悟空得名 The Naming of Sun Wukong
祖師聞言暗喜,道:「這等說,卻是個天地生成的。你起來走走我看。」猴王縱身跳起,拐呀拐的走了兩遍。祖師笑道:「你身軀雖是鄙陋,卻像個食松果的猢猻。我與你就身上取個姓氏,意思教你姓「猢」。猢字去了個獸傍,乃是個古月。古者,老也;月者,陰也。老陰不能化育,教你姓「猻」倒好。猻字去了獸傍,乃是個子系。子者,兒男也;系者,嬰細也,正合嬰兒之本論。教你姓「孫」罷。」猴王聽說,滿心歡喜,朝上叩頭道:「好!好!好!今日方知姓也。萬望師父慈悲,既然有姓,再乞賜個名字,卻好呼喚。」祖師道:「我門中有十二個字,分派起名,到你乃第十輩之小徒矣。」猴王道:「那十二個字?」祖師道:「乃廣、大、智、慧、真、如、性、海、穎、悟、圓、覺十二字。排到你,正當「悟」字。與你起個法名叫做「孫悟空」,好麼?」猴王笑道:「好!好!好!自今就叫做孫悟空也。」正是:祖师闻言暗喜,道:「这等说,却是个天地生成的。你起来走走我看。」猴王纵身跳起,拐呀拐的走了两遍。祖师笑道:「你身躯虽是鄙陋,却像个食松果的猢狲。我与你就身上取个姓氏,意思教你姓「猢」。猢字去了个兽傍,乃是个古月。古者,老也;月者,阴也。老阴不能化育,教你姓「狲」倒好。狲字去了兽傍,乃是个子系。子者,儿男也;系者,婴细也,正合婴儿之本论。教你姓「孙」罢。」猴王听说,满心欢喜,朝上叩头道:「好!好!好!今日方知姓也。万望师父慈悲,既然有姓,再乞赐个名字,却好呼唤。」祖师道:「我门中有十二个字,分派起名,到你乃第十辈之小徒矣。」猴王道:「那十二个字?」祖师道:「乃广、大、智、慧、真、如、性、海、颖、悟、圆、觉十二字。排到你,正当「悟」字。与你起个法名叫做「孙悟空」,好么?」猴王笑道:「好!好!好!自今就叫做孙悟空也。」正是:
畢竟不知向後修些甚麼道果,且聽下回分解。毕竟不知向后修些甚么道果,且听下回分解。
逐句解 Line by line
Hearing this, the patriarch was secretly glad, and said: 'Put that way, you are a thing formed by Heaven and Earth itself.
暗喜 (àn xǐ) — secretly pleased, and he does not tell the monkey why. The reason arrives at once for the reader: 天地生成的, a thing formed by Heaven and Earth. No parents means no inheritance, no clan, no accumulated family karma. It is the least encumbered student a teacher could hope for.
Get up and walk about, and let me see you.' The Monkey King sprang to his feet and waddled back and forth a couple of times.
縱身跳起 is to spring up (縱 zòng), and 拐呀拐的 is a lovely piece of sound-writing: 拐 (guǎi) is to walk with a lurch, doubled around the little filler sound 呀 to make a waddle you can hear. He has been told to walk up and down so the master can look at him, and he waddles. The surname is about to come out of this.
The patriarch laughed: 'Mean and ugly though your frame is, you do look like a pine-nut-eating macaque (húsūn).
鄙陋 is coarse and unsightly; the master is not flattering him. The word that matters is 猢猻 (hú sūn), the plain everyday word for a macaque. The pine seeds he was eating at the gate come back here as identification — and those two ordinary characters are about to be taken apart to find a name inside them.
I'll take a surname for you from your very body — my thought is to surname you 'Hú' (猢).
就身上取個姓氏 — a surname taken off your own body, which is a strange and rather beautiful idea when the usual alternative is taking it from a father. 教 is jiào, to cause or have, and 姓 is working as a verb, "to be surnamed." He begins with 猢, the first half of 猢猻.
But if you take the 'beast' radical off 猢, you're left with 古月 ('old' and 'moon'): 古 means 'old,' and 月 means 'yin.'
Now the character-play. Strip the beast radical 犭 off 猢 and what is left is 古 and 月, "old" and "moon" (傍 stands here for 旁, the side-element of a character, read páng). The master glosses each in the classical 者…也 pattern used for definitions: 古 means old, 月 means yin — the moon being the standing emblem of the yin principle, dark, receptive, female. This is Chinese wordplay in its native form. Not sounds, but strokes.
