Canonical Classics ← 第五十二回
第五十二回
kōngnàojīndōudòng
láiànshìzhǔréngōng

Wukong Makes Havoc at the Cave of the Golden Helmet · The Tathāgata Hints Covertly at the Owner

棒槍鏖戰
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

棒槍鏖戰 Cudgel and Spear in Pitched Battle

zhèngjiǎngchùzhǐtīngshānxiàluómínghǎnshēngzhènyuánláishìwángshuàizhòngjīnglíngláigǎnxíngzhěxíngzhějiànlejiàodào:「hǎohǎohǎozhènglièwèiqǐngzuòdàilǎosūnzàizhuō。」hǎoshèngtiěbàngmiànyíngláidào:「zǒukàngùn!」guài使shǐqiāngzhīzhùdào:「zéihóutóuzhuóshízěnmebáizhòujiéjiàn?」xíngzhědào:「zhèzhīdenièchùdàonòngquāntàobáizhòuqiǎngduójiànershìdeyàozǒuchīlǎogùn!」guàilūnqiāngjiàzhèchánghǎozhànzhèngjiǎngchùzhǐtīngshānxiàluómínghǎnshēngzhènyuánláishìwángshuàizhòngjīnglíngláigǎnxíngzhěxíngzhějiànlejiàodào:「hǎohǎohǎozhènglièwèiqǐngzuòdàilǎosūnzàizhuō。」hǎoshèngtiěbàngmiànyíngláidào:「zǒukàngùn!」guài使shǐqiāngzhīzhùdào:「zéihóutóuzhuóshízěnmebáizhòujiéjiàn?」xíngzhědào:「zhèzhīdenièchùdàonòngquāntàobáizhòuqiǎngduójiànershìdeyàozǒuchīlǎogùn!」guàilūnqiāngjiàzhèchánghǎozhàn

shèngshīwēiměngyāoshùnróushèngshīwēiměngyāoshùnróu
liǎngjiādòuyǒngkěngānxiūliǎngjiādòuyǒngkěngānxiū
zhètiěbànglóngwěichángqiāngmǎngtóuzhètiěbànglóngwěichángqiāngmǎngtóu
zhèbàngláixièshùfēngxiǎngqiāngjiàxióngwēishuǐliúzhèbàngláixièshùfēngxiǎngqiāngjiàxióngwēishuǐliú
zhǐjiàncǎiméngméngshānlǐngànxiángyúnàidàishùlínchóuzhǐjiàncǎiméngméngshānlǐngànxiángyúnàidàishùlínchóu
滿mǎnkōngfēiniǎojiētíngchìlángchóngjìnsuōtóumǎnkōngfēiniǎojiētíngchìlángchóngjìnsuōtóu
zhènshàngxiǎoyāohǎnzhèxiāngxíngzhědǒusǒuzhènshàngxiǎoyāohǎnzhèxiāngxíngzhědǒusǒu
tiáotiěbàngrénbiàn西fāngwànyóutiáotiěbàngrénbiàn西fāngwànyóu
gǎnchángqiāngzhēnduìshǒuyǒngzhènjīndōuchēngshàngchóugǎnchángqiāngzhēnduìshǒuyǒngzhènjīndōuchēngshàngchóu
xiāngzhèchánghǎosànjiàngāoshìxiūxiāngzhèchánghǎosànjiàngāoshìxiū

逐句解 Line by line

zhèngjiǎngchùzhǐtīngshānxiàluómínghǎnshēngzhèn zhèngjiǎngchùzhǐtīngshānxiàluómínghǎnshēngzhèn

Just as they were talking, there came from below the mountain slope a clashing of gongs and drums together, and a shouting that shook the ground.

Gongs and drums under the slope: the demon is coming out to fight. 正講處 uses the frame, "just at the point of —"; is chù. 只聽得: is . 那山坡 points at a particular slope, so is .

yuánláishìwángshuàizhòngjīnglíngláigǎnxíngzhě yuánláishìwángshuàizhòngjīnglíngláigǎnxíngzhě

It was the Rhinoceros King, leading out his host of sprites in pursuit of Pilgrim.

兕大王. The () is the one-horned wild ox of the old books — the beast in the Analects tag 虎兕出於柙, "the tiger and the wild ox break out of their cage." The demon's true shape, revealed at the very end of the chapter, is Lord Lao's blue ox, so the title has been telling the reader the answer from the first line. 帥眾: is shuài, standing in for , "to lead."

xíngzhějiànlejiàodào:「hǎohǎohǎozhènglièwèiqǐngzuòdàilǎosūnzàizhuō。」 xíngzhějiànlejiàodào:「hǎohǎohǎozhènglièwèiqǐngzuòdàilǎosūnzàizhuō。」

Pilgrim saw them and cried: "Good, good, good — this falls out just as I would have it. Be seated, my lords, and let Old Monkey go and take him."

