Canonical Classics ← 第五十二回
第五十二回
悟wù空kōng大dà鬧nào金jīn兜dōu洞dòng
如rú來lái暗àn示shì主zhǔ人rén公gōng

Wukong Makes Havoc at the Cave of the Golden Helmet · The Tathāgata Hints Covertly at the Owner

佛知不言
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

佛知不言 The Buddha Knows and Will Not Say

如rú來lái聽tīng說shuō,將jiāng慧huì眼yǎn遙yáo觀guān,早zǎo已yǐ知zhī識shí。對duì行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài物wù我wǒ雖suī知zhī之zhī,但dàn不bù可kě與yǔ你nǐ說shuō。你nǐ這zhè猴hóu兒er口kǒu敞chǎng,一yì傳chuán道dào是shì我wǒ說shuō他tā,他tā就jiù不bù與yǔ你nǐ鬥dòu,定dìng要yào嚷rǎng上shàng靈líng山shān,反fǎn遺yí禍huò於yú我wǒ也yě。我wǒ這zhè裡lǐ著zhuó法fǎ力lì助zhù你nǐ擒qín他tā去qù罷ba。」行xíng者zhě再zài拜bài稱chēng謝xiè道dào:「如rú來lái助zhù我wǒ甚shén麼me法fǎ力lì?」如rú來lái即jí令lìng十shí八bā尊zūn羅luó漢hàn開kāi寶bǎo庫kù,取qǔ十shí八bā粒lì金jīn丹dān砂shā,與yǔ悟wù空kōng助zhù力lì。行xíng者zhě道dào:「金jīn丹dān砂shā卻què如rú何hé?」如rú來lái道dào:「你nǐ去qù洞dòng外wài,叫jiào那nà妖yāo魔mó比bǐ試shì。演yǎn他tā出chū來lái,卻què教jiào羅luó漢hàn放fàng砂shā,陷xiàn住zhù他tā,使shǐ他tā動dòng不bù得de身shēn,拔bá不bù得de腳jiǎo,憑píng你nǐ揪jiū打dǎ便biàn了liǎo。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「妙miào妙miào妙miào,趁chèn早zǎo去qù來lái。」如rú来lái听tīng说shuō,将jiāng慧huì眼yǎn遥yáo观guān,早zǎo已yǐ知zhī识shí。对duì行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài物wù我wǒ虽suī知zhī之zhī,但dàn不bù可kě与yǔ你nǐ说shuō。你nǐ这zhè猴hóu儿er口kǒu敞chǎng,一yì传chuán道dào是shì我wǒ说shuō他tā,他tā就jiù不bù与yǔ你nǐ斗dòu,定dìng要yào嚷rǎng上shàng灵líng山shān,反fǎn遗yí祸huò于yú我wǒ也yě。我wǒ这zhè里lǐ着zhuó法fǎ力lì助zhù你nǐ擒qín他tā去qù罢ba。」行xíng者zhě再zài拜bài称chēng谢xiè道dào:「如rú来lái助zhù我wǒ甚shén么me法fǎ力lì?」如rú来lái即jí令lìng十shí八bā尊zūn罗luó汉hàn开kāi宝bǎo库kù,取qǔ十shí八bā粒lì金jīn丹dān砂shā,与yǔ悟wù空kōng助zhù力lì。行xíng者zhě道dào:「金jīn丹dān砂shā却què如rú何hé?」如rú来lái道dào:「你nǐ去qù洞dòng外wài,叫jiào那nà妖yāo魔mó比bǐ试shì。演yǎn他tā出chū来lái,却què教jiào罗luó汉hàn放fàng砂shā,陷xiàn住zhù他tā,使shǐ他tā动dòng不bù得de身shēn,拔bá不bù得de脚jiǎo,凭píng你nǐ揪jiū打dǎ便biàn了liǎo。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「妙miào妙miào妙miào,趁chèn早zǎo去qù来lái。」


逐句解 Line by line

如rú來lái聽tīng說shuō,將jiāng慧huì眼yǎn遙yáo觀guān,早zǎo已yǐ知zhī識shí。 如rú来lái听tīng说shuō,将jiāng慧huì眼yǎn遥yáo观guān,早zǎo已yǐ知zhī识shí。

The Tathāgata heard him out, turned his eye of wisdom to gaze into the distance, and knew already who it was.

將慧眼遙觀: 將 is jiāng, 觀 is guān. 早已知識 is "already knew and recognised" — four characters, and the whole identification is done.

對duì行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài物wù我wǒ雖suī知zhī之zhī,但dàn不bù可kě與yǔ你nǐ說shuō。 对duì行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài物wù我wǒ虽suī知zhī之zhī,但dàn不bù可kě与yǔ你nǐ说shuō。

He said to Pilgrim: "That monster — I do know him, but I may not tell you.

He knows, and he will not say. 那怪物 points, so 那 is nà. 我雖知之,但不可與你說 is the sentence the second half of the chapter's title is about: the Tathāgata will drop a hint and will not give a name.

你nǐ這zhè猴hóu兒er口kǒu敞chǎng,一yì傳chuán道dào是shì我wǒ說shuō他tā,他tā就jiù不bù與yǔ你nǐ鬥dòu,定dìng要yào嚷rǎng上shàng靈líng山shān,反fǎn遺yí禍huò於yú我wǒ也yě。 你nǐ这zhè猴hóu儿er口kǒu敞chǎng,一yì传chuán道dào是shì我wǒ说shuō他tā,他tā就jiù不bù与yǔ你nǐ斗dòu,定dìng要yào嚷rǎng上shàng灵líng山shān,反fǎn遗yí祸huò于yú我wǒ也yě。

"You are a loose-mouthed ape. Once it got about that I had told you of him, he would not fight you at all, but would be sure to come brawling up to Spirit Mountain, and the trouble would recoil upon me.

