Canonical Classics ← 第一回
第一回
靈líng根gēn育yù孕yùn源yuán流liú出chū
心xīn性xìng修xiū持chí大dà道dào生shēng

A Numinous Root, Conceived and Nurtured, Brings Forth Its Source · The Cultivation of Mind and Nature Gives Birth to the Great Way

洞府仙童
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

洞府仙童 The Grotto and the Immortal Lad

猴hóu王wáng聽tīng說shuō,只zhǐ得dé相xiāng辭cí。出chū深shēn林lín,找zhǎo上shàng路lù徑jìng,過guò一yì山shān坡pō,約yuē有yǒu七qī八bā里lǐ遠yuǎn,果guǒ然rán望wàng見jiàn一yí座zuò洞dòng府fǔ。挺tǐng身shēn觀guān看kàn,真zhēn好hǎo去qù處chù!但dàn見jiàn:猴hóu王wáng听tīng说shuō,只zhǐ得dé相xiāng辞cí。出chū深shēn林lín,找zhǎo上shàng路lù径jìng,过guò一yì山shān坡pō,约yuē有yǒu七qī八bā里lǐ远yuǎn,果guǒ然rán望wàng见jiàn一yí座zuò洞dòng府fǔ。挺tǐng身shēn观guān看kàn,真zhēn好hǎo去qù处chù!但dàn见jiàn:

煙yān霞xiá散sàn彩cǎi,日rì月yuè搖yáo光guāng。烟yān霞xiá散sàn彩cǎi,日rì月yuè摇yáo光guāng。
千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,萬wàn節jié修xiū篁huáng。千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,万wàn节jié修xiū篁huáng。
千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,帶dài雨yǔ半bàn空kōng青qīng冉rǎn冉rǎn;千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,带dài雨yǔ半bàn空kōng青qīng冉rǎn冉rǎn;
萬wàn節jié修xiū篁huáng,含hán煙yān一yí壑hè色sè蒼cāng蒼cāng。万wàn节jié修xiū篁huáng,含hán烟yān一yí壑hè色sè苍cāng苍cāng。
門mén外wài奇qí花huā佈bù錦jǐn,橋qiáo邊biān瑤yáo草cǎo噴pēn香xiāng。门mén外wài奇qí花huā布bù锦jǐn,桥qiáo边biān瑶yáo草cǎo喷pēn香xiāng。
石shí崖yá突tū兀wù青qīng苔tái潤rùn,懸xuán壁bì高gāo張zhāng翠cuì蘚xiǎn長cháng。石shí崖yá突tū兀wù青qīng苔tái润rùn,悬xuán壁bì高gāo张zhāng翠cuì藓xiǎn长cháng。
時shí聞wén仙xiān鶴hè唳lì,每měi見jiàn鳳fèng凰huáng翔xiáng。时shí闻wén仙xiān鹤hè唳lì,每měi见jiàn凤fèng凰huáng翔xiáng。
仙xiān鶴hè唳lì時shí,聲shēng振zhèn九jiǔ皋gāo霄xiāo漢hàn遠yuǎn;仙xiān鹤hè唳lì时shí,声shēng振zhèn九jiǔ皋gāo霄xiāo汉hàn远yuǎn;
鳳fèng凰huáng翔xiáng起qǐ,翎líng毛máo五wǔ色sè彩cǎi雲yún光guāng。凤fèng凰huáng翔xiáng起qǐ,翎líng毛máo五wǔ色sè彩cǎi云yún光guāng。
玄xuán猿yuán白bái鹿lù隨suí隱yǐn見xiàn,金jīn獅shī玉yù象xiàng任rèn行xíng藏cáng。玄xuán猿yuán白bái鹿lù随suí隐yǐn见xiàn,金jīn狮shī玉yù象xiàng任rèn行xíng藏cáng。
細xì觀guān靈líng福fú地dì,真zhēn個gè賽sài天tiān堂táng。细xì观guān灵líng福fú地dì,真zhēn个gè赛sài天tiān堂táng。