Aged yin cannot beget and nurture — so it would be better to surname you 'Sūn' (猻).
化育 is to transform and rear, the classical term for generation itself, and 老陰 — aged yin — cannot do it (不 as bù before the rising tone of 能). The objection is cosmological rather than aesthetic: 猢 spells out something old and barren, so it is the wrong name for a creature at the very start of his growing. 倒好 is "better, rather" — try the other half.
Take the 'beast' radical off 猻, and you're left with 子系 ('child' and 'thread'):
The same operation on 猻: take off the beast radical and what remains is 子 (zǐ) and 系 (xì) — the two pieces that compose the surname 孫.
子 means 'a boy-child,' and 系 means 'infant, small' — which fits exactly the very idea of an infant.
子 means a boy-child (兒男) and 系 means infant-small (嬰, an infant; 細, fine or tiny), which 正合嬰兒之本論 — fits exactly the idea of the newborn. The contrast with 古月 is the entire argument: one name says old and barren, the other says infant and generative. There is a wink here for readers of inner alchemy too, where 嬰兒, the "infant," is a standard term for the immortal embryo the adept grows inside himself.
So I'll surname you 'Sūn' (孫), then.'
And it is fixed: 孫, sūn, built on 子, "child." One of the commonest surnames in China, arrived at by way of a macaque, a stripped radical and a short lecture on yin. The creature who was 石猴 and then 美猴王 now has a family name — the one thing his birth could never have given him.
When the Monkey King heard this, his heart filled with joy, and he kowtowed upward, saying: 'Splendid! Splendid! Splendid! Today at last I know I have a surname.
朝上 — facing upward, toward the dais (朝 cháo). 今日方知姓也 is "today, at last, I know a surname" (方, only now). The grandeur of the moment passes him by completely. He is simply thrilled to have one, and says so three times.
I beg the master's mercy: now that I have a surname, grant me also a given name, the better to be called by.'
乞 (qǐ) is to beg and 賜 (cì) is to bestow from above — the vocabulary of a petition to a superior, which he has picked up remarkably fast for someone who was a king last week. And his reason is wonderfully practical: 卻好呼喚, so that people have something to call him by.
The patriarch said: 'In my school there are twelve characters, assigned in turn for naming, and you fall in the tenth generation, a junior disciple.'
分派起名, names assigned by allocation. This is a real and still-living Chinese practice: a lineage fixes a sequence of characters, and everyone of one generation shares the same one in their name, so that a stranger's name tells you where he stands in the family tree. Religious schools borrowed the system wholesale. 第十輩 puts the monkey in the tenth generation (輩 bèi), a junior disciple (矣, the classical closing flourish). He has walked in off the ocean and been slotted straight into a genealogy.
The Monkey King said: 'Which twelve characters?'
那 is nǎ, "which." He asks, sensibly enough, to hear them.
The patriarch said: 'They are the twelve — Broad, Great, Wisdom, Sage, True, Thus, Nature, Sea, Bright, Awaken, Round, Enlightened.
The twelve: 廣、大、智、慧、真、如、性、海、穎、悟、圓、覺 — Broad, Great, Wisdom, Sage, True, Thus, Nature, Sea, Bright, Awaken, Round, Enlightened. Read them in pairs and the sequence is unmistakable: 智慧 is prajñā, 真如 is tathatā or Suchness, 圓覺 is perfect enlightenment. The Daoist immortal's naming-scheme is a Buddhist glossary. (The ninth character is 穎, yǐng, "bright, sharp-tipped," in the 維基文庫 text; some editions print the variant 頴.)
Counting down to you, it falls exactly on 'Wù' (悟, 'awaken'). I'll give you the dharma-name 'Sun Wukong' (孫悟空) — how's that?'
Counting down the twelve (排 pái, to rank in order), the tenth is 悟 — to awaken, to realise. Joined to the surname and to 空, emptiness, it gives the 法名 or dharma-name 孫悟空: Sun Awakened-to-Emptiness. Remember who is doing the naming. Subhūti, whose name this master carries, is the disciple the tradition calls 解空第一, foremost in understanding emptiness. He has handed the monkey his own speciality. And then, charmingly, he asks whether that will do — 好麼?