見了: is le. 列位 is the polite plural, "you gentlemen", addressed to the assembled gods. 正合吾意 means "falls in exactly with what I wanted."

hǎoshèngtiěbàngmiànyíngláidào:「zǒukàngùn!」 hǎoshèngtiěbàngmiànyíngláidào:「zǒukàngùn!」

The fine Great Sage raised his iron cudgel and came on straight in the monster's face, roaring: "Where do you think you are going, wretched fiend? Mind the cudgel!"

那裡走 is not asking for directions; it is the challenge "where do you think you are going?" — so is . 看棍: is kàn. This is the warning shouted a beat before the blow lands, exactly like 看刀 or 看箭 — the fighter's equivalent of "heads up." 劈面 is "full in the face." 喝道: is , to shout, never the of drinking.

guài使shǐqiāngzhīzhùdào:「zéihóutóuzhuóshí guài使shǐqiāngzhīzhùdào:「zéihóutóuzhuóshí

The monster fended him off with his spear and cursed him: "Thieving ape's head! This is downright insolence.

那怪 points, so is . 著實: is zhuó in this set phrase, "downright, in very truth." 支住 is to prop a weapon across and stop a blow.

zěnmebáizhòujiéjiàn?」 zěnmebáizhòujiéjiàn?」

"How dare you plunder my goods in broad daylight?"

白晝, "broad daylight." Keep an eye on it — Pilgrim throws the identical phrase back at him two lines later, which is the point of the whole exchange. 物件 means articles, gear, stuff.

xíngzhědào:「zhèzhīdenièchù xíngzhědào:「zhèzhīdenièchù

Pilgrim said: "Why, you accursed beast, too dull to know your own death is upon you!

我把你這個… is the standard opening of a vernacular tirade, and it is deliberately left hanging: the verb never arrives, swallowed by the insult that follows. 孽畜: is chù, the noun "beast", not the verb , to rear animals.

dàonòngquāntàobáizhòuqiǎngduójiànershìdeyàozǒuchīlǎogùn!」 dàonòngquāntàobáizhòuqiǎngduójiànershìdeyàozǒuchīlǎogùn!」

"It is you who work a snare-ring and seize my things in broad daylight — which of them is yours? Don't run: take a rod from your lord and master!"

Here is the retort, and the joke is exact. 你倒弄圈套: is dào, "you, on the contrary —", not the dǎo of knocking over. 那件兒 asks "which one", so is , with as er. And 圈套 is a pun the English cannot quite hold: the word for a trap or snare is built on , the ring — so the demon's ring is literally a ring-trap. Pilgrim is calling the thing what it is and insulting him with it at the same time.

guàilūnqiāngjià guàilūnqiāngjià

The monster swung up his spear and warded off the blow.

那怪物 points, so is . 隔架 is "to block and parry", the standard verb that closes an exchange of insults and opens the set-piece poem.

zhèchánghǎozhàn zhèchánghǎozhàn

It was a fine fight:

The tag line that announces the verse gets a segment of its own and is not itself verse. before (chǎng, third tone) shifts to under the ordinary tone rule for .

shèngshīwēiměngyāoshùnróu shèngshīwēiměngyāoshùnróu

The Great Sage put forth his fierce might; / the fiend would neither yield nor bend.

The poem opens in five-syllable lines and moves to seven at the fourth couplet — a couplet being a matched pair of lines — and holds seven to the end. Several lines carry a lead-in tag — 這一個, 那一個, 只見那 — sitting outside the count. A single rhyme runs the whole way through, the class: . 順柔 is "to submit and soften."

liǎngjiādòuyǒngkěngānxiū liǎngjiādòuyǒngkěngānxiū

The two houses matched their valour together; / which of them would consent to break off?

那個肯干休 is a rhetorical question, so is , "which of them —?" 干休 means to let a matter drop. In traditional spelling is always gān (干戈, 何干, 若干); the gàn that means "to do" is a different character, . 兩家 is "the two sides" of a contest, not two households.

zhètiěbànglóngwěichángqiāngmǎngtóu zhètiěbànglóngwěichángqiāngmǎngtóu

This one's iron rod was like a dragon's tail; / that one's long spear was like a python's head.

The 這一個那一個 frame — this one … that one — is the standard call-and-answer device of fighting verse, pairing the two combatants clause by clause all the way down. is the pointing ; 長槍: is cháng, "long", not zhǎng.

zhèbàngláixièshùfēngxiǎngqiāngjiàxióngwēishuǐliú zhèbàngláixièshùfēngxiǎngqiāngjiàxióngwēishuǐliú

This one's rod came in a play of strokes like the sounding wind; / that one's spear held its fierce guard like running water.

