Canonical Classics ← 第五十二回
第五十二回
kōngnàojīndōudòng
láiànshìzhǔréngōng

Wukong Makes Havoc at the Cave of the Golden Helmet · The Tathāgata Hints Covertly at the Owner

具告如來
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

具告如來 The Petition to the Tathāgata

xíngzhětóubàiláiwèndào:「kōngqiánwénguānyīnzūnzhějiětuōshēnguīshìjiàobǎotángsēngláiqiújīngzěnmedàoyǒushì?」xíngzhědùnshǒudào:「shànggàobǐngjiāchítángcháoshī西láixíngzhìjīndōushānjīndōudòngzháoètóumínghuànwángshéntōngguǎngshīshīděngshèdòngzhōngxiàngqiúméihǎoliǎngjiābèngbèijiāngbáisēnsēndequānziqiǎngledetiěbàngkǒngshìtiānjiàngfánshàngjièchákānchūméngchāiqiǎntiānwángzhùyuányòubèiqiǎngletàideliùbānbīngqǐnghuǒxīngjūnfànghuǒshāoyòubèijiānghuǒqiǎngyòuqǐngshuǐxīngjūnfàngshuǐyǎnháoyòuyǎnzháofèiruògānjīngshénjiāngtiěbàngděngtōuchūsuǒzhànyòubèijiāngqiánrántàoshōuxiángyīngàowàngchuíkànkànguǒránshìchūshēnhǎojiāshǔlínqíntóujiùshīgǒngqiánchéngbàiqiúzhèngguǒ。」xíngzhětóubàiláiwèndào:「kōngqiánwénguānyīnzūnzhějiětuōshēnguīshìjiàobǎotángsēngláiqiújīngzěnmedàoyǒushì?」xíngzhědùnshǒudào:「shànggàobǐngjiāchítángcháoshī西láixíngzhìjīndōushānjīndōudòngzháoètóumínghuànwángshéntōng广guǎngshīshīděngshèdòngzhōngxiàngqiúméihǎoliǎngjiābèngbèijiāngbáisēnsēndequānziqiǎngledetiěbàngkǒngshìtiānjiàngfánshàngjièchákānchūméngchāiqiǎntiānwángzhùyuányòubèiqiǎngletàideliùbānbīngqǐnghuǒxīngjūnfànghuǒshāoyòubèijiānghuǒqiǎngyòuqǐngshuǐxīngjūnfàngshuǐyǎnháoyòuyǎnzháofèiruògānjīngshénjiāngtiěbàngděngtōuchūsuǒzhànyòubèijiāngqiánrántàoshōuxiángyīngàowàngchuíkànkànguǒránshìchūshēnhǎojiāshǔlínqíntóujiùshīgǒngqiánchéngbàiqiúzhèngguǒ。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhětóubàiláiwèndào:「kōngqiánwénguānyīnzūnzhějiětuōshēnguīshìjiàobǎotángsēngláiqiújīngzěnmedàoyǒushì?」 xíngzhětóubàiláiwèndào:「kōngqiánwénguānyīnzūnzhějiětuōshēnguīshìjiàobǎotángsēngláiqiújīngzěnmedàoyǒushì?」

Pilgrim bowed his head and made his obeisance, and when it was done the Tathāgata asked: "Wukong, I heard some while ago that the Venerable Guanyin had released you and that you had taken refuge in the teaching of Śākya, and were escorting the Tang priest here in quest of scriptures. How is it that you come alone? What has happened?"

The Buddha asks a question he already knows the answer to. 聞得: is ; 觀音: is guān; 解脫: is jiě; 釋教: is jiào, the doctrine. Three sentences further on the narrative says outright that he knew already, so the opening question is pure form — the way a magistrate asks a defendant to state his name.

xíngzhědùnshǒudào:「shànggàobǐngjiāchítángcháoshī西láixíngzhìjīndōushānjīndōudòngzháoètóumínghuànwángshéntōngguǎngshīshīděngshèdòngzhōng xíngzhědùnshǒudào:「shànggàobǐngjiāchítángcháoshī西láixíngzhìjīndōushānjīndōudòngzháoètóumínghuànwángshéntōng广guǎngshīshīděngshèdòngzhōng

Pilgrim knocked his head on the ground and said: "I report to my Buddha. Since your disciple took up the discipline and came west with his master of the Tang court, we travelled as far as the Golden Helm Mountain and the Golden Helm Cave, where we fell in with an evil demon head named the Rhinoceros King, whose magic powers are very great, and who carried my master and my fellow disciples off into his cave.

is throughout this edition. 弟子: is , the full word for son or disciple. 唐朝: is cháo, a dynasty, not the zhāo of morning. 遇著: is zháo, the reading for an action that hits its mark, on the pattern of 撞著, "ran into." 洞中: is zhōng.

xiàngqiúméihǎoliǎngjiābèngbèijiāngbáisēnsēndequānziqiǎngledetiěbàng xiàngqiúméihǎoliǎngjiābèngbèijiāngbáisēnsēndequānziqiǎngledetiěbàng

"Your disciple went to him and asked them back; he had no good intentions, and the two sides fell to contending. Then with a bone-white ring of his he snatched away my iron rod.

