Canonical Classics ← 第九十三回
第九十三回
yuánwèntányīn
tiānzhúguócháowángǒu

In the Garden of the Friendless They Ask of Old Days and Speak of Causes · In the Country of India He Attends the King and Meets a Mate

黃金滿布園地
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

黃金滿布園地 Cover the Ground with Gold

jièdào:「shīagēnshīniánzàicéngjiànshíjīnshíle?」sānzàngshuōdào:「shìchángkànjīngsòngdiǎnshuōshìzàishèwèichéngshùyuánzhèyuánshuōshìzhǎngzhěwèntàimǎileqǐngjiǎngjīngtàishuō:『zhèyuánmàiruòyàomǎideshíchúfēihuángjīn滿mǎnyuán。』zhǎngzhětīngshuōsuíhuángjīnwéizhuān滿mǎnyuáncáimǎitàiyuáncáiqǐngshìzūnshuōxiǎngzhèjīnfēijiùshìzhèshì?」jièdào:「shīagēnshīniánzàicéngjiànshíjīnshíle?」sānzàngshuōdào:「shìchángkànjīngsòngdiǎnshuōshìzàishèwèichéngshùyuánzhèyuánshuōshìzhǎngzhěwèntàimǎileqǐngjiǎngjīngtàishuō:『zhèyuánmàiruòyàomǎideshíchúfēihuángjīnmǎnyuán。』zhǎngzhětīngshuōsuíhuángjīnwéizhuānmǎnyuáncáimǎitàiyuáncáiqǐngshìzūnshuōxiǎngzhèjīnfēijiùshìzhèshì?」


逐句解 Line by line

jièdào:「shīagēnshīniánzàicéngjiànshíjīnshíle?」sānzàngshuōdào:「shì jièdào:「shīagēnshīniánzàicéngjiànshíjīnshíle?」sānzàngshuōdào:「shì

Eight Rules said, "Master, what a thing! I have followed you for years and never once knew the road, and today I know the road too?" Tripitaka said, "Not so."

Eight Rules has misheard entirely. His master said Shravasti, meaning he has recognised where they are from a story; Eight Rules hears it as knowing the way, and is delighted to have been useful for once.

識得 — knowing, recognising — turns up twice in this one line and is the same word Pilgrim and Tripitaka were arguing over a page ago, in its everyday sense. The novel has just put a joke about recognition immediately after an argument about understanding, and the two disciples walk straight past it.

chángkànjīngsòngdiǎnshuōshìzàishèwèichéngshùyuánzhèyuánshuōshìzhǎngzhěwèntàimǎileqǐngjiǎngjīng chángkànjīngsòngdiǎnshuōshìzàishèwèichéngshùyuánzhèyuánshuōshìzhǎngzhěwèntàimǎileqǐngjiǎngjīng

"I regularly read the scriptures and the canon, and they say the Buddha was at the city of Shravasti, in the Jeta Grove, the Garden of the Friendless. The story of this garden is that the Elder Anathapindika asked the prince to sell it to him, and invited the Buddha to expound scripture there."

祗樹給孤園 names the place in a single breath: the Jeta Grove and the Garden of the Friendless. Jeta was the prince who owned the trees; the Friendless were whom the rich layman fed, which is how he got his nickname.

The first character, , is not the everyday one meaning give. In this name it is read , to supply or provide — the layman's title means he who provides for the friendless. The chapter uses it nine times, every one of them part of this name, and so does the chapter's own couplet — the matched pair of lines that serves as its title.

長者 — the Elder — is the standard rendering for the Sanskrit title of a wealthy and respected householder. He is not a monk.

tàishuō:『zhèyuánmàiruòyàomǎideshíchúfēihuángjīn滿mǎnyuán。』zhǎngzhětīngshuōsuíhuángjīnwéizhuān滿mǎnyuáncáimǎitàiyuáncáiqǐngshìzūnshuō tàishuō:『zhèyuánmàiruòyàomǎideshíchúfēihuángjīnmǎnyuán。』zhǎngzhětīngshuōsuíhuángjīnwéizhuānmǎnyuáncáimǎitàiyuáncáiqǐngshìzūnshuō

"The prince said, 'This garden of mine is not for sale. If he wants to buy it from me, it will have to be gold spread out to cover the ground.' The Elder Anathapindika, hearing this, thereupon made bricks of gold and covered the garden ground with them, and only then did he manage to buy the prince's Jeta Grove, and only then did he manage to invite the World-Honoured One to preach."

There is the name explained, and the whole story arrives inside a quotation the way an anecdote does when someone is remembering it out loud.

The prince meant the price as a refusal. He named the most absurd sum he could think of, and the layman paid it, and the refusal became the most famous act of giving in the tradition.

世尊 — the World-Honoured One — is one of the standard titles of a Buddha. And notice the two in the second half: only then, only then. The Chinese puts the effort before each result, so the sentence itself has to be paid for twice.

xiǎngzhèjīnfēijiùshìzhèshì?」 xiǎngzhèjīnfēijiùshìzhèshì?」

"I am thinking this Gold-Spread Monastery may be that very story."

He is right, and it will take him until the middle of the night and an old monk's confession to find out how right.

Note how carefully he puts it. Not this is the place, but this may be that story — a scholar's hedge. The novel gives Tripitaka very few moments of competence and this is one of them, so it lets him be properly cautious about it.


總評 Commentary

The story Tripitaka tells here is the founding story of Jetavana, and it is one of the best known in Buddhism. A rich layman of Shravasti, famous for feeding the destitute, wanted to buy a park from Prince Jeta as a gift to the Buddha. The prince, meaning to be rid of him, said the price was as much gold as would cover the ground. The layman began carting gold in. The prince gave in, kept the trees as his own contribution, and the place ended up named for both of them.

That is why the two halves of the name sit oddly together — the Jeta Grove and the Garden of the Friendless. It is a joint dedication, and the Chinese preserves the seam. A Chinese reader in the Ming would have known the story the way an English reader knows the Good Samaritan, which is why the novel can drop the words gold spread on a signboard and expect it to ring.

Something quieter is going on as well. Pilgrim has just been shown to understand a scripture better than his master does. Some two hundred and twenty characters later, Tripitaka reads a signboard nobody else can read and tells a story nobody else knows. The novel is not humiliating him; it is dividing the labour, and the second half of this chapter needs exactly the kind of knowledge only he has.