解數 is a term straight out of the martial-arts hall: a set sequence of moves, what a modern school would call a form or kata. is xiè here (not jiě), and is the noun shù. The pair 風響 / 水流 sets sound against motion.

zhǐjiàncǎiméngméngshānlǐngànxiángyúnàidàishùlínchóu zhǐjiàncǎiméngméngshānlǐngànxiángyúnàidàishùlínchóu

One saw only the coloured mists hanging dense, the ridges darkened; / the auspicious clouds massed thick, the woodlands sunk in gloom.

points, so . 朦朦 and 靉靆 are both two-syllable words for light going out of the sky, the second an old poetic term for piled-up cloud. The landscape darkening as the fight goes on is a convention of the form — the weather takes sides.

滿mǎnkōngfēiniǎojiētíngchìlángchóngjìnsuōtóu mǎnkōngfēiniǎojiētíngchìlángchóngjìnsuōtóu

The birds that filled the sky all stayed their wings; / the wolves and vermin of the four wilds drew in their heads.

盡縮頭: is jìn, "one and all", the reading used throughout this edition; the concessive sense that would be jǐn is written with a different character, . 狼蟲 — "wolves and crawling things" — is a fixed pair meaning wild animals generally.

zhènshàngxiǎoyāohǎnzhèxiāngxíngzhědǒusǒu zhènshàngxiǎoyāohǎnzhèxiāngxíngzhědǒusǒu

On that side the little imps raised their war-cry; / on this side Pilgrim shook himself to the work.

那陣上 points, so is . 這壁廂, "over on this side", answers it. Having matched the two weapons against each other, the poem now matches the two camps.

tiáotiěbàngrénbiàn西fāngwànyóu tiáotiěbàngrénbiàn西fāngwànyóu

One iron rod, and no man to match it, / has beaten its way ten thousand about the West.

一條: shifts to before (tiáo, second tone). stays in Chinese as rather than becoming a mile, because it is nowhere near one: a Ming ran to something like 576 metres, roughly a third of a mile. 萬里, ten thousand of them, is not meant as a measurement anyway — it is the ordinary way of saying "the whole world over", the way English says "the ends of the earth". The couplet is Wukong's credential, stated in two lines, and it is a trailer for the enormous autobiographical poem he recites later in this same chapter.

gǎnchángqiāngzhēnduìshǒuyǒngzhènjīndōuchēngshàngchóu gǎnchángqiāngzhēnduìshǒuyǒngzhènjīndōuchēngshàngchóu

That shaft of a long spear is a true opponent, / that has held the Golden Helm forever and is reckoned first among them.

points, so ; 長槍: is cháng. 稱上籌: is chēng, "to be reckoned as"; 上籌 is the top tally-stick, first place. On the place-name 金兜 see the note to the passage as a whole.

xiāngzhèchánghǎosànjiàngāoshìxiū xiāngzhèchánghǎosànjiàngāoshìxiū

Meeting like this, there can be no fair parting; / till high and low are seen, they swear not to give over.

相遇: is xiāng, marking a thing done mutually. 無好散: is sàn, the verb "to break up, to part." 不見高低 — "until it is seen which is the higher" — closes the poem on the terms of the contest, and the next passage will leave those terms unsettled.


總評 Commentary

The slanging match before the fight repays close reading, because both sides are arguing about property. The demon accuses Pilgrim of theft in broad daylight (白晝); Pilgrim hands the phrase straight back and adds the question that settles the moral ledger of the entire arc — 那件兒是你的, "which of these things is yours?" Every object in that cave arrived by way of the ring. The demon is a fence complaining about burglary. And the chapter's ending completes the joke at his expense: the ring itself is stolen goods, lifted out of Lord Lao's own treasury by a servant who had swallowed an elixir pill and gone to sleep.

There is a pun in the middle of it that English cannot carry. The word Pilgrim uses for the demon's device, 圈套, is the ordinary word for a snare or a trap — and it is built on , the character for a ring or hoop. So "you work a snare-ring" is at once an accusation of trickery and a plain description of the object. The demon is caught by the language before he is caught by anything else.

The battle poem is a standard set-piece of the genre, but a well-made one. It opens in five-syllable lines and widens to seven at the fourth couplet; it runs the this-one-and-that-one call-and-answer down two couplets, pairing rod against spear, then stroke against guard and sound against water; then it pulls back to the landscape, where birds stop in mid-air and beasts pull their heads in, and out again to the two camps, before returning to the two weapons and closing on the vow not to part until the thing is settled. One rhyme carries the whole way. A textual point: at 永鎮金兜稱上籌 the Sìdétáng edition prints the place-name with a character made of set over and beside , which does not exist in the standard character set at all; the Wikisource transcription prints plain with an editorial note, and that is what is encoded here, at all eight occurrences in the chapter.