And the reason is delightfully practical. 猴兒: 兒 is er, the familiar ending. 口敞 is "open-mouthed", unable to keep anything to himself. 一傳: 一 shifts to yì before a second tone. The Buddha is not withholding out of doctrine; he is protecting his own front door.

我wǒ這zhè裡lǐ著zhuó法fǎ力lì助zhù你nǐ擒qín他tā去qù罷ba。」 我wǒ这zhè里lǐ着zhuó法fǎ力lì助zhù你nǐ擒qín他tā去qù罢ba。」

"I will lend you the power of dharma from here, and help you take him."

著法力: 著 is zhuó, to apply or employ. The sentence-final 罷 is ba, softening the offer, not the verb bà.

行xíng者zhě再zài拜bài稱chēng謝xiè道dào:「如rú來lái助zhù我wǒ甚shén麼me法fǎ力lì?」 行xíng者zhě再zài拜bài称chēng谢xiè道dào:「如rú来lái助zhù我wǒ甚shén么me法fǎ力lì?」

Pilgrim bowed again and gave thanks, saying: "What power of dharma will the Tathāgata lend me?"

稱謝: 稱 is chēng; 甚麼: 甚 is shén. He accepts the refusal without arguing — which for this character is remarkable — and asks only what he is getting instead.

如rú來lái即jí令lìng十shí八bā尊zūn羅luó漢hàn開kāi寶bǎo庫kù,取qǔ十shí八bā粒lì金jīn丹dān砂shā,與yǔ悟wù空kōng助zhù力lì。 如rú来lái即jí令lìng十shí八bā尊zūn罗luó汉hàn开kāi宝bǎo库kù,取qǔ十shí八bā粒lì金jīn丹dān砂shā,与yǔ悟wù空kōng助zhù力lì。

The Tathāgata at once ordered the eighteen Venerable Arhats to open the treasury and take out eighteen grains of golden cinnabar sand, to lend Wukong their strength.

十八尊羅漢 are the eighteen arhats of the standard Chinese set. 金丹砂 is "golden cinnabar sand": 金丹 is the vocabulary of Daoist alchemy, the gold elixir, and here it has been turned into a Buddhist weapon.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「金jīn丹dān砂shā卻què如rú何hé?」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「金jīn丹dān砂shā却què如rú何hé?」

Pilgrim said: "And what is this golden cinnabar sand?"

The question is the reader's own. The narrative will show the answer working, and then show it failing, four passages later.

如rú來lái道dào:「你nǐ去qù洞dòng外wài,叫jiào那nà妖yāo魔mó比bǐ試shì。 如rú来lái道dào:「你nǐ去qù洞dòng外wài,叫jiào那nà妖yāo魔mó比bǐ试shì。

The Tathāgata said: "Go outside his cave and call the fiend out to a trial.

那妖魔 points, so 那 is nà. 比試 is a match or trial of skill — the same challenge formula the chapter has used at this gate throughout.

演yǎn他tā出chū來lái,卻què教jiào羅luó漢hàn放fàng砂shā,陷xiàn住zhù他tā,使shǐ他tā動dòng不bù得de身shēn,拔bá不bù得de腳jiǎo,憑píng你nǐ揪jiū打dǎ便biàn了liǎo。」 演yǎn他tā出chū来lái,却què教jiào罗luó汉hàn放fàng砂shā,陷xiàn住zhù他tā,使shǐ他tā动dòng不bù得de身shēn,拔bá不bù得de脚jiǎo,凭píng你nǐ揪jiū打dǎ便biàn了liǎo。」

"Draw him out, and then have the arhats loose the sand to mire him, so that he can neither stir his body nor pull free his feet, and you may thrash him as you please — and there's an end of it."

The instruction is precise, and every word of it is true. 卻教: 教 is jiào, "have them." Both 得 (動不得身, 拔不得腳) are de, marking what cannot be managed. 便了: 了 is liǎo, "and that settles it", not the le that marks a completed action.

行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「妙miào妙miào妙miào,趁chèn早zǎo去qù來lái。」 行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「妙miào妙miào妙miào,趁chèn早zǎo去qù来lái。」

Pilgrim laughed and said: "Fine, fine, fine — let us be off at once."

趁早去來 is "go while the going is good." This is the chapter's second triple exclamation of delight, and the second time the confidence turns out to be misplaced.


總評 Commentary

This is the passage the chapter's title names — 如來暗示主人公, the Tathāgata hints at who the owner is — and a refusal comes before the hint, which is worth taking seriously. He knows at a glance. He will not say. And the reason he gives is not doctrinal but practical and faintly comic: Wukong cannot keep his mouth shut, word would get about that the information came from Vulture Peak, and the demon would give up fighting and come and make a scene here instead. The Buddha of this novel is a cosmic power who also manages his own security, and declines to be named as a source.

What he offers instead is a weapon, and Pilgrim takes it without pressing the question — which is unlike him, and a measure of how badly the arc has gone. The eighteen grains of golden cinnabar sand are described precisely enough to sound decisive: draw him out, mire him, thrash him at leisure. Nothing in the Buddha's instruction is untrue. But a reader who has been counting knows that the ring has taken every object aimed at it for three chapters, and that sand is an object. The hint, when it finally arrives, will not come from this conversation at all.