又yòu見jiàn那nà洞dòng門mén緊jǐn閉bì,靜jìng悄qiāo悄qiāo杳yǎo無wú人rén跡jì。忽hū回huí頭tóu,見jiàn崖yá頭tóu立lì一yí石shí碑bēi,約yuē有yǒu三sān丈zhàng餘yú高gāo,八bā尺chǐ餘yú闊kuò,上shàng有yǒu一yì行háng十shí個gè大dà字zì,乃nǎi是shì「靈líng臺tái方fāng寸cùn山shān,斜xié月yuè三sān星xīng洞dòng」。美měi猴hóu王wáng十shí分fēn歡huān喜xǐ道dào:「此cǐ間jiān人rén果guǒ是shì樸pǔ實shí,果guǒ有yǒu此cǐ山shān此cǐ洞dòng。」看kàn夠gòu多duō時shí,不bù敢gǎn敲qiāo門mén。且qiě去qù跳tiào上shàng松sōng枝zhī梢shāo頭tóu,摘zhāi松sōng子zǐ吃chī了le頑wán耍shuǎ。少shǎo頃qǐng間jiān,只zhǐ聽tīng得dé呀yā的de一yì聲shēng,洞dòng門mén開kāi處chù,裡lǐ面miàn走zǒu出chū一yí個gè仙xiān童tóng,真zhēn個gè丰fēng姿zī英yīng偉wěi,像xiàng貌mào清qīng奇qí,比bǐ尋xún常cháng俗sú子zǐ不bù同tóng。但dàn見jiàn他tā:又yòu见jiàn那nà洞dòng门mén紧jǐn闭bì,静jìng悄qiāo悄qiāo杳yǎo无wú人rén迹jì。忽hū回huí头tóu,见jiàn崖yá头tóu立lì一yí石shí碑bēi,约yuē有yǒu三sān丈zhàng余yú高gāo,八bā尺chǐ余yú阔kuò,上shàng有yǒu一yì行háng十shí个gè大dà字zì,乃nǎi是shì「灵líng台tái方fāng寸cùn山shān,斜xié月yuè三sān星xīng洞dòng」。美měi猴hóu王wáng十shí分fēn欢huān喜xǐ道dào:「此cǐ间jiān人rén果guǒ是shì朴pǔ实shí,果guǒ有yǒu此cǐ山shān此cǐ洞dòng。」看kàn够gòu多duō时shí,不bù敢gǎn敲qiāo门mén。且qiě去qù跳tiào上shàng松sōng枝zhī梢shāo头tóu,摘zhāi松sōng子zǐ吃chī了le顽wán耍shuǎ。少shǎo顷qǐng间jiān,只zhǐ听tīng得dé呀yā的de一yì声shēng,洞dòng门mén开kāi处chù,里lǐ面miàn走zǒu出chū一yí个gè仙xiān童tóng,真zhēn个gè丰fēng姿zī英yīng伟wěi,像xiàng貌mào清qīng奇qí,比bǐ寻xún常cháng俗sú子zǐ不bù同tóng。但dàn见jiàn他tā:

髽zhuā髻jì雙shuāng絲sī綰wǎn,寬kuān袍páo兩liǎng袖xiù風fēng。髽zhuā髻jì双shuāng丝sī绾wǎn,宽kuān袍páo两liǎng袖xiù风fēng。
貌mào和hé身shēn自zì別bié,心xīn與yǔ相xiàng俱jù空kōng。貌mào和hé身shēn自zì别bié,心xīn与yǔ相xiàng俱jù空kōng。
物wù外wài長cháng年nián客kè,山shān中zhōng永yǒng壽shòu童tóng。物wù外wài长cháng年nián客kè,山shān中zhōng永yǒng寿shòu童tóng。
一yì塵chén全quán不bù染rǎn,甲jiǎ子zǐ任rèn翻fān騰téng。一yì尘chén全quán不bù染rǎn,甲jiǎ子zǐ任rèn翻fān腾téng。

逐句解 Line by line

猴hóu王wáng聽tīng說shuō,只zhǐ得dé相xiāng辭cí。出chū深shēn林lín,找zhǎo上shàng路lù徑jìng, 猴hóu王wáng听tīng说shuō,只zhǐ得dé相xiāng辞cí。出chū深shēn林lín,找zhǎo上shàng路lù径jìng,

The Monkey King, hearing this, could only take his leave. Out of the deep wood he came, found the path,

只得相辭 — he "could only" take his leave, which quietly concedes that the woodcutter has won the argument. Then 找上路徑, he finds the path (徑 jìng) and follows the directions to the letter.

