山神指洞 The Mountain God Names the Cave
行有五六里,正在悽愴之際,只聞得北坡外有人言語。看時,乃一個老翁,氈衣蓋體,暖帽蒙頭,足下踏一雙半新半舊的油靴,手持著一根龍頭拐棒,後邊跟一個年幼的僮僕,折一枝臘梅花,自坡前念歌而走。行者放下缽盂,覿面道個問訊,叫:「老公公,貧僧問訊了。」那老翁即便回禮道:「長老那裡來的?」行者道:「我們東土來的,往西天拜佛求經,一行師徒四眾。我因師父飢了,特去化齋,教他三眾坐在那山坡平處相候。及回來不見,不知往那條路上去了。動問公公,可曾看見?」老者聞言,呵呵冷笑道:「你那三眾,可有一個長嘴大耳的麼?」行者道:「有有有。」「又有一個晦氣色臉的,牽著一匹白馬,領著一個白臉的胖和尚麼?」行者道:「是是是。」老翁道:「你們走錯路了,你休尋他,各人顧命去也。」行者道:「那白臉者是我師父,那怪樣者是我師弟。我與他共發虔心,要往西天取經,如何不尋他去?」老翁道:「我才然從此過時,看見他們錯走了路徑,闖入妖魔口裡去了。」行者道:「煩公公指教指教,是個甚麼妖魔?居於何方我好上門取索他等,往西天去也。」老翁道:「這座山叫做金兜山。山前有個金兜洞,那洞中有個獨角兕大王。那大王神通廣大,威武高強。那三眾此回斷沒命了,你若去尋他,只怕連你也難保,不如不去之為愈也。我也不敢阻你,也不敢留你,只憑你心中度量。」行有五六里,正在凄怆之际,只闻得北坡外有人言语。看时,乃一个老翁,毡衣盖体,暖帽蒙头,足下踏一双半新半旧的油靴,手持着一根龙头拐棒,后边跟一个年幼的僮仆,折一枝腊梅花,自坡前念歌而走。行者放下钵盂,觌面道个问讯,叫:「老公公,贫僧问讯了。」那老翁即便回礼道:「长老那里来的?」行者道:「我们东土来的,往西天拜佛求经,一行师徒四众。我因师父饥了,特去化斋,教他三众坐在那山坡平处相候。及回来不见,不知往那条路上去了。动问公公,可曾看见?」老者闻言,呵呵冷笑道:「你那三众,可有一个长嘴大耳的么?」行者道:「有有有。」「又有一个晦气色脸的,牵着一匹白马,领着一个白脸的胖和尚么?」行者道:「是是是。」老翁道:「你们走错路了,你休寻他,各人顾命去也。」行者道:「那白脸者是我师父,那怪样者是我师弟。我与他共发虔心,要往西天取经,如何不寻他去?」老翁道:「我才然从此过时,看见他们错走了路径,闯入妖魔口里去了。」行者道:「烦公公指教指教,是个甚么妖魔?居于何方我好上门取索他等,往西天去也。」老翁道:「这座山叫做金兜山。山前有个金兜洞,那洞中有个独角兕大王。那大王神通广大,威武高强。那三众此回断没命了,你若去寻他,只怕连你也难保,不如不去之为愈也。我也不敢阻你,也不敢留你,只凭你心中度量。」
逐句解 Line by line
He had gone five or six lǐ, and was in the depth of his distress, when he heard somebody talking beyond the northern slope.
聞得 takes 得 as dé, managing to hear. 悽愴 is grief and alarm at once. 里 is the lǐ, the Chinese unit of road distance, roughly half a kilometre — so five or six of them is a walk of under an hour.
He looked, and it was an old man with a felt coat over him and a warm cap on his head, a pair of half-new, half-worn oiled boots on his feet and a dragon-headed staff in his hand, with a young serving-lad following behind who had broken off a spray of wintersweet and came singing along in front of the slope.
手持著 uses zhe for a continuing state. 折 is zhé, to snap off, not shé. 臘梅 is wintersweet, which flowers in the twelfth month — the season is being kept consistent down to the shrubbery. The old man is drawn as carefully as the one at the farm was, and for the same reason. He is not what he appears.
Pilgrim set down his alms bowl, made his greeting face to face and called: "Venerable sir, this poor monk salutes you."
覿面 is face to face. Wukong observes the forms exactly, as he did at the farm gate. This time they are returned.
The old man returned the courtesy at once: "Elder, where have you come from?"
長老 is zhǎng lǎo. 那裡來的 is a question, so this 那 reads nǎ, while the 那 of 那老翁 at the head of the segment reads nà, that. Both readings inside one line, settled by where each sits.
Pilgrim said: "We come from the Eastern Land, going to the Western Heaven to bow to the Buddha and seek scriptures — master and disciples, a party of four."
一行 takes 行 as xíng, a party on the move. The full credentials again. Wukong is consistent about giving his name and errand in a way nobody else in the party ever is.
