Canonical Classics ← 第三十六回
第三十六回
xīnyuánzhèngchùzhūyuán
pángménjiànyuèmíng

The Mind-Monkey, Rightly Settled, Subdues All Conditions · Cleaving the Side-Gate, He Sees the Bright Moon

八戒攪局
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

八戒攪局 Bajie Breaks the Spell

jièshàngqiánchězhùzhǎnglǎodào:「shītīngluànjiǎngleshuìjiàozhèyuèajièshàngqiánchězhùzhǎnglǎodào:「shītīngluànjiǎngleshuìjiàozhèyuèa

quēzhījiǔyòutuányuánshēngláishíquánquēzhījiǔyòutuányuánshēngláishíquán
chīfànxiánziwǎnyòushuōyǒuniánxiánchīfànxiánziwǎnyòushuōyǒuniánxián
dōulíngxiūláichīxiàyuándōulíngxiūláichīxiàyuán
shuōjīnghuán滿mǎnsānbǎiwěiyáotóuzhíshàngtiān。」shuōjīnghuánmǎnsānbǎiwěiyáotóuzhíshàngtiān。」

逐句解 Line by line

jièshàngqiánchězhùzhǎnglǎodào:「shītīngluànjiǎngleshuìjiào jièshàngqiánchězhùzhǎnglǎodào:「shītīngluànjiǎngleshuìjiào

Bajie came forward and tugged at the elder, saying: “Master, don't listen to their wild talk and lose your sleep over it.”

扯住 "to pull at, grab hold of"; 莫聽亂講 "don't heed the loose talk"; 誤了睡覺 "to spoil one's sleep," 覺 read jiào; 長 read zhǎng.

zhèyuèa zhèyuèa

As for this moon:

Bajie introduces his own, very different moon-verse.

quēzhījiǔyòutuányuánshēngláishíquán quēzhījiǔyòutuányuánshēngláishíquán

Waned but a little while, it rounds out again — like me, born never quite complete.

不十全 "not ten-tenths whole, imperfect," 似 read . Bajie reads the moon, characteristically, as a figure for himself.

chīfànxiánziwǎnyòushuōyǒuniánxián chīfànxiánziwǎnyòushuōyǒuniánxián

At meals they grudge me my big belly; when I take up a bowl they say I slobber.

肚子大 "a big belly"; 黏涎 "sticky drool, slaver." Bajie's litany of grievances.

dōulíngxiūláichīxiàyuán dōulíngxiūláichīxiàyuán

They're all clever and have cultivated their blessings; I'm just a dolt who's piled up a bit of karmic merit.

他都 "they all," 都 read dōu; 伶俐 "clever, sharp"; 痴愚 "foolish, dull"; 積下緣 "accumulated affinity/merit."

shuōjīnghuán滿mǎnsānbǎiwěiyáotóuzhíshàngtiān。」 shuōjīnghuánmǎnsānbǎiwěiyáotóuzhíshàngtiān。」

I say your scripture-fetching just pays off the karma of the three evil paths — then you'll wag your tail and shake your head and go straight up to heaven.

還滿三塗業 "to repay in full the karma of the three (evil) paths," 還 read huán; 三塗 the three evil destinies (hell, hungry ghosts, beasts); 擺尾搖頭 "to wag the tail and shake the head," a comic-animal image. Bajie deflates the lofty discourse with earthy grumbling.


總評 Commentary

Bajie shatters the contemplative mood exactly as one would expect. Impatient with the doctrine and wanting his sleep, he grabs his master and offers his own moon-poem — a comic inversion of Tripitaka's lyric and the disciples' alchemy. Where they saw cosmic principle, Bajie sees himself: the moon, waning and waxing, is "like me, born never quite complete," and the verse tips at once into his stock grievances about being mocked for his appetite and his slobbering.

The deflation is structurally the point. After three ascending turns of high doctrine — Wukong's alchemy, Sha Monk's Five-Agent completion, the enlightenment couplet — Bajie's earthy grumbling returns the scene to the human (and porcine) ground, and returns the pilgrims to bed. His parting jibe, that the whole scripture-quest is just a way to "pay off the karma of the three evil paths" and then swan up to heaven wagging his tail, is characteristically both crude and not entirely wrong — a comic reminder, beneath the alchemical symbolism, of the plain penitential logic of the journey.