過guò一yì山shān坡pō,約yuē有yǒu七qī八bā里lǐ遠yuǎn,果guǒ然rán望wàng見jiàn一yí座zuò洞dòng府fǔ。 过guò一yì山shān坡pō,约yuē有yǒu七qī八bā里lǐ远yuǎn,果guǒ然rán望wàng见jiàn一yí座zuò洞dòng府fǔ。

crossed a hillside, and after some seven or eight li did indeed catch sight of a cave-dwelling.

坡 (pō) is a hillside, and 七八里 is seven or eight 里, left untranslated. Then 果然 — sure enough — a 洞府, a grotto-residence, exactly where he was told it would be. After ten fruitless years, something in the world has finally matched what somebody promised him.

挺tǐng身shēn觀guān看kàn,真zhēn好hǎo去qù處chù!但dàn見jiàn: 挺tǐng身shēn观guān看kàn,真zhēn好hǎo去qù处chù!但dàn见jiàn:

Drawing himself up to look, he saw it was a truly fine spot. Behold:

挺身 (挺 tǐng) is to draw yourself up straight: he has smartened his posture without being asked. 真好去處 and 但見 cue the 賦 of the master's cave.

煙yān霞xiá散sàn彩cǎi,日rì月yuè搖yáo光guāng。 烟yān霞xiá散sàn彩cǎi,日rì月yuè摇yáo光guāng。

Mist and rosy cloud scatter their colours; sun and moon shimmer their light.

The cave-賦 opens with light rather than rock — mist and rosy cloud scattering colour, sun and moon shimmering. Compare the mountain-賦 a few passages back, which opened with halberds and cliffs. This register is markedly more heavenly, and the difference is deliberate.

千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,萬wàn節jié修xiū篁huáng。 千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,万wàn节jié修xiū篁huáng。

A thousand aged cypresses, ten thousand joints of tall bamboo.

株 (zhū) is the measure word for trees and 篁 (huáng) is bamboo, counted here by its joints. The pair is stated now and picked up and expanded in the next two lines — the same "state, then amplify" pattern used on the earlier mountain.

千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,帶dài雨yǔ半bàn空kōng青qīng冉rǎn冉rǎn; 千qiān株zhū老lǎo柏bǎi,带dài雨yǔ半bàn空kōng青qīng冉rǎn冉rǎn;

A thousand aged cypresses, rain-laden, green and soft against the sky;

The cypresses again, 帶雨 rain-laden and 青冉冉, softly green, with 冉冉 suggesting something that droops or drifts gently rather than standing stiff.

萬wàn節jié修xiū篁huáng,含hán煙yān一yí壑hè色sè蒼cāng蒼cāng。 万wàn节jié修xiū篁huáng,含hán烟yān一yí壑hè色sè苍cāng苍cāng。

ten thousand joints of tall bamboo, holding mist, a whole ravine deep blue-green.

And the bamboo, 含煙 holding the mist, filling a whole ravine (壑 hè) with 蒼蒼 — the deep grey-green that distance puts on things.

門mén外wài奇qí花huā佈bù錦jǐn,橋qiáo邊biān瑤yáo草cǎo噴pēn香xiāng。 门mén外wài奇qí花huā布bù锦jǐn,桥qiáo边biān瑶yáo草cǎo喷pēn香xiāng。

Beyond the gate, rare flowers spread like brocade; by the bridge, magic herbs breathe fragrance.

佈錦 spreads rare flowers out like brocade (佈 is the 維基文庫 form of 布, to spread; 錦, brocade), and 噴香 has the jade-herbs gushing scent (噴 pēn). Note the two words of civilisation slipped in among the flowers: a gate, and a bridge. Somebody built here.

石shí崖yá突tū兀wù青qīng苔tái潤rùn,懸xuán壁bì高gāo張zhāng翠cuì蘚xiǎn長cháng。 石shí崖yá突tū兀wù青qīng苔tái润rùn,悬xuán壁bì高gāo张zhāng翠cuì藓xiǎn长cháng。

On the stone cliff, jagged, the green moss glistens; up the sheer wall, high-spread, the kingfisher lichen grows long.