One segment, two readings of the same character. 弟子 takes , the full word, while 圈子 takes zi, the bare ending — so tone alone separates the disciple from the ring. 沒好意: is méi; 將一個: is jiāng; 搶了: is le.

kǒngshìtiānjiàngfánshàngjièchákānchū kǒngshìtiānjiàngfánshàngjièchákānchū

"Fearing he might be some celestial general with a longing for the mortal world, I went up in haste to the upper realm; but the search and examination turned nothing up.

天將: is jiàng, the rank of general — the same character reads jiāng, the object-marker, in the segments both above and below. 查勘: is chá. 思凡 is the technical term for a celestial being who starts hankering after the world below and absconds — heaven's word for going absent without leave.

méngchāiqiǎntiānwángzhùyuányòubèiqiǎngletàideliùbānbīng méngchāiqiǎntiānwángzhùyuányòubèiqiǎngletàideliùbānbīng

"By the Jade Emperor's grace Devarāja Li and his son were commissioned to my help, and he snatched away the Prince's six weapons too.

差遣: is chāi, to commission someone for a duty. Both in this segment (父子, 太子) are , the full word; 搶了: is le.

qǐnghuǒxīngjūnfànghuǒshāoyòubèijiānghuǒqiǎng qǐnghuǒxīngjūnfànghuǒshāoyòubèijiānghuǒqiǎng

"Then I asked the Fire Virtue Star Lord to set fire to him, and he snatched away the fire-gear as well.

將火具搶去: is jiāng. The petition is running through the arc in order, and the verb comes out the same every single time.

yòuqǐngshuǐxīngjūnfàngshuǐyǎnháoyòuyǎnzháo yòuqǐngshuǐxīngjūnfàngshuǐyǎnháoyòuyǎnzháo

"Then I asked the Water Virtue Star Lord to loose water and drown him, and not a hair of him could be drowned.

渰他不著: is zháo, an action reaching its mark, here inside a negative — "could not manage to drown him." Because that reading lifts the character from a fourth tone to a second, the in front takes where the general rule would give . is the vernacular way of writing , to drown.

fèiruògānjīngshénjiāngtiěbàngděngtōuchūsuǒzhànyòubèijiāngqiánrántàoshōuxiáng fèiruògānjīngshénjiāngtiěbàngděngtōuchūsuǒzhànyòubèijiāngqiánrántàoshōuxiáng

"Your disciple spent no end of spirit and strength stealing the iron rod and the rest of it out again, and went back to offer battle; and he snared the whole lot away exactly as before, and there is no means of subduing him.

若干: is gān. Both here (將那鐵棒, 將前物) are jiāng; is . 收降: is xiáng, to subdue, not the jiàng of coming down.

yīngàowàngchuíkànkànguǒránshìchūshēn yīngàowàngchuíkànkànguǒránshìchūshēn

"Therefore I come especially to report to my Buddha, and to beg that in your mercy you will look for your disciple and see what thing he really is by origin,

And here is the actual request. is ; 弟子: is ; both are kàn看看 is the softening doubling, "just take a look," which is a very modest way to ask the Buddha for an identification.

hǎojiāshǔlínqíntóujiùshīgǒngqiánchéngbàiqiúzhèngguǒ。」 hǎojiāshǔlínqíntóujiùshīgǒngqiánchéngbàiqiúzhèngguǒ。」

"so that I may go and take his household and his neighbours, seize this demon head, rescue my master, and with folded hands and a sincere heart seek the true fruit of enlightenment."

家屬四鄰 — to arrest a criminal's household and his neighbours is the language of Ming penal practice, collective liability and all, and Pilgrim applies it to a demon without blinking. 正果 is the true fruit, the attainment waiting at the end of the pilgrimage.


總評 Commentary

The petition is a set piece of bureaucratic form, and it is worth reading as one. Pilgrim calls himself 弟子, your disciple, throughout, addresses the Buddha as 我佛, my Buddha, and lays the case out in exactly the order a formal memorial would take: the commission he holds, where he was travelling, what befell him, what redress he sought at each level, and what he now asks for. Every escalation is there — his own attempt, the search of the celestial registers, Devarāja Li and Nezha, the Fire Virtue, the Water Virtue, the night raid — and every one of them ends on the same verb: , , snatched, snared away.

What he asks for is not a weapon. He asks the Buddha to look and tell him 果然是何物出身 — what the creature is by origin. Fifty-one chapters have trained the reader to expect a borrowed treasure or a better fighter; what the plot actually needs is a name, and Wukong has worked that out for himself. His closing sentence gives the game away in the other direction: he wants to arrest the demon's household and neighbours, which is Ming penal practice with its collective liability fully intact, and he wants to do it as a step towards 正果, the true fruit of the Way. Courtroom and monastery sit side by side in one sentence, and nobody is embarrassed.