The Monkey King laughed: 'Splendid! Splendid! Splendid! From this day I'll be called Sun Wukong.'
好!好!好! once more, and 自今, from today. The sequence the chapter has tracked from its first page closes here: a stone, then 石猴, then 美猴王, and now 孫悟空 — the name under which he walks into world literature.
Truly it was:
正是 cues the closing couplet, the storyteller's way of setting a seal on the chapter.
In the first cleaving of primordial chaos, there were no surnames at all;
鴻蒙 is the undifferentiated primal murk and 闢 (pì) is to cleave open, so the line reaches all the way back to the chapter's first sentences — before Pángǔ, before distinctions of any kind. Its point is that surnames are not primordial. Namelessness came first, and was innocent. What the monkey lacked was not a defect but an origin.
to shatter the stubborn void, one must awaken to the void — Wukong.
The pun the whole chapter was built to land. 頑空, "stubborn emptiness," is a real Buddhist term of reproach for the beginner's error of taking emptiness to mean mere nothingness, a dead blank. To break through it you need 悟空 — which is at once a name and an instruction, "awaken to emptiness" (悟 awaken + 空 kōng, emptiness). The hero and the goal are the same three syllables. This is what the chapter title's 大道生, "the Great Dao is born," has been aiming at all along.
There is no telling yet what fruit of the Way he would cultivate hereafter; so listen to the next chapter, and all will be explained.
The storyteller's standard sign-off, kept from the days when this was performed rather than read: there is no telling yet what 道果, fruit of the Way, he will cultivate — so come back for the next instalment (不 as bù before the level tone of 知). Chapter One ends on a cliff-hanger about homework.
The chapter ends with the act it has been moving toward since its first line, and Wú Chéng'ēn (吳承恩) gets there by taking a word to pieces. Watching the monkey waddle up and down, the master calls him a 猢猻 (hú sūn) — just the ordinary word for a macaque — and proposes to quarry a surname out of it. He tries the first character, 猢: strip the beast radical and it leaves 古月, "old moon," which is to say aged yin, and aged yin 不能化育, cannot beget or nurture. Barren; rejected. He tries the second, 猻: strip the radical and it leaves 子系, "child" and "infant-fine," the very image of generative youth. From that he fixes the surname 孫. The derivation is a joke and a doctrine at the same time — this is a creature at the very start of his growing, and the name has to say so.
The given name comes from lineage rather than wordplay. The master's school assigns names from a fixed cycle of twelve characters, 廣大智慧真如性海穎悟圓覺, one to a generation — a genuine practice of Chinese clans and religious schools alike, and one whose vocabulary here is openly Buddhist: 智慧 for prajñā, 真如 for Suchness, 圓覺 for perfect enlightenment. The monkey falls in the tenth generation, on 悟, "to awaken." Joined to 空, emptiness, it makes 孫悟空, Sun Awakened-to-Emptiness. There is a quiet propriety in that. The master bears the name of Subhūti, the disciple whom tradition calls 解空第一, foremost in understanding emptiness, and what he gives the monkey is his own subject.
The closing couplet turns the name into a teaching. 鴻蒙初闢原無姓,打破頑空須悟空 — when the primal chaos was first cleft there were no surnames at all; to shatter the stubborn void, one must awaken to the void. The first line reaches back past the whole chapter to the world-making it opened with, and reframes the monkey's namelessness as innocence rather than lack. The second sets 頑空, the dead nihilistic "emptiness" that beginners mistake for insight, against 悟空, which is simultaneously the hero's name and the instruction addressed to him. The chapter's title promised 心性修持大道生, "mind and nature cultivated, the Great Dao is born." The naming is that birth.
Then 且聽下回分解, "listen to the next chapter and all will be explained" — the formula of a live storyteller holding a crowd, preserved in the written novel like a stage direction nobody thought to cut. Look back over the ground covered. A stone conceived by Heaven and Earth splits and lets out a monkey; the monkey wins a kingdom by daring a waterfall; the king, appalled by the thought of dying, gives up that kingdom for a raft; the seeker crosses two oceans, wastes nine years among people chasing money and rank, and is finally pointed to the right mountain by a woodcutter who cannot go there himself. As Andrew H. Plaks observes, the chapter is one continuous movement from undifferentiated nature to conferred identity. What remains — the arts of transformation, the somersault cloud, the immortality that started all of this — belongs to 第二回, where 孫悟空 begins his education in earnest.