突兀 (兀 wù) is jutting out abruptly; 懸壁 is a sheer hanging wall (懸 the 維基文庫 reading against 縣), and 翠蘚 is kingfisher-green lichen (蘚 xiǎn) growing 長 (cháng), long. Wet, old and undisturbed.

時shí聞wén仙xiān鶴hè唳lì,每měi見jiàn鳳fèng凰huáng翔xiáng。 时shí闻wén仙xiān鹤hè唳lì,每měi见jiàn凤fèng凰huáng翔xiáng。

Now and then one hears immortal cranes cry; often one sees phoenixes wheel.

唳 (lì) is the particular word for a crane's cry. Cranes and phoenixes are the standard birds of the immortals, and their presence gives the same certification the earlier mountain-賦 gave with its peaches and evergreens — except that this poem stops to expand on each.

仙xiān鶴hè唳lì時shí,聲shēng振zhèn九jiǔ皋gāo霄xiāo漢hàn遠yuǎn; 仙xiān鹤hè唳lì时shí,声shēng振zhèn九jiǔ皋gāo霄xiāo汉hàn远yuǎn;

When the immortal cranes cry, the sound shakes the deep marsh, far as the heavens;

The line reaches back to the Book of Songs: 鶴鳴於九皋,聲聞於天, "the crane cries in the deep marsh, and its voice is heard in heaven." 九皋 (jiǔ gāo) is that ninefold marsh and 霄漢 the high heavens. Quoting it is a way of saying that what happens in this hidden place is audible a very long way up.

鳳fèng凰huáng翔xiáng起qǐ,翎líng毛máo五wǔ色sè彩cǎi雲yún光guāng。 凤fèng凰huáng翔xiáng起qǐ,翎líng毛máo五wǔ色sè彩cǎi云yún光guāng。

when the phoenixes rise in flight, their plumage glows five-coloured as the painted clouds.

翎 (líng) is a feather, and the phoenix's plumage is 五色, five-coloured, glowing like painted cloud (彩 is the 維基文庫 reading against 綵).

玄xuán猿yuán白bái鹿lù隨suí隱yǐn見xiàn,金jīn獅shī玉yù象xiàng任rèn行xíng藏cáng。 玄xuán猿yuán白bái鹿lù随suí隐yǐn见xiàn,金jīn狮shī玉yù象xiàng任rèn行xíng藏cáng。

Black gibbons and white deer come and go at will; golden lions and jade elephants appear or hide as they please.

Black gibbons, white deer, golden lions, jade elephants — a menagerie no forest ever held. What matters is what they do: 隨隱見 and 任行藏, appearing and vanishing exactly as they please (見 here xiàn, to appear; 行藏 xíng cáng, a set phrase for showing yourself or staying hidden). Even the animals here have the freedom the monkey came looking for.

細xì觀guān靈líng福fú地dì,真zhēn個gè賽sài天tiān堂táng。 细xì观guān灵líng福fú地dì,真zhēn个gè赛sài天tiān堂táng。

Look closely at this numinous, blessed land — it truly rivals heaven.

賽 (sài) is to match or outdo, and 真個 is the 維基文庫 form of 真箇. The 賦 ends by declaring the place a rival to heaven — which, in a book where heaven is a real address with a real civil service, is a specific claim rather than a compliment.

又yòu見jiàn那nà洞dòng門mén緊jǐn閉bì,靜jìng悄qiāo悄qiāo杳yǎo無wú人rén跡jì。 又yòu见jiàn那nà洞dòng门mén紧jǐn闭bì,静jìng悄qiāo悄qiāo杳yǎo无wú人rén迹jì。

He saw, too, that the cave door was tightly shut, silent and still, with no trace of anyone.

And after all that, a shut door. 洞門緊閉, and 靜悄悄杳無人跡, silent and still, with no trace of anybody (杳 yǎo, vanished from sight). He has arrived, and nothing happens. It is the first obstacle in the chapter he cannot get past by jumping.

忽hū回huí頭tóu,見jiàn崖yá頭tóu立lì一yí石shí碑bēi,約yuē有yǒu三sān丈zhàng餘yú高gāo,八bā尺chǐ餘yú闊kuò, 忽hū回huí头tóu,见jiàn崖yá头tóu立lì一yí石shí碑bēi,约yuē有yǒu三sān丈zhàng余yú高gāo,八bā尺chǐ余yú阔kuò,

Turning suddenly, he saw on the cliff-head a stone tablet, some three zhàng and more high and eight chǐ and more wide,

石碑 is a stele (碑 bēi), over three 丈 tall and eight 尺 wide (餘, "and more"; the units are left untranslated). Note the scale. This is a monument, not a signpost — and taller than the immortal stone he was born from.