Because my master was hungry I went off specially to beg food, and told the three of them to sit and wait for me on the level ground of that hillside.
教 is jiào, to make someone do something; 平處 takes chù; 相候 has 相 as xiāng, mutually, waiting for one another. He states the arrangement exactly, which is what makes the answer so cutting when it comes.
And when I came back they were gone, and I do not know which road they took.
往那條路 is a question — which road — so 那 reads nǎ.
May I ask, venerable sir, whether you have seen them?"
動問 is the polite formula for putting a question, roughly "may I trouble you to ask". Eight characters, and the whole of his errand.
Hearing this, the old man laughed a cold laugh: "Those three of yours — was there one with a long snout and big ears?"
長嘴 takes 長 as cháng, the dimension. 呵呵冷笑 is a laugh with no amusement in it. The old man knows the answer before he asks the question, and the cold laugh is what gives him away.
Pilgrim said: "There was, there was, there was."
Six characters, the last three identical. The eagerness is the point.
"And another with a face the colour of ill luck, leading a white horse, with a fat white-faced monk in his charge?"
The question arrives with no "he said" attached, so the speech runs straight on from the old man. 牽著 and 領著 both use zhe for a continuing state. 晦氣色臉, a face the colour of bad luck, picks up the 晦氣星 the narrator used of the master's lapse — the ill luck has got into Sha Monk's complexion.
Pilgrim said: "That is right, that is right, that is right."
The same shape as before, three identical characters, and the last easy exchange in the passage.
The old man said: "You have taken the wrong road. Do not go looking for them — each of you had best go and see to his own life."
你們走錯路了 is the farm elder's phrase from twelve passages back, and it now means something else entirely. There it was a wrong turning; here it is a sentence of death. 顧命 is to look to your own survival.
Pilgrim said: "The white-faced one is my master, the odd-looking one is my brother in religion. We took a devout vow together to go to the Western Heaven for the scriptures. How should I not go looking for them?"
Both instances of 那 are the pointing nà, marking off two of the three just described. 共發虔心 is the shared vow. The question is rhetorical and it is also a statement of the entire plot.
The old man said: "I was passing this way just now and saw them take the wrong path and walk into a fiend's mouth."
闖入妖魔口裡 — walked into a fiend's mouth — will turn out to be very nearly literal, given what the fiend has ordered done with them.
Pilgrim said: "Be so kind as to instruct me, venerable sir — what sort of fiend is he? Where does he live, so that I may go to his door and demand them back, and get on to the Western Heaven?"
指教指教 doubles the verb, softening a request into something more like a nudge; 教 is jiào. 甚麼 is shén me. 上門取索 is to go to a man's door and demand what he owes you. Wukong frames a rescue as debt collection, which tells you how he expects the conversation to go.
The old man said: "This mountain is called Jindou Shan, the Mountain of the Golden Helm. In front of the mountain there is a cave called Jindou Dong, and in that cave there is a great king, the One-Horned Si."
Here the 世德堂本 prints, for both the mountain and the cave, a character that Unicode has never encoded: the mountain radical set beside 兜. 兜 is substituted and the difference recorded rather than passed over. With the mountain radical the original is a place-name and carries no separate meaning; the substitute 兜 means a helmet or a coif, which is how the name has come to be read as the Golden Helm. As for 兕, it is an ancient one-horned beast of the rhinoceros or wild-buffalo kind — the animal in the line from the Analects about tigers and 兕 getting out of their cage, and a byword for something that should have been shut in and was not. The novel takes the name and puts a single horn on a demon king.
That great king has vast magic powers and is high and strong in arms.
神通廣大, vast magic powers, is word for word the phrase the fiend used of Wukong two passages earlier. The two are being measured against each other in the same terms before they have even met.
Those three of yours are certainly done for this time. If you go looking for them, I am afraid you will not save yourself either, and it would be better not to go at all.
斷沒命了 is flat: certainly dead. 難保 has 難 as nán, hard to do. 之為愈也 takes 為 as the verb wéi, and the classical turn of phrase marks the advice as considered rather than merely frightened.
I do not presume to stop you, nor to keep you. It rests entirely on your own judgement."
度量 is read dù liàng, discretion or judgement; read as a verb it would be duó liàng, to weigh a thing up, and either reading makes sense of the line. The speech is a formal disclaimer — I do not presume to stop you — which is what a local god says before letting a Great Sage do exactly as he likes.
The scene rhymes with the farm, point for point: an old man on a road, a courteous exchange, and a warning that the traveller has come the wrong way. The first old man was a mortal and was wrong. This one is not, and is right.
It is also the chapter's only piece of formal exposition. Mountain, cave and fiend are all named in three clauses, which is how this novel habitually opens the fighting half of an arc.
The old man finishes by refusing to give advice, and Wukong has already decided anyway. The refusal is a form of respect, and both of them know it.