi夫fū妻qī,这zhè长zhǎng老lǎo忧yōu惶huáng惶huáng只zhǐ思sī拜bài佛fó。

The sovereign lady, all gladness, desired to be joined as man and wife; the elder, all dread, thought only of worshipping Buddha.

The opposition that governs the whole piece is stated here for the first time and will be restated four more ways before the verse ends. 喜孜孜 and 憂惶惶 are matched doubled sound-words and keep their ordinary readings; 佛 is fó.

一yí個gè要yào洞dòng房fáng花huā燭zhú交jiāo鴛yuān侶lǚ,一yí個gè要yào西xī宇yǔ靈líng山shān見jiàn世shì尊zūn。 一yí个gè要yào洞dòng房fáng花huā烛zhú交jiāo鸳yuān侣lǚ,一yí个gè要yào西xī宇yǔ灵líng山shān见jiàn世shì尊zūn。

The one would have the bridal chamber, the flowering candles, the mated ducks; the other would have the Spirit Mountain of the Western Region, and the sight of the World-Honoured One.

Two complete and incompatible futures in exactly parallel wording. 洞房花燭 is the fixed four-character phrase for a wedding night — bridal chamber and flowering candles — and is still the phrase used today. 鴛侶 are mandarin ducks standing for a married pair. 靈山 is Vulture Peak and 世尊 renders bhagavat, the World-Honoured One.

女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,聖shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì。 女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,圣shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì。

The woman emperor in true feeling; the holy monk in false.

女帝真情, 聖僧假意 is the couplet the passage is named for. Four characters against four, and the piece will now expand each half in turn — statement first, then gloss, a small structural move these set verses use to organise an opposition.

女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,指zhǐ望wàng和hé諧xié同tóng到dào老lǎo; 女nǚ帝dì真zhēn情qíng,指zhǐ望wàng和hé谐xié同tóng到dào老lǎo;

The woman emperor in true feeling, hoping for concord and to grow old together;

指望和諧同到老 — hoping for concord and to grow old together — is what she actually wants, and the verse says it without a trace of irony. The novel is careful, here as everywhere in this chapter, not to make her ridiculous.

聖shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì,牢láo藏cáng情qíng意yì養yǎng元yuán神shén。 圣shèng僧sēng假jiǎ意yì,牢láo藏cáng情qíng意yì养yǎng元yuán神shén。

the holy monk in false, hiding his feeling away close and nourishing his primal spirit.

養元神 answers the 喪元陽 of the plan passage: what he refused to lose there, he is hoarding here. 牢藏 takes 藏 as cáng, to store or conceal — the first time in this chapter the character appears on any reading but the zàng of 三藏.

一yí個gè喜xǐ見jiàn男nán身shēn,恨hèn不bù得dé白bái晝zhòu並bìng頭tóu諧xié伉kàng儷lì; 一yí个gè喜xǐ见jiàn男nán身shēn,恨hèn不bù得dé白bái昼zhòu并bìng头tóu谐xié伉kàng俪lì;

The one, glad at the sight of a man's body, could hardly wait to lay their heads together in broad day and be husband and wife;

伉儷 is the formal literary word for a married couple, and setting it against 白晝並頭 — heads together in broad daylight — is a deliberate collision of high and low. 恨不得 takes 得 as dé, in a fixed idiom of impatient wishing: to wish one could hardly wait.

一yí個gè怕pà逢féng女nǚ色sè,只zhǐ思sī量liáng即jí時shí脫tuō網wǎng上shàng雷léi音yīn。 一yí个gè怕pà逢féng女nǚ色sè,只zhǐ思sī量liáng即jí时shí脱tuō网wǎng上shàng雷léi音yīn。

the other, afraid to meet a woman's beauty, thought only of slipping the net that instant and going up to Thunderclap.

脫網 is the chapter's own word for the plan — 假親脫網 — so the verse is quoting the scheme back at the reader. 雷音 is Thunderclap Monastery, the pilgrimage's destination. 思量 takes 量 as liáng.

二èr人rén和hé會huì同tóng登dēng輦niǎn,豈qǐ料liào唐táng僧sēng各gè有yǒu心xīn。 二èr人rén和hé会huì同tóng登dēng辇niǎn,岂qǐ料liào唐táng僧sēng各gè有yǒu心xīn。

The two came together and mounted the palanquin as one — who would have guessed the Tang monk had a mind apart?

和會同登輦 describes what an onlooker sees; 各有心 — each with a mind of his own — supplies what only the reader and three disciples know, and closes the verse on what makes the whole tableau false.


總評 Commentary

This is the chapter's cruellest passage and it works by making the reader watch two things at once. On the surface a marriage is being celebrated: a queen takes a man's hand, they mount the carriage together, they sit shoulder to shoulder before the whole court. Underneath, one of the two is carrying out a fraud he agreed to under duress, weeping while he does it, and being coached through it by a disciple who calls the bride 師娘 — teacher-mother — to her face.

The verse exists to hold both readings in view at once, and its structure is built for the job. Every couplet is an opposition with the same two subjects: she desires, he dreads; she wants the bridal chamber, he wants Vulture Peak; she is glad at a man's body, he is afraid of a woman's beauty. Then the four-character 女帝真情, 聖僧假意 names the asymmetry outright, and the piece expands each half in turn. Nothing is concealed from the reader and everything is concealed from the court.

What keeps it from being merely clever is the line the verse gives her straight. 指望和諧同到老 — hoping for concord and to grow old together — is the plainest language in the passage, and it is the one wish in the chapter that nobody is going to get. She is being deceived by four men and a plan, and the novel will not let the reader enjoy that without noticing what it costs her.

The passage also contains the chapter's one moment of unwitnessed contact. 把行者抹了兩抹 — the elder, unable to speak, gives Pilgrim two rubs with his hand. The novel does not say what the gesture means and Pilgrim does not answer it; what follows is only the tears he cannot stop. It is a small thing, six characters, and it is the only time in the whole episode that Tripitaka communicates anything at all.