上shàng有yǒu一yì行háng十shí個gè大dà字zì,乃nǎi是shì「靈líng臺tái方fāng寸cùn山shān,斜xié月yuè三sān星xīng洞dòng」。 上shàng有yǒu一yì行háng十shí个gè大dà字zì,乃nǎi是shì「灵líng台tái方fāng寸cùn山shān,斜xié月yuè三sān星xīng洞dòng」。

and on it a single line of ten large characters, reading: 'Mountain of the Numinous Terrace and the Square Inch; Cave of the Slanting Moon and Three Stars.'

Ten characters in a single line (行 here háng, a row of script, not xíng or héng). They are exactly the two names the woodcutter spoke. For the monkey this is confirmation; for the reader it is the riddle set out in stone — Heart Mountain, and the cave whose name draws the character 心.

美měi猴hóu王wáng十shí分fēn歡huān喜xǐ道dào:「此cǐ間jiān人rén果guǒ是shì樸pǔ實shí,果guǒ有yǒu此cǐ山shān此cǐ洞dòng。」 美měi猴hóu王wáng十shí分fēn欢huān喜xǐ道dào:「此cǐ间jiān人rén果guǒ是shì朴pǔ实shí,果guǒ有yǒu此cǐ山shān此cǐ洞dòng。」

The Handsome Monkey King was delighted: 'The folk here really are honest — there truly is such a mountain and such a cave!'

樸實 (樸 pǔ) is plain and honest. His delight is disarmingly literal: not "I have reached the seat of the Way" but "the locals here don't tell lies." After a decade among people chasing money and rank, an honest set of directions genuinely impresses him.

看kàn夠gòu多duō時shí,不bù敢gǎn敲qiāo門mén。且qiě去qù跳tiào上shàng松sōng枝zhī梢shāo頭tóu,摘zhāi松sōng子zǐ吃chī了le頑wán耍shuǎ。 看kàn够gòu多duō时shí,不bù敢gǎn敲qiāo门mén。且qiě去qù跳tiào上shàng松sōng枝zhī梢shāo头tóu,摘zhāi松sōng子zǐ吃chī了le顽wán耍shuǎ。

He gazed a good while but dared not knock; so he went and sprang up to the tip of a pine branch, picked pine seeds, ate them, and played.

不敢敲門 — he does not dare knock (敲 qiāo). The monkey who leapt blind through a waterfall and walked past tigers is frightened of a door. Then, because he is still himself, he climbs a pine, eats the seeds (松子, with 子 in full tone zǐ) and plays. Awe and appetite in a single sentence.

少shǎo頃qǐng間jiān,只zhǐ聽tīng得dé呀yā的de一yì聲shēng,洞dòng門mén開kāi處chù, 少shǎo顷qǐng间jiān,只zhǐ听tīng得dé呀yā的de一yì声shēng,洞dòng门mén开kāi处chù,

After a little while, with a creak — yā! — the cave door opened,

少頃間 is "after a short while" (頃 qǐng), and 呀的一聲 writes the creak of the door as a sound (呀 yā). Nobody knocked. The door opens because the master already knows.

裡lǐ面miàn走zǒu出chū一yí個gè仙xiān童tóng,真zhēn個gè丰fēng姿zī英yīng偉wěi,像xiàng貌mào清qīng奇qí, 里lǐ面miàn走zǒu出chū一yí个gè仙xiān童tóng,真zhēn个gè丰fēng姿zī英yīng伟wěi,像xiàng貌mào清qīng奇qí,

and out came an immortal lad, his bearing truly handsome and grand, his features fresh and rare,

丰姿英偉 is a fine, imposing bearing (丰 fēng, comely) and 像貌清奇 is a face out of the ordinary run. This is the doorman, and he looks like that.

比bǐ尋xún常cháng俗sú子zǐ不bù同tóng。但dàn見jiàn他tā: 比bǐ寻xún常cháng俗sú子zǐ不bù同tóng。但dàn见jiàn他tā:

unlike any common mortal. Behold him:

俗子 is a worldly person — the sort the monkey has spent nine years among. 但見他 cues the verse portrait.

髽zhuā髻jì雙shuāng絲sī綰wǎn,寬kuān袍páo兩liǎng袖xiù風fēng。 髽zhuā髻jì双shuāng丝sī绾wǎn,宽kuān袍páo两liǎng袖xiù风fēng。

A twin hair-knot bound with twin silk cords, a loose robe, wind in both sleeves.

髽髻 (髽 zhuā) is a doubled top-knot bound with silk cords (綰 wǎn, to tie up; the 維基文庫 reads 髽髻 against 鬢髻 elsewhere), and 寬袍兩袖風 is a loose robe with the wind in both sleeves. Exactly how a Daoist acolyte is drawn in every painting: nothing tight, nothing heavy.

貌mào和hé身shēn自zì別bié,心xīn與yǔ相xiàng俱jù空kōng。 貌mào和hé身shēn自zì别bié,心xīn与yǔ相xiàng俱jù空kōng。

His face and form set him apart; heart and appearance alike are empty.

And then the portrait turns strange. 心與相俱空 — heart and outward form alike 空, empty (相 xiàng, appearance). That is the Buddhist śūnyatā, emptiness, and it is being attributed to a boy who answers doors, in a Daoist grotto. The novel's mixing of traditions is nowhere more casual than here.

物wù外wài長cháng年nián客kè,山shān中zhōng永yǒng壽shòu童tóng。 物wù外wài长cháng年nián客kè,山shān中zhōng永yǒng寿shòu童tóng。

A long-years guest beyond the world of things, an ever-living lad of the mountains.

物外 is outside the world of things, and 長年 (長 cháng) and 永壽 both mean everliving. The doorman, in other words, is deathless. If that is the servant, the monkey must be thinking, what is the master?

一yì塵chén全quán不bù染rǎn,甲jiǎ子zǐ任rèn翻fān騰téng。 一yì尘chén全quán不bù染rǎn,甲jiǎ子zǐ任rèn翻fān腾téng。

Not a speck of dust clings to him; he lets the cycling years tumble by.

一塵不染, "not a speck of dust clings," is still a current idiom for someone spotless — of hands as much as habits. And 甲子任翻騰 lets the sixty-year cycles tumble past without touching him (甲子 the cyclical count, 子 in full tone; 翻騰, to roll over). Compare 山中無甲子 back on the monkey's own mountain. There, time was simply never counted. Here it is counted, and it does not matter.


總評 Commentary

After ten years of fruitless searching and two ocean crossings, the monkey reaches the master's gate, and Wú Chéng'ēn (吳承恩) marks the arrival with the most heavenly landscape in the chapter. The cave-賦 drops the martial peaks and dragon-veins of the earlier mountain and takes up a register of pure transcendence: mist scattering colour, cranes whose cries reach heaven, phoenixes with five-coloured plumage, gibbons and deer and jade elephants coming and going as they please. Its closing line — 真個賽天堂, "it truly rivals heaven" — sets the cave on the border of the immortal realm. The seeker has crossed out of the human world.

The stone tablet, three 丈 high, carries the two riddling names the woodcutter spoke, and the monkey's reaction to it is disarmingly simple: "the folk here really are honest." Then comes a lovely human touch. The king who fears no tiger 不敢敲門, does not dare knock; instead he climbs a pine, eats its seeds and plays while he waits. The diffidence is new — a flicker of awe at the edge of something sacred — and the pine seeds are pure monkey, his ordinary nature surfacing at the gate of enlightenment.

The door opens by itself, and out steps an immortal lad whose verse portrait is soaked in the vocabulary of attainment: 心與相俱空, "heart and form alike empty"; 一塵不染, "not a speck of dust"; 甲子任翻騰, letting the years tumble by. That a doorkeeper should be described in terms of realised emptiness — a Buddhist 空 in a Daoist cave — is the novel's syncretism in miniature, and it raises the stakes nicely. If the servant is deathless and spotless, what is the master? Andrew H. Plaks observes that thresholds of this kind — woodcutter, tablet, lad, and finally the patriarch — stage the seeker's approach as a passage through rising degrees of the sacred. The lad is the last of them. The next passage takes the monkey into the master's presence at last.